|
Browse categories
|
 |
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
 Customer Reviews
Make sure you have a lot of time on your hands for this one!, 17 Nov 2008
Apparently the book was originally serialised and it shows - it does have the feeling that it goes on a bit too long. It also tends towards the depressing. Otherwise, a very good read (Kept me busy for a couple of days on holiday)
Absolutely blown away by this book!, 15 Jul 2008
When our Book Club chose CoMC, I sighed inside thinking oh no not another achingly dull 'classic'.
How wrong was I - I can't put the thing down and am busy devouring it at every opportunity! It's got a bit of everything - double crossing dirty dealers, treasure hunting, starcrossed lovers, wrongful imprisonment - any one of these would make a fantastic film plot by itself but here you have them all in one book. It is in reasonably straightforward language which means you don't have to think 'too hard' whilst you're reading it, so you can relax and enjoy it.
I would agree that some of the chapters don't immediately seem to bear any relevance to the tale - but then as you read on you see that actually Dumas is busy setting the scene so all of a sudden you'll get an 'aahhh NOW it makes sense' moment!
Thoroughly enjoyable, unputdownable - this is the only book you'll need on holiday this year!
One of the greatest literary works, 28 Mar 2008
An entralling book of magnificent scale. The way dumas ties the many different links of the story togther is genius. I didn't find one moment of this story boring. It is a long novel and, as such, it is something of a commitment, but it is well worth it. A story that is primarly about the morality of vengeance, I wished at times that I could be transported back to france under the bonapartist revolution. I strongly recommend the penguin unabridge version.
Wow!, 25 Feb 2008
Going through some of the classic novels, and not being a great reader, I was not sure what to expect from this. But all I can say is what a novel.
Originally the huge size of the full version of the novel put me off somewhat, but ultimately it is one of the easiest novels to read and one you don't want to end or put down. I would agree with other reviews, make sure the unabridged version is bought.
It does lag a little when the Count is in Rome, but readers should preserve. Some could argue that there are some flaws with the development of the characters, I particularly thought that there needed to be more regret in Dantes' actions.
But really, go and buy this novel and read one of the greatest stories ever written.
Superb!!, 28 Jan 2008
In an email to a friend, I had this to say of what surely is one of the most wonderful books of all times:
"I'm currently reading "The Count of Monte Cristo", a monster of a book at almost 1,200 pages. It's definitely one of the best books I've ever read. I strongly recommend it, if you've not read it already (somehow, I suspect you have). It's got everything I value in a book - beautiful (though quaint and antiquated , which makes it more pleasing) language, intrigue, jealousy, vindictiveness, power; in short, very rich in moral fibre.
The only problem is that I'm into the last 70 or so pages, and will finish it soon (a prospect I truly dread!); the obvious problem is - what book does one read after reading a masterpiece like this? A philanderer who has had the good fortune of dating the most desired woman around faces the same problem - who does he date after such an exploit?"
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
Customer Reviews
Make sure you have a lot of time on your hands for this one!, 17 Nov 2008
Apparently the book was originally serialised and it shows - it does have the feeling that it goes on a bit too long. It also tends towards the depressing. Otherwise, a very good read (Kept me busy for a couple of days on holiday)
Absolutely blown away by this book!, 15 Jul 2008
When our Book Club chose CoMC, I sighed inside thinking oh no not another achingly dull 'classic'.
How wrong was I - I can't put the thing down and am busy devouring it at every opportunity! It's got a bit of everything - double crossing dirty dealers, treasure hunting, starcrossed lovers, wrongful imprisonment - any one of these would make a fantastic film plot by itself but here you have them all in one book. It is in reasonably straightforward language which means you don't have to think 'too hard' whilst you're reading it, so you can relax and enjoy it.
I would agree that some of the chapters don't immediately seem to bear any relevance to the tale - but then as you read on you see that actually Dumas is busy setting the scene so all of a sudden you'll get an 'aahhh NOW it makes sense' moment!
Thoroughly enjoyable, unputdownable - this is the only book you'll need on holiday this year!
One of the greatest literary works, 28 Mar 2008
An entralling book of magnificent scale. The way dumas ties the many different links of the story togther is genius. I didn't find one moment of this story boring. It is a long novel and, as such, it is something of a commitment, but it is well worth it. A story that is primarly about the morality of vengeance, I wished at times that I could be transported back to france under the bonapartist revolution. I strongly recommend the penguin unabridge version.
Wow!, 25 Feb 2008
Going through some of the classic novels, and not being a great reader, I was not sure what to expect from this. But all I can say is what a novel.
Originally the huge size of the full version of the novel put me off somewhat, but ultimately it is one of the easiest novels to read and one you don't want to end or put down. I would agree with other reviews, make sure the unabridged version is bought.
It does lag a little when the Count is in Rome, but readers should preserve. Some could argue that there are some flaws with the development of the characters, I particularly thought that there needed to be more regret in Dantes' actions.
But really, go and buy this novel and read one of the greatest stories ever written.
Superb!!, 28 Jan 2008
In an email to a friend, I had this to say of what surely is one of the most wonderful books of all times:
"I'm currently reading "The Count of Monte Cristo", a monster of a book at almost 1,200 pages. It's definitely one of the best books I've ever read. I strongly recommend it, if you've not read it already (somehow, I suspect you have). It's got everything I value in a book - beautiful (though quaint and antiquated , which makes it more pleasing) language, intrigue, jealousy, vindictiveness, power; in short, very rich in moral fibre.
The only problem is that I'm into the last 70 or so pages, and will finish it soon (a prospect I truly dread!); the obvious problem is - what book does one read after reading a masterpiece like this? A philanderer who has had the good fortune of dating the most desired woman around faces the same problem - who does he date after such an exploit?"
Get the new Penguin edition!, 02 Dec 2008
I was surprised at how easy and enjoyable a read this was. I absolutely recommend getting the Penguin edition as it's the only new translation since the book first reached England in 1860 so all the other editions have the sex and drugs cut out, plus a few scenes that the translator found boring. This truly is the epitome of revenge dramas.
Amazing read, 21 Nov 2008
What I loved about this book was that it is the perfect revenge story and I loved the plan he had set up. What I had expected to take me a long time to read didn't take me long at all because by half way through I just wanted to know what the revenge was going to be.
Absolutly amazing and a must read.
One of my favourite novels, 04 Apr 2008
I strongly believe that anyone with a passing interest in literature should read this book. A fantastic adventure story of revenge, love and redemption, the characters are wonderfully developed and the plot lines intertwine very cleverly. A long book but very, very rewarding.
Not just another adventure book..., 09 Mar 2008
Absolutely draws you into a multi-layered tale of revenge, love, intrigue, redemption and philosophy. Deserving of the 'classic' status, not many writers now or before can write like this - the count himself is one of the most enigmatic character's ever written and the story is constructed on so many levels I'm surprised that it's been described as a 'children's book' in the foreword. And be warned, may make you want to go sailing.
1800s soap opera, 23 Sep 2007
I had been looking forward to reading this 'classic' for ages, but was mightily disappointed by often poorly written poppycock. After a strong opening, the plot and the quality of writing soon went downhill. I got the impression that some weeks he couldn't be bothered writing anything decent, so sent in any old drivel. This is the 1800s equivilant to sitting down and watching Eastenders for a year! It's that trite. Go to the pub, read something else (Dickens maybe), but for god's sake, I urge you to do something more productive with your life.
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Customer Reviews
Make sure you have a lot of time on your hands for this one!, 17 Nov 2008
Apparently the book was originally serialised and it shows - it does have the feeling that it goes on a bit too long. It also tends towards the depressing. Otherwise, a very good read (Kept me busy for a couple of days on holiday) Absolutely blown away by this book!, 15 Jul 2008
When our Book Club chose CoMC, I sighed inside thinking oh no not another achingly dull 'classic'.
How wrong was I - I can't put the thing down and am busy devouring it at every opportunity! It's got a bit of everything - double crossing dirty dealers, treasure hunting, starcrossed lovers, wrongful imprisonment - any one of these would make a fantastic film plot by itself but here you have them all in one book. It is in reasonably straightforward language which means you don't have to think 'too hard' whilst you're reading it, so you can relax and enjoy it.
I would agree that some of the chapters don't immediately seem to bear any relevance to the tale - but then as you read on you see that actually Dumas is busy setting the scene so all of a sudden you'll get an 'aahhh NOW it makes sense' moment!
Thoroughly enjoyable, unputdownable - this is the only book you'll need on holiday this year! One of the greatest literary works, 28 Mar 2008
An entralling book of magnificent scale. The way dumas ties the many different links of the story togther is genius. I didn't find one moment of this story boring. It is a long novel and, as such, it is something of a commitment, but it is well worth it. A story that is primarly about the morality of vengeance, I wished at times that I could be transported back to france under the bonapartist revolution. I strongly recommend the penguin unabridge version. Wow!, 25 Feb 2008
Going through some of the classic novels, and not being a great reader, I was not sure what to expect from this. But all I can say is what a novel.
