|
Browse categories
|
 |
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
 Customer Reviews
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK!, 15 Nov 2008
I am a trained midwife, currently practising as a maternity nurse. I like to read to keep up to date with what the women I work with are reading. I would NEVER recommend this book. It is full of inaccurate sweeping statements and not even one single reference - the whole book is solely based on what she thinks! NEVER take a book seriously if it can't be backed up with references.
The book regularly had me shouting out loud at her inaccuracies (eg re getting baby to take a bottle 'You can use the same bottle of milk for up to one-and-a-half hours, reheating it as often as is necessary to keep it at an attractive temperature for him.' - JUST NOT TRUE AND ACTUALLY POTENTIALLY DANGEROUS) and therefore had me extremely worried about ALL the advice she was giving. Some of it is so inaccurate and misleading.
Never once in this book does she suggest holding your baby or playing with your baby. It's all feed, wind, sleep. What about relationship and nurturing? I think she's missed an important point about breast feeding and the early days relationship.
Breast feeding doesn't require a text book. It requires patience, common sense, a good sense of humour and a relaxed approach. If you're really struggling see a local breast feeding counsellor (BUT even then be wary, and follow your gut and your heart, and your baby!).
The book desperately needs updating, but preferably, in my opinion needs removing from the market. DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK!
Just what I needed!, 28 Aug 2008
This book was a real God-send when my baby was born. I think that it is written in a very pragmatic and realistic manner and is simple to work with. I was nearly put off by the lack of glossy pictures but after dipping into it many a time I realised that what mattered was good content rather than expensive photography. I have recommended this to all my friends expecting babies and plan to use it next time round. One of the most valuable books I had during the early months. Breastfeeding should be easy but sadly that isn't always the case and since many grandmothers didn't breastfeed (my mum was in the bottle is best generation) they can't pass on their advice as was the way in the past.
The most helpful baby book ever!!!, 26 Jun 2008
Just a quick review. I am soooo glad that I ignored the negative reviews of this book. We bought the book and the DVD by Clare Byam-Cook and it really helped. My wife was having a lot of trouble breast feeding and we had no support from the midwives, this book and the dvd changed all that. My wife is now able to breast feed quite well but still using bottle feeding. It is a very morale boosting book, with most other books and NHS literature giving women guilty feelings for not being able to breast feed.
Buy it!!
Dreafdul, 03 Apr 2008
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! I was wandering round Mothercare and thought this might be useful. I had had difficulties right from the beginning with latching sore nipples etc etc., but about 8 weeks in and with nipple shields all was well. However, I was wondering if I had enough milk and followed her advice for finding out if I did. Within in a day I was defrosting frozen milk (surplus you notice). LUCKILY, I came across a superb website whilst waiting for good advice response from an email sent to our breastfeeding co-ordinator. A very comprehensive website which includes lots of advice on milk supply and what are not signs of poor supply (i.e. what I thought!) By the following day I was back to expressing surplus. He was weighed the next day and had put on 9oz! I don't think there was anything wrong with my supply - one day didn't make 9oz!
Many readers here have found this book helpful. There may well be areas that are, however it probably depends which section you read and as you can see I would have been using formula top ups as would any woman following this advice as it is inaccurate as you will find out from any expert on breastfeeding and/or websites. I had got through the difficulties and this book set me back! I fully understand that breastfeeding is not easy and had I read this book earlier I would have had more problems! Her whole premise of breast milk supply is wrong, physiology, mechanisms and latching. (e.g. breasts do not empty) If you still think that she is right then it means that every other medical person in the country and beyond that deals with breastfeeding is wrong! Just because people pay for her services does not mean that she is right! As far as I aware all the organisations set up to support breastfeeding do not support this author, there is little to no evidence for much of what she says but there is to the contrary!
Get advice from breastfeeding counsellors/co-ordinators/organisations and websites. Free, helpful and accurate. I would not still be exclusively or even partly breastfeeding had it not been for the hospital breastfeeding co-ordinator. I was going to sell this book on Amazon! However I would not wish anyone to go through the worry I did and feel it would be morally wrong! I am giving it to the co-ordinator to use in training as what not to do. If anyone puts a positive review after this then all I can say is that you did not read the sections I did! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK.
Excellent and invaluable - keep it by your pillow!, 14 Jan 2008
This is the ONLY book I have needed so far, to feed, wind and settle my now 3 month old baby. Both my baby and I would most certainly be unhappy, stressed out and miserable if it weren't for the advice Clare gives. I was given this book by my tenant who has also recently had a baby, and I was at first reluctant to open ANY book. However, I have read it from cover to cover at least 5 times, either mid-feed in desperation to know what to do next, or during a 'break' from caring for my pumpkin, and I am about to buy another 3 copies to give to friends who are expecting. I am CERTAIN that every mother and baby would benefit from this book. It is an excellent and invaluable support whether you find breastfeeding a tough challenge or a wonderful pleasure. I experience both!
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
Customer Reviews
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK!, 15 Nov 2008
I am a trained midwife, currently practising as a maternity nurse. I like to read to keep up to date with what the women I work with are reading. I would NEVER recommend this book. It is full of inaccurate sweeping statements and not even one single reference - the whole book is solely based on what she thinks! NEVER take a book seriously if it can't be backed up with references.
The book regularly had me shouting out loud at her inaccuracies (eg re getting baby to take a bottle 'You can use the same bottle of milk for up to one-and-a-half hours, reheating it as often as is necessary to keep it at an attractive temperature for him.' - JUST NOT TRUE AND ACTUALLY POTENTIALLY DANGEROUS) and therefore had me extremely worried about ALL the advice she was giving. Some of it is so inaccurate and misleading.
Never once in this book does she suggest holding your baby or playing with your baby. It's all feed, wind, sleep. What about relationship and nurturing? I think she's missed an important point about breast feeding and the early days relationship.
Breast feeding doesn't require a text book. It requires patience, common sense, a good sense of humour and a relaxed approach. If you're really struggling see a local breast feeding counsellor (BUT even then be wary, and follow your gut and your heart, and your baby!).
The book desperately needs updating, but preferably, in my opinion needs removing from the market. DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK!
Just what I needed!, 28 Aug 2008
This book was a real God-send when my baby was born. I think that it is written in a very pragmatic and realistic manner and is simple to work with. I was nearly put off by the lack of glossy pictures but after dipping into it many a time I realised that what mattered was good content rather than expensive photography. I have recommended this to all my friends expecting babies and plan to use it next time round. One of the most valuable books I had during the early months. Breastfeeding should be easy but sadly that isn't always the case and since many grandmothers didn't breastfeed (my mum was in the bottle is best generation) they can't pass on their advice as was the way in the past.
The most helpful baby book ever!!!, 26 Jun 2008
Just a quick review. I am soooo glad that I ignored the negative reviews of this book. We bought the book and the DVD by Clare Byam-Cook and it really helped. My wife was having a lot of trouble breast feeding and we had no support from the midwives, this book and the dvd changed all that. My wife is now able to breast feed quite well but still using bottle feeding. It is a very morale boosting book, with most other books and NHS literature giving women guilty feelings for not being able to breast feed.
Buy it!!
Dreafdul, 03 Apr 2008
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! I was wandering round Mothercare and thought this might be useful. I had had difficulties right from the beginning with latching sore nipples etc etc., but about 8 weeks in and with nipple shields all was well. However, I was wondering if I had enough milk and followed her advice for finding out if I did. Within in a day I was defrosting frozen milk (surplus you notice). LUCKILY, I came across a superb website whilst waiting for good advice response from an email sent to our breastfeeding co-ordinator. A very comprehensive website which includes lots of advice on milk supply and what are not signs of poor supply (i.e. what I thought!) By the following day I was back to expressing surplus. He was weighed the next day and had put on 9oz! I don't think there was anything wrong with my supply - one day didn't make 9oz!
Many readers here have found this book helpful. There may well be areas that are, however it probably depends which section you read and as you can see I would have been using formula top ups as would any woman following this advice as it is inaccurate as you will find out from any expert on breastfeeding and/or websites. I had got through the difficulties and this book set me back! I fully understand that breastfeeding is not easy and had I read this book earlier I would have had more problems! Her whole premise of breast milk supply is wrong, physiology, mechanisms and latching. (e.g. breasts do not empty) If you still think that she is right then it means that every other medical person in the country and beyond that deals with breastfeeding is wrong! Just because people pay for her services does not mean that she is right! As far as I aware all the organisations set up to support breastfeeding do not support this author, there is little to no evidence for much of what she says but there is to the contrary!
Get advice from breastfeeding counsellors/co-ordinators/organisations and websites. Free, helpful and accurate. I would not still be exclusively or even partly breastfeeding had it not been for the hospital breastfeeding co-ordinator. I was going to sell this book on Amazon! However I would not wish anyone to go through the worry I did and feel it would be morally wrong! I am giving it to the co-ordinator to use in training as what not to do. If anyone puts a positive review after this then all I can say is that you did not read the sections I did! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK.
