Superb, 18 Nov 2008
The book covers South African history from the 1870s to 1910, a fascinating period of history involving the clash of British Imperialism, the Afrikaaner states of the Transvaal and Orange Free State, indiginous Zulu uprisings and the beginnings of the pass system. Central characters are Cecil Rhodes, Jameson, Kruger, De La Rey - and their roles in the ultimate disaster of the Anglo-Boer war.

For anyone interested in SA, late Victorian history or history generally, this is a superb book, well written and fascinating.

Superb, 18 Nov 2008
The book covers South African history from the 1870s to 1910, a fascinating period of history involving the clash of British Imperialism, the Afrikaaner states of the Transvaal and Orange Free State, indiginous Zulu uprisings and the beginnings of the pass system. Central characters are Cecil Rhodes, Jameson, Kruger, De La Rey - and their roles in the ultimate disaster of the Anglo-Boer war.

For anyone interested in SA, late Victorian history or history generally, this is a superb book, well written and fascinating.

Very Good, 08 Oct 2008
The Scramble for Africa by Thomas Pakenham is a very good book which deals with the remarkable last two decades in the nineteenth century when Africa was carved up by the nations of Europe. It is an immensely readable book which deals with a number of different areas and time periods but also goes further and deals with individuals and more forgotten examples of European colonisation such as the Belgians in the Congo. All in all a remarkable book which is a pleasure to read.

Great book of a harrowing journey of a continent. , 11 Jun 2008
This is a great book, and like other readers, I think it gave account of every region fairly evenly. Pakenham shows that mistreatment of the native population was endemic across the continent, regardless of the ruling European power. He also managed to avoid romanticizing the situation prior to colonization, bringing to life the personalities of the Kings, Sultans and Chiefs that ruled before the europeans arrived.

Pakenham did however get mixed up with what was British and what was English, as English historians often do.

Best history book ever!, 17 May 2008
Pakenham gives you the detail without the drudgery; the tale without the tediousness; takes you right into the heart of history but manages to make the ride effortless. His story spans two continents, includes a myriad of characters and covers many years of imperial intrigue in Africa. Yet, he not only stays true to the facts, he also gives you a human story. You can close your eyes and see Leopold or Lobengula or any of the hundreds of actors that claimed this stage of human history. Here is a priceless account of how and why it happened; the partition of Africa in the nineteenth century by several European nations. A must read!

Superb, i finished it at 5am!, 09 Apr 2007
This book covers every issue you could possibly think of in colonial africa in just enough detail to give you a pan-african diorama without getting bogged down in any individual area (each of which deserves a book on their own). The only other example ive read got so bogged down with the Boer war that lesser known colonial hi-jinx such as the Sudan and Uganda were lost within a sea of Zulus. A rarely touched subject, especially relevant with current events in Zimbabwe.
If you can splash out on the Hardback do- the paper used for the paperback is appalling.


An enlightening read, 20 Dec 2006
This is a beautifully written work that provides a fascinating insight into the continent's history, underdevelopment and civil strife. Devoid of sentimentality and full of objectivity, the author conveys the deep message, which explains not only the resilience of the continent but also the ravages that it has been subjected to throughout its turbulent history. Behind the tragedies of the continent are the heavy hands of the ex-colonial masters and the exploitative drives of some business concerns working in partnership with African dictators, psychopaths and administrative kleptomaniacs that have power and are excluding the people in the running of the land. With more piteous prospects than any other continent, Africa mirrors the failures of humanity as well as its hopes and reams.
Other titles that treat this African malaise are DISCIPLES OF FORTUNE , AFRICA UNCHAINED, THE SCHACKLED CONTINENT, TRIPLE AGENT DOUBLE CROSS. Together these titles exposed the personal and collective problems of the people and the personal and collective efforts made, and the means and ways to take the Africa forward despite all the constrains.

Superb, 18 Nov 2008
The book covers South African history from the 1870s to 1910, a fascinating period of history involving the clash of British Imperialism, the Afrikaaner states of the Transvaal and Orange Free State, indiginous Zulu uprisings and the beginnings of the pass system. Central characters are Cecil Rhodes, Jameson, Kruger, De La Rey - and their roles in the ultimate disaster of the Anglo-Boer war.

For anyone interested in SA, late Victorian history or history generally, this is a superb book, well written and fascinating.

Very Good, 08 Oct 2008
The Scramble for Africa by Thomas Pakenham is a very good book which deals with the remarkable last two decades in the nineteenth century when Africa was carved up by the nations of Europe. It is an immensely readable book which deals with a number of different areas and time periods but also goes further and deals with individuals and more forgotten examples of European colonisation such as the Belgians in the Congo. All in all a remarkable book which is a pleasure to read.

Great book of a harrowing journey of a continent. , 11 Jun 2008
This is a great book, and like other readers, I think it gave account of every region fairly evenly. Pakenham shows that mistreatment of the native population was endemic across the continent, regardless of the ruling European power. He also managed to avoid romanticizing the situation prior to colonization, bringing to life the personalities of the Kings, Sultans and Chiefs that ruled before the europeans arrived.

Pakenham did however get mixed up with what was British and what was English, as English historians often do.

Best history book ever!, 17 May 2008
Pakenham gives you the detail without the drudgery; the tale without the tediousness; takes you right into the heart of history but manages to make the ride effortless. His story spans two continents, includes a myriad of characters and covers many years of imperial intrigue in Africa. Yet, he not only stays true to the facts, he also gives you a human story. You can close your eyes and see Leopold or Lobengula or any of the hundreds of actors that claimed this stage of human history. Here is a priceless account of how and why it happened; the partition of Africa in the nineteenth century by several European nations. A must read!

Superb, i finished it at 5am!, 09 Apr 2007
This book covers every issue you could possibly think of in colonial africa in just enough detail to give you a pan-african diorama without getting bogged down in any individual area (each of which deserves a book on their own). The only other example ive read got so bogged down with the Boer war that lesser known colonial hi-jinx such as the Sudan and Uganda were lost within a sea of Zulus. A rarely touched subject, especially relevant with current events in Zimbabwe.
If you can splash out on the Hardback do- the paper used for the paperback is appalling.


An enlightening read, 20 Dec 2006
This is a beautifully written work that provides a fascinating insight into the continent's history, underdevelopment and civil strife. Devoid of sentimentality and full of objectivity, the author conveys the deep message, which explains not only the resilience of the continent but also the ravages that it has been subjected to throughout its turbulent history. Behind the tragedies of the continent are the heavy hands of the ex-colonial masters and the exploitative drives of some business concerns working in partnership with African dictators, psychopaths and administrative kleptomaniacs that have power and are excluding the people in the running of the land. With more piteous prospects than any other continent, Africa mirrors the failures of humanity as well as its hopes and reams.
Other titles that treat this African malaise are DISCIPLES OF FORTUNE , AFRICA UNCHAINED, THE SCHACKLED CONTINENT, TRIPLE AGENT DOUBLE CROSS. Together these titles exposed the personal and collective problems of the people and the personal and collective efforts made, and the means and ways to take the Africa forward despite all the constrains.

A Modern Classic, 08 Jan 2008
The first thing that should strike the reader is that the work is over 25 years old yet still has a freshness about its approach to the conflict. This and the comprehensive coverage of events leading up to the war, as well as the war itself, suggests it will be many more years before it ceases to be the definitive history of the Boer War. One particularly interesting feature is Pakenham's defence of General Buller who has been vilified for his incompetence in just about every other book on the subject. Not everyone will agree with Pakenham's defence of Buller but it's undoubtedly well argued, based as it is on documents and other material discovered at Buller's family home in Devon. A must read for anyone with an interest in the Boer War.

History alive., 30 May 2007
This is the way history should be written. Facts are offered in such an interesting way. Rutland's Guns by Roger Carpenter is a novel about the Boer War based on accurate facts while this book is history written as a novel. A great read.

Fantastic! , 05 Jul 2006
This was the first book I had ever read on the Boer War and what an introduction! Pakenham not only wields a gripping narrative account of the battles, political intrigue and the affairs of the individuals involved, which has you eagerly turning every page, but also expertly analyses many aspects of the war. It is an especially good book for analysing the causes of the war, the performance of the various British generals (especially in revising attitudes towards Buller) and the factors that made British victory so difficult. In fact the latter means that the book is not only a good account of the Boer War but also essential reading for anyone interested in 20th century military history as it helps explain some of the bloodshed of World War One. The focus is on the British perspective but I would not say it is unfavourable or greatly unfair towards the Boers as a good account of the Concentration camps is given for example. As an introduction to topic or just a book for someone with a general interest in military history it is a fantastic read.

Best book I've read on the Boer War, 19 Jun 2005
I am a collector of British military medals with a particular interest in the Boer War and the First World War. As a result I have read many books on about these wars and I can honestly say that this book is the best one I have ever read concerning the Boer War of 1899 to 1902.