Originally the huge size of the full version of the novel put me off somewhat, but ultimately it is one of the easiest novels to read and one you don't want to end or put down. I would agree with other reviews, make sure the unabridged version is bought.
It does lag a little when the Count is in Rome, but readers should preserve. Some could argue that there are some flaws with the development of the characters, I particularly thought that there needed to be more regret in Dantes' actions.
But really, go and buy this novel and read one of the greatest stories ever written. Superb!!, 28 Jan 2008
In an email to a friend, I had this to say of what surely is one of the most wonderful books of all times:
"I'm currently reading "The Count of Monte Cristo", a monster of a book at almost 1,200 pages. It's definitely one of the best books I've ever read. I strongly recommend it, if you've not read it already (somehow, I suspect you have). It's got everything I value in a book - beautiful (though quaint and antiquated , which makes it more pleasing) language, intrigue, jealousy, vindictiveness, power; in short, very rich in moral fibre.
The only problem is that I'm into the last 70 or so pages, and will finish it soon (a prospect I truly dread!); the obvious problem is - what book does one read after reading a masterpiece like this? A philanderer who has had the good fortune of dating the most desired woman around faces the same problem - who does he date after such an exploit?" Get the new Penguin edition!, 02 Dec 2008
I was surprised at how easy and enjoyable a read this was. I absolutely recommend getting the Penguin edition as it's the only new translation since the book first reached England in 1860 so all the other editions have the sex and drugs cut out, plus a few scenes that the translator found boring. This truly is the epitome of revenge dramas. Amazing read, 21 Nov 2008
What I loved about this book was that it is the perfect revenge story and I loved the plan he had set up. What I had expected to take me a long time to read didn't take me long at all because by half way through I just wanted to know what the revenge was going to be.
Absolutly amazing and a must read. One of my favourite novels, 04 Apr 2008
I strongly believe that anyone with a passing interest in literature should read this book. A fantastic adventure story of revenge, love and redemption, the characters are wonderfully developed and the plot lines intertwine very cleverly. A long book but very, very rewarding. Not just another adventure book..., 09 Mar 2008
Absolutely draws you into a multi-layered tale of revenge, love, intrigue, redemption and philosophy. Deserving of the 'classic' status, not many writers now or before can write like this - the count himself is one of the most enigmatic character's ever written and the story is constructed on so many levels I'm surprised that it's been described as a 'children's book' in the foreword. And be warned, may make you want to go sailing. 1800s soap opera, 23 Sep 2007
I had been looking forward to reading this 'classic' for ages, but was mightily disappointed by often poorly written poppycock. After a strong opening, the plot and the quality of writing soon went downhill. I got the impression that some weeks he couldn't be bothered writing anything decent, so sent in any old drivel. This is the 1800s equivilant to sitting down and watching Eastenders for a year! It's that trite. Go to the pub, read something else (Dickens maybe), but for god's sake, I urge you to do something more productive with your life. Swashbuckling Good Fun!!, 31 Jan 2007
What fun! This books just jumps right out and keeps moving along (except for a couple of slow spots -- but needed to develop the character's past, etc.) The cameraderie between the Musketeers is awesome and they are incredibly wonderful scamps.
D'artagnon was adorable, as were Athos, Aramis and Porthos. The evil Milady was truly EVIL and WICKED. The dialogue was awesome, it just crackled right along. I think we all know the basic story and how it ended, but reading the book was much more enjoyable than the movie, as they always are. It did bring back many memories of that wonderful version from the 70's, with Michael York and Raquel Welch. I will have to revisit that, and am looking forward to reading the sequels. Dumas is truly a brilliant author.
A historical novel wrapped up with a 1st-class folk tale, 23 Jan 2004
Three things struck me when I read this for the first time, one is it's striking accuracy to historical events, and the other the way it seems like a timeless tale which could have been told by Viking warlords or Roman generals. And finally, the way in which it is just a fantastic story, that can be enjoyed just as much as the latest Hollywood action movie or soap opera on T.V. As an A-level student. I have only read one novel, Wuthering Heights, before. After reading a novel with such a heavy beginning, I was amazed at how Dumas got right to the point. He doesn't dawdle about as Bronte does in the first three chapters of Wuthering Heights. Apart from being an English AS level student, I'm also a History student who had just finished studying Louis XIV France. Although 50 years after d'Artangnan's adventure, I found it easy to understand and I would recommend that anyone who has a brief knowledge of 17th Century France will enjoy this novel more. Which is why I recommend this version particulary. As it comes with a historical note, introduction and a set of small notes at the back. If you're not a student, I would recommend you this book anyway, as I feel it is a rare gem which can ,unlike some 19th Century novels, still be enjoyed today. Unmistakably a classic, 12 Jan 2004
Having spent most of my life reading boyish books such as the ones written authors such as McNab and Ryan I decided to get stuck into some of the real fictional masterpieces. Having encountered the Three Muusketeers before in the cinema I thought I would give the written version a try. Im glad I did because the book is brilliant. The story is told in a refreshingly different way than modern books and opens your eyes to what times were like back then. Forget all your preconceptions about classics being difficult to read and hence boring because once you strat reading this you will realsise that they are not. In simple terms reading this was a wise choice and I would strongly recommend it to anyone. Seen the movies?, 02 Jun 2003
My first introduction to 'the three musketeers' was during my childhood when I used to avidly watch 'dogtanian and the three muskehounds' - you may well laugh, but years later my fond memories of this cartoon impelled me to read the book. Yes the book is much better than any cartoon or film version, but when you read it you realise why. Basically, the characters are initially introduced in a rather sketchy manner - you only 'get to know' the characters as you read through the book. It is therefore understandable that this is difficult to portray in a film - hence reading the book is a must, it is a classic. masterpiece of adventure/literature, 23 Dec 1999
An unusual book that reflects Dumas's views of both honour and chivalry as well as his interest in esoteric societies. Woven into the adventure romp are countless referernces to the philosophical dilemas that confront man's existence and most of all regarding his relationship with fellow man. It is hard not to identify with the politically incorrect charcters of the four heroes and even the villains lack any real malice. By far and away the best aspect (for me) is the astoundingly uplifting quality of the narrative. Comparable to three pints of Youngs on an empty stomach after half a chapter you will feel that all is right with the world and after the battle scenes you may feel it necessary to re-enact the sword play with an old golf club. Far outshines the authors other work and will provide you with many hours priceless entertainment.
|
|
|
 |
|
|
 |
|
|
 |
|
|
Customer Reviews
Make sure you have a lot of time on your hands for this one!, 17 Nov 2008
Apparently the book was originally serialised and it shows - it does have the feeling that it goes on a bit too long. It also tends towards the depressing. Otherwise, a very good read (Kept me busy for a couple of days on holiday) Absolutely blown away by this book!, 15 Jul 2008
When our Book Club chose CoMC, I sighed inside thinking oh no not another achingly dull 'classic'.
How wrong was I - I can't put the thing down and am busy devouring it at every opportunity! It's got a bit of everything - double crossing dirty dealers, treasure hunting, starcrossed lovers, wrongful imprisonment - any one of these would make a fantastic film plot by itself but here you have them all in one book. It is in reasonably straightforward language which means you don't have to think 'too hard' whilst you're reading it, so you can relax and enjoy it.
I would agree that some of the chapters don't immediately seem to bear any relevance to the tale - but then as you read on you see that actually Dumas is busy setting the scene so all of a sudden you'll get an 'aahhh NOW it makes sense' moment!
Thoroughly enjoyable, unputdownable - this is the only book you'll need on holiday this year! One of the greatest literary works, 28 Mar 2008
An entralling book of magnificent scale. The way dumas ties the many different links of the story togther is genius. I didn't find one moment of this story boring. It is a long novel and, as such, it is something of a commitment, but it is well worth it. A story that is primarly about the morality of vengeance, I wished at times that I could be transported back to france under the bonapartist revolution. I strongly recommend the penguin unabridge version. Wow!, 25 Feb 2008
Going through some of the classic novels, and not being a great reader, I was not sure what to expect from this. But all I can say is what a novel.
Originally the huge size of the full version of the novel put me off somewhat, but ultimately it is one of the easiest novels to read and one you don't want to end or put down. I would agree with other reviews, make sure the unabridged version is bought.
It does lag a little when the Count is in Rome, but readers should preserve. Some could argue that there are some flaws with the development of the characters, I particularly thought that there needed to be more regret in Dantes' actions.
But really, go and buy this novel and read one of the greatest stories ever written. Superb!!, 28 Jan 2008
In an email to a friend, I had this to say of what surely is one of the most wonderful books of all times:
"I'm currently reading "The Count of Monte Cristo", a monster of a book at almost 1,200 pages. It's definitely one of the best books I've ever read. I strongly recommend it, if you've not read it already (somehow, I suspect you have). It's got everything I value in a book - beautiful (though quaint and antiquated , which makes it more pleasing) language, intrigue, jealousy, vindictiveness, power; in short, very rich in moral fibre.