Excellent and invaluable - keep it by your pillow!, 14 Jan 2008
This is the ONLY book I have needed so far, to feed, wind and settle my now 3 month old baby. Both my baby and I would most certainly be unhappy, stressed out and miserable if it weren't for the advice Clare gives. I was given this book by my tenant who has also recently had a baby, and I was at first reluctant to open ANY book. However, I have read it from cover to cover at least 5 times, either mid-feed in desperation to know what to do next, or during a 'break' from caring for my pumpkin, and I am about to buy another 3 copies to give to friends who are expecting. I am CERTAIN that every mother and baby would benefit from this book. It is an excellent and invaluable support whether you find breastfeeding a tough challenge or a wonderful pleasure. I experience both!
Brilliant resource, 13 Nov 2008
This is an invaluable resource for any midwife or student midwife to carry around to dip in to when needed. This book assumes a certain degree of knowledge about anatomy and physiology, pregnancy, and the metabolism of drugs but all medical abreviations used are laid out in a glossary of terms at the beginning.
Drugs are grouped by type and each drug is explored in a very well laid out and logical way detailing both generic and trade names, preparations, doses, contraindications, side effects, interactions as well as an excellent midwifery-centred fetal risk and breastfeeding section for each drug.
Finally, a short and simple reminder of drug calculations as a final chapter makes this a work bag essential.
Invaluable while in practice, 30 Jul 2005
This book easy to understand and well organised in its layout, contraindications and side effects of drugs are displayed clearly in sections on the same page. It's not too bulky to carry around if your wanting to take it to work with you. I am in my final year of training as a midwife and find it easier to use than the BNF which can be sometimes difficult to find what you want quickly. I recommend this book to be in any student, or qualified midwifes top 5 buys
Excellent, wouldn't be without it, 15 May 2005
I am a student midwife and whilst on placement am constantly hearing names of drugs and often don't have the opportunity for them to be fully explined to me, and the BNF can be confusing so i wanted something I could take on placement with me and look things up in. This is perfect, small and set out in sections of different drug types, including usage, dosage, routes of admin, contraindications, side effects, effects on fetus and breastfeeding. Its easy to understand and each drug is easy to find, theres enough information to aid understanding but it doesnt go too in depth and confuse! Definitely recommend this book, I use it all the time and would be lost without it!
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
Customer Reviews
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK!, 15 Nov 2008
I am a trained midwife, currently practising as a maternity nurse. I like to read to keep up to date with what the women I work with are reading. I would NEVER recommend this book. It is full of inaccurate sweeping statements and not even one single reference - the whole book is solely based on what she thinks! NEVER take a book seriously if it can't be backed up with references.
The book regularly had me shouting out loud at her inaccuracies (eg re getting baby to take a bottle 'You can use the same bottle of milk for up to one-and-a-half hours, reheating it as often as is necessary to keep it at an attractive temperature for him.' - JUST NOT TRUE AND ACTUALLY POTENTIALLY DANGEROUS) and therefore had me extremely worried about ALL the advice she was giving. Some of it is so inaccurate and misleading.
Never once in this book does she suggest holding your baby or playing with your baby. It's all feed, wind, sleep. What about relationship and nurturing? I think she's missed an important point about breast feeding and the early days relationship.
Breast feeding doesn't require a text book. It requires patience, common sense, a good sense of humour and a relaxed approach. If you're really struggling see a local breast feeding counsellor (BUT even then be wary, and follow your gut and your heart, and your baby!).
The book desperately needs updating, but preferably, in my opinion needs removing from the market. DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK!
Just what I needed!, 28 Aug 2008
This book was a real God-send when my baby was born. I think that it is written in a very pragmatic and realistic manner and is simple to work with. I was nearly put off by the lack of glossy pictures but after dipping into it many a time I realised that what mattered was good content rather than expensive photography. I have recommended this to all my friends expecting babies and plan to use it next time round. One of the most valuable books I had during the early months. Breastfeeding should be easy but sadly that isn't always the case and since many grandmothers didn't breastfeed (my mum was in the bottle is best generation) they can't pass on their advice as was the way in the past.
The most helpful baby book ever!!!, 26 Jun 2008
Just a quick review. I am soooo glad that I ignored the negative reviews of this book. We bought the book and the DVD by Clare Byam-Cook and it really helped. My wife was having a lot of trouble breast feeding and we had no support from the midwives, this book and the dvd changed all that. My wife is now able to breast feed quite well but still using bottle feeding. It is a very morale boosting book, with most other books and NHS literature giving women guilty feelings for not being able to breast feed.
Buy it!!
Dreafdul, 03 Apr 2008
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! I was wandering round Mothercare and thought this might be useful. I had had difficulties right from the beginning with latching sore nipples etc etc., but about 8 weeks in and with nipple shields all was well. However, I was wondering if I had enough milk and followed her advice for finding out if I did. Within in a day I was defrosting frozen milk (surplus you notice). LUCKILY, I came across a superb website whilst waiting for good advice response from an email sent to our breastfeeding co-ordinator. A very comprehensive website which includes lots of advice on milk supply and what are not signs of poor supply (i.e. what I thought!) By the following day I was back to expressing surplus. He was weighed the next day and had put on 9oz! I don't think there was anything wrong with my supply - one day didn't make 9oz!
Many readers here have found this book helpful. There may well be areas that are, however it probably depends which section you read and as you can see I would have been using formula top ups as would any woman following this advice as it is inaccurate as you will find out from any expert on breastfeeding and/or websites. I had got through the difficulties and this book set me back! I fully understand that breastfeeding is not easy and had I read this book earlier I would have had more problems! Her whole premise of breast milk supply is wrong, physiology, mechanisms and latching. (e.g. breasts do not empty) If you still think that she is right then it means that every other medical person in the country and beyond that deals with breastfeeding is wrong! Just because people pay for her services does not mean that she is right! As far as I aware all the organisations set up to support breastfeeding do not support this author, there is little to no evidence for much of what she says but there is to the contrary!
Get advice from breastfeeding counsellors/co-ordinators/organisations and websites. Free, helpful and accurate. I would not still be exclusively or even partly breastfeeding had it not been for the hospital breastfeeding co-ordinator. I was going to sell this book on Amazon! However I would not wish anyone to go through the worry I did and feel it would be morally wrong! I am giving it to the co-ordinator to use in training as what not to do. If anyone puts a positive review after this then all I can say is that you did not read the sections I did! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK.
Excellent and invaluable - keep it by your pillow!, 14 Jan 2008
This is the ONLY book I have needed so far, to feed, wind and settle my now 3 month old baby. Both my baby and I would most certainly be unhappy, stressed out and miserable if it weren't for the advice Clare gives. I was given this book by my tenant who has also recently had a baby, and I was at first reluctant to open ANY book. However, I have read it from cover to cover at least 5 times, either mid-feed in desperation to know what to do next, or during a 'break' from caring for my pumpkin, and I am about to buy another 3 copies to give to friends who are expecting. I am CERTAIN that every mother and baby would benefit from this book. It is an excellent and invaluable support whether you find breastfeeding a tough challenge or a wonderful pleasure. I experience both!
Brilliant resource, 13 Nov 2008
This is an invaluable resource for any midwife or student midwife to carry around to dip in to when needed. This book assumes a certain degree of knowledge about anatomy and physiology, pregnancy, and the metabolism of drugs but all medical abreviations used are laid out in a glossary of terms at the beginning.
Drugs are grouped by type and each drug is explored in a very well laid out and logical way detailing both generic and trade names, preparations, doses, contraindications, side effects, interactions as well as an excellent midwifery-centred fetal risk and breastfeeding section for each drug.
Finally, a short and simple reminder of drug calculations as a final chapter makes this a work bag essential.
Invaluable while in practice, 30 Jul 2005
This book easy to understand and well organised in its layout, contraindications and side effects of drugs are displayed clearly in sections on the same page. It's not too bulky to carry around if your wanting to take it to work with you. I am in my final year of training as a midwife and find it easier to use than the BNF which can be sometimes difficult to find what you want quickly. I recommend this book to be in any student, or qualified midwifes top 5 buys
Excellent, wouldn't be without it, 15 May 2005
I am a student midwife and whilst on placement am constantly hearing names of drugs and often don't have the opportunity for them to be fully explined to me, and the BNF can be confusing so i wanted something I could take on placement with me and look things up in. This is perfect, small and set out in sections of different drug types, including usage, dosage, routes of admin, contraindications, side effects, effects on fetus and breastfeeding. Its easy to understand and each drug is easy to find, theres enough information to aid understanding but it doesnt go too in depth and confuse! Definitely recommend this book, I use it all the time and would be lost without it!
Doesn't exactly do what it says on the tin, 20 Jun 2008
A very misleading title - doesn't really do what it says.
Imagine that you wanted a book about how to repair a bicycle puncture. You go out and buy 'Bicycle Punctures for Beginners' and expect to find some instructions on how to repair punctures, maybe some clear, labeled diagrams some hints and tips on how to repair particularly tricky punctures, that kind of thing.
What you don't expect is a book about the environmental benefits of riding a bicycle as opposed to driving a car. The importance of riding a bicycle, other people's opinions on bicycles, where you can ride your bicycle and what to do if you can't ride a bicycle. But don't forget, cars are generally pretty bad things.