The author takes an in depth look at the causes of the war in both a detailed and refreshingly modern analytic way not found in previous works. He then moves on and examines the various phases of the war from the large set piece battles to the guerrila war that followed as well as the aftermath.

However, what is really pleasing about this book is the way it is written being more akin to a novel than a history textbook. The result is a highly readble text with very little dry bits that often tire the reader when he or she embarks on reading a book as large as this one.

If you want one good general history of the Boer War then this is the one to buy. It will suit those who wish to learn more about the politics of the war as well as those who have a keen interest in the military tatics used.

In short this really is a first class book which shlould be read by anyone with an interest in this conflict.

Good book, 16 Dec 2002
The conflict between my ancestors and the British Empire comes to life through Pakenham’s masterful and researched account. Unfortunately Pakenham tells the story from primarily a British perspective and often lacks balance. At Spioenkop and Colenso, for instance, you can’t help but feel sorry for Gen. Buller and his men. But later, after Roberts arrives with his armada, Pakenham deliberately fails to evoke the same sympathies towards the Boers suffering under truly horrific Imperial decision-making.
It’s an informative and exciting read with lots of details and opinions reminding the reader that hindsight is always 20/20 vision. The author presumes that the reader is familiar with weapons of that period and battlefield tactics used up ‘till then. Would have liked more photos.

Superb, 18 Nov 2008
The book covers South African history from the 1870s to 1910, a fascinating period of history involving the clash of British Imperialism, the Afrikaaner states of the Transvaal and Orange Free State, indiginous Zulu uprisings and the beginnings of the pass system. Central characters are Cecil Rhodes, Jameson, Kruger, De La Rey - and their roles in the ultimate disaster of the Anglo-Boer war.

For anyone interested in SA, late Victorian history or history generally, this is a superb book, well written and fascinating.

Very Good, 08 Oct 2008
The Scramble for Africa by Thomas Pakenham is a very good book which deals with the remarkable last two decades in the nineteenth century when Africa was carved up by the nations of Europe. It is an immensely readable book which deals with a number of different areas and time periods but also goes further and deals with individuals and more forgotten examples of European colonisation such as the Belgians in the Congo. All in all a remarkable book which is a pleasure to read.

Great book of a harrowing journey of a continent. , 11 Jun 2008
This is a great book, and like other readers, I think it gave account of every region fairly evenly. Pakenham shows that mistreatment of the native population was endemic across the continent, regardless of the ruling European power. He also managed to avoid romanticizing the situation prior to colonization, bringing to life the personalities of the Kings, Sultans and Chiefs that ruled before the europeans arrived.

Pakenham did however get mixed up with what was British and what was English, as English historians often do.

Best history book ever!, 17 May 2008
Pakenham gives you the detail without the drudgery; the tale without the tediousness; takes you right into the heart of history but manages to make the ride effortless. His story spans two continents, includes a myriad of characters and covers many years of imperial intrigue in Africa. Yet, he not only stays true to the facts, he also gives you a human story. You can close your eyes and see Leopold or Lobengula or any of the hundreds of actors that claimed this stage of human history. Here is a priceless account of how and why it happened; the partition of Africa in the nineteenth century by several European nations. A must read!

Superb, i finished it at 5am!, 09 Apr 2007
This book covers every issue you could possibly think of in colonial africa in just enough detail to give you a pan-african diorama without getting bogged down in any individual area (each of which deserves a book on their own). The only other example ive read got so bogged down with the Boer war that lesser known colonial hi-jinx such as the Sudan and Uganda were lost within a sea of Zulus. A rarely touched subject, especially relevant with current events in Zimbabwe.
If you can splash out on the Hardback do- the paper used for the paperback is appalling.


An enlightening read, 20 Dec 2006
This is a beautifully written work that provides a fascinating insight into the continent's history, underdevelopment and civil strife. Devoid of sentimentality and full of objectivity, the author conveys the deep message, which explains not only the resilience of the continent but also the ravages that it has been subjected to throughout its turbulent history. Behind the tragedies of the continent are the heavy hands of the ex-colonial masters and the exploitative drives of some business concerns working in partnership with African dictators, psychopaths and administrative kleptomaniacs that have power and are excluding the people in the running of the land. With more piteous prospects than any other continent, Africa mirrors the failures of humanity as well as its hopes and reams.
Other titles that treat this African malaise are DISCIPLES OF FORTUNE , AFRICA UNCHAINED, THE SCHACKLED CONTINENT, TRIPLE AGENT DOUBLE CROSS. Together these titles exposed the personal and collective problems of the people and the personal and collective efforts made, and the means and ways to take the Africa forward despite all the constrains.

A Modern Classic, 08 Jan 2008
The first thing that should strike the reader is that the work is over 25 years old yet still has a freshness about its approach to the conflict. This and the comprehensive coverage of events leading up to the war, as well as the war itself, suggests it will be many more years before it ceases to be the definitive history of the Boer War. One particularly interesting feature is Pakenham's defence of General Buller who has been vilified for his incompetence in just about every other book on the subject. Not everyone will agree with Pakenham's defence of Buller but it's undoubtedly well argued, based as it is on documents and other material discovered at Buller's family home in Devon. A must read for anyone with an interest in the Boer War.

History alive., 30 May 2007
This is the way history should be written. Facts are offered in such an interesting way. Rutland's Guns by Roger Carpenter is a novel about the Boer War based on accurate facts while this book is history written as a novel. A great read.

Fantastic! , 05 Jul 2006
This was the first book I had ever read on the Boer War and what an introduction! Pakenham not only wields a gripping narrative account of the battles, political intrigue and the affairs of the individuals involved, which has you eagerly turning every page, but also expertly analyses many aspects of the war. It is an especially good book for analysing the causes of the war, the performance of the various British generals (especially in revising attitudes towards Buller) and the factors that made British victory so difficult. In fact the latter means that the book is not only a good account of the Boer War but also essential reading for anyone interested in 20th century military history as it helps explain some of the bloodshed of World War One. The focus is on the British perspective but I would not say it is unfavourable or greatly unfair towards the Boers as a good account of the Concentration camps is given for example. As an introduction to topic or just a book for someone with a general interest in military history it is a fantastic read.

Best book I've read on the Boer War, 19 Jun 2005
I am a collector of British military medals with a particular interest in the Boer War and the First World War. As a result I have read many books on about these wars and I can honestly say that this book is the best one I have ever read concerning the Boer War of 1899 to 1902.

The author takes an in depth look at the causes of the war in both a detailed and refreshingly modern analytic way not found in previous works. He then moves on and examines the various phases of the war from the large set piece battles to the guerrila war that followed as well as the aftermath.

However, what is really pleasing about this book is the way it is written being more akin to a novel than a history textbook. The result is a highly readble text with very little dry bits that often tire the reader when he or she embarks on reading a book as large as this one.

If you want one good general history of the Boer War then this is the one to buy. It will suit those who wish to learn more about the politics of the war as well as those who have a keen interest in the military tatics used.

In short this really is a first class book which shlould be read by anyone with an interest in this conflict.

Good book, 16 Dec 2002
The conflict between my ancestors and the British Empire comes to life through Pakenham’s masterful and researched account. Unfortunately Pakenham tells the story from primarily a British perspective and often lacks balance. At Spioenkop and Colenso, for instance, you can’t help but feel sorry for Gen. Buller and his men. But later, after Roberts arrives with his armada, Pakenham deliberately fails to evoke the same sympathies towards the Boers suffering under truly horrific Imperial decision-making.
It’s an informative and exciting read with lots of details and opinions reminding the reader that hindsight is always 20/20 vision. The author presumes that the reader is familiar with weapons of that period and battlefield tactics used up ‘till then. Would have liked more photos.

African Shipwreck, 09 Nov 2008
An account of the fate of the Grosvenor, an East Indiaman that ran aground off the coast of Africa on its way from India to the U.K. Personal histories mixed with investigation. I was not surprised that the survivors of the grounding split into smaller groups, but the fact that the women and injured being abandoned was shocking. I suppose we have spent so long hearing "Women and Children first".

stare death in the face, 13 Aug 2008
The set up of the story took too long for me
By page 76 I was no nearer to weighing anchor than page one

By the time the wreck happened it turned into a hell of a tale
The survival instinct kicked in and all sense of comradmanship was abandoned

Wrong decision after wrong decision in the end cost many lives

The epilogue and folk law tales of the assimilation of people who may have survived amongst the natives was great


First rate factual adventure., 05 Jul 2008
A tragic tale of shipwreck off the East African coast. Although a very sad account of the fate of men, women and children, the book also gives a detailed account of the various lifestyles of Europeans living and trading in 1780s India. Initially I thought that this was going to be an account of man and meteorology but the book is a good balance of biography, geography, history and maritime facts. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and found it hard to put down in the wee hours of the morning.