The only problem is that I'm into the last 70 or so pages, and will finish it soon (a prospect I truly dread!); the obvious problem is - what book does one read after reading a masterpiece like this? A philanderer who has had the good fortune of dating the most desired woman around faces the same problem - who does he date after such an exploit?" Get the new Penguin edition!, 02 Dec 2008
I was surprised at how easy and enjoyable a read this was. I absolutely recommend getting the Penguin edition as it's the only new translation since the book first reached England in 1860 so all the other editions have the sex and drugs cut out, plus a few scenes that the translator found boring. This truly is the epitome of revenge dramas. Amazing read, 21 Nov 2008
What I loved about this book was that it is the perfect revenge story and I loved the plan he had set up. What I had expected to take me a long time to read didn't take me long at all because by half way through I just wanted to know what the revenge was going to be.
Absolutly amazing and a must read. One of my favourite novels, 04 Apr 2008
I strongly believe that anyone with a passing interest in literature should read this book. A fantastic adventure story of revenge, love and redemption, the characters are wonderfully developed and the plot lines intertwine very cleverly. A long book but very, very rewarding. Not just another adventure book..., 09 Mar 2008
Absolutely draws you into a multi-layered tale of revenge, love, intrigue, redemption and philosophy. Deserving of the 'classic' status, not many writers now or before can write like this - the count himself is one of the most enigmatic character's ever written and the story is constructed on so many levels I'm surprised that it's been described as a 'children's book' in the foreword. And be warned, may make you want to go sailing. 1800s soap opera, 23 Sep 2007
I had been looking forward to reading this 'classic' for ages, but was mightily disappointed by often poorly written poppycock. After a strong opening, the plot and the quality of writing soon went downhill. I got the impression that some weeks he couldn't be bothered writing anything decent, so sent in any old drivel. This is the 1800s equivilant to sitting down and watching Eastenders for a year! It's that trite. Go to the pub, read something else (Dickens maybe), but for god's sake, I urge you to do something more productive with your life. Swashbuckling Good Fun!!, 31 Jan 2007
What fun! This books just jumps right out and keeps moving along (except for a couple of slow spots -- but needed to develop the character's past, etc.) The cameraderie between the Musketeers is awesome and they are incredibly wonderful scamps.
D'artagnon was adorable, as were Athos, Aramis and Porthos. The evil Milady was truly EVIL and WICKED. The dialogue was awesome, it just crackled right along. I think we all know the basic story and how it ended, but reading the book was much more enjoyable than the movie, as they always are. It did bring back many memories of that wonderful version from the 70's, with Michael York and Raquel Welch. I will have to revisit that, and am looking forward to reading the sequels. Dumas is truly a brilliant author.
A historical novel wrapped up with a 1st-class folk tale, 23 Jan 2004
Three things struck me when I read this for the first time, one is it's striking accuracy to historical events, and the other the way it seems like a timeless tale which could have been told by Viking warlords or Roman generals. And finally, the way in which it is just a fantastic story, that can be enjoyed just as much as the latest Hollywood action movie or soap opera on T.V. As an A-level student. I have only read one novel, Wuthering Heights, before. After reading a novel with such a heavy beginning, I was amazed at how Dumas got right to the point. He doesn't dawdle about as Bronte does in the first three chapters of Wuthering Heights. Apart from being an English AS level student, I'm also a History student who had just finished studying Louis XIV France. Although 50 years after d'Artangnan's adventure, I found it easy to understand and I would recommend that anyone who has a brief knowledge of 17th Century France will enjoy this novel more. Which is why I recommend this version particulary. As it comes with a historical note, introduction and a set of small notes at the back. If you're not a student, I would recommend you this book anyway, as I feel it is a rare gem which can ,unlike some 19th Century novels, still be enjoyed today. Unmistakably a classic, 12 Jan 2004
Having spent most of my life reading boyish books such as the ones written authors such as McNab and Ryan I decided to get stuck into some of the real fictional masterpieces. Having encountered the Three Muusketeers before in the cinema I thought I would give the written version a try. Im glad I did because the book is brilliant. The story is told in a refreshingly different way than modern books and opens your eyes to what times were like back then. Forget all your preconceptions about classics being difficult to read and hence boring because once you strat reading this you will realsise that they are not. In simple terms reading this was a wise choice and I would strongly recommend it to anyone. Seen the movies?, 02 Jun 2003
My first introduction to 'the three musketeers' was during my childhood when I used to avidly watch 'dogtanian and the three muskehounds' - you may well laugh, but years later my fond memories of this cartoon impelled me to read the book. Yes the book is much better than any cartoon or film version, but when you read it you realise why. Basically, the characters are initially introduced in a rather sketchy manner - you only 'get to know' the characters as you read through the book. It is therefore understandable that this is difficult to portray in a film - hence reading the book is a must, it is a classic. masterpiece of adventure/literature, 23 Dec 1999
An unusual book that reflects Dumas's views of both honour and chivalry as well as his interest in esoteric societies. Woven into the adventure romp are countless referernces to the philosophical dilemas that confront man's existence and most of all regarding his relationship with fellow man. It is hard not to identify with the politically incorrect charcters of the four heroes and even the villains lack any real malice. By far and away the best aspect (for me) is the astoundingly uplifting quality of the narrative. Comparable to three pints of Youngs on an empty stomach after half a chapter you will feel that all is right with the world and after the battle scenes you may feel it necessary to re-enact the sword play with an old golf club. Far outshines the authors other work and will provide you with many hours priceless entertainment.
Neither Monte Cristo nor Three Musketeers, 26 Aug 2008
A lost masterpiece? Not for me. The frequent disruption to narrative thrust noted by another reviewer eventually became too much - I gave upon page 421. Dumas' strengths are undeniably there but payment by quantity undermines him. When Napoleon goes to hear a performance of The Creation, most of a page is given to a biography of Haydn; when St Hermine arrives in St Malo, a whole chapter relates the port's history; when his ship arrives at Mauritius, the narrative stalls again for another chapter of history. And St Hermine himself disappears from the story for well over a hundred pages. This is not The Count of Monte Cristo
or The Three Musketeers rediscovered. What Dumas needed was not a generous paymaster but a ruthless editor.
A Dumas novel no one new existed!, 12 Aug 2008
What a find this must have been, to discover an unknown work of Dumas hidden away in the Library of Paris. As the novel opens, it is the dawn of the 19th century and Napoleon rules as First Consul, not yet having being having been crowned Emperor, and the Royalist forces are still battling to restore the crown. Our hero, Hector, the Count Sainte-Hermine has seen his father and two older brothers nobly die for the Royalist cause. During a brief truce, Hector hopes to set all battles aside and declares for his true love, Claire de Sourdis. However, just before the marriage contract is signed, Hector is called back to the Royalist forces and is eventually imprisoned (and forgotten) for three years. When he is remembered and released, Hector is stripped of his title and must serve in either army or navy as a mere enlisted man, an insult for one of his class.
Hector signs on as a Corsair instead of the regular Navy and the adventure begins. Bereft of his lost love and his family fallen before him, Hector's only wish is to live life to the fullest and if he must, to die as nobly as his father and brothers did. Problem is, no matter how hard he tries, he never succeeds. Thus begins battles at sea, a fight to the death with a shark, hunting tigers and crocodiles and a close call with a python, as Hector carries off every situation with dignity, charm and élan. If this book hadn't been unknown until two years ago, I'd swear that Hector was the model for our present day super heroes. Swooning female? Out come the smelling salts and more from his bat-belt! It was so over the top and campy at times, but jolly good fun.
No, I'm not giving away the whole story -- actually the first half of the book has very little to do with Hector and very much to do with Napoleon at the start of his reign -- those who read the book jacket and expect it all to be about Hector and his heroics will be sorely disappointed. There is much politics, intrigue and battles about Europe. About half way through Hector comes back into the story and things cooked along for most of the rest of the book until the last 100 pages or so and then dragged down again. I'm not huge on battle scenes, so those were slow for me also, particularly the intricate details of the battle of Trafalgar. I confess to skipping a few pages there.
Readers should be advised that this recently discovered novel was never finished, and we'll never know where he planned to take the story in the end. There are many chapters of what appear to be needless characters, history and scenes, but not knowing how Dumas planned to complete the story, how are we to judge? I recall reading The Count of Monte Cristo (Penguin Classics)and so many chapters that went off into another direction until the end where he pulled all the threads together in the end, and perhaps that is what Dumas planned with The Last Cavalier as well. We'll never know.
All in all, entertaining but far from my favorite Dumas and not one I'll plan to read again and again. Note, if you are new to this author this book should not be your first Dumas novel. But, for Dumas fans (and I'm one) this was an interesting read and I also learned much more about Napoleon than I ever picked up from the history books. Four stars.
Flawed , 08 Aug 2008
As the previous reviewer noted a great deal of excitement surrounded the publication of this book, apparently lost until being recently rediscovered by scholar Claude Schopp, after having followed a literary trail which led from an unpublished letter to the eventual reassembly of the work in to a novel from its original serialised form.
