Wonderful, 09 Nov 2008
Having read all the Baxter books I was keen to read this last one. It did not disappoint and was just as thrilling as the rest. Highly recommended,enjoyable read on it's own, but best read as set, then they make great sense.

Healing, 29 Sep 2008
I bought this MP3 version of the book as I was beginning to tire of reading all about the Baxter family. Actually my husband and I listened to all of this reading and it was terrific.

The Baxter family have come a long way from their beginnings and many hurts are healed in this book.

Wonderful, 09 Nov 2008
Having read all the Baxter books I was keen to read this last one. It did not disappoint and was just as thrilling as the rest. Highly recommended,enjoyable read on it's own, but best read as set, then they make great sense.

Healing, 29 Sep 2008
I bought this MP3 version of the book as I was beginning to tire of reading all about the Baxter family. Actually my husband and I listened to all of this reading and it was terrific.

The Baxter family have come a long way from their beginnings and many hurts are healed in this book.

Great Christian Fiction for everyone, 13 Jan 2008
I have read this whole series a number of times. I come from a Christian family who have worked for the Lord in Nepal for most of my childhood. I have always gone to church, my schools in Nepal were Christian and most of my friends - Christian. But on returning back to Britain and growing up in a growing materialistic country, my faith has had all too many lows.

But i read this book and i finish within 2 days. I read 'An Echo In The Darkness' and i'm finished almost straight away. Suddenly my life is put into perspective and I am reduced to tears and pleading to the Lord for forgivness of my sins. It is inspiring how Hadassah manages to be so strong in her faith after seeing such harrowing scenes and being intwine with those who dispise her race and her faith the most.

Hadassah is brought to Rome after the Romans obliterate the Jews and spread her race across a number of cities. She becomes a slave to the Valerian family and is given as personal handmaid to Julia Valerian. For over 5 years she stays with her and loves her and is repulsed by julia's way of life and slowly watches her commit terrible sin after terrible sin. Yet still loves her like a sister and prays for her constantly.
On the otherhand she falls in love with Julia's older brother who lives to please himself and to increase his wealth. Marcus and Hadassah's relationship grows painfully slowly but the conversations between them are intense and inspiring to any reader.
Her commitment to the family is reflected in her prayers for all members of the family and her LOVE for serving them rather than just her obediant service.

I then go on to read the last book in the series 'As Sure As The Dawn' and again i am inspired by Atretes determination.
In 'A Voice In The Wind' we see him go from a respected tribesman who loved his family and those around him and fought to keep his men safe, to a captured slave passed from Roman hand to Roman hand, from Ludos to Ludos, where he has to fight to entertain the Romans. He has to kill other innocent slaves for no other reasons than to gain freedom and to entertain the mob. After he is freed his relationship with Julia Valerian comes to an explosive end and he is plagued by dreams that only Hadassah can interpret for him while she awaits death.
His story is continued in the final book.

My faith doubles and triples when i read these books and I am filled with a new longing to tell the good news to my friends and to pray and give my life to the Lord again and again. This book is a good push in life and then it's up to us to keep the passion going.

To keep being like Hadassah.

Without a doubt, the best, 25 Nov 2007
All three books in the Mark of the Lion series are the best I have ever read. Even if you're not a Chrisitian they are still the best story you will ever read. I don't know anyone who doesn't absolutely adore them and I have given them to all my friends. I have never been this moved or this engrossed in a story. Make sure you read all three books. These are an absolute must and you are in for such a treat! I promise.

Brilliant, 02 Jul 2007
This is a book I've not been able to put down.. It was given to me as a gift, and probably one of the best gifts I've recieved in a very long time. I'm now getting the second one, and cant wait to start reading. I've been captivated by the message the book gives, and find I cant stop thinking about Hadassah, and her difficult journey, and how it relates to our own lives.

The book is discriptive, and it gives you a very clear picture of what went on in those crewel times, and how difficult it was for Christians as well as Jews. It gives some history and feeling and insight into Jesus's time, and I'm sure will help with reading the Bible, which I'd now like to start reading.

If nothing else, this book is an eye opener, and if you are looking for a good read, or a message of hope and love, then this is your book. It has something for everyone, and you wont be able to put it down once you start.

I definately recomended Francine Rivers - A Voice in the Wind. Plese read it.

well written, interesting plot but..., 05 May 2006
I kept feeling as if I was reading a trashy romance novel. I don't read trashy romance novels, so could be completely off the mark here. I felt tricked into reading it as it seemingly had the sanction of Christians. The opposite of good works in strange ways.

I also felt like the characters were thinking and speaking as if they lived in the 21st Century.

Isn't there anybody else who thinks the way I do about this book?

best book ever read - very suitable for men, 12 Apr 2006
This is one of the first book written by Rivers which I would say is the best book to give to a man to read! It is graphic, and descriptive of the evil of the time so be warned! That is why I think it is a good outreach tool for any man.
Just as it gets too descriptive she expertly then focuses on God or anything positive to turn your mind back to God realising God does shine through anything however bad, Which I think is very appropriate in this day and age. It helps my reading now of the new testament knowing the background these disciples had to face daily.It so aids in many different levels your walk with God.

Wonderful, 09 Nov 2008
Having read all the Baxter books I was keen to read this last one. It did not disappoint and was just as thrilling as the rest. Highly recommended,enjoyable read on it's own, but best read as set, then they make great sense.

Healing, 29 Sep 2008
I bought this MP3 version of the book as I was beginning to tire of reading all about the Baxter family. Actually my husband and I listened to all of this reading and it was terrific.

The Baxter family have come a long way from their beginnings and many hurts are healed in this book.

Great Christian Fiction for everyone, 13 Jan 2008
I have read this whole series a number of times. I come from a Christian family who have worked for the Lord in Nepal for most of my childhood. I have always gone to church, my schools in Nepal were Christian and most of my friends - Christian. But on returning back to Britain and growing up in a growing materialistic country, my faith has had all too many lows.

But i read this book and i finish within 2 days. I read 'An Echo In The Darkness' and i'm finished almost straight away. Suddenly my life is put into perspective and I am reduced to tears and pleading to the Lord for forgivness of my sins. It is inspiring how Hadassah manages to be so strong in her faith after seeing such harrowing scenes and being intwine with those who dispise her race and her faith the most.

Hadassah is brought to Rome after the Romans obliterate the Jews and spread her race across a number of cities. She becomes a slave to the Valerian family and is given as personal handmaid to Julia Valerian. For over 5 years she stays with her and loves her and is repulsed by julia's way of life and slowly watches her commit terrible sin after terrible sin. Yet still loves her like a sister and prays for her constantly.
On the otherhand she falls in love with Julia's older brother who lives to please himself and to increase his wealth. Marcus and Hadassah's relationship grows painfully slowly but the conversations between them are intense and inspiring to any reader.
Her commitment to the family is reflected in her prayers for all members of the family and her LOVE for serving them rather than just her obediant service.

I then go on to read the last book in the series 'As Sure As The Dawn' and again i am inspired by Atretes determination.
In 'A Voice In The Wind' we see him go from a respected tribesman who loved his family and those around him and fought to keep his men safe, to a captured slave passed from Roman hand to Roman hand, from Ludos to Ludos, where he has to fight to entertain the Romans. He has to kill other innocent slaves for no other reasons than to gain freedom and to entertain the mob. After he is freed his relationship with Julia Valerian comes to an explosive end and he is plagued by dreams that only Hadassah can interpret for him while she awaits death.
His story is continued in the final book.

My faith doubles and triples when i read these books and I am filled with a new longing to tell the good news to my friends and to pray and give my life to the Lord again and again. This book is a good push in life and then it's up to us to keep the passion going.

To keep being like Hadassah.

Without a doubt, the best, 25 Nov 2007
All three books in the Mark of the Lion series are the best I have ever read. Even if you're not a Chrisitian they are still the best story you will ever read. I don't know anyone who doesn't absolutely adore them and I have given them to all my friends. I have never been this moved or this engrossed in a story. Make sure you read all three books. These are an absolute must and you are in for such a treat! I promise.