Bring a film out on it!, 10 Aug 2007
The Grosvenor was one of the finest East Indiamen of her day, but she ran aground on the treacherous coast of south-east Africa. An astonishing number of her crew and passengers, including women and children, reached the shore safely, but the castaways found themselves hundreds of miles from the nearest European outpost - and utterly ignorant of their surroundings and the people among whom they found themselves.

Drawing upon much new research, Stephen Taylor pieces together this extraordinary saga, sifting the myths that became attached to The Grosvenor from a reality that is no less gripping. Taking the reader to the heart of what is now the Wild Coast of Pondoland, he reveals the misunderstandings that led to tragedy, tells the story of those who escaped, and unravels the mystery of those who stayed. An unforgetable story of its time of how the survivors trekked for over 400 miles across the most hostile of lands suffering the most extreme of privations. After many months they reach safety amongst kind hearted dutch settlers...but alas for many it was not to be!

Gripping story, told really well with great detail and a flowing easy to read narrative....great read!


The Caliban Shore, 26 Jul 2007
The book is very detailed, in fact I think too detailed. If you just want to read about the actual experience these unfortunate people suffered only read the middle or their abouts of the book. The rest is more akin to a study.
While I admire the effort Stephen Taylor has put into writing this book, does all the detailed back ground about each character really enhance the yarn ?

Superb, 18 Nov 2008
The book covers South African history from the 1870s to 1910, a fascinating period of history involving the clash of British Imperialism, the Afrikaaner states of the Transvaal and Orange Free State, indiginous Zulu uprisings and the beginnings of the pass system. Central characters are Cecil Rhodes, Jameson, Kruger, De La Rey - and their roles in the ultimate disaster of the Anglo-Boer war.

For anyone interested in SA, late Victorian history or history generally, this is a superb book, well written and fascinating.

Very Good, 08 Oct 2008
The Scramble for Africa by Thomas Pakenham is a very good book which deals with the remarkable last two decades in the nineteenth century when Africa was carved up by the nations of Europe. It is an immensely readable book which deals with a number of different areas and time periods but also goes further and deals with individuals and more forgotten examples of European colonisation such as the Belgians in the Congo. All in all a remarkable book which is a pleasure to read.

Great book of a harrowing journey of a continent. , 11 Jun 2008
This is a great book, and like other readers, I think it gave account of every region fairly evenly. Pakenham shows that mistreatment of the native population was endemic across the continent, regardless of the ruling European power. He also managed to avoid romanticizing the situation prior to colonization, bringing to life the personalities of the Kings, Sultans and Chiefs that ruled before the europeans arrived.

Pakenham did however get mixed up with what was British and what was English, as English historians often do.

Best history book ever!, 17 May 2008
Pakenham gives you the detail without the drudgery; the tale without the tediousness; takes you right into the heart of history but manages to make the ride effortless. His story spans two continents, includes a myriad of characters and covers many years of imperial intrigue in Africa. Yet, he not only stays true to the facts, he also gives you a human story. You can close your eyes and see Leopold or Lobengula or any of the hundreds of actors that claimed this stage of human history. Here is a priceless account of how and why it happened; the partition of Africa in the nineteenth century by several European nations. A must read!

Superb, i finished it at 5am!, 09 Apr 2007
This book covers every issue you could possibly think of in colonial africa in just enough detail to give you a pan-african diorama without getting bogged down in any individual area (each of which deserves a book on their own). The only other example ive read got so bogged down with the Boer war that lesser known colonial hi-jinx such as the Sudan and Uganda were lost within a sea of Zulus. A rarely touched subject, especially relevant with current events in Zimbabwe.
If you can splash out on the Hardback do- the paper used for the paperback is appalling.


An enlightening read, 20 Dec 2006
This is a beautifully written work that provides a fascinating insight into the continent's history, underdevelopment and civil strife. Devoid of sentimentality and full of objectivity, the author conveys the deep message, which explains not only the resilience of the continent but also the ravages that it has been subjected to throughout its turbulent history. Behind the tragedies of the continent are the heavy hands of the ex-colonial masters and the exploitative drives of some business concerns working in partnership with African dictators, psychopaths and administrative kleptomaniacs that have power and are excluding the people in the running of the land. With more piteous prospects than any other continent, Africa mirrors the failures of humanity as well as its hopes and reams.
Other titles that treat this African malaise are DISCIPLES OF FORTUNE , AFRICA UNCHAINED, THE SCHACKLED CONTINENT, TRIPLE AGENT DOUBLE CROSS. Together these titles exposed the personal and collective problems of the people and the personal and collective efforts made, and the means and ways to take the Africa forward despite all the constrains.

A Modern Classic, 08 Jan 2008
The first thing that should strike the reader is that the work is over 25 years old yet still has a freshness about its approach to the conflict. This and the comprehensive coverage of events leading up to the war, as well as the war itself, suggests it will be many more years before it ceases to be the definitive history of the Boer War. One particularly interesting feature is Pakenham's defence of General Buller who has been vilified for his incompetence in just about every other book on the subject. Not everyone will agree with Pakenham's defence of Buller but it's undoubtedly well argued, based as it is on documents and other material discovered at Buller's family home in Devon. A must read for anyone with an interest in the Boer War.

History alive., 30 May 2007
This is the way history should be written. Facts are offered in such an interesting way. Rutland's Guns by Roger Carpenter is a novel about the Boer War based on accurate facts while this book is history written as a novel. A great read.

Fantastic! , 05 Jul 2006
This was the first book I had ever read on the Boer War and what an introduction! Pakenham not only wields a gripping narrative account of the battles, political intrigue and the affairs of the individuals involved, which has you eagerly turning every page, but also expertly analyses many aspects of the war. It is an especially good book for analysing the causes of the war, the performance of the various British generals (especially in revising attitudes towards Buller) and the factors that made British victory so difficult. In fact the latter means that the book is not only a good account of the Boer War but also essential reading for anyone interested in 20th century military history as it helps explain some of the bloodshed of World War One. The focus is on the British perspective but I would not say it is unfavourable or greatly unfair towards the Boers as a good account of the Concentration camps is given for example. As an introduction to topic or just a book for someone with a general interest in military history it is a fantastic read.

Best book I've read on the Boer War, 19 Jun 2005
I am a collector of British military medals with a particular interest in the Boer War and the First World War. As a result I have read many books on about these wars and I can honestly say that this book is the best one I have ever read concerning the Boer War of 1899 to 1902.

The author takes an in depth look at the causes of the war in both a detailed and refreshingly modern analytic way not found in previous works. He then moves on and examines the various phases of the war from the large set piece battles to the guerrila war that followed as well as the aftermath.

However, what is really pleasing about this book is the way it is written being more akin to a novel than a history textbook. The result is a highly readble text with very little dry bits that often tire the reader when he or she embarks on reading a book as large as this one.

If you want one good general history of the Boer War then this is the one to buy. It will suit those who wish to learn more about the politics of the war as well as those who have a keen interest in the military tatics used.

In short this really is a first class book which shlould be read by anyone with an interest in this conflict.

Good book, 16 Dec 2002
The conflict between my ancestors and the British Empire comes to life through Pakenham’s masterful and researched account. Unfortunately Pakenham tells the story from primarily a British perspective and often lacks balance. At Spioenkop and Colenso, for instance, you can’t help but feel sorry for Gen. Buller and his men. But later, after Roberts arrives with his armada, Pakenham deliberately fails to evoke the same sympathies towards the Boers suffering under truly horrific Imperial decision-making.
It’s an informative and exciting read with lots of details and opinions reminding the reader that hindsight is always 20/20 vision. The author presumes that the reader is familiar with weapons of that period and battlefield tactics used up ‘till then. Would have liked more photos.

African Shipwreck, 09 Nov 2008
An account of the fate of the Grosvenor, an East Indiaman that ran aground off the coast of Africa on its way from India to the U.K. Personal histories mixed with investigation. I was not surprised that the survivors of the grounding split into smaller groups, but the fact that the women and injured being abandoned was shocking. I suppose we have spent so long hearing "Women and Children first".

stare death in the face, 13 Aug 2008
The set up of the story took too long for me
By page 76 I was no nearer to weighing anchor than page one

By the time the wreck happened it turned into a hell of a tale
The survival instinct kicked in and all sense of comradmanship was abandoned

Wrong decision after wrong decision in the end cost many lives

The epilogue and folk law tales of the assimilation of people who may have survived amongst the natives was great


First rate factual adventure., 05 Jul 2008
A tragic tale of shipwreck off the East African coast. Although a very sad account of the fate of men, women and children, the book also gives a detailed account of the various lifestyles of Europeans living and trading in 1780s India. Initially I thought that this was going to be an account of man and meteorology but the book is a good balance of biography, geography, history and maritime facts. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and found it hard to put down in the wee hours of the morning.