The story is typical of Dumas, take an individual (possibly based on a historical figure) and weave them in, around and through key events drawn from French history - in this case the aftermath of the French Revolution and Napoleon's move from champion of freedom to despised despot. Here, in this text, the figure is the Count Sainte-Hermaine, a Royalist set to re-engage with wider society until recalled to a former life by a debt of honour. Eventually imprisoned for three years (having narrowly avoided death through the machinations of the Minister of Police), the Count is released - and thereupon seeks death in the best manner appropriate (having been advised to do so by Napoleon) - to be thwarted, in a rather romanticised manner, by his innate excellence.
Readers familiar with the work of Dumas may already detect the parallels apparent with 'The Count of Monte Cristo', the fight of the wronged individual to attain justice or revenge at whatever cost, in defiance of the present order and what might be termed 'God' or 'fate'. Reading through the text one is continually struck by the echoes and influence of the earlier text ('Monte Cristo'), leading, ultimately, to the reader to comparatively consider the two works - a judgement which I shall leave each reader to make alone.
As with the 'Count of Monte Cristo' this is an extremely long text, a fact influenced no doubt by the circumstance of Dumas being paid by each line he wrote. This quantative consideration perhaps explains the moments which abound throughout, when the impetus of the narrative drive is lost, and the story is unneccesarily stalled. The legacy of its earlier form also contributes to the (naturally) episodic and linear way in which the narrative moves. Unfortunately this also has the effect of producing an entirely predictable framework, which, when coupled with the particular characteristics of the Count Saint Hermine, renders the text free of dramatic tension. Whatever the situation encountered by the Count, the reader instinctively knows that no great ill will befall him, no individual will better him, no event is beyond his comprehension - and as the book progresses these factors combine to produce longueurs of increasing frequency.
This is not to suggest that the story is without merit, Dumas is too great a writer for that to be the case, but one suspects that the reconstruction effected by Schopp requires further consideration. Mr Schopp is, however, to be congratulated for making available again a novel by an often great story teller.
Buyers should also be aware that, despite its length, the book remains unfinished, although in an essay accompanying the text Claude Schopp suggests that further sections of the story might exist undiscovered and unrecognised in MS form.
On a more practical note, the publishers ought to consider subjecting new editions of this text to a greater standard of proof reading - spelling mistakes and printing errors and omissions abound throughout the text. Given the importance attached to the publication of this work such a poor standard is to be deplored (particularly given the importance of such matters to Dumas).
In conclusion, this is an intriguing read, offering a respite from the current conventions demanded of the novel form. It is, however, a structurally flawed text, which, in order to join other works by Dumas accorded the status of 'classic', requires a greater degree of editorial attention and intervention.
Get ready to Swash your Buckle!, 30 May 2008
It must be 35 years since I last read an Alexander Dumas novel. Add to this the sub-title "The Lost Masterpiece" and you can imagine that I approached this book with a little trepidation even though I had read a good review in a Saturday newspaper. My thoughts went along the lines that if it that much of a masterpiece why had it lain forgotten for 130+ years?!
Well - I need not have doubted it for one minute! The book is a great read - it bubbles along so quickly that you can not put it down (I went past my stop on the train because of a specially exciting part) - the characters both real and imaginary are well drawn, the action is compelling (maybe slightly gory for, say, the under 10's) and it is all beautifully written.
Yes it truely is a masterpiece and I would recommend it to anyone interested in historic fiction. It does help if you are familiar with the period but if you are not please do not let that put you off.
I have only two tiny quibbles - the translation is not brilliant all the time - only the odd word - and I think it was probably printed for the American market because the word 'gotten' crops up too often for my liking but, hey, please do not let that put you off either.
The Last Cavalier has left me wanting to re-read The Three Musketeers and The Count of Monte Cristo and to seek out other Dumas works.
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Customer Reviews
Make sure you have a lot of time on your hands for this one!, 17 Nov 2008
Apparently the book was originally serialised and it shows - it does have the feeling that it goes on a bit too long. It also tends towards the depressing. Otherwise, a very good read (Kept me busy for a couple of days on holiday) Absolutely blown away by this book!, 15 Jul 2008
When our Book Club chose CoMC, I sighed inside thinking oh no not another achingly dull 'classic'.
How wrong was I - I can't put the thing down and am busy devouring it at every opportunity! It's got a bit of everything - double crossing dirty dealers, treasure hunting, starcrossed lovers, wrongful imprisonment - any one of these would make a fantastic film plot by itself but here you have them all in one book. It is in reasonably straightforward language which means you don't have to think 'too hard' whilst you're reading it, so you can relax and enjoy it.
I would agree that some of the chapters don't immediately seem to bear any relevance to the tale - but then as you read on you see that actually Dumas is busy setting the scene so all of a sudden you'll get an 'aahhh NOW it makes sense' moment!
Thoroughly enjoyable, unputdownable - this is the only book you'll need on holiday this year! One of the greatest literary works, 28 Mar 2008
An entralling book of magnificent scale. The way dumas ties the many different links of the story togther is genius. I didn't find one moment of this story boring. It is a long novel and, as such, it is something of a commitment, but it is well worth it. A story that is primarly about the morality of vengeance, I wished at times that I could be transported back to france under the bonapartist revolution. I strongly recommend the penguin unabridge version. Wow!, 25 Feb 2008
Going through some of the classic novels, and not being a great reader, I was not sure what to expect from this. But all I can say is what a novel.
Originally the huge size of the full version of the novel put me off somewhat, but ultimately it is one of the easiest novels to read and one you don't want to end or put down. I would agree with other reviews, make sure the unabridged version is bought.
It does lag a little when the Count is in Rome, but readers should preserve. Some could argue that there are some flaws with the development of the characters, I particularly thought that there needed to be more regret in Dantes' actions.
But really, go and buy this novel and read one of the greatest stories ever written. Superb!!, 28 Jan 2008
In an email to a friend, I had this to say of what surely is one of the most wonderful books of all times:
"I'm currently reading "The Count of Monte Cristo", a monster of a book at almost 1,200 pages. It's definitely one of the best books I've ever read. I strongly recommend it, if you've not read it already (somehow, I suspect you have). It's got everything I value in a book - beautiful (though quaint and antiquated , which makes it more pleasing) language, intrigue, jealousy, vindictiveness, power; in short, very rich in moral fibre.
The only problem is that I'm into the last 70 or so pages, and will finish it soon (a prospect I truly dread!); the obvious problem is - what book does one read after reading a masterpiece like this? A philanderer who has had the good fortune of dating the most desired woman around faces the same problem - who does he date after such an exploit?" Get the new Penguin edition!, 02 Dec 2008
I was surprised at how easy and enjoyable a read this was. I absolutely recommend getting the Penguin edition as it's the only new translation since the book first reached England in 1860 so all the other editions have the sex and drugs cut out, plus a few scenes that the translator found boring. This truly is the epitome of revenge dramas. Amazing read, 21 Nov 2008
What I loved about this book was that it is the perfect revenge story and I loved the plan he had set up. What I had expected to take me a long time to read didn't take me long at all because by half way through I just wanted to know what the revenge was going to be.
Absolutly amazing and a must read. One of my favourite novels, 04 Apr 2008
I strongly believe that anyone with a passing interest in literature should read this book. A fantastic adventure story of revenge, love and redemption, the characters are wonderfully developed and the plot lines intertwine very cleverly. A long book but very, very rewarding. Not just another adventure book..., 09 Mar 2008
Absolutely draws you into a multi-layered tale of revenge, love, intrigue, redemption and philosophy. Deserving of the 'classic' status, not many writers now or before can write like this - the count himself is one of the most enigmatic character's ever written and the story is constructed on so many levels I'm surprised that it's been described as a 'children's book' in the foreword. And be warned, may make you want to go sailing. 1800s soap opera, 23 Sep 2007
I had been looking forward to reading this 'classic' for ages, but was mightily disappointed by often poorly written poppycock. After a strong opening, the plot and the quality of writing soon went downhill. I got the impression that some weeks he couldn't be bothered writing anything decent, so sent in any old drivel. This is the 1800s equivilant to sitting down and watching Eastenders for a year! It's that trite. Go to the pub, read something else (Dickens maybe), but for god's sake, I urge you to do something more productive with your life. Swashbuckling Good Fun!!, 31 Jan 2007
What fun! This books just jumps right out and keeps moving along (except for a couple of slow spots -- but needed to develop the character's past, etc.) The cameraderie between the Musketeers is awesome and they are incredibly wonderful scamps.
D'artagnon was adorable, as were Athos, Aramis and Porthos. The evil Milady was truly EVIL and WICKED. The dialogue was awesome, it just crackled right along. I think we all know the basic story and how it ended, but reading the book was much more enjoyable than the movie, as they always are. It did bring back many memories of that wonderful version from the 70's, with Michael York and Raquel Welch. I will have to revisit that, and am looking forward to reading the sequels. Dumas is truly a brilliant author.