Brilliant, 02 Jul 2007
This is a book I've not been able to put down.. It was given to me as a gift, and probably one of the best gifts I've recieved in a very long time. I'm now getting the second one, and cant wait to start reading. I've been captivated by the message the book gives, and find I cant stop thinking about Hadassah, and her difficult journey, and how it relates to our own lives.

The book is discriptive, and it gives you a very clear picture of what went on in those crewel times, and how difficult it was for Christians as well as Jews. It gives some history and feeling and insight into Jesus's time, and I'm sure will help with reading the Bible, which I'd now like to start reading.

If nothing else, this book is an eye opener, and if you are looking for a good read, or a message of hope and love, then this is your book. It has something for everyone, and you wont be able to put it down once you start.

I definately recomended Francine Rivers - A Voice in the Wind. Plese read it.

well written, interesting plot but..., 05 May 2006
I kept feeling as if I was reading a trashy romance novel. I don't read trashy romance novels, so could be completely off the mark here. I felt tricked into reading it as it seemingly had the sanction of Christians. The opposite of good works in strange ways.

I also felt like the characters were thinking and speaking as if they lived in the 21st Century.

Isn't there anybody else who thinks the way I do about this book?

best book ever read - very suitable for men, 12 Apr 2006
This is one of the first book written by Rivers which I would say is the best book to give to a man to read! It is graphic, and descriptive of the evil of the time so be warned! That is why I think it is a good outreach tool for any man.
Just as it gets too descriptive she expertly then focuses on God or anything positive to turn your mind back to God realising God does shine through anything however bad, Which I think is very appropriate in this day and age. It helps my reading now of the new testament knowing the background these disciples had to face daily.It so aids in many different levels your walk with God.

what happened next, 07 Jun 2008
I have just read books 1 and 2 in this series. I preferred this novel to the first one which I found too violent for my taste in places. The plot is well paced and the characters are strong which makes you want to know what happens to them. An enjoyable read.

DISAPPOINTED, 10 Dec 2007
I read "A Voice in the Wind" which so moved me that I wanted to read An Echo in the Darkness. I wanted to find out what happened to Hadassah, Marcus and Julia. Francine Rivers is excellent at describing the scene as it might have been during that era and there was a lot of history. But I found the story a little corny in places and somewhat predictable. I didn't like this book very much.

A truly amazing story, 28 Sep 2007
I could not put this book down, as the sequel to the first book A Voice in the Wind. After reading these books, I still think about the characters- mostly the main one Hadassah, and how she is an example to mirror. It wasn't just an incredible stroy, it had so many powerful messages that I feel changed from reading it.

Mark of The Lion Series by Francine Rivers, 27 Sep 2005
I have ready many books but never have I been so captivated by these three books. Excellantly written,very well researched. Definately a must!!

Powerful Story of God's Love and Forgiveness, 29 Jan 2003
It's been a year since the end of A VOICE IN THE WIND. Marcus is feeling restless. His life of pleasure no longer holds any happiness for him. Julia is finding that her friends really don't care for her, and she is fighting an illness that no one seems to be able to cure. Their mother, Phoebe, prays constantly for their salvation. Fortunately, God has not given up on them. And the answer might come from the strange woman hidden in veils who assists the young doctor Alexander at his shop in the poor part of town.

Francine Rivers has once again captured the Roman empire of the 1st century AD. Rome, Ephesus, and Israel come alive with compelling people and small historic details. The theme of God's love and the power of forgiveness are beautifully shown through the lives of these characters. The ending was so powerful, I'm sure it will stay with me for quite some time.

This novel is definitely a sequel to the first book in the series, A VOICE IN THE WIND. Enough of the first book is explained so you won't be lost if you choose to read this one first. However, since you'll ultimately want to read the first one, I recommend starting with it so none of the surprises will be spoiled.

These novels are some of the best Christian fiction I've ever read. If you enjoy a good story with strong characters, you'll want to pick these up and read them today.

Wonderful, 09 Nov 2008
Having read all the Baxter books I was keen to read this last one. It did not disappoint and was just as thrilling as the rest. Highly recommended,enjoyable read on it's own, but best read as set, then they make great sense.

Healing, 29 Sep 2008
I bought this MP3 version of the book as I was beginning to tire of reading all about the Baxter family. Actually my husband and I listened to all of this reading and it was terrific.

The Baxter family have come a long way from their beginnings and many hurts are healed in this book.

Great Christian Fiction for everyone, 13 Jan 2008
I have read this whole series a number of times. I come from a Christian family who have worked for the Lord in Nepal for most of my childhood. I have always gone to church, my schools in Nepal were Christian and most of my friends - Christian. But on returning back to Britain and growing up in a growing materialistic country, my faith has had all too many lows.

But i read this book and i finish within 2 days. I read 'An Echo In The Darkness' and i'm finished almost straight away. Suddenly my life is put into perspective and I am reduced to tears and pleading to the Lord for forgivness of my sins. It is inspiring how Hadassah manages to be so strong in her faith after seeing such harrowing scenes and being intwine with those who dispise her race and her faith the most.

Hadassah is brought to Rome after the Romans obliterate the Jews and spread her race across a number of cities. She becomes a slave to the Valerian family and is given as personal handmaid to Julia Valerian. For over 5 years she stays with her and loves her and is repulsed by julia's way of life and slowly watches her commit terrible sin after terrible sin. Yet still loves her like a sister and prays for her constantly.
On the otherhand she falls in love with Julia's older brother who lives to please himself and to increase his wealth. Marcus and Hadassah's relationship grows painfully slowly but the conversations between them are intense and inspiring to any reader.
Her commitment to the family is reflected in her prayers for all members of the family and her LOVE for serving them rather than just her obediant service.

I then go on to read the last book in the series 'As Sure As The Dawn' and again i am inspired by Atretes determination.
In 'A Voice In The Wind' we see him go from a respected tribesman who loved his family and those around him and fought to keep his men safe, to a captured slave passed from Roman hand to Roman hand, from Ludos to Ludos, where he has to fight to entertain the Romans. He has to kill other innocent slaves for no other reasons than to gain freedom and to entertain the mob. After he is freed his relationship with Julia Valerian comes to an explosive end and he is plagued by dreams that only Hadassah can interpret for him while she awaits death.
His story is continued in the final book.

My faith doubles and triples when i read these books and I am filled with a new longing to tell the good news to my friends and to pray and give my life to the Lord again and again. This book is a good push in life and then it's up to us to keep the passion going.

To keep being like Hadassah.

Without a doubt, the best, 25 Nov 2007
All three books in the Mark of the Lion series are the best I have ever read. Even if you're not a Chrisitian they are still the best story you will ever read. I don't know anyone who doesn't absolutely adore them and I have given them to all my friends. I have never been this moved or this engrossed in a story. Make sure you read all three books. These are an absolute must and you are in for such a treat! I promise.

Brilliant, 02 Jul 2007
This is a book I've not been able to put down.. It was given to me as a gift, and probably one of the best gifts I've recieved in a very long time. I'm now getting the second one, and cant wait to start reading. I've been captivated by the message the book gives, and find I cant stop thinking about Hadassah, and her difficult journey, and how it relates to our own lives.

The book is discriptive, and it gives you a very clear picture of what went on in those crewel times, and how difficult it was for Christians as well as Jews. It gives some history and feeling and insight into Jesus's time, and I'm sure will help with reading the Bible, which I'd now like to start reading.

If nothing else, this book is an eye opener, and if you are looking for a good read, or a message of hope and love, then this is your book. It has something for everyone, and you wont be able to put it down once you start.

I definately recomended Francine Rivers - A Voice in the Wind. Plese read it.

well written, interesting plot but..., 05 May 2006
I kept feeling as if I was reading a trashy romance novel. I don't read trashy romance novels, so could be completely off the mark here. I felt tricked into reading it as it seemingly had the sanction of Christians. The opposite of good works in strange ways.

I also felt like the characters were thinking and speaking as if they lived in the 21st Century.

Isn't there anybody else who thinks the way I do about this book?

best book ever read - very suitable for men, 12 Apr 2006
This is one of the first book written by Rivers which I would say is the best book to give to a man to read! It is graphic, and descriptive of the evil of the time so be warned! That is why I think it is a good outreach tool for any man.
Just as it gets too descriptive she expertly then focuses on God or anything positive to turn your mind back to God realising God does shine through anything however bad, Which I think is very appropriate in this day and age. It helps my reading now of the new testament knowing the background these disciples had to face daily.It so aids in many different levels your walk with God.

what happened next, 07 Jun 2008
I have just read books 1 and 2 in this series. I preferred this novel to the first one which I found too violent for my taste in places. The plot is well paced and the characters are strong which makes you want to know what happens to them. An enjoyable read.