Bring a film out on it!, 10 Aug 2007
The Grosvenor was one of the finest East Indiamen of her day, but she ran aground on the treacherous coast of south-east Africa. An astonishing number of her crew and passengers, including women and children, reached the shore safely, but the castaways found themselves hundreds of miles from the nearest European outpost - and utterly ignorant of their surroundings and the people among whom they found themselves.

Drawing upon much new research, Stephen Taylor pieces together this extraordinary saga, sifting the myths that became attached to The Grosvenor from a reality that is no less gripping. Taking the reader to the heart of what is now the Wild Coast of Pondoland, he reveals the misunderstandings that led to tragedy, tells the story of those who escaped, and unravels the mystery of those who stayed. An unforgetable story of its time of how the survivors trekked for over 400 miles across the most hostile of lands suffering the most extreme of privations. After many months they reach safety amongst kind hearted dutch settlers...but alas for many it was not to be!

Gripping story, told really well with great detail and a flowing easy to read narrative....great read!


The Caliban Shore, 26 Jul 2007
The book is very detailed, in fact I think too detailed. If you just want to read about the actual experience these unfortunate people suffered only read the middle or their abouts of the book. The rest is more akin to a study.
While I admire the effort Stephen Taylor has put into writing this book, does all the detailed back ground about each character really enhance the yarn ?

Delusions of Grandeur, 08 Aug 2007
A belief that one is Napoleon is a common cypher for madness. But such delusions of grandeur are not confined to comic references to asylums inmates; Old Boney himself had visions of being the next Alexander the Great. Unlike most lunatics, however, when thwarted in his designs for an Oriental empire, he settled for being the next Julius Caesar with a European empire instead. He was an extraordinary man without a doubt.

One fascinating aspect of his expedition to Egypt in 1798 was the presence of 167 savants, learned men in every walk of science and the arts, including the great mathematician Fourier, who accompanied the general and his army. Napoleon had recently been made a member of the Institute of France, and regarded this honour more highly than his military rank. Once ensconced in Cairo he formed an Institute of Egypt, and the work of this body formed the basis of modern Egypotology, tetraology and other important strands of learning. However, despite Napoleon's ardent attempts to appear to be the friend of Islam, the occupation suffered a fundamental failure to understand the country he was trying to civilise; the first attempt in modern times by a western power to occupy a Middle Eastern country holds parallels for the latest efforts to import western political systems. `The very core of what the French thought they were bringing to the Egyptians ... was not only incomprehensible but offensive to the people they were addressing. This was a situation which the French, in their turn, would soon begin to find incomprehensible and offensive.'

Unfortunately the military descriptions are badly let down by the author's continuous reference to `rifles', something the French army of the period did not have. Muskets absolutely were not rifles, nor were ramrods designed to clean them; such fundamental errors should not have been allowed to pass in what is otherwise a very entertaining and well written book. Ultimately the expedition was a failure long before Napoleon's decision to return to France, but Nelson's victory and the brilliance of Sir Sidney Smith helped thwart his initial scheme, and as he was taken aboard Bellerophon for his final journey to St Helena in 1815, he exclaimed: `But for you English, I would have been Emperor of the East.'

A great history book, 10 Jul 2007

I would recommend this book to anyone intereseted in the history of the Napoleonic wars in general and/or Napoleon in general. It is a great read.

Starthern has written a very readable and enjoyable study of Napoleon's campaign in Egypt covering in detail (with maps) the various battles of this amazing episode, including Nelson's Battle of the Nile, and the Battle of the Pyramids, the characters involved; the Generals, the Beys and Mamelukes, the Savants and the experiences of the French soldiers.

I felt it read like good historical novel in places and being a big fan of historic fiction (books like the Sharpe series) this added to my enjoyment. Read this book!

Must Read for Napoleon Fans, 22 Jun 2007
"A must read for any fans of Napoleon or the period. Napoleon in Egypt is scholarly, insightful and also good fun. The resonance of Napoleon invading Egypt - and today's incursions into the East - make Napoleon In Egypt all the more readable and rewarding."

Superb, 18 Nov 2008
The book covers South African history from the 1870s to 1910, a fascinating period of history involving the clash of British Imperialism, the Afrikaaner states of the Transvaal and Orange Free State, indiginous Zulu uprisings and the beginnings of the pass system. Central characters are Cecil Rhodes, Jameson, Kruger, De La Rey - and their roles in the ultimate disaster of the Anglo-Boer war.

For anyone interested in SA, late Victorian history or history generally, this is a superb book, well written and fascinating.

Very Good, 08 Oct 2008
The Scramble for Africa by Thomas Pakenham is a very good book which deals with the remarkable last two decades in the nineteenth century when Africa was carved up by the nations of Europe. It is an immensely readable book which deals with a number of different areas and time periods but also goes further and deals with individuals and more forgotten examples of European colonisation such as the Belgians in the Congo. All in all a remarkable book which is a pleasure to read.

Great book of a harrowing journey of a continent. , 11 Jun 2008
This is a great book, and like other readers, I think it gave account of every region fairly evenly. Pakenham shows that mistreatment of the native population was endemic across the continent, regardless of the ruling European power. He also managed to avoid romanticizing the situation prior to colonization, bringing to life the personalities of the Kings, Sultans and Chiefs that ruled before the europeans arrived.

Pakenham did however get mixed up with what was British and what was English, as English historians often do.

Best history book ever!, 17 May 2008
Pakenham gives you the detail without the drudgery; the tale without the tediousness; takes you right into the heart of history but manages to make the ride effortless. His story spans two continents, includes a myriad of characters and covers many years of imperial intrigue in Africa. Yet, he not only stays true to the facts, he also gives you a human story. You can close your eyes and see Leopold or Lobengula or any of the hundreds of actors that claimed this stage of human history. Here is a priceless account of how and why it happened; the partition of Africa in the nineteenth century by several European nations. A must read!

Superb, i finished it at 5am!, 09 Apr 2007
This book covers every issue you could possibly think of in colonial africa in just enough detail to give you a pan-african diorama without getting bogged down in any individual area (each of which deserves a book on their own). The only other example ive read got so bogged down with the Boer war that lesser known colonial hi-jinx such as the Sudan and Uganda were lost within a sea of Zulus. A rarely touched subject, especially relevant with current events in Zimbabwe.
If you can splash out on the Hardback do- the paper used for the paperback is appalling.


An enlightening read, 20 Dec 2006
This is a beautifully written work that provides a fascinating insight into the continent's history, underdevelopment and civil strife. Devoid of sentimentality and full of objectivity, the author conveys the deep message, which explains not only the resilience of the continent but also the ravages that it has been subjected to throughout its turbulent history. Behind the tragedies of the continent are the heavy hands of the ex-colonial masters and the exploitative drives of some business concerns working in partnership with African dictators, psychopaths and administrative kleptomaniacs that have power and are excluding the people in the running of the land. With more piteous prospects than any other continent, Africa mirrors the failures of humanity as well as its hopes and reams.
Other titles that treat this African malaise are DISCIPLES OF FORTUNE , AFRICA UNCHAINED, THE SCHACKLED CONTINENT, TRIPLE AGENT DOUBLE CROSS. Together these titles exposed the personal and collective problems of the people and the personal and collective efforts made, and the means and ways to take the Africa forward despite all the constrains.

A Modern Classic, 08 Jan 2008
The first thing that should strike the reader is that the work is over 25 years old yet still has a freshness about its approach to the conflict. This and the comprehensive coverage of events leading up to the war, as well as the war itself, suggests it will be many more years before it ceases to be the definitive history of the Boer War. One particularly interesting feature is Pakenham's defence of General Buller who has been vilified for his incompetence in just about every other book on the subject. Not everyone will agree with Pakenham's defence of Buller but it's undoubtedly well argued, based as it is on documents and other material discovered at Buller's family home in Devon. A must read for anyone with an interest in the Boer War.

History alive., 30 May 2007
This is the way history should be written. Facts are offered in such an interesting way. Rutland's Guns by Roger Carpenter is a novel about the Boer War based on accurate facts while this book is history written as a novel. A great read.

Fantastic! , 05 Jul 2006
This was the first book I had ever read on the Boer War and what an introduction! Pakenham not only wields a gripping narrative account of the battles, political intrigue and the affairs of the individuals involved, which has you eagerly turning every page, but also expertly analyses many aspects of the war. It is an especially good book for analysing the causes of the war, the performance of the various British generals (especially in revising attitudes towards Buller) and the factors that made British victory so difficult. In fact the latter means that the book is not only a good account of the Boer War but also essential reading for anyone interested in 20th century military history as it helps explain some of the bloodshed of World War One. The focus is on the British perspective but I would not say it is unfavourable or greatly unfair towards the Boers as a good account of the Concentration camps is given for example. As an introduction to topic or just a book for someone with a general interest in military history it is a fantastic read.