Whilst this is a slightly exaggerated analogy, this 16 chapter-long book has just six short pages on the actual mechanics of, you know, breastfeeding. There are some pictures, but they're not annotated or labeled in any way. There is talk of different positions and holds but no diagrams of them to relate to (what does an 'underarm hold' look like? No idea? Me neither). In fact, nearly every picture is of a mother gazing adoringly at their baby. Is this the trick?
I don't need beating round the head repeatedly about the benefits of breastfeeding - I've just bought the book, of course I want to breastfeed! Every other book I own and every healthcare professional I come into contact with are doing a perfectly adequate job of backing this up, thanks. What I needed were some guidance on 'How?', not 'Why?'.
There may well be comprehensive books on how to breastfeed out there, but this isn't it. If, however you want a book about pros and cons on breastfeeding as a concept or a general overview, then this is worth a read.
There are much better books out there, 17 Jan 2008
I found this book far too prescriptive and not very helpful at all. I actually put it in the bin and relied entirely on 'So That's What They're For'.
Great resource for a beginner!, 16 May 2003
I really enjoyed reading this book. It was supportive without being too militant. It answered a lot of questions I had about breastfeeding and I am sure I will refer to it often when I have my baby. The only reason why it didn't get 5 stars was I thought it was a little short and could have had some picture or diagrams describing how to position the baby instead of just a written description.
Brief giude to the basics, 02 May 2003
Ok as far as it goes but only covers the bare essentials - good if your baby has turned up in a hurry and you don't have time to read more than a few pages! Other books (such as 'So that's what their for') contain more information that answers more questions
The book title says it all really, 09 Nov 2002
This is a great book for first time breastfeeders. Just the right amount of information and you have the security that, coming from the NCT, its going to be accurate, research based information. Every woman coming to breastfeeding for the first time should be issued this book in pregnancy - it covers not only the common things like positioning and how milk is made but also common problems too.
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Customer Reviews
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK!, 15 Nov 2008
I am a trained midwife, currently practising as a maternity nurse. I like to read to keep up to date with what the women I work with are reading. I would NEVER recommend this book. It is full of inaccurate sweeping statements and not even one single reference - the whole book is solely based on what she thinks! NEVER take a book seriously if it can't be backed up with references.
The book regularly had me shouting out loud at her inaccuracies (eg re getting baby to take a bottle 'You can use the same bottle of milk for up to one-and-a-half hours, reheating it as often as is necessary to keep it at an attractive temperature for him.' - JUST NOT TRUE AND ACTUALLY POTENTIALLY DANGEROUS) and therefore had me extremely worried about ALL the advice she was giving. Some of it is so inaccurate and misleading.
Never once in this book does she suggest holding your baby or playing with your baby. It's all feed, wind, sleep. What about relationship and nurturing? I think she's missed an important point about breast feeding and the early days relationship.
Breast feeding doesn't require a text book. It requires patience, common sense, a good sense of humour and a relaxed approach. If you're really struggling see a local breast feeding counsellor (BUT even then be wary, and follow your gut and your heart, and your baby!).
The book desperately needs updating, but preferably, in my opinion needs removing from the market. DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! Just what I needed!, 28 Aug 2008
This book was a real God-send when my baby was born. I think that it is written in a very pragmatic and realistic manner and is simple to work with. I was nearly put off by the lack of glossy pictures but after dipping into it many a time I realised that what mattered was good content rather than expensive photography. I have recommended this to all my friends expecting babies and plan to use it next time round. One of the most valuable books I had during the early months. Breastfeeding should be easy but sadly that isn't always the case and since many grandmothers didn't breastfeed (my mum was in the bottle is best generation) they can't pass on their advice as was the way in the past. The most helpful baby book ever!!!, 26 Jun 2008
Just a quick review. I am soooo glad that I ignored the negative reviews of this book. We bought the book and the DVD by Clare Byam-Cook and it really helped. My wife was having a lot of trouble breast feeding and we had no support from the midwives, this book and the dvd changed all that. My wife is now able to breast feed quite well but still using bottle feeding. It is a very morale boosting book, with most other books and NHS literature giving women guilty feelings for not being able to breast feed.
Buy it!! Dreafdul, 03 Apr 2008
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! I was wandering round Mothercare and thought this might be useful. I had had difficulties right from the beginning with latching sore nipples etc etc., but about 8 weeks in and with nipple shields all was well. However, I was wondering if I had enough milk and followed her advice for finding out if I did. Within in a day I was defrosting frozen milk (surplus you notice). LUCKILY, I came across a superb website whilst waiting for good advice response from an email sent to our breastfeeding co-ordinator. A very comprehensive website which includes lots of advice on milk supply and what are not signs of poor supply (i.e. what I thought!) By the following day I was back to expressing surplus. He was weighed the next day and had put on 9oz! I don't think there was anything wrong with my supply - one day didn't make 9oz!
Many readers here have found this book helpful. There may well be areas that are, however it probably depends which section you read and as you can see I would have been using formula top ups as would any woman following this advice as it is inaccurate as you will find out from any expert on breastfeeding and/or websites. I had got through the difficulties and this book set me back! I fully understand that breastfeeding is not easy and had I read this book earlier I would have had more problems! Her whole premise of breast milk supply is wrong, physiology, mechanisms and latching. (e.g. breasts do not empty) If you still think that she is right then it means that every other medical person in the country and beyond that deals with breastfeeding is wrong! Just because people pay for her services does not mean that she is right! As far as I aware all the organisations set up to support breastfeeding do not support this author, there is little to no evidence for much of what she says but there is to the contrary!
Get advice from breastfeeding counsellors/co-ordinators/organisations and websites. Free, helpful and accurate. I would not still be exclusively or even partly breastfeeding had it not been for the hospital breastfeeding co-ordinator. I was going to sell this book on Amazon! However I would not wish anyone to go through the worry I did and feel it would be morally wrong! I am giving it to the co-ordinator to use in training as what not to do. If anyone puts a positive review after this then all I can say is that you did not read the sections I did! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK.
Excellent and invaluable - keep it by your pillow!, 14 Jan 2008
This is the ONLY book I have needed so far, to feed, wind and settle my now 3 month old baby. Both my baby and I would most certainly be unhappy, stressed out and miserable if it weren't for the advice Clare gives. I was given this book by my tenant who has also recently had a baby, and I was at first reluctant to open ANY book. However, I have read it from cover to cover at least 5 times, either mid-feed in desperation to know what to do next, or during a 'break' from caring for my pumpkin, and I am about to buy another 3 copies to give to friends who are expecting. I am CERTAIN that every mother and baby would benefit from this book. It is an excellent and invaluable support whether you find breastfeeding a tough challenge or a wonderful pleasure. I experience both! Brilliant resource, 13 Nov 2008
This is an invaluable resource for any midwife or student midwife to carry around to dip in to when needed. This book assumes a certain degree of knowledge about anatomy and physiology, pregnancy, and the metabolism of drugs but all medical abreviations used are laid out in a glossary of terms at the beginning.
Drugs are grouped by type and each drug is explored in a very well laid out and logical way detailing both generic and trade names, preparations, doses, contraindications, side effects, interactions as well as an excellent midwifery-centred fetal risk and breastfeeding section for each drug.
Finally, a short and simple reminder of drug calculations as a final chapter makes this a work bag essential. Invaluable while in practice, 30 Jul 2005
This book easy to understand and well organised in its layout, contraindications and side effects of drugs are displayed clearly in sections on the same page. It's not too bulky to carry around if your wanting to take it to work with you. I am in my final year of training as a midwife and find it easier to use than the BNF which can be sometimes difficult to find what you want quickly. I recommend this book to be in any student, or qualified midwifes top 5 buys Excellent, wouldn't be without it, 15 May 2005
I am a student midwife and whilst on placement am constantly hearing names of drugs and often don't have the opportunity for them to be fully explined to me, and the BNF can be confusing so i wanted something I could take on placement with me and look things up in. This is perfect, small and set out in sections of different drug types, including usage, dosage, routes of admin, contraindications, side effects, effects on fetus and breastfeeding. Its easy to understand and each drug is easy to find, theres enough information to aid understanding but it doesnt go too in depth and confuse! Definitely recommend this book, I use it all the time and would be lost without it! Doesn't exactly do what it says on the tin, 20 Jun 2008
A very misleading title - doesn't really do what it says.
Imagine that you wanted a book about how to repair a bicycle puncture. You go out and buy 'Bicycle Punctures for Beginners' and expect to find some instructions on how to repair punctures, maybe some clear, labeled diagrams some hints and tips on how to repair particularly tricky punctures, that kind of thing.
What you don't expect is a book about the environmental benefits of riding a bicycle as opposed to driving a car. The importance of riding a bicycle, other people's opinions on bicycles, where you can ride your bicycle and what to do if you can't ride a bicycle. But don't forget, cars are generally pretty bad things.
Whilst this is a slightly exaggerated analogy, this 16 chapter-long book has just six short pages on the actual mechanics of, you know, breastfeeding. There are some pictures, but they're not annotated or labeled in any way. There is talk of different positions and holds but no diagrams of them to relate to (what does an 'underarm hold' look like? No idea? Me neither). In fact, nearly every picture is of a mother gazing adoringly at their baby. Is this the trick?