DISAPPOINTED, 10 Dec 2007
I read "A Voice in the Wind" which so moved me that I wanted to read An Echo in the Darkness. I wanted to find out what happened to Hadassah, Marcus and Julia. Francine Rivers is excellent at describing the scene as it might have been during that era and there was a lot of history. But I found the story a little corny in places and somewhat predictable. I didn't like this book very much.

A truly amazing story, 28 Sep 2007
I could not put this book down, as the sequel to the first book A Voice in the Wind. After reading these books, I still think about the characters- mostly the main one Hadassah, and how she is an example to mirror. It wasn't just an incredible stroy, it had so many powerful messages that I feel changed from reading it.

Mark of The Lion Series by Francine Rivers, 27 Sep 2005
I have ready many books but never have I been so captivated by these three books. Excellantly written,very well researched. Definately a must!!

Powerful Story of God's Love and Forgiveness, 29 Jan 2003
It's been a year since the end of A VOICE IN THE WIND. Marcus is feeling restless. His life of pleasure no longer holds any happiness for him. Julia is finding that her friends really don't care for her, and she is fighting an illness that no one seems to be able to cure. Their mother, Phoebe, prays constantly for their salvation. Fortunately, God has not given up on them. And the answer might come from the strange woman hidden in veils who assists the young doctor Alexander at his shop in the poor part of town.

Francine Rivers has once again captured the Roman empire of the 1st century AD. Rome, Ephesus, and Israel come alive with compelling people and small historic details. The theme of God's love and the power of forgiveness are beautifully shown through the lives of these characters. The ending was so powerful, I'm sure it will stay with me for quite some time.

This novel is definitely a sequel to the first book in the series, A VOICE IN THE WIND. Enough of the first book is explained so you won't be lost if you choose to read this one first. However, since you'll ultimately want to read the first one, I recommend starting with it so none of the surprises will be spoiled.

These novels are some of the best Christian fiction I've ever read. If you enjoy a good story with strong characters, you'll want to pick these up and read them today.

The gladiator returns ý but not as gloriously., 30 Jun 2001
In this third volume of the "Mark of the Lion" series, Francine Rivers chronicles the journey of the ex-gladiator Atretes back to his Germanic homeland, accompanied by the Christian widow Rizpah, nursemaid to his son. For Atretes, it proves to be much more than just a journey to his barbarian Chatti tribe, but also a romantic journey of love, and a spiritual journey of faith.

Readers familiar with the "Mark of the Lion" series will know that the central issue of the first volume in the series - "A Voice in the Wind" - was how to witness to an unbelieving world, and this is the most powerful and convincing book of the entire series. Like the second volume of the series ("An Echo in the Darkness" - an exploration of forgiveness), the third volume ("As Sure as the Dawn" - an exploration of anger) is much more introspective than the first. Since "As Sure as the Dawn" shares with "An Echo in the Darkness" a focus on inner conflict, it unfortunately also shares many of its weaknesses. Certainly it has to be conceded that Rivers writes on a much higher level than most contemporary Christian fiction. When packed with a deep theological message, such literary fiction has the potential to pack a serious punch. But not when the theology is weak. Sadly, that is the case not only with "An Echo in the Darkness", but also with "As Sure as the Dawn".

The most serious theological weakness is that Rivers places the events of her story *after* the apostolic era, and yet incorporates signs and wonders that were unique to the apostolic era. These include direct revelation (to Rizpah p.26 and Theophilus p.354), the gift of tongues (when the main characters suddenly speak German, p.314), and miracles (resurrection, p.278-80 and miraculous deliverance by walking on water, p.467). The presence of miracles outside of the apostolic era is particularly unfortunate, because Rivers makes them decisive turning points of the plot - in both instances resulting in conversions. That the miracle of resurrection causes a conversion appears to be in direct contradiction with the words of Jesus in Luke 16:31 "If they do not listen to Moses and the Prophets, they will not be convinced even if someone rises from the dead." Not only do these miracles and wonders result in an overly optimistic story-line that fails to reflect the harshness of real life for Christians today, they are dependent on a tenuous theological position. If one agrees with the assertion that apostolic wonders and miracles ceased with the apostolic era, one must also concede the plot of "As Sure as the Dawn" is not credible.

There are other minor theological weaknesses that are not as crucial to the plot. The portrayal of first century worship (p.126) is questionable, and certainly the idea of "coming forward" (p.5) is anachronistic and without basis in the New Testament, and is more indicative of contemporary rather than ancient worship. The exegesis of several Bible passages is highly disputable, such the use of Matt. 7:1 "do not judge" (p.53) which fails to take into consideration the immediate context dealing with hypocrisy; the use of 1 John 4 "love one another" to include unbelievers (p.83,373), despite the clear application of this text in Scripture to fellow believers; the suggestion that each piece of the armor of God in Eph. 6 is another name for Christ (p.87); the understanding of Rom. 6 as requiring baptism by immersion (p.283); and the explanation of Gen. 6:5 as meaning that after the fall there was just a "seed of sin" which progressed into increasing corruption (p.291). Also questionable are the assertions that Satan was God's most beautiful creation (p.291), that the Israelites are still God's children today (p.301), and that forgiveness is required independent of repentance (p.423 - note that Christ did not forgive his murderers, rather He *prayed* for their forgiveness). As usual, the theology of universal atonement (p.60,112,314), partial depravity (p.248-9, 290) and the emphasis on Christ as an example rather than as an atoning substitute (p.306) is typically Arminian.

Like the first volume of the series, the graphic allusions to Atretes' sexual relations outside of marriage and frank discussion of sexual thoughts makes "As Sure as the Dawn" unsuitable for children. In fact the emphasis that Rivers lays on physical attraction is somewhat disturbing (p.187,189). Romantic love appears to play just as much a role as religion in determining the course of events, as evidenced in the fact that one of the religious climaxes of the novel (baptism) is promptly overshadowed by a romantic climax (marriage). The fact that this baptism was rather premature (one of the characters later observes that the baptized person does not even really understand what it means to be a Christian! p.309) appears to confirm this.

The above criticisms may seem harsh but they are honest. At the same time, there are many positive theological insights that Rivers successfully and effectively shares. The fact that the apostle John quotes numerous Scripture passages verbatim is a real strength. The portrayal of spiritual conflict as the gospel is proclaimed in pagan territory is particularly convincing. Rivers' description of demonic powers at work among the pagans under the guise of their gods is powerful and accurate. Thankfully the third volume of the series is not ALL internal conflict like the second volume, and thus overcomes some of its weaknesses. There are also some exciting action scenes reminiscent of the first volume. A reasonable effort, but unfortunately not enough to equal the first gem produced in this series. Like Atretes, Rivers is back, but not with the same glory as we saw at our first meeting.

A wonderful conclusion, 26 Apr 2001
The final part of 'The Mark Of The Lion' trilogy. This book follows the events in the life of Atretes, who was first introduced in 'Voice In The Wind'. The gutsy determination of Rizpah, along with the struggles she faces combine to make this a compelling story. The author takes us on a journey into another culture and it is easy to become completely engrossed in the fascinating historical side to the story. You have to admire this lady for the hours of research she must have had to do to produce such a brilliant novel. A wonderful conclusion to a brilliant series.

Rizpah, 08 Jun 1999
I can identify so much with Rizpah, that I even named my screename for her. I enjoyed this last of the trilogy. My favorite character has to be Theophilis. His quiet and gentle spirit, and his faith and love, comforted me. He seemed like the kind of grandfather I always wished I'd had. I cant wait for the next book to come out so that I can find out what happens to everyone.

No words can express!, 25 Apr 1999
This 3rd and final book of the Mark of the Lion Series was SUCH A BLESSING to me! I am a lot like Rizpah (I tend to be stubborn in situations like hers, and I am sometimes far too outspoken for my own good). This book encouraged me in so many ways... proved how deep God's forgiveness and love reach, and how dramatically they change the lives of those they touch! I was so BLESSED! This book dramatically portrays God's faithfulness, answers to prayer, and real-life examples of where we would all be without God. Even if you haven't read Books 1 and 2, this one stands alone and is a must-read.