Best book I've read on the Boer War, 19 Jun 2005
I am a collector of British military medals with a particular interest in the Boer War and the First World War. As a result I have read many books on about these wars and I can honestly say that this book is the best one I have ever read concerning the Boer War of 1899 to 1902.

The author takes an in depth look at the causes of the war in both a detailed and refreshingly modern analytic way not found in previous works. He then moves on and examines the various phases of the war from the large set piece battles to the guerrila war that followed as well as the aftermath.

However, what is really pleasing about this book is the way it is written being more akin to a novel than a history textbook. The result is a highly readble text with very little dry bits that often tire the reader when he or she embarks on reading a book as large as this one.

If you want one good general history of the Boer War then this is the one to buy. It will suit those who wish to learn more about the politics of the war as well as those who have a keen interest in the military tatics used.

In short this really is a first class book which shlould be read by anyone with an interest in this conflict.

Good book, 16 Dec 2002
The conflict between my ancestors and the British Empire comes to life through Pakenham’s masterful and researched account. Unfortunately Pakenham tells the story from primarily a British perspective and often lacks balance. At Spioenkop and Colenso, for instance, you can’t help but feel sorry for Gen. Buller and his men. But later, after Roberts arrives with his armada, Pakenham deliberately fails to evoke the same sympathies towards the Boers suffering under truly horrific Imperial decision-making.
It’s an informative and exciting read with lots of details and opinions reminding the reader that hindsight is always 20/20 vision. The author presumes that the reader is familiar with weapons of that period and battlefield tactics used up ‘till then. Would have liked more photos.

African Shipwreck, 09 Nov 2008
An account of the fate of the Grosvenor, an East Indiaman that ran aground off the coast of Africa on its way from India to the U.K. Personal histories mixed with investigation. I was not surprised that the survivors of the grounding split into smaller groups, but the fact that the women and injured being abandoned was shocking. I suppose we have spent so long hearing "Women and Children first".

stare death in the face, 13 Aug 2008
The set up of the story took too long for me
By page 76 I was no nearer to weighing anchor than page one

By the time the wreck happened it turned into a hell of a tale
The survival instinct kicked in and all sense of comradmanship was abandoned

Wrong decision after wrong decision in the end cost many lives

The epilogue and folk law tales of the assimilation of people who may have survived amongst the natives was great


First rate factual adventure., 05 Jul 2008
A tragic tale of shipwreck off the East African coast. Although a very sad account of the fate of men, women and children, the book also gives a detailed account of the various lifestyles of Europeans living and trading in 1780s India. Initially I thought that this was going to be an account of man and meteorology but the book is a good balance of biography, geography, history and maritime facts. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and found it hard to put down in the wee hours of the morning.

Bring a film out on it!, 10 Aug 2007
The Grosvenor was one of the finest East Indiamen of her day, but she ran aground on the treacherous coast of south-east Africa. An astonishing number of her crew and passengers, including women and children, reached the shore safely, but the castaways found themselves hundreds of miles from the nearest European outpost - and utterly ignorant of their surroundings and the people among whom they found themselves.

Drawing upon much new research, Stephen Taylor pieces together this extraordinary saga, sifting the myths that became attached to The Grosvenor from a reality that is no less gripping. Taking the reader to the heart of what is now the Wild Coast of Pondoland, he reveals the misunderstandings that led to tragedy, tells the story of those who escaped, and unravels the mystery of those who stayed. An unforgetable story of its time of how the survivors trekked for over 400 miles across the most hostile of lands suffering the most extreme of privations. After many months they reach safety amongst kind hearted dutch settlers...but alas for many it was not to be!

Gripping story, told really well with great detail and a flowing easy to read narrative....great read!


The Caliban Shore, 26 Jul 2007
The book is very detailed, in fact I think too detailed. If you just want to read about the actual experience these unfortunate people suffered only read the middle or their abouts of the book. The rest is more akin to a study.
While I admire the effort Stephen Taylor has put into writing this book, does all the detailed back ground about each character really enhance the yarn ?

Delusions of Grandeur, 08 Aug 2007
A belief that one is Napoleon is a common cypher for madness. But such delusions of grandeur are not confined to comic references to asylums inmates; Old Boney himself had visions of being the next Alexander the Great. Unlike most lunatics, however, when thwarted in his designs for an Oriental empire, he settled for being the next Julius Caesar with a European empire instead. He was an extraordinary man without a doubt.

One fascinating aspect of his expedition to Egypt in 1798 was the presence of 167 savants, learned men in every walk of science and the arts, including the great mathematician Fourier, who accompanied the general and his army. Napoleon had recently been made a member of the Institute of France, and regarded this honour more highly than his military rank. Once ensconced in Cairo he formed an Institute of Egypt, and the work of this body formed the basis of modern Egypotology, tetraology and other important strands of learning. However, despite Napoleon's ardent attempts to appear to be the friend of Islam, the occupation suffered a fundamental failure to understand the country he was trying to civilise; the first attempt in modern times by a western power to occupy a Middle Eastern country holds parallels for the latest efforts to import western political systems. `The very core of what the French thought they were bringing to the Egyptians ... was not only incomprehensible but offensive to the people they were addressing. This was a situation which the French, in their turn, would soon begin to find incomprehensible and offensive.'

Unfortunately the military descriptions are badly let down by the author's continuous reference to `rifles', something the French army of the period did not have. Muskets absolutely were not rifles, nor were ramrods designed to clean them; such fundamental errors should not have been allowed to pass in what is otherwise a very entertaining and well written book. Ultimately the expedition was a failure long before Napoleon's decision to return to France, but Nelson's victory and the brilliance of Sir Sidney Smith helped thwart his initial scheme, and as he was taken aboard Bellerophon for his final journey to St Helena in 1815, he exclaimed: `But for you English, I would have been Emperor of the East.'

A great history book, 10 Jul 2007

I would recommend this book to anyone intereseted in the history of the Napoleonic wars in general and/or Napoleon in general. It is a great read.

Starthern has written a very readable and enjoyable study of Napoleon's campaign in Egypt covering in detail (with maps) the various battles of this amazing episode, including Nelson's Battle of the Nile, and the Battle of the Pyramids, the characters involved; the Generals, the Beys and Mamelukes, the Savants and the experiences of the French soldiers.

I felt it read like good historical novel in places and being a big fan of historic fiction (books like the Sharpe series) this added to my enjoyment. Read this book!

Must Read for Napoleon Fans, 22 Jun 2007
"A must read for any fans of Napoleon or the period. Napoleon in Egypt is scholarly, insightful and also good fun. The resonance of Napoleon invading Egypt - and today's incursions into the East - make Napoleon In Egypt all the more readable and rewarding."

The A-Z of the A-Z War , 10 Dec 2008
Of one thing there is no doubt - Ian Knight is THE leading authority on the Anglo-Zulu War of 1879. So there is no-one better placed to compile what is a much-needed book on a campaign which has spawned vast amounts of literature and comment - not all of it as well-informed as this volume.
Ian Knight's superb book is an ecletic mixture of various topics connected with the A-Z War - and fittingly is produced in A-Z order, from Ammunition Boxes to the Zulu Royal House, and everything in between.
Each entry is in itself a journey - and whether you are an Anglo-Zulu War enthusiast, someone new to the campaign - or have a general interest in military/Victorian history, this book informs at every level.
Ian's writing style - in this and his many other books - is constantly engaging and never lapses into the sometimes impenetrable language of academia.
Get it!

Knight's new offering fills neglected gap in Zulu War literature, 05 Dec 2008
In the genre of historical inquiry and interpretation, a book bearing the word "Companion" within its title, seems to immediately conjure the image of a reference manual. Often, such references are quickly dismissed as dry, boring and only of value to the most zealous students. In this instance however, the term "Companion" is somewhat misleading. To be sure, it does fulfill it's reference expectations in the manner one would expect from Ian Knight, with absolute accuracy, unassailable scholarship and thorough annotation. But the real genius of this work did not strike me until I was near the end of page 53. I had devoured the first twelve topical studies, from Ammunition Boxes to Burying the Dead, in one swipe----as if I were on vacation guiltily reading tawdry fiction. Within this type of book, which seems to have more ambiguous literary parameters than that of a serious history, Knight is able to stretch a bit, and he shows himself as a writer of most excellent quality. Indeed, it is his commentary on the facts and anecdotes examined that gives this work it's tremendous value. Beyond that, the amount of subjects covered is very broad. I was extremely pleased to see nearly every topic I expected, but some of the best little gems can be found under headings less obviously anticipated, such as the thread entitled 'Liars, Fakes and Rogues.'