I don't need beating round the head repeatedly about the benefits of breastfeeding - I've just bought the book, of course I want to breastfeed! Every other book I own and every healthcare professional I come into contact with are doing a perfectly adequate job of backing this up, thanks. What I needed were some guidance on 'How?', not 'Why?'.
There may well be comprehensive books on how to breastfeed out there, but this isn't it. If, however you want a book about pros and cons on breastfeeding as a concept or a general overview, then this is worth a read. There are much better books out there, 17 Jan 2008
I found this book far too prescriptive and not very helpful at all. I actually put it in the bin and relied entirely on 'So That's What They're For'. Great resource for a beginner!, 16 May 2003
I really enjoyed reading this book. It was supportive without being too militant. It answered a lot of questions I had about breastfeeding and I am sure I will refer to it often when I have my baby. The only reason why it didn't get 5 stars was I thought it was a little short and could have had some picture or diagrams describing how to position the baby instead of just a written description. Brief giude to the basics, 02 May 2003
Ok as far as it goes but only covers the bare essentials - good if your baby has turned up in a hurry and you don't have time to read more than a few pages! Other books (such as 'So that's what their for') contain more information that answers more questions The book title says it all really, 09 Nov 2002
This is a great book for first time breastfeeders. Just the right amount of information and you have the security that, coming from the NCT, its going to be accurate, research based information. Every woman coming to breastfeeding for the first time should be issued this book in pregnancy - it covers not only the common things like positioning and how milk is made but also common problems too. One of the most powerful books ever written, 17 Mar 2008
I was overwhelmed when I read this book. I think it should be required reading in schools. It's so much more than just about how you feed a baby. It shows how choices have been taken away from women - and men - and how corrupt the world is. It's profoundly powerful, and sad in places. Everyone should read this book. I wonder why Oprah hasn't got hold of it yet? Powerful book! A real eye-opener!, 15 May 2001
I often wondered why women do not breastfeed anymore. Is it because it seems easier to bottlefeed, is it because they heard so much about possible problems, is it just because they are to vain and afraid what it will do to their breasts, etc? Then I came across this book... breastfeeding is a long forgotten art, caused by many factors, main of them change in woman's place in society and workplace through industrial revolution, forceful and false advertising of artificial baby foods from manufacturers, often supported by medical profession, etc. This book is a great study of the phenomena of breastfeeding (or rather its decline) and is well researched and supported by references of studies. The style is very friendly and easy to read, full of photos and with the extensive reference guide at the end. I strongly recommend this book not only to mothers, but also to medical profession, anyone who studies the history of economics, media or advertising as well as human relations! An absolute MUST read!
Useful breastfeeding info as well as politics, 03 Feb 1999
This book will make you angry, as it describes the way many women and babies have been conned out of their birthright. However, it is not just about politics. It contains plenty of information about breastfeeding and health (for both mother and baby), with references. The writing style is easy to read and entertaining, and lots of anecdotes make it personal in tone. There is practical information on breastfeeding too - good to read BEFORE you have a child. As far as the 'politics' bit goes, the book was stimulating, informative, and yes, I got angry. This is despite the fact that I disagreed totally with the author's views on economics - she is straight out of the pages of the Socialist Workers Student Society newsletter. She appears to blame most of the world's evils on the free market, but it was Government-employed medical staff who wrecked breastfeeding in the 1950s and thereabouts. Nestle & co may peddle artificial baby milks, but women only started using them when doctors, midwives or health visitors told them to supplement. Aside from that, great book - exposes the pro-bottlefeeding arguments for the deceitful tosh that they are.
A real eye opener!, 10 Jul 1998
As someone who had to defend breastfeeding my child, I already had strong views about how society looks at the practise. The first time I read this book (first edition)I found the history behind it fascinating. What really alarmed me, though, was the truth behind formulas and what used to pass as formula! After getting the second edition, I was dismayed to find that nothing had improved in 10 years. This book is well researched an passionate. Be warned! After reading this, you may just become an activist!
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Customer Reviews
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK!, 15 Nov 2008
I am a trained midwife, currently practising as a maternity nurse. I like to read to keep up to date with what the women I work with are reading. I would NEVER recommend this book. It is full of inaccurate sweeping statements and not even one single reference - the whole book is solely based on what she thinks! NEVER take a book seriously if it can't be backed up with references.
The book regularly had me shouting out loud at her inaccuracies (eg re getting baby to take a bottle 'You can use the same bottle of milk for up to one-and-a-half hours, reheating it as often as is necessary to keep it at an attractive temperature for him.' - JUST NOT TRUE AND ACTUALLY POTENTIALLY DANGEROUS) and therefore had me extremely worried about ALL the advice she was giving. Some of it is so inaccurate and misleading.
Never once in this book does she suggest holding your baby or playing with your baby. It's all feed, wind, sleep. What about relationship and nurturing? I think she's missed an important point about breast feeding and the early days relationship.
Breast feeding doesn't require a text book. It requires patience, common sense, a good sense of humour and a relaxed approach. If you're really struggling see a local breast feeding counsellor (BUT even then be wary, and follow your gut and your heart, and your baby!).
The book desperately needs updating, but preferably, in my opinion needs removing from the market. DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! Just what I needed!, 28 Aug 2008
This book was a real God-send when my baby was born. I think that it is written in a very pragmatic and realistic manner and is simple to work with. I was nearly put off by the lack of glossy pictures but after dipping into it many a time I realised that what mattered was good content rather than expensive photography. I have recommended this to all my friends expecting babies and plan to use it next time round. One of the most valuable books I had during the early months. Breastfeeding should be easy but sadly that isn't always the case and since many grandmothers didn't breastfeed (my mum was in the bottle is best generation) they can't pass on their advice as was the way in the past. The most helpful baby book ever!!!, 26 Jun 2008
Just a quick review. I am soooo glad that I ignored the negative reviews of this book. We bought the book and the DVD by Clare Byam-Cook and it really helped. My wife was having a lot of trouble breast feeding and we had no support from the midwives, this book and the dvd changed all that. My wife is now able to breast feed quite well but still using bottle feeding. It is a very morale boosting book, with most other books and NHS literature giving women guilty feelings for not being able to breast feed.
Buy it!! Dreafdul, 03 Apr 2008
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! I was wandering round Mothercare and thought this might be useful. I had had difficulties right from the beginning with latching sore nipples etc etc., but about 8 weeks in and with nipple shields all was well. However, I was wondering if I had enough milk and followed her advice for finding out if I did. Within in a day I was defrosting frozen milk (surplus you notice). LUCKILY, I came across a superb website whilst waiting for good advice response from an email sent to our breastfeeding co-ordinator. A very comprehensive website which includes lots of advice on milk supply and what are not signs of poor supply (i.e. what I thought!) By the following day I was back to expressing surplus. He was weighed the next day and had put on 9oz! I don't think there was anything wrong with my supply - one day didn't make 9oz!
Many readers here have found this book helpful. There may well be areas that are, however it probably depends which section you read and as you can see I would have been using formula top ups as would any woman following this advice as it is inaccurate as you will find out from any expert on breastfeeding and/or websites. I had got through the difficulties and this book set me back! I fully understand that breastfeeding is not easy and had I read this book earlier I would have had more problems! Her whole premise of breast milk supply is wrong, physiology, mechanisms and latching. (e.g. breasts do not empty) If you still think that she is right then it means that every other medical person in the country and beyond that deals with breastfeeding is wrong! Just because people pay for her services does not mean that she is right! As far as I aware all the organisations set up to support breastfeeding do not support this author, there is little to no evidence for much of what she says but there is to the contrary!
Get advice from breastfeeding counsellors/co-ordinators/organisations and websites. Free, helpful and accurate. I would not still be exclusively or even partly breastfeeding had it not been for the hospital breastfeeding co-ordinator. I was going to sell this book on Amazon! However I would not wish anyone to go through the worry I did and feel it would be morally wrong! I am giving it to the co-ordinator to use in training as what not to do. If anyone puts a positive review after this then all I can say is that you did not read the sections I did! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK.
Excellent and invaluable - keep it by your pillow!, 14 Jan 2008
This is the ONLY book I have needed so far, to feed, wind and settle my now 3 month old baby. Both my baby and I would most certainly be unhappy, stressed out and miserable if it weren't for the advice Clare gives. I was given this book by my tenant who has also recently had a baby, and I was at first reluctant to open ANY book. However, I have read it from cover to cover at least 5 times, either mid-feed in desperation to know what to do next, or during a 'break' from caring for my pumpkin, and I am about to buy another 3 copies to give to friends who are expecting. I am CERTAIN that every mother and baby would benefit from this book. It is an excellent and invaluable support whether you find breastfeeding a tough challenge or a wonderful pleasure. I experience both! Brilliant resource, 13 Nov 2008
This is an invaluable resource for any midwife or student midwife to carry around to dip in to when needed. This book assumes a certain degree of knowledge about anatomy and physiology, pregnancy, and the metabolism of drugs but all medical abreviations used are laid out in a glossary of terms at the beginning.