A historical novel wrapped up with a 1st-class folk tale, 23 Jan 2004
Three things struck me when I read this for the first time, one is it's striking accuracy to historical events, and the other the way it seems like a timeless tale which could have been told by Viking warlords or Roman generals. And finally, the way in which it is just a fantastic story, that can be enjoyed just as much as the latest Hollywood action movie or soap opera on T.V. As an A-level student. I have only read one novel, Wuthering Heights, before. After reading a novel with such a heavy beginning, I was amazed at how Dumas got right to the point. He doesn't dawdle about as Bronte does in the first three chapters of Wuthering Heights. Apart from being an English AS level student, I'm also a History student who had just finished studying Louis XIV France. Although 50 years after d'Artangnan's adventure, I found it easy to understand and I would recommend that anyone who has a brief knowledge of 17th Century France will enjoy this novel more. Which is why I recommend this version particulary. As it comes with a historical note, introduction and a set of small notes at the back. If you're not a student, I would recommend you this book anyway, as I feel it is a rare gem which can ,unlike some 19th Century novels, still be enjoyed today. Unmistakably a classic, 12 Jan 2004
Having spent most of my life reading boyish books such as the ones written authors such as McNab and Ryan I decided to get stuck into some of the real fictional masterpieces. Having encountered the Three Muusketeers before in the cinema I thought I would give the written version a try. Im glad I did because the book is brilliant. The story is told in a refreshingly different way than modern books and opens your eyes to what times were like back then. Forget all your preconceptions about classics being difficult to read and hence boring because once you strat reading this you will realsise that they are not. In simple terms reading this was a wise choice and I would strongly recommend it to anyone. Seen the movies?, 02 Jun 2003
My first introduction to 'the three musketeers' was during my childhood when I used to avidly watch 'dogtanian and the three muskehounds' - you may well laugh, but years later my fond memories of this cartoon impelled me to read the book. Yes the book is much better than any cartoon or film version, but when you read it you realise why. Basically, the characters are initially introduced in a rather sketchy manner - you only 'get to know' the characters as you read through the book. It is therefore understandable that this is difficult to portray in a film - hence reading the book is a must, it is a classic. masterpiece of adventure/literature, 23 Dec 1999
An unusual book that reflects Dumas's views of both honour and chivalry as well as his interest in esoteric societies. Woven into the adventure romp are countless referernces to the philosophical dilemas that confront man's existence and most of all regarding his relationship with fellow man. It is hard not to identify with the politically incorrect charcters of the four heroes and even the villains lack any real malice. By far and away the best aspect (for me) is the astoundingly uplifting quality of the narrative. Comparable to three pints of Youngs on an empty stomach after half a chapter you will feel that all is right with the world and after the battle scenes you may feel it necessary to re-enact the sword play with an old golf club. Far outshines the authors other work and will provide you with many hours priceless entertainment.
Neither Monte Cristo nor Three Musketeers, 26 Aug 2008
A lost masterpiece? Not for me. The frequent disruption to narrative thrust noted by another reviewer eventually became too much - I gave upon page 421. Dumas' strengths are undeniably there but payment by quantity undermines him. When Napoleon goes to hear a performance of The Creation, most of a page is given to a biography of Haydn; when St Hermine arrives in St Malo, a whole chapter relates the port's history; when his ship arrives at Mauritius, the narrative stalls again for another chapter of history. And St Hermine himself disappears from the story for well over a hundred pages. This is not The Count of Monte Cristo
or The Three Musketeers rediscovered. What Dumas needed was not a generous paymaster but a ruthless editor.
A Dumas novel no one new existed!, 12 Aug 2008
What a find this must have been, to discover an unknown work of Dumas hidden away in the Library of Paris. As the novel opens, it is the dawn of the 19th century and Napoleon rules as First Consul, not yet having being having been crowned Emperor, and the Royalist forces are still battling to restore the crown. Our hero, Hector, the Count Sainte-Hermine has seen his father and two older brothers nobly die for the Royalist cause. During a brief truce, Hector hopes to set all battles aside and declares for his true love, Claire de Sourdis. However, just before the marriage contract is signed, Hector is called back to the Royalist forces and is eventually imprisoned (and forgotten) for three years. When he is remembered and released, Hector is stripped of his title and must serve in either army or navy as a mere enlisted man, an insult for one of his class.
Hector signs on as a Corsair instead of the regular Navy and the adventure begins. Bereft of his lost love and his family fallen before him, Hector's only wish is to live life to the fullest and if he must, to die as nobly as his father and brothers did. Problem is, no matter how hard he tries, he never succeeds. Thus begins battles at sea, a fight to the death with a shark, hunting tigers and crocodiles and a close call with a python, as Hector carries off every situation with dignity, charm and élan. If this book hadn't been unknown until two years ago, I'd swear that Hector was the model for our present day super heroes. Swooning female? Out come the smelling salts and more from his bat-belt! It was so over the top and campy at times, but jolly good fun.
No, I'm not giving away the whole story -- actually the first half of the book has very little to do with Hector and very much to do with Napoleon at the start of his reign -- those who read the book jacket and expect it all to be about Hector and his heroics will be sorely disappointed. There is much politics, intrigue and battles about Europe. About half way through Hector comes back into the story and things cooked along for most of the rest of the book until the last 100 pages or so and then dragged down again. I'm not huge on battle scenes, so those were slow for me also, particularly the intricate details of the battle of Trafalgar. I confess to skipping a few pages there.
Readers should be advised that this recently discovered novel was never finished, and we'll never know where he planned to take the story in the end. There are many chapters of what appear to be needless characters, history and scenes, but not knowing how Dumas planned to complete the story, how are we to judge? I recall reading The Count of Monte Cristo (Penguin Classics)and so many chapters that went off into another direction until the end where he pulled all the threads together in the end, and perhaps that is what Dumas planned with The Last Cavalier as well. We'll never know.
All in all, entertaining but far from my favorite Dumas and not one I'll plan to read again and again. Note, if you are new to this author this book should not be your first Dumas novel. But, for Dumas fans (and I'm one) this was an interesting read and I also learned much more about Napoleon than I ever picked up from the history books. Four stars.
Flawed , 08 Aug 2008
As the previous reviewer noted a great deal of excitement surrounded the publication of this book, apparently lost until being recently rediscovered by scholar Claude Schopp, after having followed a literary trail which led from an unpublished letter to the eventual reassembly of the work in to a novel from its original serialised form.
The story is typical of Dumas, take an individual (possibly based on a historical figure) and weave them in, around and through key events drawn from French history - in this case the aftermath of the French Revolution and Napoleon's move from champion of freedom to despised despot. Here, in this text, the figure is the Count Sainte-Hermaine, a Royalist set to re-engage with wider society until recalled to a former life by a debt of honour. Eventually imprisoned for three years (having narrowly avoided death through the machinations of the Minister of Police), the Count is released - and thereupon seeks death in the best manner appropriate (having been advised to do so by Napoleon) - to be thwarted, in a rather romanticised manner, by his innate excellence.
Readers familiar with the work of Dumas may already detect the parallels apparent with 'The Count of Monte Cristo', the fight of the wronged individual to attain justice or revenge at whatever cost, in defiance of the present order and what might be termed 'God' or 'fate'. Reading through the text one is continually struck by the echoes and influence of the earlier text ('Monte Cristo'), leading, ultimately, to the reader to comparatively consider the two works - a judgement which I shall leave each reader to make alone.
As with the 'Count of Monte Cristo' this is an extremely long text, a fact influenced no doubt by the circumstance of Dumas being paid by each line he wrote. This quantative consideration perhaps explains the moments which abound throughout, when the impetus of the narrative drive is lost, and the story is unneccesarily stalled. The legacy of its earlier form also contributes to the (naturally) episodic and linear way in which the narrative moves. Unfortunately this also has the effect of producing an entirely predictable framework, which, when coupled with the particular characteristics of the Count Saint Hermine, renders the text free of dramatic tension. Whatever the situation encountered by the Count, the reader instinctively knows that no great ill will befall him, no individual will better him, no event is beyond his comprehension - and as the book progresses these factors combine to produce longueurs of increasing frequency.
This is not to suggest that the story is without merit, Dumas is too great a writer for that to be the case, but one suspects that the reconstruction effected by Schopp requires further consideration. Mr Schopp is, however, to be congratulated for making available again a novel by an often great story teller.
Buyers should also be aware that, despite its length, the book remains unfinished, although in an essay accompanying the text Claude Schopp suggests that further sections of the story might exist undiscovered and unrecognised in MS form.
On a more practical note, the publishers ought to consider subjecting new editions of this text to a greater standard of proof reading - spelling mistakes and printing errors and omissions abound throughout the text. Given the importance attached to the publication of this work such a poor standard is to be deplored (particularly given the importance of such matters to Dumas).
In conclusion, this is an intriguing read, offering a respite from the current conventions demanded of the novel form. It is, however, a structurally flawed text, which, in order to join other works by Dumas accorded the status of 'classic', requires a greater degree of editorial attention and intervention.
Get ready to Swash your Buckle!, 30 May 2008
It must be 35 years since I last read an Alexander Dumas novel. Add to this the sub-title "The Lost Masterpiece" and you can imagine that I approached this book with a little trepidation even though I had read a good review in a Saturday newspaper. My thoughts went along the lines that if it that much of a masterpiece why had it lain forgotten for 130+ years?!