Regarding the gap in Zulu War literature alluded to in the title, it's filled by this book in the following manner. A quick examination of my book shelves revealed a count of no less than 75 major titles dealing specifically with the Anglo-Zulu War of 1879, not to mention countless magazine articles, society journals and smaller specialty books concerning aspects such as uniforms and weaponry. The point is then, when one is reading these accounts, often they cause as many questions to arise as those they answer. A simplistic yet clear enough example is the Ammunition Box controversy at Isandlwana. It's well and good to read about a possible shortage of ammunition due to the nature of the boxes. However, this book explains why or why not that may have been the case, but only after a comprehensive look at the evidence, from the design of the box, to survivor testimony and archaeological data. As this is the standard methodology applied to all the scrutinized subjects, a great many of my questions finally have answers.

A feature that should be well appreciated for it's convenience factor, is the inclusion within the introduction of maps associated with every major military action of the war. The biggest visual treat however is on the dust cover, which features a newly discovered contemporary period painting from an as yet unknown Victorian artist, of the action at the mission station at Rorke's Drift. Unfortunately, as the size of the original painting is obviously too large to fit even wrapped around the cover, one is not afforded a truly satisfying view. Hopefully at some point the entire painting will be made available in print form.

In the age of the internet, many students of history find themselves debating and discussing favorite subjects online with others of like interests. For those who find themselves enmeshed in the history of the Anglo-Zulu War, having this book will most assuredly lend an advantage over fellow debaters, as well as saving one from having to rampage through 75 books for that one all important reference!


Its exactly what it says it is! , 16 Oct 2008
This is a great reference work for all those interested in the Zulu war. Its basically an A-Z guide to the war covering everything from Dogs, uniforms, cinema, the Zulu royal family, rockets etc. I thought it was fascinating book and I could not put it down.

Its exactly what it says it is, a great companion to the study of the Zulu war written by one of the leading historians of the Zulu war.

Superb, 18 Nov 2008
The book covers South African history from the 1870s to 1910, a fascinating period of history involving the clash of British Imperialism, the Afrikaaner states of the Transvaal and Orange Free State, indiginous Zulu uprisings and the beginnings of the pass system. Central characters are Cecil Rhodes, Jameson, Kruger, De La Rey - and their roles in the ultimate disaster of the Anglo-Boer war.

For anyone interested in SA, late Victorian history or history generally, this is a superb book, well written and fascinating.

Very Good, 08 Oct 2008
The Scramble for Africa by Thomas Pakenham is a very good book which deals with the remarkable last two decades in the nineteenth century when Africa was carved up by the nations of Europe. It is an immensely readable book which deals with a number of different areas and time periods but also goes further and deals with individuals and more forgotten examples of European colonisation such as the Belgians in the Congo. All in all a remarkable book which is a pleasure to read.

Great book of a harrowing journey of a continent. , 11 Jun 2008
This is a great book, and like other readers, I think it gave account of every region fairly evenly. Pakenham shows that mistreatment of the native population was endemic across the continent, regardless of the ruling European power. He also managed to avoid romanticizing the situation prior to colonization, bringing to life the personalities of the Kings, Sultans and Chiefs that ruled before the europeans arrived.

Pakenham did however get mixed up with what was British and what was English, as English historians often do.

Best history book ever!, 17 May 2008
Pakenham gives you the detail without the drudgery; the tale without the tediousness; takes you right into the heart of history but manages to make the ride effortless. His story spans two continents, includes a myriad of characters and covers many years of imperial intrigue in Africa. Yet, he not only stays true to the facts, he also gives you a human story. You can close your eyes and see Leopold or Lobengula or any of the hundreds of actors that claimed this stage of human history. Here is a priceless account of how and why it happened; the partition of Africa in the nineteenth century by several European nations. A must read!

Superb, i finished it at 5am!, 09 Apr 2007
This book covers every issue you could possibly think of in colonial africa in just enough detail to give you a pan-african diorama without getting bogged down in any individual area (each of which deserves a book on their own). The only other example ive read got so bogged down with the Boer war that lesser known colonial hi-jinx such as the Sudan and Uganda were lost within a sea of Zulus. A rarely touched subject, especially relevant with current events in Zimbabwe.
If you can splash out on the Hardback do- the paper used for the paperback is appalling.


An enlightening read, 20 Dec 2006
This is a beautifully written work that provides a fascinating insight into the continent's history, underdevelopment and civil strife. Devoid of sentimentality and full of objectivity, the author conveys the deep message, which explains not only the resilience of the continent but also the ravages that it has been subjected to throughout its turbulent history. Behind the tragedies of the continent are the heavy hands of the ex-colonial masters and the exploitative drives of some business concerns working in partnership with African dictators, psychopaths and administrative kleptomaniacs that have power and are excluding the people in the running of the land. With more piteous prospects than any other continent, Africa mirrors the failures of humanity as well as its hopes and reams.
Other titles that treat this African malaise are DISCIPLES OF FORTUNE , AFRICA UNCHAINED, THE SCHACKLED CONTINENT, TRIPLE AGENT DOUBLE CROSS. Together these titles exposed the personal and collective problems of the people and the personal and collective efforts made, and the means and ways to take the Africa forward despite all the constrains.

A Modern Classic, 08 Jan 2008
The first thing that should strike the reader is that the work is over 25 years old yet still has a freshness about its approach to the conflict. This and the comprehensive coverage of events leading up to the war, as well as the war itself, suggests it will be many more years before it ceases to be the definitive history of the Boer War. One particularly interesting feature is Pakenham's defence of General Buller who has been vilified for his incompetence in just about every other book on the subject. Not everyone will agree with Pakenham's defence of Buller but it's undoubtedly well argued, based as it is on documents and other material discovered at Buller's family home in Devon. A must read for anyone with an interest in the Boer War.

History alive., 30 May 2007
This is the way history should be written. Facts are offered in such an interesting way. Rutland's Guns by Roger Carpenter is a novel about the Boer War based on accurate facts while this book is history written as a novel. A great read.

Fantastic! , 05 Jul 2006
This was the first book I had ever read on the Boer War and what an introduction! Pakenham not only wields a gripping narrative account of the battles, political intrigue and the affairs of the individuals involved, which has you eagerly turning every page, but also expertly analyses many aspects of the war. It is an especially good book for analysing the causes of the war, the performance of the various British generals (especially in revising attitudes towards Buller) and the factors that made British victory so difficult. In fact the latter means that the book is not only a good account of the Boer War but also essential reading for anyone interested in 20th century military history as it helps explain some of the bloodshed of World War One. The focus is on the British perspective but I would not say it is unfavourable or greatly unfair towards the Boers as a good account of the Concentration camps is given for example. As an introduction to topic or just a book for someone with a general interest in military history it is a fantastic read.

Best book I've read on the Boer War, 19 Jun 2005
I am a collector of British military medals with a particular interest in the Boer War and the First World War. As a result I have read many books on about these wars and I can honestly say that this book is the best one I have ever read concerning the Boer War of 1899 to 1902.

The author takes an in depth look at the causes of the war in both a detailed and refreshingly modern analytic way not found in previous works. He then moves on and examines the various phases of the war from the large set piece battles to the guerrila war that followed as well as the aftermath.

However, what is really pleasing about this book is the way it is written being more akin to a novel than a history textbook. The result is a highly readble text with very little dry bits that often tire the reader when he or she embarks on reading a book as large as this one.

If you want one good general history of the Boer War then this is the one to buy. It will suit those who wish to learn more about the politics of the war as well as those who have a keen interest in the military tatics used.

In short this really is a first class book which shlould be read by anyone with an interest in this conflict.

Good book, 16 Dec 2002
The conflict between my ancestors and the British Empire comes to life through Pakenham’s masterful and researched account. Unfortunately Pakenham tells the story from primarily a British perspective and often lacks balance. At Spioenkop and Colenso, for instance, you can’t help but feel sorry for Gen. Buller and his men. But later, after Roberts arrives with his armada, Pakenham deliberately fails to evoke the same sympathies towards the Boers suffering under truly horrific Imperial decision-making.
It’s an informative and exciting read with lots of details and opinions reminding the reader that hindsight is always 20/20 vision. The author presumes that the reader is familiar with weapons of that period and battlefield tactics used up ‘till then. Would have liked more photos.