Drugs are grouped by type and each drug is explored in a very well laid out and logical way detailing both generic and trade names, preparations, doses, contraindications, side effects, interactions as well as an excellent midwifery-centred fetal risk and breastfeeding section for each drug.
Finally, a short and simple reminder of drug calculations as a final chapter makes this a work bag essential. Invaluable while in practice, 30 Jul 2005
This book easy to understand and well organised in its layout, contraindications and side effects of drugs are displayed clearly in sections on the same page. It's not too bulky to carry around if your wanting to take it to work with you. I am in my final year of training as a midwife and find it easier to use than the BNF which can be sometimes difficult to find what you want quickly. I recommend this book to be in any student, or qualified midwifes top 5 buys Excellent, wouldn't be without it, 15 May 2005
I am a student midwife and whilst on placement am constantly hearing names of drugs and often don't have the opportunity for them to be fully explined to me, and the BNF can be confusing so i wanted something I could take on placement with me and look things up in. This is perfect, small and set out in sections of different drug types, including usage, dosage, routes of admin, contraindications, side effects, effects on fetus and breastfeeding. Its easy to understand and each drug is easy to find, theres enough information to aid understanding but it doesnt go too in depth and confuse! Definitely recommend this book, I use it all the time and would be lost without it! Doesn't exactly do what it says on the tin, 20 Jun 2008
A very misleading title - doesn't really do what it says.
Imagine that you wanted a book about how to repair a bicycle puncture. You go out and buy 'Bicycle Punctures for Beginners' and expect to find some instructions on how to repair punctures, maybe some clear, labeled diagrams some hints and tips on how to repair particularly tricky punctures, that kind of thing.
What you don't expect is a book about the environmental benefits of riding a bicycle as opposed to driving a car. The importance of riding a bicycle, other people's opinions on bicycles, where you can ride your bicycle and what to do if you can't ride a bicycle. But don't forget, cars are generally pretty bad things.
Whilst this is a slightly exaggerated analogy, this 16 chapter-long book has just six short pages on the actual mechanics of, you know, breastfeeding. There are some pictures, but they're not annotated or labeled in any way. There is talk of different positions and holds but no diagrams of them to relate to (what does an 'underarm hold' look like? No idea? Me neither). In fact, nearly every picture is of a mother gazing adoringly at their baby. Is this the trick?
I don't need beating round the head repeatedly about the benefits of breastfeeding - I've just bought the book, of course I want to breastfeed! Every other book I own and every healthcare professional I come into contact with are doing a perfectly adequate job of backing this up, thanks. What I needed were some guidance on 'How?', not 'Why?'.
There may well be comprehensive books on how to breastfeed out there, but this isn't it. If, however you want a book about pros and cons on breastfeeding as a concept or a general overview, then this is worth a read. There are much better books out there, 17 Jan 2008
I found this book far too prescriptive and not very helpful at all. I actually put it in the bin and relied entirely on 'So That's What They're For'. Great resource for a beginner!, 16 May 2003
I really enjoyed reading this book. It was supportive without being too militant. It answered a lot of questions I had about breastfeeding and I am sure I will refer to it often when I have my baby. The only reason why it didn't get 5 stars was I thought it was a little short and could have had some picture or diagrams describing how to position the baby instead of just a written description. Brief giude to the basics, 02 May 2003
Ok as far as it goes but only covers the bare essentials - good if your baby has turned up in a hurry and you don't have time to read more than a few pages! Other books (such as 'So that's what their for') contain more information that answers more questions The book title says it all really, 09 Nov 2002
This is a great book for first time breastfeeders. Just the right amount of information and you have the security that, coming from the NCT, its going to be accurate, research based information. Every woman coming to breastfeeding for the first time should be issued this book in pregnancy - it covers not only the common things like positioning and how milk is made but also common problems too. One of the most powerful books ever written, 17 Mar 2008
I was overwhelmed when I read this book. I think it should be required reading in schools. It's so much more than just about how you feed a baby. It shows how choices have been taken away from women - and men - and how corrupt the world is. It's profoundly powerful, and sad in places. Everyone should read this book. I wonder why Oprah hasn't got hold of it yet? Powerful book! A real eye-opener!, 15 May 2001
I often wondered why women do not breastfeed anymore. Is it because it seems easier to bottlefeed, is it because they heard so much about possible problems, is it just because they are to vain and afraid what it will do to their breasts, etc? Then I came across this book... breastfeeding is a long forgotten art, caused by many factors, main of them change in woman's place in society and workplace through industrial revolution, forceful and false advertising of artificial baby foods from manufacturers, often supported by medical profession, etc. This book is a great study of the phenomena of breastfeeding (or rather its decline) and is well researched and supported by references of studies. The style is very friendly and easy to read, full of photos and with the extensive reference guide at the end. I strongly recommend this book not only to mothers, but also to medical profession, anyone who studies the history of economics, media or advertising as well as human relations! An absolute MUST read!
Useful breastfeeding info as well as politics, 03 Feb 1999
This book will make you angry, as it describes the way many women and babies have been conned out of their birthright. However, it is not just about politics. It contains plenty of information about breastfeeding and health (for both mother and baby), with references. The writing style is easy to read and entertaining, and lots of anecdotes make it personal in tone. There is practical information on breastfeeding too - good to read BEFORE you have a child. As far as the 'politics' bit goes, the book was stimulating, informative, and yes, I got angry. This is despite the fact that I disagreed totally with the author's views on economics - she is straight out of the pages of the Socialist Workers Student Society newsletter. She appears to blame most of the world's evils on the free market, but it was Government-employed medical staff who wrecked breastfeeding in the 1950s and thereabouts. Nestle & co may peddle artificial baby milks, but women only started using them when doctors, midwives or health visitors told them to supplement. Aside from that, great book - exposes the pro-bottlefeeding arguments for the deceitful tosh that they are.
A real eye opener!, 10 Jul 1998
As someone who had to defend breastfeeding my child, I already had strong views about how society looks at the practise. The first time I read this book (first edition)I found the history behind it fascinating. What really alarmed me, though, was the truth behind formulas and what used to pass as formula! After getting the second edition, I was dismayed to find that nothing had improved in 10 years. This book is well researched an passionate. Be warned! After reading this, you may just become an activist!
Inspirational, 01 Dec 2008
I bought an earlier edition of this book in 1993 when nursing my first child. It is informative, interesting and supportive, the next best thing to having a La Leche League leader in my cupboard.
The book does not only give information on breastfeeding but many other aspects of parenting too. Ideally read it while you are pregnant and make contact with your local LLL group as early as you can. Hospital midwives do support breastfeeding but are always so busy, an LLL leader will make time for you and support you through the hard times, the core members of my group became like extended famiy to us.
Very American, but lots of good information., 04 Jul 2007
Excellent for a reference guide, but as another reviewer says, don't try and read it all at once! It is a bit American in its style and you may find parts of it a little prescriptive, but if you use it to refer to in case of any problems, it's serving its purpose.
Comprehensive book, but rather American, 15 Jan 2007
I like this book but if you read it in one go it will make you sick! It's too saccharin American and a bit too earth mother for me. That said, the questions I had on breastfeeding were answered in this book. Use it as a reference textbook and it's fantastic. Oh and bear in mind that whilst breastfeeding can be absolutely awful to begin with... those sickly sweet comments I was moaning about become true about 3 months down the line when you and your baby have got the hang of it. It really is worth perserving with. Buy this book, but more importantly find out where your local LLL group is and make contact with them when you are pregnant. Happy Breastfeeding!!
I would thoroughly recommend this book, 11 Jan 2006
I bought this book even though I am on my 3rd child!! Have breast fed both times before, but had to go back to work early both times, so didn't feed much beyond this and wanted to get some perspective on feeding beyond the first few months. I would recommend this book whether you are on your first or subsequent child, as it really does have something for everyone. Would be a really nice present for a mum to be to help prepare for breast feeding too. I found the bits on how breastfeeding works and how amazing breast milk is really fascinating and also very supportive, as I have had a few ambivalent comments and was able to say - "aha, but..."
Fantastic book, 03 Mar 2005
I love this book. It gives both the basics on how to breastfeed and also lots of more general parenting information. It also looks at the comman and not so comman problems and gives helpful and reassuring advice. Although quite American sometimes the basic mother baby relationship is the same the world over! I have referred to my copy at least once a week over the past 20 months of breastfeeding. I would recommend it to everyone wanting to breastfeed or wanting to know more about breastfeeding
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Customer Reviews
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK!, 15 Nov 2008
I am a trained midwife, currently practising as a maternity nurse. I like to read to keep up to date with what the women I work with are reading. I would NEVER recommend this book. It is full of inaccurate sweeping statements and not even one single reference - the whole book is solely based on what she thinks! NEVER take a book seriously if it can't be backed up with references.
The book regularly had me shouting out loud at her inaccuracies (eg re getting baby to take a bottle 'You can use the same bottle of milk for up to one-and-a-half hours, reheating it as often as is necessary to keep it at an attractive temperature for him.' - JUST NOT TRUE AND ACTUALLY POTENTIALLY DANGEROUS) and therefore had me extremely worried about ALL the advice she was giving. Some of it is so inaccurate and misleading.