Not as good as the first two, 26 Nov 1998
I have read the first two books in this series and I really didn't enjoy this one as much as the others. I was bored with the book almost from the start. I would recomend the first two, A Voice in the Wind and An Echo in the Darkness, but not this one.

Wonderful, 09 Nov 2008
Having read all the Baxter books I was keen to read this last one. It did not disappoint and was just as thrilling as the rest. Highly recommended,enjoyable read on it's own, but best read as set, then they make great sense.

Healing, 29 Sep 2008
I bought this MP3 version of the book as I was beginning to tire of reading all about the Baxter family. Actually my husband and I listened to all of this reading and it was terrific.

The Baxter family have come a long way from their beginnings and many hurts are healed in this book.

Great Christian Fiction for everyone, 13 Jan 2008
I have read this whole series a number of times. I come from a Christian family who have worked for the Lord in Nepal for most of my childhood. I have always gone to church, my schools in Nepal were Christian and most of my friends - Christian. But on returning back to Britain and growing up in a growing materialistic country, my faith has had all too many lows.

But i read this book and i finish within 2 days. I read 'An Echo In The Darkness' and i'm finished almost straight away. Suddenly my life is put into perspective and I am reduced to tears and pleading to the Lord for forgivness of my sins. It is inspiring how Hadassah manages to be so strong in her faith after seeing such harrowing scenes and being intwine with those who dispise her race and her faith the most.

Hadassah is brought to Rome after the Romans obliterate the Jews and spread her race across a number of cities. She becomes a slave to the Valerian family and is given as personal handmaid to Julia Valerian. For over 5 years she stays with her and loves her and is repulsed by julia's way of life and slowly watches her commit terrible sin after terrible sin. Yet still loves her like a sister and prays for her constantly.
On the otherhand she falls in love with Julia's older brother who lives to please himself and to increase his wealth. Marcus and Hadassah's relationship grows painfully slowly but the conversations between them are intense and inspiring to any reader.
Her commitment to the family is reflected in her prayers for all members of the family and her LOVE for serving them rather than just her obediant service.

I then go on to read the last book in the series 'As Sure As The Dawn' and again i am inspired by Atretes determination.
In 'A Voice In The Wind' we see him go from a respected tribesman who loved his family and those around him and fought to keep his men safe, to a captured slave passed from Roman hand to Roman hand, from Ludos to Ludos, where he has to fight to entertain the Romans. He has to kill other innocent slaves for no other reasons than to gain freedom and to entertain the mob. After he is freed his relationship with Julia Valerian comes to an explosive end and he is plagued by dreams that only Hadassah can interpret for him while she awaits death.
His story is continued in the final book.

My faith doubles and triples when i read these books and I am filled with a new longing to tell the good news to my friends and to pray and give my life to the Lord again and again. This book is a good push in life and then it's up to us to keep the passion going.

To keep being like Hadassah.

Without a doubt, the best, 25 Nov 2007
All three books in the Mark of the Lion series are the best I have ever read. Even if you're not a Chrisitian they are still the best story you will ever read. I don't know anyone who doesn't absolutely adore them and I have given them to all my friends. I have never been this moved or this engrossed in a story. Make sure you read all three books. These are an absolute must and you are in for such a treat! I promise.

Brilliant, 02 Jul 2007
This is a book I've not been able to put down.. It was given to me as a gift, and probably one of the best gifts I've recieved in a very long time. I'm now getting the second one, and cant wait to start reading. I've been captivated by the message the book gives, and find I cant stop thinking about Hadassah, and her difficult journey, and how it relates to our own lives.

The book is discriptive, and it gives you a very clear picture of what went on in those crewel times, and how difficult it was for Christians as well as Jews. It gives some history and feeling and insight into Jesus's time, and I'm sure will help with reading the Bible, which I'd now like to start reading.

If nothing else, this book is an eye opener, and if you are looking for a good read, or a message of hope and love, then this is your book. It has something for everyone, and you wont be able to put it down once you start.

I definately recomended Francine Rivers - A Voice in the Wind. Plese read it.

well written, interesting plot but..., 05 May 2006
I kept feeling as if I was reading a trashy romance novel. I don't read trashy romance novels, so could be completely off the mark here. I felt tricked into reading it as it seemingly had the sanction of Christians. The opposite of good works in strange ways.

I also felt like the characters were thinking and speaking as if they lived in the 21st Century.

Isn't there anybody else who thinks the way I do about this book?

best book ever read - very suitable for men, 12 Apr 2006
This is one of the first book written by Rivers which I would say is the best book to give to a man to read! It is graphic, and descriptive of the evil of the time so be warned! That is why I think it is a good outreach tool for any man.
Just as it gets too descriptive she expertly then focuses on God or anything positive to turn your mind back to God realising God does shine through anything however bad, Which I think is very appropriate in this day and age. It helps my reading now of the new testament knowing the background these disciples had to face daily.It so aids in many different levels your walk with God.

what happened next, 07 Jun 2008
I have just read books 1 and 2 in this series. I preferred this novel to the first one which I found too violent for my taste in places. The plot is well paced and the characters are strong which makes you want to know what happens to them. An enjoyable read.

DISAPPOINTED, 10 Dec 2007
I read "A Voice in the Wind" which so moved me that I wanted to read An Echo in the Darkness. I wanted to find out what happened to Hadassah, Marcus and Julia. Francine Rivers is excellent at describing the scene as it might have been during that era and there was a lot of history. But I found the story a little corny in places and somewhat predictable. I didn't like this book very much.

A truly amazing story, 28 Sep 2007
I could not put this book down, as the sequel to the first book A Voice in the Wind. After reading these books, I still think about the characters- mostly the main one Hadassah, and how she is an example to mirror. It wasn't just an incredible stroy, it had so many powerful messages that I feel changed from reading it.

Mark of The Lion Series by Francine Rivers, 27 Sep 2005
I have ready many books but never have I been so captivated by these three books. Excellantly written,very well researched. Definately a must!!

Powerful Story of God's Love and Forgiveness, 29 Jan 2003
It's been a year since the end of A VOICE IN THE WIND. Marcus is feeling restless. His life of pleasure no longer holds any happiness for him. Julia is finding that her friends really don't care for her, and she is fighting an illness that no one seems to be able to cure. Their mother, Phoebe, prays constantly for their salvation. Fortunately, God has not given up on them. And the answer might come from the strange woman hidden in veils who assists the young doctor Alexander at his shop in the poor part of town.

Francine Rivers has once again captured the Roman empire of the 1st century AD. Rome, Ephesus, and Israel come alive with compelling people and small historic details. The theme of God's love and the power of forgiveness are beautifully shown through the lives of these characters. The ending was so powerful, I'm sure it will stay with me for quite some time.

This novel is definitely a sequel to the first book in the series, A VOICE IN THE WIND. Enough of the first book is explained so you won't be lost if you choose to read this one first. However, since you'll ultimately want to read the first one, I recommend starting with it so none of the surprises will be spoiled.

These novels are some of the best Christian fiction I've ever read. If you enjoy a good story with strong characters, you'll want to pick these up and read them today.

The gladiator returns ý but not as gloriously., 30 Jun 2001
In this third volume of the "Mark of the Lion" series, Francine Rivers chronicles the journey of the ex-gladiator Atretes back to his Germanic homeland, accompanied by the Christian widow Rizpah, nursemaid to his son. For Atretes, it proves to be much more than just a journey to his barbarian Chatti tribe, but also a romantic journey of love, and a spiritual journey of faith.

Readers familiar with the "Mark of the Lion" series will know that the central issue of the first volume in the series - "A Voice in the Wind" - was how to witness to an unbelieving world, and this is the most powerful and convincing book of the entire series. Like the second volume of the series ("An Echo in the Darkness" - an exploration of forgiveness), the third volume ("As Sure as the Dawn" - an exploration of anger) is much more introspective than the first. Since "As Sure as the Dawn" shares with "An Echo in the Darkness" a focus on inner conflict, it unfortunately also shares many of its weaknesses. Certainly it has to be conceded that Rivers writes on a much higher level than most contemporary Christian fiction. When packed with a deep theological message, such literary fiction has the potential to pack a serious punch. But not when the theology is weak. Sadly, that is the case not only with "An Echo in the Darkness", but also with "As Sure as the Dawn".