African Shipwreck, 09 Nov 2008
An account of the fate of the Grosvenor, an East Indiaman that ran aground off the coast of Africa on its way from India to the U.K. Personal histories mixed with investigation. I was not surprised that the survivors of the grounding split into smaller groups, but the fact that the women and injured being abandoned was shocking. I suppose we have spent so long hearing "Women and Children first".

stare death in the face, 13 Aug 2008
The set up of the story took too long for me
By page 76 I was no nearer to weighing anchor than page one

By the time the wreck happened it turned into a hell of a tale
The survival instinct kicked in and all sense of comradmanship was abandoned

Wrong decision after wrong decision in the end cost many lives

The epilogue and folk law tales of the assimilation of people who may have survived amongst the natives was great


First rate factual adventure., 05 Jul 2008
A tragic tale of shipwreck off the East African coast. Although a very sad account of the fate of men, women and children, the book also gives a detailed account of the various lifestyles of Europeans living and trading in 1780s India. Initially I thought that this was going to be an account of man and meteorology but the book is a good balance of biography, geography, history and maritime facts. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and found it hard to put down in the wee hours of the morning.

Bring a film out on it!, 10 Aug 2007
The Grosvenor was one of the finest East Indiamen of her day, but she ran aground on the treacherous coast of south-east Africa. An astonishing number of her crew and passengers, including women and children, reached the shore safely, but the castaways found themselves hundreds of miles from the nearest European outpost - and utterly ignorant of their surroundings and the people among whom they found themselves.

Drawing upon much new research, Stephen Taylor pieces together this extraordinary saga, sifting the myths that became attached to The Grosvenor from a reality that is no less gripping. Taking the reader to the heart of what is now the Wild Coast of Pondoland, he reveals the misunderstandings that led to tragedy, tells the story of those who escaped, and unravels the mystery of those who stayed. An unforgetable story of its time of how the survivors trekked for over 400 miles across the most hostile of lands suffering the most extreme of privations. After many months they reach safety amongst kind hearted dutch settlers...but alas for many it was not to be!

Gripping story, told really well with great detail and a flowing easy to read narrative....great read!


The Caliban Shore, 26 Jul 2007
The book is very detailed, in fact I think too detailed. If you just want to read about the actual experience these unfortunate people suffered only read the middle or their abouts of the book. The rest is more akin to a study.
While I admire the effort Stephen Taylor has put into writing this book, does all the detailed back ground about each character really enhance the yarn ?

Delusions of Grandeur, 08 Aug 2007
A belief that one is Napoleon is a common cypher for madness. But such delusions of grandeur are not confined to comic references to asylums inmates; Old Boney himself had visions of being the next Alexander the Great. Unlike most lunatics, however, when thwarted in his designs for an Oriental empire, he settled for being the next Julius Caesar with a European empire instead. He was an extraordinary man without a doubt.

One fascinating aspect of his expedition to Egypt in 1798 was the presence of 167 savants, learned men in every walk of science and the arts, including the great mathematician Fourier, who accompanied the general and his army. Napoleon had recently been made a member of the Institute of France, and regarded this honour more highly than his military rank. Once ensconced in Cairo he formed an Institute of Egypt, and the work of this body formed the basis of modern Egypotology, tetraology and other important strands of learning. However, despite Napoleon's ardent attempts to appear to be the friend of Islam, the occupation suffered a fundamental failure to understand the country he was trying to civilise; the first attempt in modern times by a western power to occupy a Middle Eastern country holds parallels for the latest efforts to import western political systems. `The very core of what the French thought they were bringing to the Egyptians ... was not only incomprehensible but offensive to the people they were addressing. This was a situation which the French, in their turn, would soon begin to find incomprehensible and offensive.'

Unfortunately the military descriptions are badly let down by the author's continuous reference to `rifles', something the French army of the period did not have. Muskets absolutely were not rifles, nor were ramrods designed to clean them; such fundamental errors should not have been allowed to pass in what is otherwise a very entertaining and well written book. Ultimately the expedition was a failure long before Napoleon's decision to return to France, but Nelson's victory and the brilliance of Sir Sidney Smith helped thwart his initial scheme, and as he was taken aboard Bellerophon for his final journey to St Helena in 1815, he exclaimed: `But for you English, I would have been Emperor of the East.'

A great history book, 10 Jul 2007

I would recommend this book to anyone intereseted in the history of the Napoleonic wars in general and/or Napoleon in general. It is a great read.

Starthern has written a very readable and enjoyable study of Napoleon's campaign in Egypt covering in detail (with maps) the various battles of this amazing episode, including Nelson's Battle of the Nile, and the Battle of the Pyramids, the characters involved; the Generals, the Beys and Mamelukes, the Savants and the experiences of the French soldiers.

I felt it read like good historical novel in places and being a big fan of historic fiction (books like the Sharpe series) this added to my enjoyment. Read this book!

Must Read for Napoleon Fans, 22 Jun 2007
"A must read for any fans of Napoleon or the period. Napoleon in Egypt is scholarly, insightful and also good fun. The resonance of Napoleon invading Egypt - and today's incursions into the East - make Napoleon In Egypt all the more readable and rewarding."

The A-Z of the A-Z War , 10 Dec 2008
Of one thing there is no doubt - Ian Knight is THE leading authority on the Anglo-Zulu War of 1879. So there is no-one better placed to compile what is a much-needed book on a campaign which has spawned vast amounts of literature and comment - not all of it as well-informed as this volume.
Ian Knight's superb book is an ecletic mixture of various topics connected with the A-Z War - and fittingly is produced in A-Z order, from Ammunition Boxes to the Zulu Royal House, and everything in between.
Each entry is in itself a journey - and whether you are an Anglo-Zulu War enthusiast, someone new to the campaign - or have a general interest in military/Victorian history, this book informs at every level.
Ian's writing style - in this and his many other books - is constantly engaging and never lapses into the sometimes impenetrable language of academia.
Get it!

Knight's new offering fills neglected gap in Zulu War literature, 05 Dec 2008
In the genre of historical inquiry and interpretation, a book bearing the word "Companion" within its title, seems to immediately conjure the image of a reference manual. Often, such references are quickly dismissed as dry, boring and only of value to the most zealous students. In this instance however, the term "Companion" is somewhat misleading. To be sure, it does fulfill it's reference expectations in the manner one would expect from Ian Knight, with absolute accuracy, unassailable scholarship and thorough annotation. But the real genius of this work did not strike me until I was near the end of page 53. I had devoured the first twelve topical studies, from Ammunition Boxes to Burying the Dead, in one swipe----as if I were on vacation guiltily reading tawdry fiction. Within this type of book, which seems to have more ambiguous literary parameters than that of a serious history, Knight is able to stretch a bit, and he shows himself as a writer of most excellent quality. Indeed, it is his commentary on the facts and anecdotes examined that gives this work it's tremendous value. Beyond that, the amount of subjects covered is very broad. I was extremely pleased to see nearly every topic I expected, but some of the best little gems can be found under headings less obviously anticipated, such as the thread entitled 'Liars, Fakes and Rogues.'

Regarding the gap in Zulu War literature alluded to in the title, it's filled by this book in the following manner. A quick examination of my book shelves revealed a count of no less than 75 major titles dealing specifically with the Anglo-Zulu War of 1879, not to mention countless magazine articles, society journals and smaller specialty books concerning aspects such as uniforms and weaponry. The point is then, when one is reading these accounts, often they cause as many questions to arise as those they answer. A simplistic yet clear enough example is the Ammunition Box controversy at Isandlwana. It's well and good to read about a possible shortage of ammunition due to the nature of the boxes. However, this book explains why or why not that may have been the case, but only after a comprehensive look at the evidence, from the design of the box, to survivor testimony and archaeological data. As this is the standard methodology applied to all the scrutinized subjects, a great many of my questions finally have answers.

A feature that should be well appreciated for it's convenience factor, is the inclusion within the introduction of maps associated with every major military action of the war. The biggest visual treat however is on the dust cover, which features a newly discovered contemporary period painting from an as yet unknown Victorian artist, of the action at the mission station at Rorke's Drift. Unfortunately, as the size of the original painting is obviously too large to fit even wrapped around the cover, one is not afforded a truly satisfying view. Hopefully at some point the entire painting will be made available in print form.

In the age of the internet, many students of history find themselves debating and discussing favorite subjects online with others of like interests. For those who find themselves enmeshed in the history of the Anglo-Zulu War, having this book will most assuredly lend an advantage over fellow debaters, as well as saving one from having to rampage through 75 books for that one all important reference!


Its exactly what it says it is! , 16 Oct 2008
This is a great reference work for all those interested in the Zulu war. Its basically an A-Z guide to the war covering everything from Dogs, uniforms, cinema, the Zulu royal family, rockets etc. I thought it was fascinating book and I could not put it down.

Its exactly what it says it is, a great companion to the study of the Zulu war written by one of the leading historians of the Zulu war.

The Zulu War 1879 (Essential Histories S.)., 10 Feb 2004
Ian Knight is a well known author of Zulu histories and this one is, as ever, very good. Well illustrated and with good, clear maps, you are guided through the campaign by an expert. Easy reading - well worth adding to your library.