Never once in this book does she suggest holding your baby or playing with your baby. It's all feed, wind, sleep. What about relationship and nurturing? I think she's missed an important point about breast feeding and the early days relationship.
Breast feeding doesn't require a text book. It requires patience, common sense, a good sense of humour and a relaxed approach. If you're really struggling see a local breast feeding counsellor (BUT even then be wary, and follow your gut and your heart, and your baby!).
The book desperately needs updating, but preferably, in my opinion needs removing from the market. DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! Just what I needed!, 28 Aug 2008
This book was a real God-send when my baby was born. I think that it is written in a very pragmatic and realistic manner and is simple to work with. I was nearly put off by the lack of glossy pictures but after dipping into it many a time I realised that what mattered was good content rather than expensive photography. I have recommended this to all my friends expecting babies and plan to use it next time round. One of the most valuable books I had during the early months. Breastfeeding should be easy but sadly that isn't always the case and since many grandmothers didn't breastfeed (my mum was in the bottle is best generation) they can't pass on their advice as was the way in the past. The most helpful baby book ever!!!, 26 Jun 2008
Just a quick review. I am soooo glad that I ignored the negative reviews of this book. We bought the book and the DVD by Clare Byam-Cook and it really helped. My wife was having a lot of trouble breast feeding and we had no support from the midwives, this book and the dvd changed all that. My wife is now able to breast feed quite well but still using bottle feeding. It is a very morale boosting book, with most other books and NHS literature giving women guilty feelings for not being able to breast feed.
Buy it!! Dreafdul, 03 Apr 2008
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! I was wandering round Mothercare and thought this might be useful. I had had difficulties right from the beginning with latching sore nipples etc etc., but about 8 weeks in and with nipple shields all was well. However, I was wondering if I had enough milk and followed her advice for finding out if I did. Within in a day I was defrosting frozen milk (surplus you notice). LUCKILY, I came across a superb website whilst waiting for good advice response from an email sent to our breastfeeding co-ordinator. A very comprehensive website which includes lots of advice on milk supply and what are not signs of poor supply (i.e. what I thought!) By the following day I was back to expressing surplus. He was weighed the next day and had put on 9oz! I don't think there was anything wrong with my supply - one day didn't make 9oz!
Many readers here have found this book helpful. There may well be areas that are, however it probably depends which section you read and as you can see I would have been using formula top ups as would any woman following this advice as it is inaccurate as you will find out from any expert on breastfeeding and/or websites. I had got through the difficulties and this book set me back! I fully understand that breastfeeding is not easy and had I read this book earlier I would have had more problems! Her whole premise of breast milk supply is wrong, physiology, mechanisms and latching. (e.g. breasts do not empty) If you still think that she is right then it means that every other medical person in the country and beyond that deals with breastfeeding is wrong! Just because people pay for her services does not mean that she is right! As far as I aware all the organisations set up to support breastfeeding do not support this author, there is little to no evidence for much of what she says but there is to the contrary!
Get advice from breastfeeding counsellors/co-ordinators/organisations and websites. Free, helpful and accurate. I would not still be exclusively or even partly breastfeeding had it not been for the hospital breastfeeding co-ordinator. I was going to sell this book on Amazon! However I would not wish anyone to go through the worry I did and feel it would be morally wrong! I am giving it to the co-ordinator to use in training as what not to do. If anyone puts a positive review after this then all I can say is that you did not read the sections I did! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK.
Excellent and invaluable - keep it by your pillow!, 14 Jan 2008
This is the ONLY book I have needed so far, to feed, wind and settle my now 3 month old baby. Both my baby and I would most certainly be unhappy, stressed out and miserable if it weren't for the advice Clare gives. I was given this book by my tenant who has also recently had a baby, and I was at first reluctant to open ANY book. However, I have read it from cover to cover at least 5 times, either mid-feed in desperation to know what to do next, or during a 'break' from caring for my pumpkin, and I am about to buy another 3 copies to give to friends who are expecting. I am CERTAIN that every mother and baby would benefit from this book. It is an excellent and invaluable support whether you find breastfeeding a tough challenge or a wonderful pleasure. I experience both! Brilliant resource, 13 Nov 2008
This is an invaluable resource for any midwife or student midwife to carry around to dip in to when needed. This book assumes a certain degree of knowledge about anatomy and physiology, pregnancy, and the metabolism of drugs but all medical abreviations used are laid out in a glossary of terms at the beginning.
Drugs are grouped by type and each drug is explored in a very well laid out and logical way detailing both generic and trade names, preparations, doses, contraindications, side effects, interactions as well as an excellent midwifery-centred fetal risk and breastfeeding section for each drug.
Finally, a short and simple reminder of drug calculations as a final chapter makes this a work bag essential. Invaluable while in practice, 30 Jul 2005
This book easy to understand and well organised in its layout, contraindications and side effects of drugs are displayed clearly in sections on the same page. It's not too bulky to carry around if your wanting to take it to work with you. I am in my final year of training as a midwife and find it easier to use than the BNF which can be sometimes difficult to find what you want quickly. I recommend this book to be in any student, or qualified midwifes top 5 buys Excellent, wouldn't be without it, 15 May 2005
I am a student midwife and whilst on placement am constantly hearing names of drugs and often don't have the opportunity for them to be fully explined to me, and the BNF can be confusing so i wanted something I could take on placement with me and look things up in. This is perfect, small and set out in sections of different drug types, including usage, dosage, routes of admin, contraindications, side effects, effects on fetus and breastfeeding. Its easy to understand and each drug is easy to find, theres enough information to aid understanding but it doesnt go too in depth and confuse! Definitely recommend this book, I use it all the time and would be lost without it! Doesn't exactly do what it says on the tin, 20 Jun 2008
A very misleading title - doesn't really do what it says.
Imagine that you wanted a book about how to repair a bicycle puncture. You go out and buy 'Bicycle Punctures for Beginners' and expect to find some instructions on how to repair punctures, maybe some clear, labeled diagrams some hints and tips on how to repair particularly tricky punctures, that kind of thing.
What you don't expect is a book about the environmental benefits of riding a bicycle as opposed to driving a car. The importance of riding a bicycle, other people's opinions on bicycles, where you can ride your bicycle and what to do if you can't ride a bicycle. But don't forget, cars are generally pretty bad things.
Whilst this is a slightly exaggerated analogy, this 16 chapter-long book has just six short pages on the actual mechanics of, you know, breastfeeding. There are some pictures, but they're not annotated or labeled in any way. There is talk of different positions and holds but no diagrams of them to relate to (what does an 'underarm hold' look like? No idea? Me neither). In fact, nearly every picture is of a mother gazing adoringly at their baby. Is this the trick?
I don't need beating round the head repeatedly about the benefits of breastfeeding - I've just bought the book, of course I want to breastfeed! Every other book I own and every healthcare professional I come into contact with are doing a perfectly adequate job of backing this up, thanks. What I needed were some guidance on 'How?', not 'Why?'.
There may well be comprehensive books on how to breastfeed out there, but this isn't it. If, however you want a book about pros and cons on breastfeeding as a concept or a general overview, then this is worth a read. There are much better books out there, 17 Jan 2008
I found this book far too prescriptive and not very helpful at all. I actually put it in the bin and relied entirely on 'So That's What They're For'. Great resource for a beginner!, 16 May 2003
I really enjoyed reading this book. It was supportive without being too militant. It answered a lot of questions I had about breastfeeding and I am sure I will refer to it often when I have my baby. The only reason why it didn't get 5 stars was I thought it was a little short and could have had some picture or diagrams describing how to position the baby instead of just a written description. Brief giude to the basics, 02 May 2003
Ok as far as it goes but only covers the bare essentials - good if your baby has turned up in a hurry and you don't have time to read more than a few pages! Other books (such as 'So that's what their for') contain more information that answers more questions The book title says it all really, 09 Nov 2002
This is a great book for first time breastfeeders. Just the right amount of information and you have the security that, coming from the NCT, its going to be accurate, research based information. Every woman coming to breastfeeding for the first time should be issued this book in pregnancy - it covers not only the common things like positioning and how milk is made but also common problems too. One of the most powerful books ever written, 17 Mar 2008
I was overwhelmed when I read this book. I think it should be required reading in schools. It's so much more than just about how you feed a baby. It shows how choices have been taken away from women - and men - and how corrupt the world is. It's profoundly powerful, and sad in places. Everyone should read this book. I wonder why Oprah hasn't got hold of it yet? Powerful book! A real eye-opener!, 15 May 2001
I often wondered why women do not breastfeed anymore. Is it because it seems easier to bottlefeed, is it because they heard so much about possible problems, is it just because they are to vain and afraid what it will do to their breasts, etc? Then I came across this book... breastfeeding is a long forgotten art, caused by many factors, main of them change in woman's place in society and workplace through industrial revolution, forceful and false advertising of artificial baby foods from manufacturers, often supported by medical profession, etc. This book is a great study of the phenomena of breastfeeding (or rather its decline) and is well researched and supported by references of studies. The style is very friendly and easy to read, full of photos and with the extensive reference guide at the end. I strongly recommend this book not only to mothers, but also to medical profession, anyone who studies the history of economics, media or advertising as well as human relations! An absolute MUST read!