The most serious theological weakness is that Rivers places the events of her story *after* the apostolic era, and yet incorporates signs and wonders that were unique to the apostolic era. These include direct revelation (to Rizpah p.26 and Theophilus p.354), the gift of tongues (when the main characters suddenly speak German, p.314), and miracles (resurrection, p.278-80 and miraculous deliverance by walking on water, p.467). The presence of miracles outside of the apostolic era is particularly unfortunate, because Rivers makes them decisive turning points of the plot - in both instances resulting in conversions. That the miracle of resurrection causes a conversion appears to be in direct contradiction with the words of Jesus in Luke 16:31 "If they do not listen to Moses and the Prophets, they will not be convinced even if someone rises from the dead." Not only do these miracles and wonders result in an overly optimistic story-line that fails to reflect the harshness of real life for Christians today, they are dependent on a tenuous theological position. If one agrees with the assertion that apostolic wonders and miracles ceased with the apostolic era, one must also concede the plot of "As Sure as the Dawn" is not credible.

There are other minor theological weaknesses that are not as crucial to the plot. The portrayal of first century worship (p.126) is questionable, and certainly the idea of "coming forward" (p.5) is anachronistic and without basis in the New Testament, and is more indicative of contemporary rather than ancient worship. The exegesis of several Bible passages is highly disputable, such the use of Matt. 7:1 "do not judge" (p.53) which fails to take into consideration the immediate context dealing with hypocrisy; the use of 1 John 4 "love one another" to include unbelievers (p.83,373), despite the clear application of this text in Scripture to fellow believers; the suggestion that each piece of the armor of God in Eph. 6 is another name for Christ (p.87); the understanding of Rom. 6 as requiring baptism by immersion (p.283); and the explanation of Gen. 6:5 as meaning that after the fall there was just a "seed of sin" which progressed into increasing corruption (p.291). Also questionable are the assertions that Satan was God's most beautiful creation (p.291), that the Israelites are still God's children today (p.301), and that forgiveness is required independent of repentance (p.423 - note that Christ did not forgive his murderers, rather He *prayed* for their forgiveness). As usual, the theology of universal atonement (p.60,112,314), partial depravity (p.248-9, 290) and the emphasis on Christ as an example rather than as an atoning substitute (p.306) is typically Arminian.

Like the first volume of the series, the graphic allusions to Atretes' sexual relations outside of marriage and frank discussion of sexual thoughts makes "As Sure as the Dawn" unsuitable for children. In fact the emphasis that Rivers lays on physical attraction is somewhat disturbing (p.187,189). Romantic love appears to play just as much a role as religion in determining the course of events, as evidenced in the fact that one of the religious climaxes of the novel (baptism) is promptly overshadowed by a romantic climax (marriage). The fact that this baptism was rather premature (one of the characters later observes that the baptized person does not even really understand what it means to be a Christian! p.309) appears to confirm this.

The above criticisms may seem harsh but they are honest. At the same time, there are many positive theological insights that Rivers successfully and effectively shares. The fact that the apostle John quotes numerous Scripture passages verbatim is a real strength. The portrayal of spiritual conflict as the gospel is proclaimed in pagan territory is particularly convincing. Rivers' description of demonic powers at work among the pagans under the guise of their gods is powerful and accurate. Thankfully the third volume of the series is not ALL internal conflict like the second volume, and thus overcomes some of its weaknesses. There are also some exciting action scenes reminiscent of the first volume. A reasonable effort, but unfortunately not enough to equal the first gem produced in this series. Like Atretes, Rivers is back, but not with the same glory as we saw at our first meeting.

A wonderful conclusion, 26 Apr 2001
The final part of 'The Mark Of The Lion' trilogy. This book follows the events in the life of Atretes, who was first introduced in 'Voice In The Wind'. The gutsy determination of Rizpah, along with the struggles she faces combine to make this a compelling story. The author takes us on a journey into another culture and it is easy to become completely engrossed in the fascinating historical side to the story. You have to admire this lady for the hours of research she must have had to do to produce such a brilliant novel. A wonderful conclusion to a brilliant series.

Rizpah, 08 Jun 1999
I can identify so much with Rizpah, that I even named my screename for her. I enjoyed this last of the trilogy. My favorite character has to be Theophilis. His quiet and gentle spirit, and his faith and love, comforted me. He seemed like the kind of grandfather I always wished I'd had. I cant wait for the next book to come out so that I can find out what happens to everyone.

No words can express!, 25 Apr 1999
This 3rd and final book of the Mark of the Lion Series was SUCH A BLESSING to me! I am a lot like Rizpah (I tend to be stubborn in situations like hers, and I am sometimes far too outspoken for my own good). This book encouraged me in so many ways... proved how deep God's forgiveness and love reach, and how dramatically they change the lives of those they touch! I was so BLESSED! This book dramatically portrays God's faithfulness, answers to prayer, and real-life examples of where we would all be without God. Even if you haven't read Books 1 and 2, this one stands alone and is a must-read.

Not as good as the first two, 26 Nov 1998
I have read the first two books in this series and I really didn't enjoy this one as much as the others. I was bored with the book almost from the start. I would recomend the first two, A Voice in the Wind and An Echo in the Darkness, but not this one.

From the back cover:, 16 Sep 2008
Token Creek 1884

Jessie Wheeler knows how to take care of herself and her girls. The owner of Token Creek's general store has been doing it for a long time -nearly eight years - since the day her husband walked out on her.

Seth Redding, Jessie's husband, has done a lot of thinking in those years, some of it in a jail cell. Looking back on his marriage, he can't believe he left Jessie and their baby. It was true that Jessie had her own way of doing things and could be hardheaded. But they had shared a special kind of love too, at least early on. If only he'd known then what he knows now ...

Seth is a changed man, but will he ever be able to show Jessie that? Will she even let him try?

Jessie's story, told from the beginning, is a timeless account of the transforming power of God's love and forgiveness.

Wonderful, 09 Nov 2008
Having read all the Baxter books I was keen to read this last one. It did not disappoint and was just as thrilling as the rest. Highly recommended,enjoyable read on it's own, but best read as set, then they make great sense.

Healing, 29 Sep 2008
I bought this MP3 version of the book as I was beginning to tire of reading all about the Baxter family. Actually my husband and I listened to all of this reading and it was terrific.

The Baxter family have come a long way from their beginnings and many hurts are healed in this book.

Great Christian Fiction for everyone, 13 Jan 2008
I have read this whole series a number of times. I come from a Christian family who have worked for the Lord in Nepal for most of my childhood. I have always gone to church, my schools in Nepal were Christian and most of my friends - Christian. But on returning back to Britain and growing up in a growing materialistic country, my faith has had all too many lows.

But i read this book and i finish within 2 days. I read 'An Echo In The Darkness' and i'm finished almost straight away. Suddenly my life is put into perspective and I am reduced to tears and pleading to the Lord for forgivness of my sins. It is inspiring how Hadassah manages to be so strong in her faith after seeing such harrowing scenes and being intwine with those who dispise her race and her faith the most.

Hadassah is brought to Rome after the Romans obliterate the Jews and spread her race across a number of cities. She becomes a slave to the Valerian family and is given as personal handmaid to Julia Valerian. For over 5 years she stays with her and loves her and is repulsed by julia's way of life and slowly watches her commit terrible sin after terrible sin. Yet still loves her like a sister and prays for her constantly.
On the otherhand she falls in love with Julia's older brother who lives to please himself and to increase his wealth. Marcus and Hadassah's relationship grows painfully slowly but the conversations between them are intense and inspiring to any reader.
Her commitment to the family is reflected in her prayers for all members of the family and her LOVE for serving them rather than just her obediant service.