Well - I need not have doubted it for one minute! The book is a great read - it bubbles along so quickly that you can not put it down (I went past my stop on the train because of a specially exciting part) - the characters both real and imaginary are well drawn, the action is compelling (maybe slightly gory for, say, the under 10's) and it is all beautifully written.
Yes it truely is a masterpiece and I would recommend it to anyone interested in historic fiction. It does help if you are familiar with the period but if you are not please do not let that put you off.
I have only two tiny quibbles - the translation is not brilliant all the time - only the odd word - and I think it was probably printed for the American market because the word 'gotten' crops up too often for my liking but, hey, please do not let that put you off either.
The Last Cavalier has left me wanting to re-read The Three Musketeers and The Count of Monte Cristo and to seek out other Dumas works.
Make sure you have a lot of time on your hands for this one!, 17 Nov 2008
Apparently the book was originally serialised and it shows - it does have the feeling that it goes on a bit too long. It also tends towards the depressing. Otherwise, a very good read (Kept me busy for a couple of days on holiday)
Absolutely blown away by this book!, 15 Jul 2008
When our Book Club chose CoMC, I sighed inside thinking oh no not another achingly dull 'classic'.
How wrong was I - I can't put the thing down and am busy devouring it at every opportunity! It's got a bit of everything - double crossing dirty dealers, treasure hunting, starcrossed lovers, wrongful imprisonment - any one of these would make a fantastic film plot by itself but here you have them all in one book. It is in reasonably straightforward language which means you don't have to think 'too hard' whilst you're reading it, so you can relax and enjoy it.
I would agree that some of the chapters don't immediately seem to bear any relevance to the tale - but then as you read on you see that actually Dumas is busy setting the scene so all of a sudden you'll get an 'aahhh NOW it makes sense' moment!
Thoroughly enjoyable, unputdownable - this is the only book you'll need on holiday this year!
One of the greatest literary works, 28 Mar 2008
An entralling book of magnificent scale. The way dumas ties the many different links of the story togther is genius. I didn't find one moment of this story boring. It is a long novel and, as such, it is something of a commitment, but it is well worth it. A story that is primarly about the morality of vengeance, I wished at times that I could be transported back to france under the bonapartist revolution. I strongly recommend the penguin unabridge version.
Wow!, 25 Feb 2008
Going through some of the classic novels, and not being a great reader, I was not sure what to expect from this. But all I can say is what a novel.
Originally the huge size of the full version of the novel put me off somewhat, but ultimately it is one of the easiest novels to read and one you don't want to end or put down. I would agree with other reviews, make sure the unabridged version is bought.
It does lag a little when the Count is in Rome, but readers should preserve. Some could argue that there are some flaws with the development of the characters, I particularly thought that there needed to be more regret in Dantes' actions.
But really, go and buy this novel and read one of the greatest stories ever written.
Superb!!, 28 Jan 2008
In an email to a friend, I had this to say of what surely is one of the most wonderful books of all times:
"I'm currently reading "The Count of Monte Cristo", a monster of a book at almost 1,200 pages. It's definitely one of the best books I've ever read. I strongly recommend it, if you've not read it already (somehow, I suspect you have). It's got everything I value in a book - beautiful (though quaint and antiquated , which makes it more pleasing) language, intrigue, jealousy, vindictiveness, power; in short, very rich in moral fibre.
The only problem is that I'm into the last 70 or so pages, and will finish it soon (a prospect I truly dread!); the obvious problem is - what book does one read after reading a masterpiece like this? A philanderer who has had the good fortune of dating the most desired woman around faces the same problem - who does he date after such an exploit?"
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Customer Reviews
Make sure you have a lot of time on your hands for this one!, 17 Nov 2008
Apparently the book was originally serialised and it shows - it does have the feeling that it goes on a bit too long. It also tends towards the depressing. Otherwise, a very good read (Kept me busy for a couple of days on holiday) Absolutely blown away by this book!, 15 Jul 2008
When our Book Club chose CoMC, I sighed inside thinking oh no not another achingly dull 'classic'.
How wrong was I - I can't put the thing down and am busy devouring it at every opportunity! It's got a bit of everything - double crossing dirty dealers, treasure hunting, starcrossed lovers, wrongful imprisonment - any one of these would make a fantastic film plot by itself but here you have them all in one book. It is in reasonably straightforward language which means you don't have to think 'too hard' whilst you're reading it, so you can relax and enjoy it.
I would agree that some of the chapters don't immediately seem to bear any relevance to the tale - but then as you read on you see that actually Dumas is busy setting the scene so all of a sudden you'll get an 'aahhh NOW it makes sense' moment!
Thoroughly enjoyable, unputdownable - this is the only book you'll need on holiday this year! One of the greatest literary works, 28 Mar 2008
An entralling book of magnificent scale. The way dumas ties the many different links of the story togther is genius. I didn't find one moment of this story boring. It is a long novel and, as such, it is something of a commitment, but it is well worth it. A story that is primarly about the morality of vengeance, I wished at times that I could be transported back to france under the bonapartist revolution. I strongly recommend the penguin unabridge version. Wow!, 25 Feb 2008
Going through some of the classic novels, and not being a great reader, I was not sure what to expect from this. But all I can say is what a novel.
Originally the huge size of the full version of the novel put me off somewhat, but ultimately it is one of the easiest novels to read and one you don't want to end or put down. I would agree with other reviews, make sure the unabridged version is bought.
It does lag a little when the Count is in Rome, but readers should preserve. Some could argue that there are some flaws with the development of the characters, I particularly thought that there needed to be more regret in Dantes' actions.
But really, go and buy this novel and read one of the greatest stories ever written. Superb!!, 28 Jan 2008
In an email to a friend, I had this to say of what surely is one of the most wonderful books of all times:
"I'm currently reading "The Count of Monte Cristo", a monster of a book at almost 1,200 pages. It's definitely one of the best books I've ever read. I strongly recommend it, if you've not read it already (somehow, I suspect you have). It's got everything I value in a book - beautiful (though quaint and antiquated , which makes it more pleasing) language, intrigue, jealousy, vindictiveness, power; in short, very rich in moral fibre.
The only problem is that I'm into the last 70 or so pages, and will finish it soon (a prospect I truly dread!); the obvious problem is - what book does one read after reading a masterpiece like this? A philanderer who has had the good fortune of dating the most desired woman around faces the same problem - who does he date after such an exploit?" Get the new Penguin edition!, 02 Dec 2008
I was surprised at how easy and enjoyable a read this was. I absolutely recommend getting the Penguin edition as it's the only new translation since the book first reached England in 1860 so all the other editions have the sex and drugs cut out, plus a few scenes that the translator found boring. This truly is the epitome of revenge dramas. Amazing read, 21 Nov 2008
What I loved about this book was that it is the perfect revenge story and I loved the plan he had set up. What I had expected to take me a long time to read didn't take me long at all because by half way through I just wanted to know what the revenge was going to be.
Absolutly amazing and a must read. One of my favourite novels, 04 Apr 2008
I strongly believe that anyone with a passing interest in literature should read this book. A fantastic adventure story of revenge, love and redemption, the characters are wonderfully developed and the plot lines intertwine very cleverly. A long book but very, very rewarding. Not just another adventure book..., 09 Mar 2008
Absolutely draws you into a multi-layered tale of revenge, love, intrigue, redemption and philosophy. Deserving of the 'classic' status, not many writers now or before can write like this - the count himself is one of the most enigmatic character's ever written and the story is constructed on so many levels I'm surprised that it's been described as a 'children's book' in the foreword. And be warned, may make you want to go sailing. 1800s soap opera, 23 Sep 2007
I had been looking forward to reading this 'classic' for ages, but was mightily disappointed by often poorly written poppycock. After a strong opening, the plot and the quality of writing soon went downhill. I got the impression that some weeks he couldn't be bothered writing anything decent, so sent in any old drivel. This is the 1800s equivilant to sitting down and watching Eastenders for a year! It's that trite. Go to the pub, read something else (Dickens maybe), but for god's sake, I urge you to do something more productive with your life. Swashbuckling Good Fun!!, 31 Jan 2007
What fun! This books just jumps right out and keeps moving along (except for a couple of slow spots -- but needed to develop the character's past, etc.) The cameraderie between the Musketeers is awesome and they are incredibly wonderful scamps.
D'artagnon was adorable, as were Athos, Aramis and Porthos. The evil Milady was truly EVIL and WICKED. The dialogue was awesome, it just crackled right along. I think we all know the basic story and how it ended, but reading the book was much more enjoyable than the movie, as they always are. It did bring back many memories of that wonderful version from the 70's, with Michael York and Raquel Welch. I will have to revisit that, and am looking forward to reading the sequels. Dumas is truly a brilliant author.