Useful breastfeeding info as well as politics, 03 Feb 1999
This book will make you angry, as it describes the way many women and babies have been conned out of their birthright. However, it is not just about politics. It contains plenty of information about breastfeeding and health (for both mother and baby), with references. The writing style is easy to read and entertaining, and lots of anecdotes make it personal in tone. There is practical information on breastfeeding too - good to read BEFORE you have a child. As far as the 'politics' bit goes, the book was stimulating, informative, and yes, I got angry. This is despite the fact that I disagreed totally with the author's views on economics - she is straight out of the pages of the Socialist Workers Student Society newsletter. She appears to blame most of the world's evils on the free market, but it was Government-employed medical staff who wrecked breastfeeding in the 1950s and thereabouts. Nestle & co may peddle artificial baby milks, but women only started using them when doctors, midwives or health visitors told them to supplement. Aside from that, great book - exposes the pro-bottlefeeding arguments for the deceitful tosh that they are.
A real eye opener!, 10 Jul 1998
As someone who had to defend breastfeeding my child, I already had strong views about how society looks at the practise. The first time I read this book (first edition)I found the history behind it fascinating. What really alarmed me, though, was the truth behind formulas and what used to pass as formula! After getting the second edition, I was dismayed to find that nothing had improved in 10 years. This book is well researched an passionate. Be warned! After reading this, you may just become an activist!
Inspirational, 01 Dec 2008
I bought an earlier edition of this book in 1993 when nursing my first child. It is informative, interesting and supportive, the next best thing to having a La Leche League leader in my cupboard.
The book does not only give information on breastfeeding but many other aspects of parenting too. Ideally read it while you are pregnant and make contact with your local LLL group as early as you can. Hospital midwives do support breastfeeding but are always so busy, an LLL leader will make time for you and support you through the hard times, the core members of my group became like extended famiy to us.
Very American, but lots of good information., 04 Jul 2007
Excellent for a reference guide, but as another reviewer says, don't try and read it all at once! It is a bit American in its style and you may find parts of it a little prescriptive, but if you use it to refer to in case of any problems, it's serving its purpose.
Comprehensive book, but rather American, 15 Jan 2007
I like this book but if you read it in one go it will make you sick! It's too saccharin American and a bit too earth mother for me. That said, the questions I had on breastfeeding were answered in this book. Use it as a reference textbook and it's fantastic. Oh and bear in mind that whilst breastfeeding can be absolutely awful to begin with... those sickly sweet comments I was moaning about become true about 3 months down the line when you and your baby have got the hang of it. It really is worth perserving with. Buy this book, but more importantly find out where your local LLL group is and make contact with them when you are pregnant. Happy Breastfeeding!!
I would thoroughly recommend this book, 11 Jan 2006
I bought this book even though I am on my 3rd child!! Have breast fed both times before, but had to go back to work early both times, so didn't feed much beyond this and wanted to get some perspective on feeding beyond the first few months. I would recommend this book whether you are on your first or subsequent child, as it really does have something for everyone. Would be a really nice present for a mum to be to help prepare for breast feeding too. I found the bits on how breastfeeding works and how amazing breast milk is really fascinating and also very supportive, as I have had a few ambivalent comments and was able to say - "aha, but..."
Fantastic book, 03 Mar 2005
I love this book. It gives both the basics on how to breastfeed and also lots of more general parenting information. It also looks at the comman and not so comman problems and gives helpful and reassuring advice. Although quite American sometimes the basic mother baby relationship is the same the world over! I have referred to my copy at least once a week over the past 20 months of breastfeeding. I would recommend it to everyone wanting to breastfeed or wanting to know more about breastfeeding
Very Interesting, 21 Nov 2008
I knew nothing about breastfeeding before I bought this book and I read the reviews on here and thought it was the best book for me.
I found it very imformative and thoroughly enjoyed the writing stlye. The author made it easy to read and it was full of helpful hints and tips and some of them were not even about breastfeeding.
I didnt buy any other books on the market in this subject as I felt that this had everything that I needed. I have kept it even though I have stopped breastfeeding as I may want to refer back to it next time.
Definately recommend and its great value for money too.
Brilliant, 13 Oct 2008
This book contains EVERYTHING you might want to ever know about breastfeeding. It's written in a clear, easy to read way so it's not a chore to read.
It's main joy is how comprehensive it is. It goes through the benefits, how to do it, weaning, sleeping, just everything. I don't know how she fits it all into a normal sized book!
I could not have managed without this book, 17 Jan 2008
This book is a lifesaver. The fantastic mixture of facts, advice and humour meant that I just couldn't put it down (used my free hand). I didn't manage to successfully breastfeed my first child (for various reasons) and was determined to do it for my second. This book gave me much more advice (and more useful advice) than any midwife or well meaning friend/relative plus it actually made me laugh out loud!
This is a must have!, 21 Oct 2007
I loved this book so much I couldn't put it down. It is full of information and I would say it covers just about everything you would ever want to know. I am always going back to this book and going over chapters again when a new problem arises (as they do!) or I want an answer to a particular question. I actually believe this book has helped to keep me breastfeeding - especially because the author doesn't claim to be a so called expert and encountered problems herself and it has certainly made me stop and think when I feel like reaching for the formula tin. I'm glad I read this book and would happily recommend it.
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Customer Reviews
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK!, 15 Nov 2008
I am a trained midwife, currently practising as a maternity nurse. I like to read to keep up to date with what the women I work with are reading. I would NEVER recommend this book. It is full of inaccurate sweeping statements and not even one single reference - the whole book is solely based on what she thinks! NEVER take a book seriously if it can't be backed up with references.
The book regularly had me shouting out loud at her inaccuracies (eg re getting baby to take a bottle 'You can use the same bottle of milk for up to one-and-a-half hours, reheating it as often as is necessary to keep it at an attractive temperature for him.' - JUST NOT TRUE AND ACTUALLY POTENTIALLY DANGEROUS) and therefore had me extremely worried about ALL the advice she was giving. Some of it is so inaccurate and misleading.
Never once in this book does she suggest holding your baby or playing with your baby. It's all feed, wind, sleep. What about relationship and nurturing? I think she's missed an important point about breast feeding and the early days relationship.
Breast feeding doesn't require a text book. It requires patience, common sense, a good sense of humour and a relaxed approach. If you're really struggling see a local breast feeding counsellor (BUT even then be wary, and follow your gut and your heart, and your baby!).
The book desperately needs updating, but preferably, in my opinion needs removing from the market. DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! Just what I needed!, 28 Aug 2008
This book was a real God-send when my baby was born. I think that it is written in a very pragmatic and realistic manner and is simple to work with. I was nearly put off by the lack of glossy pictures but after dipping into it many a time I realised that what mattered was good content rather than expensive photography. I have recommended this to all my friends expecting babies and plan to use it next time round. One of the most valuable books I had during the early months. Breastfeeding should be easy but sadly that isn't always the case and since many grandmothers didn't breastfeed (my mum was in the bottle is best generation) they can't pass on their advice as was the way in the past. The most helpful baby book ever!!!, 26 Jun 2008
Just a quick review. I am soooo glad that I ignored the negative reviews of this book. We bought the book and the DVD by Clare Byam-Cook and it really helped. My wife was having a lot of trouble breast feeding and we had no support from the midwives, this book and the dvd changed all that. My wife is now able to breast feed quite well but still using bottle feeding. It is a very morale boosting book, with most other books and NHS literature giving women guilty feelings for not being able to breast feed.
Buy it!! Dreafdul, 03 Apr 2008
DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK! I was wandering round Mothercare and thought this might be useful. I had had difficulties right from the beginning with latching sore nipples etc etc., but about 8 weeks in and with nipple shields all was well. However, I was wondering if I had enough milk and followed her advice for finding out if I did. Within in a day I was defrosting frozen milk (surplus you notice). LUCKILY, I came across a superb website whilst waiting for good advice response from an email sent to our breastfeeding co-ordinator. A very comprehensive website which includes lots of advice on milk supply and what are not signs of poor supply (i.e. what I thought!) By the following day I was back to expressing surplus. He was weighed the next day and had put on 9oz! I don't think there was anything wrong with my supply - one day didn't make 9oz!
Many readers here have found this book helpful. There may well be areas that are, however it probably depends which section you read and as you can see I would have been using formula top ups as would any woman following this advice as it is inaccurate as you will find out from any expert on breastfeeding and/or websites. I had got through the difficulties and this book set me back! I fully understand that breastfeeding is not easy and had I read this book earlier I would have had more problems! Her whole premise of breast milk supply is wrong, physiology, mechanisms and latching. (e.g. breasts do not empty) If you still think that she is right then it means that every other medical person in the country and beyond that deals with breastfeeding is wrong! Just because people pay for her services does not mean that she is right! As far as I aware all the organisations set up to support breastfeeding do not support this author, there is little to no evidence for much of what she says but there is to the contrary!