I then go on to read the last book in the series 'As Sure As The Dawn' and again i am inspired by Atretes determination.
In 'A Voice In The Wind' we see him go from a respected tribesman who loved his family and those around him and fought to keep his men safe, to a captured slave passed from Roman hand to Roman hand, from Ludos to Ludos, where he has to fight to entertain the Romans. He has to kill other innocent slaves for no other reasons than to gain freedom and to entertain the mob. After he is freed his relationship with Julia Valerian comes to an explosive end and he is plagued by dreams that only Hadassah can interpret for him while she awaits death.
His story is continued in the final book.

My faith doubles and triples when i read these books and I am filled with a new longing to tell the good news to my friends and to pray and give my life to the Lord again and again. This book is a good push in life and then it's up to us to keep the passion going.

To keep being like Hadassah.

Without a doubt, the best, 25 Nov 2007
All three books in the Mark of the Lion series are the best I have ever read. Even if you're not a Chrisitian they are still the best story you will ever read. I don't know anyone who doesn't absolutely adore them and I have given them to all my friends. I have never been this moved or this engrossed in a story. Make sure you read all three books. These are an absolute must and you are in for such a treat! I promise.

Brilliant, 02 Jul 2007
This is a book I've not been able to put down.. It was given to me as a gift, and probably one of the best gifts I've recieved in a very long time. I'm now getting the second one, and cant wait to start reading. I've been captivated by the message the book gives, and find I cant stop thinking about Hadassah, and her difficult journey, and how it relates to our own lives.

The book is discriptive, and it gives you a very clear picture of what went on in those crewel times, and how difficult it was for Christians as well as Jews. It gives some history and feeling and insight into Jesus's time, and I'm sure will help with reading the Bible, which I'd now like to start reading.

If nothing else, this book is an eye opener, and if you are looking for a good read, or a message of hope and love, then this is your book. It has something for everyone, and you wont be able to put it down once you start.

I definately recomended Francine Rivers - A Voice in the Wind. Plese read it.

well written, interesting plot but..., 05 May 2006
I kept feeling as if I was reading a trashy romance novel. I don't read trashy romance novels, so could be completely off the mark here. I felt tricked into reading it as it seemingly had the sanction of Christians. The opposite of good works in strange ways.

I also felt like the characters were thinking and speaking as if they lived in the 21st Century.

Isn't there anybody else who thinks the way I do about this book?

best book ever read - very suitable for men, 12 Apr 2006
This is one of the first book written by Rivers which I would say is the best book to give to a man to read! It is graphic, and descriptive of the evil of the time so be warned! That is why I think it is a good outreach tool for any man.
Just as it gets too descriptive she expertly then focuses on God or anything positive to turn your mind back to God realising God does shine through anything however bad, Which I think is very appropriate in this day and age. It helps my reading now of the new testament knowing the background these disciples had to face daily.It so aids in many different levels your walk with God.

what happened next, 07 Jun 2008
I have just read books 1 and 2 in this series. I preferred this novel to the first one which I found too violent for my taste in places. The plot is well paced and the characters are strong which makes you want to know what happens to them. An enjoyable read.

DISAPPOINTED, 10 Dec 2007
I read "A Voice in the Wind" which so moved me that I wanted to read An Echo in the Darkness. I wanted to find out what happened to Hadassah, Marcus and Julia. Francine Rivers is excellent at describing the scene as it might have been during that era and there was a lot of history. But I found the story a little corny in places and somewhat predictable. I didn't like this book very much.

A truly amazing story, 28 Sep 2007
I could not put this book down, as the sequel to the first book A Voice in the Wind. After reading these books, I still think about the characters- mostly the main one Hadassah, and how she is an example to mirror. It wasn't just an incredible stroy, it had so many powerful messages that I feel changed from reading it.

Mark of The Lion Series by Francine Rivers, 27 Sep 2005
I have ready many books but never have I been so captivated by these three books. Excellantly written,very well researched. Definately a must!!

Powerful Story of God's Love and Forgiveness, 29 Jan 2003
It's been a year since the end of A VOICE IN THE WIND. Marcus is feeling restless. His life of pleasure no longer holds any happiness for him. Julia is finding that her friends really don't care for her, and she is fighting an illness that no one seems to be able to cure. Their mother, Phoebe, prays constantly for their salvation. Fortunately, God has not given up on them. And the answer might come from the strange woman hidden in veils who assists the young doctor Alexander at his shop in the poor part of town.

Francine Rivers has once again captured the Roman empire of the 1st century AD. Rome, Ephesus, and Israel come alive with compelling people and small historic details. The theme of God's love and the power of forgiveness are beautifully shown through the lives of these characters. The ending was so powerful, I'm sure it will stay with me for quite some time.

This novel is definitely a sequel to the first book in the series, A VOICE IN THE WIND. Enough of the first book is explained so you won't be lost if you choose to read this one first. However, since you'll ultimately want to read the first one, I recommend starting with it so none of the surprises will be spoiled.

These novels are some of the best Christian fiction I've ever read. If you enjoy a good story with strong characters, you'll want to pick these up and read them today.

The gladiator returns ý but not as gloriously., 30 Jun 2001
In this third volume of the "Mark of the Lion" series, Francine Rivers chronicles the journey of the ex-gladiator Atretes back to his Germanic homeland, accompanied by the Christian widow Rizpah, nursemaid to his son. For Atretes, it proves to be much more than just a journey to his barbarian Chatti tribe, but also a romantic journey of love, and a spiritual journey of faith.

Readers familiar with the "Mark of the Lion" series will know that the central issue of the first volume in the series - "A Voice in the Wind" - was how to witness to an unbelieving world, and this is the most powerful and convincing book of the entire series. Like the second volume of the series ("An Echo in the Darkness" - an exploration of forgiveness), the third volume ("As Sure as the Dawn" - an exploration of anger) is much more introspective than the first. Since "As Sure as the Dawn" shares with "An Echo in the Darkness" a focus on inner conflict, it unfortunately also shares many of its weaknesses. Certainly it has to be conceded that Rivers writes on a much higher level than most contemporary Christian fiction. When packed with a deep theological message, such literary fiction has the potential to pack a serious punch. But not when the theology is weak. Sadly, that is the case not only with "An Echo in the Darkness", but also with "As Sure as the Dawn".

The most serious theological weakness is that Rivers places the events of her story *after* the apostolic era, and yet incorporates signs and wonders that were unique to the apostolic era. These include direct revelation (to Rizpah p.26 and Theophilus p.354), the gift of tongues (when the main characters suddenly speak German, p.314), and miracles (resurrection, p.278-80 and miraculous deliverance by walking on water, p.467). The presence of miracles outside of the apostolic era is particularly unfortunate, because Rivers makes them decisive turning points of the plot - in both instances resulting in conversions. That the miracle of resurrection causes a conversion appears to be in direct contradiction with the words of Jesus in Luke 16:31 "If they do not listen to Moses and the Prophets, they will not be convinced even if someone rises from the dead." Not only do these miracles and wonders result in an overly optimistic story-line that fails to reflect the harshness of real life for Christians today, they are dependent on a tenuous theological position. If one agrees with the assertion that apostolic wonders and miracles ceased with the apostolic era, one must also concede the plot of "As Sure as the Dawn" is not credible.

There are other minor theological weaknesses that are not as crucial to the plot. The portrayal of first century worship (p.126) is questionable, and certainly the idea of "coming forward" (p.5) is anachronistic and without basis in the New Testament, and is more indicative of contemporary rather than ancient worship. The exegesis of several Bible passages is highly disputable, such the use of Matt. 7:1 "do not judge" (p.53) which fails to take into consideration the immediate context dealing with hypocrisy; the use of 1 John 4 "love one another" to include unbelievers (p.83,373), despite the clear application of this text in Scripture to fellow believers; the suggestion that each piece of the armor of God in Eph. 6 is another name for Christ (p.87); the understanding of Rom. 6 as requiring baptism by immersion (p.283); and the explanation of Gen. 6:5 as meaning that after the fall there was just a "seed of sin" which progressed into increasing corruption (p.291). Also questionable are the assertions that Satan was God's most beautiful creation (p.291), that the Israelites are still God's children today (p.301), and that forgiveness is required independent of repentance (p.423 - note that Christ did not forgive his murderers, rather He *prayed* for their forgiveness). As usual, the theology of universal atonement (p.60,112,314), partial depravity (p.248-9, 290) and the emphasis on Christ as an example rather than as an atoning substitute (p.306) is typically Arminian.