A historical novel wrapped up with a 1st-class folk tale, 23 Jan 2004
Three things struck me when I read this for the first time, one is it's striking accuracy to historical events, and the other the way it seems like a timeless tale which could have been told by Viking warlords or Roman generals. And finally, the way in which it is just a fantastic story, that can be enjoyed just as much as the latest Hollywood action movie or soap opera on T.V. As an A-level student. I have only read one novel, Wuthering Heights, before. After reading a novel with such a heavy beginning, I was amazed at how Dumas got right to the point. He doesn't dawdle about as Bronte does in the first three chapters of Wuthering Heights. Apart from being an English AS level student, I'm also a History student who had just finished studying Louis XIV France. Although 50 years after d'Artangnan's adventure, I found it easy to understand and I would recommend that anyone who has a brief knowledge of 17th Century France will enjoy this novel more. Which is why I recommend this version particulary. As it comes with a historical note, introduction and a set of small notes at the back. If you're not a student, I would recommend you this book anyway, as I feel it is a rare gem which can ,unlike some 19th Century novels, still be enjoyed today. Unmistakably a classic, 12 Jan 2004
Having spent most of my life reading boyish books such as the ones written authors such as McNab and Ryan I decided to get stuck into some of the real fictional masterpieces. Having encountered the Three Muusketeers before in the cinema I thought I would give the written version a try. Im glad I did because the book is brilliant. The story is told in a refreshingly different way than modern books and opens your eyes to what times were like back then. Forget all your preconceptions about classics being difficult to read and hence boring because once you strat reading this you will realsise that they are not. In simple terms reading this was a wise choice and I would strongly recommend it to anyone. Seen the movies?, 02 Jun 2003
My first introduction to 'the three musketeers' was during my childhood when I used to avidly watch 'dogtanian and the three muskehounds' - you may well laugh, but years later my fond memories of this cartoon impelled me to read the book. Yes the book is much better than any cartoon or film version, but when you read it you realise why. Basically, the characters are initially introduced in a rather sketchy manner - you only 'get to know' the characters as you read through the book. It is therefore understandable that this is difficult to portray in a film - hence reading the book is a must, it is a classic. masterpiece of adventure/literature, 23 Dec 1999
An unusual book that reflects Dumas's views of both honour and chivalry as well as his interest in esoteric societies. Woven into the adventure romp are countless referernces to the philosophical dilemas that confront man's existence and most of all regarding his relationship with fellow man. It is hard not to identify with the politically incorrect charcters of the four heroes and even the villains lack any real malice. By far and away the best aspect (for me) is the astoundingly uplifting quality of the narrative. Comparable to three pints of Youngs on an empty stomach after half a chapter you will feel that all is right with the world and after the battle scenes you may feel it necessary to re-enact the sword play with an old golf club. Far outshines the authors other work and will provide you with many hours priceless entertainment.
Neither Monte Cristo nor Three Musketeers, 26 Aug 2008
A lost masterpiece? Not for me. The frequent disruption to narrative thrust noted by another reviewer eventually became too much - I gave upon page 421. Dumas' strengths are undeniably there but payment by quantity undermines him. When Napoleon goes to hear a performance of The Creation, most of a page is given to a biography of Haydn; when St Hermine arrives in St Malo, a whole chapter relates the port's history; when his ship arrives at Mauritius, the narrative stalls again for another chapter of history. And St Hermine himself disappears from the story for well over a hundred pages. This is not The Count of Monte Cristo
or The Three Musketeers rediscovered. What Dumas needed was not a generous paymaster but a ruthless editor.
A Dumas novel no one new existed!, 12 Aug 2008
What a find this must have been, to discover an unknown work of Dumas hidden away in the Library of Paris. As the novel opens, it is the dawn of the 19th century and Napoleon rules as First Consul, not yet having being having been crowned Emperor, and the Royalist forces are still battling to restore the crown. Our hero, Hector, the Count Sainte-Hermine has seen his father and two older brothers nobly die for the Royalist cause. During a brief truce, Hector hopes to set all battles aside and declares for his true love, Claire de Sourdis. However, just before the marriage contract is signed, Hector is called back to the Royalist forces and is eventually imprisoned (and forgotten) for three years. When he is remembered and released, Hector is stripped of his title and must serve in either army or navy as a mere enlisted man, an insult for one of his class.
Hector signs on as a Corsair instead of the regular Navy and the adventure begins. Bereft of his lost love and his family fallen before him, Hector's only wish is to live life to the fullest and if he must, to die as nobly as his father and brothers did. Problem is, no matter how hard he tries, he never succeeds. Thus begins battles at sea, a fight to the death with a shark, hunting tigers and crocodiles and a close call with a python, as Hector carries off every situation with dignity, charm and élan. If this book hadn't been unknown until two years ago, I'd swear that Hector was the model for our present day super heroes. Swooning female? Out come the smelling salts and more from his bat-belt! It was so over the top and campy at times, but jolly good fun.
No, I'm not giving away the whole story -- actually the first half of the book has very little to do with Hector and very much to do with Napoleon at the start of his reign -- those who read the book jacket and expect it all to be about Hector and his heroics will be sorely disappointed. There is much politics, intrigue and battles about Europe. About half way through Hector comes back into the story and things cooked along for most of the rest of the book until the last 100 pages or so and then dragged down again. I'm not huge on battle scenes, so those were slow for me also, particularly the intricate details of the battle of Trafalgar. I confess to skipping a few pages there.
Readers should be advised that this recently discovered novel was never finished, and we'll never know where he planned to take the story in the end. There are many chapters of what appear to be needless characters, history and scenes, but not knowing how Dumas planned to complete the story, how are we to judge? I recall reading The Count of Monte Cristo (Penguin Classics)and so many chapters that went off into another direction until the end where he pulled all the threads together in the end, and perhaps that is what Dumas planned with The Last Cavalier as well. We'll never know.
All in all, entertaining but far from my favorite Dumas and not one I'll plan to read again and again. Note, if you are new to this author this book should not be your first Dumas novel. But, for Dumas fans (and I'm one) this was an interesting read and I also learned much more about Napoleon than I ever picked up from the history books. Four stars.
Flawed , 08 Aug 2008
As the previous reviewer noted a great deal of excitement surrounded the publication of this book, apparently lost until being recently rediscovered by scholar Claude Schopp, after having followed a literary trail which led from an unpublished letter to the eventual reassembly of the work in to a novel from its original serialised form.
The story is typical of Dumas, take an individual (possibly based on a historical figure) and weave them in, around and through key events drawn from French history - in this case the aftermath of the French Revolution and Napoleon's move from champion of freedom to despised despot. Here, in this text, the figure is the Count Sainte-Hermaine, a Royalist set to re-engage with wider society until recalled to a former life by a debt of honour. Eventually imprisoned for three years (having narrowly avoided death through the machinations of the Minister of Police), the Count is released - and thereupon seeks death in the best manner appropriate (having been advised to do so by Napoleon) - to be thwarted, in a rather romanticised manner, by his innate excellence.
Readers familiar with the work of Dumas may already detect the parallels apparent with 'The Count of Monte Cristo', the fight of the wronged individual to attain justice or revenge at whatever cost, in defiance of the present order and what might be termed 'God' or 'fate'. Reading through the text one is continually struck by the echoes and influence of the earlier text ('Monte Cristo'), leading, ultimately, to the reader to comparatively consider the two works - a judgement which I shall leave each reader to make alone.
As with the 'Count of Monte Cristo' this is an extremely long text, a fact influenced no doubt by the circumstance of Dumas being paid by each line he wrote. This quantative consideration perhaps explains the moments which abound throughout, when the impetus of the narrative drive is lost, and the story is unneccesarily stalled. The legacy of its earlier form also contributes to the (naturally) episodic and linear way in which the narrative moves. Unfortunately this also has the effect of producing an entirely predictable framework, which, when coupled with the particular characteristics of the Count Saint Hermine, renders the text free of dramatic tension. Whatever the situation encountered by the Count, the reader instinctively knows that no great ill will befall him, no individual will better him, no event is beyond his comprehension - and as the book progresses these factors combine to produce longueurs of increasing frequency.
This is not to suggest that the story is without merit, Dumas is too great a writer for that to be the case, but one suspects that the reconstruction effected by Schopp requires further consideration. Mr Schopp is, however, to be congratulated for making available again a novel by an often great story teller.
Buyers should also be aware that, despite its length, the book remains unfinished, although in an essay accompanying the text Claude Schopp suggests that further sections of the story might exist undiscovered and unrecognised in MS form.
On a more practical note, the publishers ought to consider subjecting new editions of this text to a greater standard of proof reading - spelling mistakes and printing errors and omissions abound throughout the text. Given the importance attached to the publication of this work such a poor standard is to be deplored (particularly given the importance of such matters to Dumas).
In conclusion, this is an intriguing read, offering a respite from the current conventions demanded of the novel form. It is, however, a structurally flawed text, which, in order to join other works by Dumas accorded the status of 'classic', requires a greater degree of editorial attention and intervention.
Get ready to Swash your Buckle!, 30 May 2008
It must be 35 years since I last read an Alexander Dumas novel. Add to this the sub-title "The Lost Masterpiece" and you can imagine that I approached this book with a little trepidation even though I had read a good review in a Saturday newspaper. My thoughts went along the lines that if it that much of a masterpiece why had it lain forgotten for 130+ years?!