Superb, 18 Nov 2008
The book covers South African history from the 1870s to 1910, a fascinating period of history involving the clash of British Imperialism, the Afrikaaner states of the Transvaal and Orange Free State, indiginous Zulu uprisings and the beginnings of the pass system. Central characters are Cecil Rhodes, Jameson, Kruger, De La Rey - and their roles in the ultimate disaster of the Anglo-Boer war.

For anyone interested in SA, late Victorian history or history generally, this is a superb book, well written and fascinating.

Very Good, 08 Oct 2008
The Scramble for Africa by Thomas Pakenham is a very good book which deals with the remarkable last two decades in the nineteenth century when Africa was carved up by the nations of Europe. It is an immensely readable book which deals with a number of different areas and time periods but also goes further and deals with individuals and more forgotten examples of European colonisation such as the Belgians in the Congo. All in all a remarkable book which is a pleasure to read.

Great book of a harrowing journey of a continent. , 11 Jun 2008
This is a great book, and like other readers, I think it gave account of every region fairly evenly. Pakenham shows that mistreatment of the native population was endemic across the continent, regardless of the ruling European power. He also managed to avoid romanticizing the situation prior to colonization, bringing to life the personalities of the Kings, Sultans and Chiefs that ruled before the europeans arrived.

Pakenham did however get mixed up with what was British and what was English, as English historians often do.

Best history book ever!, 17 May 2008
Pakenham gives you the detail without the drudgery; the tale without the tediousness; takes you right into the heart of history but manages to make the ride effortless. His story spans two continents, includes a myriad of characters and covers many years of imperial intrigue in Africa. Yet, he not only stays true to the facts, he also gives you a human story. You can close your eyes and see Leopold or Lobengula or any of the hundreds of actors that claimed this stage of human history. Here is a priceless account of how and why it happened; the partition of Africa in the nineteenth century by several European nations. A must read!

Superb, i finished it at 5am!, 09 Apr 2007
This book covers every issue you could possibly think of in colonial africa in just enough detail to give you a pan-african diorama without getting bogged down in any individual area (each of which deserves a book on their own). The only other example ive read got so bogged down with the Boer war that lesser known colonial hi-jinx such as the Sudan and Uganda were lost within a sea of Zulus. A rarely touched subject, especially relevant with current events in Zimbabwe.
If you can splash out on the Hardback do- the paper used for the paperback is appalling.


An enlightening read, 20 Dec 2006
This is a beautifully written work that provides a fascinating insight into the continent's history, underdevelopment and civil strife. Devoid of sentimentality and full of objectivity, the author conveys the deep message, which explains not only the resilience of the continent but also the ravages that it has been subjected to throughout its turbulent history. Behind the tragedies of the continent are the heavy hands of the ex-colonial masters and the exploitative drives of some business concerns working in partnership with African dictators, psychopaths and administrative kleptomaniacs that have power and are excluding the people in the running of the land. With more piteous prospects than any other continent, Africa mirrors the failures of humanity as well as its hopes and reams.
Other titles that treat this African malaise are DISCIPLES OF FORTUNE , AFRICA UNCHAINED, THE SCHACKLED CONTINENT, TRIPLE AGENT DOUBLE CROSS. Together these titles exposed the personal and collective problems of the people and the personal and collective efforts made, and the means and ways to take the Africa forward despite all the constrains.

A Modern Classic, 08 Jan 2008
The first thing that should strike the reader is that the work is over 25 years old yet still has a freshness about its approach to the conflict. This and the comprehensive coverage of events leading up to the war, as well as the war itself, suggests it will be many more years before it ceases to be the definitive history of the Boer War. One particularly interesting feature is Pakenham's defence of General Buller who has been vilified for his incompetence in just about every other book on the subject. Not everyone will agree with Pakenham's defence of Buller but it's undoubtedly well argued, based as it is on documents and other material discovered at Buller's family home in Devon. A must read for anyone with an interest in the Boer War.

History alive., 30 May 2007
This is the way history should be written. Facts are offered in such an interesting way. Rutland's Guns by Roger Carpenter is a novel about the Boer War based on accurate facts while this book is history written as a novel. A great read.

Fantastic! , 05 Jul 2006
This was the first book I had ever read on the Boer War and what an introduction! Pakenham not only wields a gripping narrative account of the battles, political intrigue and the affairs of the individuals involved, which has you eagerly turning every page, but also expertly analyses many aspects of the war. It is an especially good book for analysing the causes of the war, the performance of the various British generals (especially in revising attitudes towards Buller) and the factors that made British victory so difficult. In fact the latter means that the book is not only a good account of the Boer War but also essential reading for anyone interested in 20th century military history as it helps explain some of the bloodshed of World War One. The focus is on the British perspective but I would not say it is unfavourable or greatly unfair towards the Boers as a good account of the Concentration camps is given for example. As an introduction to topic or just a book for someone with a general interest in military history it is a fantastic read.

Best book I've read on the Boer War, 19 Jun 2005
I am a collector of British military medals with a particular interest in the Boer War and the First World War. As a result I have read many books on about these wars and I can honestly say that this book is the best one I have ever read concerning the Boer War of 1899 to 1902.

The author takes an in depth look at the causes of the war in both a detailed and refreshingly modern analytic way not found in previous works. He then moves on and examines the various phases of the war from the large set piece battles to the guerrila war that followed as well as the aftermath.

However, what is really pleasing about this book is the way it is written being more akin to a novel than a history textbook. The result is a highly readble text with very little dry bits that often tire the reader when he or she embarks on reading a book as large as this one.

If you want one good general history of the Boer War then this is the one to buy. It will suit those who wish to learn more about the politics of the war as well as those who have a keen interest in the military tatics used.

In short this really is a first class book which shlould be read by anyone with an interest in this conflict.

Good book, 16 Dec 2002
The conflict between my ancestors and the British Empire comes to life through Pakenham’s masterful and researched account. Unfortunately Pakenham tells the story from primarily a British perspective and often lacks balance. At Spioenkop and Colenso, for instance, you can’t help but feel sorry for Gen. Buller and his men. But later, after Roberts arrives with his armada, Pakenham deliberately fails to evoke the same sympathies towards the Boers suffering under truly horrific Imperial decision-making.
It’s an informative and exciting read with lots of details and opinions reminding the reader that hindsight is always 20/20 vision. The author presumes that the reader is familiar with weapons of that period and battlefield tactics used up ‘till then. Would have liked more photos.

African Shipwreck, 09 Nov 2008
An account of the fate of the Grosvenor, an East Indiaman that ran aground off the coast of Africa on its way from India to the U.K. Personal histories mixed with investigation. I was not surprised that the survivors of the grounding split into smaller groups, but the fact that the women and injured being abandoned was shocking. I suppose we have spent so long hearing "Women and Children first".

stare death in the face, 13 Aug 2008
The set up of the story took too long for me
By page 76 I was no nearer to weighing anchor than page one

By the time the wreck happened it turned into a hell of a tale
The survival instinct kicked in and all sense of comradmanship was abandoned

Wrong decision after wrong decision in the end cost many lives

The epilogue and folk law tales of the assimilation of people who may have survived amongst the natives was great


First rate factual adventure., 05 Jul 2008
A tragic tale of shipwreck off the East African coast. Although a very sad account of the fate of men, women and children, the book also gives a detailed account of the various lifestyles of Europeans living and trading in 1780s India. Initially I thought that this was going to be an account of man and meteorology but the book is a good balance of biography, geography, history and maritime facts. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and found it hard to put down in the wee hours of the morning.

Bring a film out on it!, 10 Aug 2007
The Grosvenor was one of the finest East Indiamen of her day, but she ran aground on the treacherous coast of south-east Africa. An astonishing number of her crew and passengers, including women and children, reached the shore safely, but the castaways found themselves hundreds of miles from the nearest European outpost - and utterly ignorant of their surroundings and the people among whom they found themselves.

Drawing upon much new research, Stephen Taylor pieces together this extraordinary saga, sifting the myths that became attached to The Grosvenor from a reality that is no less gripping. Taking the reader to the heart of what is now the Wild Coast of Pondoland, he reveals the misunderstandings that led to tragedy, tells the story of those who escaped, and unravels the mystery of those who stayed. An unforgetable story of its time of how the survivors trekked for over 400 miles across the most hostile of lands suffering the most extreme of privations. After many months they reach safety amongst kind hearted dutch settlers...but alas for many it was not to be!

Gripping story, told really well with great detail and a flowing easy to read narrative....great read!


The Caliban Shore, 26 Jul 2007
The book is very detailed, in fact I think too detailed. If you just want to read about the actual experience these unfortunate people suffered only read the middle or their abouts of the book. The rest is more akin to a study.
While I admire the effort Stephen Taylor has put into writing this book, does all the detailed back ground about each character really enhance the yarn ?

Delusions of Grandeur, 08 Aug 2007
A belief that one is Napoleon is a common cypher for madness. But such delusions of gr