Like the first volume of the series, the graphic allusions to Atretes' sexual relations outside of marriage and frank discussion of sexual thoughts makes "As Sure as the Dawn" unsuitable for children. In fact the emphasis that Rivers lays on physical attraction is somewhat disturbing (p.187,189). Romantic love appears to play just as much a role as religion in determining the course of events, as evidenced in the fact that one of the religious climaxes of the novel (baptism) is promptly overshadowed by a romantic climax (marriage). The fact that this baptism was rather premature (one of the characters later observes that the baptized person does not even really understand what it means to be a Christian! p.309) appears to confirm this.

The above criticisms may seem harsh but they are honest. At the same time, there are many positive theological insights that Rivers successfully and effectively shares. The fact that the apostle John quotes numerous Scripture passages verbatim is a real strength. The portrayal of spiritual conflict as the gospel is proclaimed in pagan territory is particularly convincing. Rivers' description of demonic powers at work among the pagans under the guise of their gods is powerful and accurate. Thankfully the third volume of the series is not ALL internal conflict like the second volume, and thus overcomes some of its weaknesses. There are also some exciting action scenes reminiscent of the first volume. A reasonable effort, but unfortunately not enough to equal the first gem produced in this series. Like Atretes, Rivers is back, but not with the same glory as we saw at our first meeting.

A wonderful conclusion, 26 Apr 2001
The final part of 'The Mark Of The Lion' trilogy. This book follows the events in the life of Atretes, who was first introduced in 'Voice In The Wind'. The gutsy determination of Rizpah, along with the struggles she faces combine to make this a compelling story. The author takes us on a journey into another culture and it is easy to become completely engrossed in the fascinating historical side to the story. You have to admire this lady for the hours of research she must have had to do to produce such a brilliant novel. A wonderful conclusion to a brilliant series.

Rizpah, 08 Jun 1999
I can identify so much with Rizpah, that I even named my screename for her. I enjoyed this last of the trilogy. My favorite character has to be Theophilis. His quiet and gentle spirit, and his faith and love, comforted me. He seemed like the kind of grandfather I always wished I'd had. I cant wait for the next book to come out so that I can find out what happens to everyone.

No words can express!, 25 Apr 1999
This 3rd and final book of the Mark of the Lion Series was SUCH A BLESSING to me! I am a lot like Rizpah (I tend to be stubborn in situations like hers, and I am sometimes far too outspoken for my own good). This book encouraged me in so many ways... proved how deep God's forgiveness and love reach, and how dramatically they change the lives of those they touch! I was so BLESSED! This book dramatically portrays God's faithfulness, answers to prayer, and real-life examples of where we would all be without God. Even if you haven't read Books 1 and 2, this one stands alone and is a must-read.

Not as good as the first two, 26 Nov 1998
I have read the first two books in this series and I really didn't enjoy this one as much as the others. I was bored with the book almost from the start. I would recomend the first two, A Voice in the Wind and An Echo in the Darkness, but not this one.

From the back cover:, 16 Sep 2008
Token Creek 1884

Jessie Wheeler knows how to take care of herself and her girls. The owner of Token Creek's general store has been doing it for a long time -nearly eight years - since the day her husband walked out on her.

Seth Redding, Jessie's husband, has done a lot of thinking in those years, some of it in a jail cell. Looking back on his marriage, he can't believe he left Jessie and their baby. It was true that Jessie had her own way of doing things and could be hardheaded. But they had shared a special kind of love too, at least early on. If only he'd known then what he knows now ...

Seth is a changed man, but will he ever be able to show Jessie that? Will she even let him try?

Jessie's story, told from the beginning, is a timeless account of the transforming power of God's love and forgiveness.

Electrifying and edifying, 23 Sep 2008
These three books were the best that I have ever read because not only were they a fantastic read, they also challenged me in terms of my christian walk and how I behave in times of stress and trouble. I have now read them over and over again, and my daughter has too. I really love history and Francine took me back in time, I was really there!

Go Francine! And may the Lord bless you and family beyond your wildest dreams!

Three books, one message of God's love, 25 Apr 2003
An excellent trilogy. A set of books that can be read again and again. Each book interacts with the others, therefore I suggest all three should be bought at the same time, since I had to 'beg, borrow and steal' before I was able to have a fulfilling read. The reader is transported back to ancient Rome and is able to identify with the struggles of the inwardly beautiful (as well as outside to me!!) Hadassah and the strong, untameable Artrtes, only to realise we are still living in a world with the same morals and ideas...excellent. I also recommend Redeeming Love (see my review: da_mancoonian, November 2001)

WOW!, 23 Apr 2002
After an intial thought, I'm not going to get into these, I couldn't but them down. The heroine Haddassah is what you dream to be like, her faith and devotion to God is amazing. Francine Rivers has completely woven history, and truth together.

I could not put it down., 08 Jun 1999
I learn so much from this series about the histroy of the Jews and Rome, the love of God to his people, and so much more. I really could not put it down and I told so many people about it. It impressed me so much, I could feel the power of God as I read it. The greatness of God and His goodness. I am not one to get into books or even movies to the point that I show an emotion, but this moved me to cry and laugh, fear and rejoice with the chatacters of the book. It brings you into another world and makes you want to stay and never leave. I was changed after reading it, truly blessed by it. I have never read something so powerful like this series.

Rivers at her best, 06 Jun 1999
I read this series not long after it was published, and Francine Rivers' Mark of the Lion series is one of the best Christian trilogies published. Following Hadassah, Marcus, Atretes, Rizpah and all the other characters' lives is truly a journey well worth the time. The books are historically accurate and very informative while still being highly entertaining. This is Rivers at her best. Her other books are good as well; I especially recommend _Redeeming Love_ and _The Scarlet Thread_.

I loaned my books to a friend at church, and from there, the series fanned out to at least nine people -- moms, daughters and even my father is now reading the series. These are books everyone can enjoy, learn and grow from.

Wonderful, 09 Nov 2008
Having read all the Baxter books I was keen to read this last one. It did not disappoint and was just as thrilling as the rest. Highly recommended,enjoyable read on it's own, but best read as set, then they make great sense.

Healing, 29 Sep 2008
I bought this MP3 version of the book as I was beginning to tire of reading all about the Baxter family. Actually my husband and I listened to all of this reading and it was terrific.

The Baxter family have come a long way from their beginnings and many hurts are healed in this book.

Great Christian Fiction for everyone, 13 Jan 2008
I have read this whole series a number of times. I come from a Christian family who have worked for the Lord in Nepal for most of my childhood. I have always gone to church, my schools in Nepal were Christian and most of my friends - Christian. But on returning back to Britain and growing up in a growing materialistic country, my faith has had all too many lows.

But i read this book and i finish within 2 days. I read 'An Echo In The Darkness' and i'm finished almost straight away. Suddenly my life is put into perspective and I am reduced to tears and pleading to the Lord for forgivness of my sins. It is inspiring how Hadassah manages to be so strong in her faith after seeing such harrowing scenes and being intwine with those who dispise her race and her faith the most.

Hadassah is brought to Rome after the Romans obliterate the Jews and spread her race across a number of cities. She becomes a slave to the Valerian family and is given as personal handmaid to Julia Valerian. For over 5 years she stays with her and loves her and is repulsed by julia's way of life and slowly watches her commit terrible sin after terrible sin. Yet still loves her like a sister and prays for her constantly.
On the otherhand she falls in love with Julia's older brother who lives to please himself and to increase his wealth. Marcus and Hadassah's relationship grows painfully slowly but the conversations between them are intense and inspiring to any reader.
Her commitment to the family is reflected in her prayers for all members of the family and her LOVE for serving them rather than just her obediant service.

I then go on to read the last book in the series 'As Sure As The Dawn' and again i am inspired by Atretes determination.
In 'A Voice In The Wind' we see him go from a respected tribesman who loved his family and those around him and fought to keep his men safe, to a captured slave passed from Roman hand to Roman hand, from Ludos to Ludos, where he has to fight to entertain the Romans. He has to kill other innocent slaves for no other reasons than to gain freedom and to entertain the mob. After he is freed his relationship with Julia Valerian comes to an explosive end and he is plagued by dreams that only Hadassah can interpret for him while she awaits death.
His story is continued in the final book.