Well - I need not have doubted it for one minute! The book is a great read - it bubbles along so quickly that you can not put it down (I went past my stop on the train because of a specially exciting part) - the characters both real and imaginary are well drawn, the action is compelling (maybe slightly gory for, say, the under 10's) and it is all beautifully written.
Yes it truely is a masterpiece and I would recommend it to anyone interested in historic fiction. It does help if you are familiar with the period but if you are not please do not let that put you off.
I have only two tiny quibbles - the translation is not brilliant all the time - only the odd word - and I think it was probably printed for the American market because the word 'gotten' crops up too often for my liking but, hey, please do not let that put you off either.
The Last Cavalier has left me wanting to re-read The Three Musketeers and The Count of Monte Cristo and to seek out other Dumas works.
Make sure you have a lot of time on your hands for this one!, 17 Nov 2008
Apparently the book was originally serialised and it shows - it does have the feeling that it goes on a bit too long. It also tends towards the depressing. Otherwise, a very good read (Kept me busy for a couple of days on holiday)
Absolutely blown away by this book!, 15 Jul 2008
When our Book Club chose CoMC, I sighed inside thinking oh no not another achingly dull 'classic'.
How wrong was I - I can't put the thing down and am busy devouring it at every opportunity! It's got a bit of everything - double crossing dirty dealers, treasure hunting, starcrossed lovers, wrongful imprisonment - any one of these would make a fantastic film plot by itself but here you have them all in one book. It is in reasonably straightforward language which means you don't have to think 'too hard' whilst you're reading it, so you can relax and enjoy it.
I would agree that some of the chapters don't immediately seem to bear any relevance to the tale - but then as you read on you see that actually Dumas is busy setting the scene so all of a sudden you'll get an 'aahhh NOW it makes sense' moment!
Thoroughly enjoyable, unputdownable - this is the only book you'll need on holiday this year!
One of the greatest literary works, 28 Mar 2008
An entralling book of magnificent scale. The way dumas ties the many different links of the story togther is genius. I didn't find one moment of this story boring. It is a long novel and, as such, it is something of a commitment, but it is well worth it. A story that is primarly about the morality of vengeance, I wished at times that I could be transported back to france under the bonapartist revolution. I strongly recommend the penguin unabridge version.
Wow!, 25 Feb 2008
Going through some of the classic novels, and not being a great reader, I was not sure what to expect from this. But all I can say is what a novel.
Originally the huge size of the full version of the novel put me off somewhat, but ultimately it is one of the easiest novels to read and one you don't want to end or put down. I would agree with other reviews, make sure the unabridged version is bought.
It does lag a little when the Count is in Rome, but readers should preserve. Some could argue that there are some flaws with the development of the characters, I particularly thought that there needed to be more regret in Dantes' actions.
But really, go and buy this novel and read one of the greatest stories ever written.
Superb!!, 28 Jan 2008
In an email to a friend, I had this to say of what surely is one of the most wonderful books of all times:
"I'm currently reading "The Count of Monte Cristo", a monster of a book at almost 1,200 pages. It's definitely one of the best books I've ever read. I strongly recommend it, if you've not read it already (somehow, I suspect you have). It's got everything I value in a book - beautiful (though quaint and antiquated , which makes it more pleasing) language, intrigue, jealousy, vindictiveness, power; in short, very rich in moral fibre.
The only problem is that I'm into the last 70 or so pages, and will finish it soon (a prospect I truly dread!); the obvious problem is - what book does one read after reading a masterpiece like this? A philanderer who has had the good fortune of dating the most desired woman around faces the same problem - who does he date after such an exploit?"
Gripping read, 28 Jun 2008
This is a very good translation of the full story with excellent notes to explain the more obscure references - or the references to the classics if these too are unfamiliar. The book is surprisingly fast and gripping. The characters are fully formed with insight into their motivations and actions revealed at just the right time. A beautifully told story - with many memorable phrases. A must for your bookshelf to read again and again.
Dumas is indeed the master story teller!, 08 Apr 2007
Who would have thought that a book, with a simple plot about two rivals trying racing to be the first to grow a black tulip, could be so unputdownable? There are no lords and ladies, no swashbuckling heros, no evil cardinals or Miladys -- nothing but a darn good yarn, and a very sweet love story.
Dumas is just brilliant (as always) and his dialogue (as always) is among the finest I've ever come across. A very quick, albeit enjoyable, read. Highly recommended.
Dumas on a smaller scale, 01 Feb 2004
While most of Dumas works travel around a variety of places this book spends most of its time in Holland, a very different place to the France of his other works. The charm this book has for me is that it is typical Dumas in the style of writing and in the detail with which he describes scenes, but it is on a smaller scale then most of his works enabling him to spend a little more time on some of the details. It does share certain plot elements with the Count of Monte Cristo but by centering the story around an obsession with tullips it lends an eccentricity to the story which makes it an easy and pleasant read. I would recommend this to any Dumas fans and indeed to anyone who reads widely.
A dated Dumas, 21 Jun 2000
I have been an avid reader of Dumas for quite some time, and so when I came across this short, strangely titled book, I was eager to get between its sheets. The main focus of this novel is Holland in the 17th century, and there is a lot of historical content which I spent most of the first half getting to grips with. Tulipmania, which gripped the Dutch at the time, is the setting for a political and romantic plot. There are shades of a shortened Monte Cristo - prison and revenge - although I did not feel that Dumas could express such depth in so few pages. The plot is good, but predictable. Still, I would recommend this if you're a Dumas fan; and it is interesting to see so much strife over a flower.
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
Customer Reviews
Make sure you have a lot of time on your hands for this one!, 17 Nov 2008
Apparently the book was originally serialised and it shows - it does have the feeling that it goes on a bit too long. It also tends towards the depressing. Otherwise, a very good read (Kept me busy for a couple of days on holiday)
Absolutely blown away by this book!, 15 Jul 2008
When our Book Club chose CoMC, I sighed inside thinking oh no not another achingly dull 'classic'.
How wrong was I - I can't put the thing down and am busy devouring it at every opportunity! It's got a bit of everything - double crossing dirty dealers, treasure hunting, starcrossed lovers, wrongful imprisonment - any one of these would make a fantastic film plot by itself but here you have them all in one book. It is in reasonably straightforward language which means you don't have to think 'too hard' whilst you're reading it, so you can relax and enjoy it.
I would agree that some of the chapters don't immediately seem to bear any relevance to the tale - but then as you read on you see that actually Dumas is busy setting the scene so all of a sudden you'll get an 'aahhh NOW it makes sense' moment!
Thoroughly enjoyable, unputdownable - this is the only book you'll need on holiday this year!
One of the greatest literary works, 28 Mar 2008
An entralling book of magnificent scale. The way dumas ties the many different links of the story togther is genius. I didn't find one moment of this story boring. It is a long novel and, as such, it is something of a commitment, but it is well worth it. A story that is primarly about the morality of vengeance, I wished at times that I could be transported back to france under the bonapartist revolution. I strongly recommend the penguin unabridge version.
Wow!, 25 Feb 2008
Going through some of the classic novels, and not being a great reader, I was not sure what to expect from this. But all I can say is what a novel.
Originally the huge size of the full version of the novel put me off somewhat, but ultimately it is one of the easiest novels to read and one you don't want to end or put down. I would agree with other reviews, make sure the unabridged version is bought.
It does lag a little when the Count is in Rome, but readers should preserve. Some could argue that there are some flaws with the development of the characters, I particularly thought that there needed to be more regret in Dantes' actions.
But really, go and buy this novel and read one of the greatest stories ever written.
Superb!!, 28 Jan 2008
In an email to a friend, I had this to say of what surely is one of the most wonderful books of all times:
"I'm currently reading "The Count of Monte Cristo", a monster of a book at almost 1,200 pages. It's definitely one of the best books I've ever read. I strongly recommend it, if you've not read it already (somehow, I suspect you have). It's got everything I value in a book - beautiful (though quaint and antiquated , which makes it more pleasing) language, intrigue, jealousy, vindictiveness, power; in short, very rich in moral fibre.
The only problem is that I'm into the last 70 or so pages, and will finish it soon (a prospect I truly dread!); the obvious problem is - what book does one read after reading a masterpiece like this? A philanderer who has had the good fortune of dating the most desired woman around faces the same problem - who does he date after such an exploit?"
Get the new Penguin edition!, 02 Dec 2008
I was surprised at how easy and enjoyable a read this was. I absolutely recommend getting the Penguin edition as it's the only new translation since the book first reached England in 1860 so all the other editions have the sex and drugs cut out, plus a few scenes that the translator found boring. This truly is the epitome of revenge dramas.
Amazing read, 21 Nov 2008
What I loved about this book was that it is the perfect revenge story and I loved the plan he had set up. What I had expected to take me a long time to read didn't take me long at all because by half way through I just wanted to know what the revenge was going to be.
Absolutly amazing and a must | | |