Get advice from breastfeeding counsellors/co-ordinators/organisations and websites. Free, helpful and accurate. I would not still be exclusively or even partly breastfeeding had it not been for the hospital breastfeeding co-ordinator. I was going to sell this book on Amazon! However I would not wish anyone to go through the worry I did and feel it would be morally wrong! I am giving it to the co-ordinator to use in training as what not to do. If anyone puts a positive review after this then all I can say is that you did not read the sections I did! DO NOT BUY THIS BOOK.
Excellent and invaluable - keep it by your pillow!, 14 Jan 2008
This is the ONLY book I have needed so far, to feed, wind and settle my now 3 month old baby. Both my baby and I would most certainly be unhappy, stressed out and miserable if it weren't for the advice Clare gives. I was given this book by my tenant who has also recently had a baby, and I was at first reluctant to open ANY book. However, I have read it from cover to cover at least 5 times, either mid-feed in desperation to know what to do next, or during a 'break' from caring for my pumpkin, and I am about to buy another 3 copies to give to friends who are expecting. I am CERTAIN that every mother and baby would benefit from this book. It is an excellent and invaluable support whether you find breastfeeding a tough challenge or a wonderful pleasure. I experience both! Brilliant resource, 13 Nov 2008
This is an invaluable resource for any midwife or student midwife to carry around to dip in to when needed. This book assumes a certain degree of knowledge about anatomy and physiology, pregnancy, and the metabolism of drugs but all medical abreviations used are laid out in a glossary of terms at the beginning.
Drugs are grouped by type and each drug is explored in a very well laid out and logical way detailing both generic and trade names, preparations, doses, contraindications, side effects, interactions as well as an excellent midwifery-centred fetal risk and breastfeeding section for each drug.
Finally, a short and simple reminder of drug calculations as a final chapter makes this a work bag essential. Invaluable while in practice, 30 Jul 2005
This book easy to understand and well organised in its layout, contraindications and side effects of drugs are displayed clearly in sections on the same page. It's not too bulky to carry around if your wanting to take it to work with you. I am in my final year of training as a midwife and find it easier to use than the BNF which can be sometimes difficult to find what you want quickly. I recommend this book to be in any student, or qualified midwifes top 5 buys Excellent, wouldn't be without it, 15 May 2005
I am a student midwife and whilst on placement am constantly hearing names of drugs and often don't have the opportunity for them to be fully explined to me, and the BNF can be confusing so i wanted something I could take on placement with me and look things up in. This is perfect, small and set out in sections of different drug types, including usage, dosage, routes of admin, contraindications, side effects, effects on fetus and breastfeeding. Its easy to understand and each drug is easy to find, theres enough information to aid understanding but it doesnt go too in depth and confuse! Definitely recommend this book, I use it all the time and would be lost without it! Doesn't exactly do what it says on the tin, 20 Jun 2008
A very misleading title - doesn't really do what it says.
Imagine that you wanted a book about how to repair a bicycle puncture. You go out and buy 'Bicycle Punctures for Beginners' and expect to find some instructions on how to repair punctures, maybe some clear, labeled diagrams some hints and tips on how to repair particularly tricky punctures, that kind of thing.
What you don't expect is a book about the environmental benefits of riding a bicycle as opposed to driving a car. The importance of riding a bicycle, other people's opinions on bicycles, where you can ride your bicycle and what to do if you can't ride a bicycle. But don't forget, cars are generally pretty bad things.
Whilst this is a slightly exaggerated analogy, this 16 chapter-long book has just six short pages on the actual mechanics of, you know, breastfeeding. There are some pictures, but they're not annotated or labeled in any way. There is talk of different positions and holds but no diagrams of them to relate to (what does an 'underarm hold' look like? No idea? Me neither). In fact, nearly every picture is of a mother gazing adoringly at their baby. Is this the trick?
I don't need beating round the head repeatedly about the benefits of breastfeeding - I've just bought the book, of course I want to breastfeed! Every other book I own and every healthcare professional I come into contact with are doing a perfectly adequate job of backing this up, thanks. What I needed were some guidance on 'How?', not 'Why?'.
There may well be comprehensive books on how to breastfeed out there, but this isn't it. If, however you want a book about pros and cons on breastfeeding as a concept or a general overview, then this is worth a read. There are much better books out there, 17 Jan 2008
I found this book far too prescriptive and not very helpful at all. I actually put it in the bin and relied entirely on 'So That's What They're For'. Great resource for a beginner!, 16 May 2003
I really enjoyed reading this book. It was supportive without being too militant. It answered a lot of questions I had about breastfeeding and I am sure I will refer to it often when I have my baby. The only reason why it didn't get 5 stars was I thought it was a little short and could have had some picture or diagrams describing how to position the baby instead of just a written description. Brief giude to the basics, 02 May 2003
Ok as far as it goes but only covers the bare essentials - good if your baby has turned up in a hurry and you don't have time to read more than a few pages! Other books (such as 'So that's what their for') contain more information that answers more questions The book title says it all really, 09 Nov 2002
This is a great book for first time breastfeeders. Just the right amount of information and you have the security that, coming from the NCT, its going to be accurate, research based information. Every woman coming to breastfeeding for the first time should be issued this book in pregnancy - it covers not only the common things like positioning and how milk is made but also common problems too. One of the most powerful books ever written, 17 Mar 2008
I was overwhelmed when I read this book. I think it should be required reading in schools. It's so much more than just about how you feed a baby. It shows how choices have been taken away from women - and men - and how corrupt the world is. It's profoundly powerful, and sad in places. Everyone should read this book. I wonder why Oprah hasn't got hold of it yet? Powerful book! A real eye-opener!, 15 May 2001
I often wondered why women do not breastfeed anymore. Is it because it seems easier to bottlefeed, is it because they heard so much about possible problems, is it just because they are to vain and afraid what it will do to their breasts, etc? Then I came across this book... breastfeeding is a long forgotten art, caused by many factors, main of them change in woman's place in society and workplace through industrial revolution, forceful and false advertising of artificial baby foods from manufacturers, often supported by medical profession, etc. This book is a great study of the phenomena of breastfeeding (or rather its decline) and is well researched and supported by references of studies. The style is very friendly and easy to read, full of photos and with the extensive reference guide at the end. I strongly recommend this book not only to mothers, but also to medical profession, anyone who studies the history of economics, media or advertising as well as human relations! An absolute MUST read!
Useful breastfeeding info as well as politics, 03 Feb 1999
This book will make you angry, as it describes the way many women and babies have been conned out of their birthright. However, it is not just about politics. It contains plenty of information about breastfeeding and health (for both mother and baby), with references. The writing style is easy to read and entertaining, and lots of anecdotes make it personal in tone. There is practical information on breastfeeding too - good to read BEFORE you have a child. As far as the 'politics' bit goes, the book was stimulating, informative, and yes, I got angry. This is despite the fact that I disagreed totally with the author's views on economics - she is straight out of the pages of the Socialist Workers Student Society newsletter. She appears to blame most of the world's evils on the free market, but it was Government-employed medical staff who wrecked breastfeeding in the 1950s and thereabouts. Nestle & co may peddle artificial baby milks, but women only started using them when doctors, midwives or health visitors told them to supplement. Aside from that, great book - exposes the pro-bottlefeeding arguments for the deceitful tosh that they are.
A real eye opener!, 10 Jul 1998
As someone who had to defend breastfeeding my child, I already had strong views about how society looks at the practise. The first time I read this book (first edition)I found the history behind it fascinating. What really alarmed me, though, was the truth behind formulas and what used to pass as formula! After getting the second edition, I was dismayed to find that nothing had improved in 10 years. This book is well researched an passionate. Be warned! After reading this, you may just become an activist!
Inspirational, 01 Dec 2008
I bought an earlier edition of this book in 1993 when nursing my first child. It is informative, interesting and supportive, the next best thing to having a La Leche League leader in my cupboard.
The book does not only give information on breastfeeding but many other aspects of parenting too. Ideally read it while you are pregnant and make contact with your local LLL group as early as you can. Hospital midwives do support breastfeeding but are always so busy, an LLL leader will make time for you and support you through the hard times, the core members of my group became like extended famiy to us.
Very American, but lots of good information., 04 Jul 2007
Excellent for a reference guide, but as another reviewer says, don't try and read it all at once! It is a bit American in its style and you may find parts of it a little prescriptive, but if you use it to refer to in case of any problems, it's serving its purpose.
Comprehensive book, but rather American, 15 Jan 2007
I like this book but if you read it in one go it will make you sick! It's too saccharin American and a bit too earth mother for me. That said, the questions I had on breastfeeding were answered in this book. Use it as a reference textbook and it's fantastic. Oh and bear in mind that whilst breastfeeding can be absolutely awful to begin with... those sickly sweet comments I was moaning about become true about 3 months down the line when you and your baby have got the hang of it. It really is worth perserving with. Buy this book, but more importantly find out where your local LLL group is and make contact with them when you are pregnant. Happy Breastfeeding!!
I would thoroughly recommend this book, 11 Jan 2006
I bought this book even though I am on my 3rd child!! Have breast fed both times before, but had to go back to work early both times, so didn't feed much beyond this and wanted to get some perspective on feeding beyond the first few months. I would recommend this book whether you are on your first or subsequent child, as it really does have something for everyone. Would be a really nice present for a mum to be to help prepare for breast feeding too. | | |