My faith doubles and triples when i read these books and I am filled with a new longing to tell the good news to my friends and to pray and give my life to the Lord again and again. This book is a good push in life and then it's up to us to keep the passion going.

To keep being like Hadassah.

Without a doubt, the best, 25 Nov 2007
All three books in the Mark of the Lion series are the best I have ever read. Even if you're not a Chrisitian they are still the best story you will ever read. I don't know anyone who doesn't absolutely adore them and I have given them to all my friends. I have never been this moved or this engrossed in a story. Make sure you read all three books. These are an absolute must and you are in for such a treat! I promise.

Brilliant, 02 Jul 2007
This is a book I've not been able to put down.. It was given to me as a gift, and probably one of the best gifts I've recieved in a very long time. I'm now getting the second one, and cant wait to start reading. I've been captivated by the message the book gives, and find I cant stop thinking about Hadassah, and her difficult journey, and how it relates to our own lives.

The book is discriptive, and it gives you a very clear picture of what went on in those crewel times, and how difficult it was for Christians as well as Jews. It gives some history and feeling and insight into Jesus's time, and I'm sure will help with reading the Bible, which I'd now like to start reading.

If nothing else, this book is an eye opener, and if you are looking for a good read, or a message of hope and love, then this is your book. It has something for everyone, and you wont be able to put it down once you start.

I definately recomended Francine Rivers - A Voice in the Wind. Plese read it.

well written, interesting plot but..., 05 May 2006
I kept feeling as if I was reading a trashy romance novel. I don't read trashy romance novels, so could be completely off the mark here. I felt tricked into reading it as it seemingly had the sanction of Christians. The opposite of good works in strange ways.

I also felt like the characters were thinking and speaking as if they lived in the 21st Century.

Isn't there anybody else who thinks the way I do about this book?

best book ever read - very suitable for men, 12 Apr 2006
This is one of the first book written by Rivers which I would say is the best book to give to a man to read! It is graphic, and descriptive of the evil of the time so be warned! That is why I think it is a good outreach tool for any man.
Just as it gets too descriptive she expertly then focuses on God or anything positive to turn your mind back to God realising God does shine through anything however bad, Which I think is very appropriate in this day and age. It helps my reading now of the new testament knowing the background these disciples had to face daily.It so aids in many different levels your walk with God.

what happened next, 07 Jun 2008
I have just read books 1 and 2 in this series. I preferred this novel to the first one which I found too violent for my taste in places. The plot is well paced and the characters are strong which makes you want to know what happens to them. An enjoyable read.

DISAPPOINTED, 10 Dec 2007
I read "A Voice in the Wind" which so moved me that I wanted to read An Echo in the Darkness. I wanted to find out what happened to Hadassah, Marcus and Julia. Francine Rivers is excellent at describing the scene as it might have been during that era and there was a lot of history. But I found the story a little corny in places and somewhat predictable. I didn't like this book very much.

A truly amazing story, 28 Sep 2007
I could not put this book down, as the sequel to the first book A Voice in the Wind. After reading these books, I still think about the characters- mostly the main one Hadassah, and how she is an example to mirror. It wasn't just an incredible stroy, it had so many powerful messages that I feel changed from reading it.

Mark of The Lion Series by Francine Rivers, 27 Sep 2005
I have ready many books but never have I been so captivated by these three books. Excellantly written,very well researched. Definately a must!!

Powerful Story of God's Love and Forgiveness, 29 Jan 2003
It's been a year since the end of A VOICE IN THE WIND. Marcus is feeling restless. His life of pleasure no longer holds any happiness for him. Julia is finding that her friends really don't care for her, and she is fighting an illness that no one seems to be able to cure. Their mother, Phoebe, prays constantly for their salvation. Fortunately, God has not given up on them. And the answer might come from the strange woman hidden in veils who assists the young doctor Alexander at his shop in the poor part of town.

Francine Rivers has once again captured the Roman empire of the 1st century AD. Rome, Ephesus, and Israel come alive with compelling people and small historic details. The theme of God's love and the power of forgiveness are beautifully shown through the lives of these characters. The ending was so powerful, I'm sure it will stay with me for quite some time.

This novel is definitely a sequel to the first book in the series, A VOICE IN THE WIND. Enough of the first book is explained so you won't be lost if you choose to read this one first. However, since you'll ultimately want to read the first one, I recommend starting with it so none of the surprises will be spoiled.

These novels are some of the best Christian fiction I've ever read. If you enjoy a good story with strong characters, you'll want to pick these up and read them today.

The gladiator returns ý but not as gloriously., 30 Jun 2001
In this third volume of the "Mark of the Lion" series, Francine Rivers chronicles the journey of the ex-gladiator Atretes back to his Germanic homeland, accompanied by the Christian widow Rizpah, nursemaid to his son. For Atretes, it proves to be much more than just a journey to his barbarian Chatti tribe, but also a romantic journey of love, and a spiritual journey of faith.

Readers familiar with the "Mark of the Lion" series will know that the central issue of the first volume in the series - "A Voice in the Wind" - was how to witness to an unbelieving world, and this is the most powerful and convincing book of the entire series. Like the second volume of the series ("An Echo in the Darkness" - an exploration of forgiveness), the third volume ("As Sure as the Dawn" - an exploration of anger) is much more introspective than the first. Since "As Sure as the Dawn" shares with "An Echo in the Darkness" a focus on inner conflict, it unfortunately also shares many of its weaknesses. Certainly it has to be conceded that Rivers writes on a much higher level than most contemporary Christian fiction. When packed with a deep theological message, such literary fiction has the potential to pack a serious punch. But not when the theology is weak. Sadly, that is the case not only with "An Echo in the Darkness", but also with "As Sure as the Dawn".

The most serious theological weakness is that Rivers places the events of her story *after* the apostolic era, and yet incorporates signs and wonders that were unique to the apostolic era. These include direct revelation (to Rizpah p.26 and Theophilus p.354), the gift of tongues (when the main characters suddenly speak German, p.314), and miracles (resurrection, p.278-80 and miraculous deliverance by walking on water, p.467). The presence of miracles outside of the apostolic era is particularly unfortunate, because Rivers makes them decisive turning points of the plot - in both instances resulting in conversions. That the miracle of resurrection causes a conversion appears to be in direct contradiction with the words of Jesus in Luke 16:31 "If they do not listen to Moses and the Prophets, they will not be convinced even if someone rises from the dead." Not only do these miracles and wonders result in an overly optimistic story-line that fails to reflect the harshness of real life for Christians today, they are dependent on a tenuous theological position. If one agrees with the assertion that apostolic wonders and miracles ceased with the apostolic era, one must also concede the plot of "As Sure as the Dawn" is not credible.

There are other minor theological weaknesses that are not as crucial to the plot. The portrayal of first century worship (p.126) is questionable, and certainly the idea of "coming forward" (p.5) is anachronistic and without basis in the New Testament, and is more indicative of contemporary rather than ancient worship. The exegesis of several Bible passages is highly disputable, such the use of Matt. 7:1 "do not judge" (p.53) which fails to take into consideration the immediate context dealing with hypocrisy; the use of 1 John 4 "love one another" to include unbelievers (p.83,373), despite the clear application of this text in Scripture to fellow believers; the suggestion that each piece of the armor of God in Eph. 6 is another name for Christ (p.87); the understanding of Rom. 6 as requiring baptism by immersion (p.283); and the explanation of Gen. 6:5 as meaning that after the fall there was just a "seed of sin" which progressed into increasing corruption (p.291). Also questionable are the assertions that Satan was God's most beautiful creation (p.291), that the Israelites are still God's children today (p.301), and that forgiveness is required independent of repentance (p.423 - note that Christ did not forgive his murderers, rather He *prayed* for their forgiveness). As usual, the theology of universal atonement (p.60,112,314), partial depravity (p.248-9, 290) and the emphasis on Christ as an example rather than as an atoning substitute (p.306) is typically Arminian.

Like the first volume of the series, the graphic allusions to Atretes' sexual relations outside of marriage and frank discussion of sexual thoughts makes "As Sure as the Dawn" unsuitable for children. In fact the emphasis that Rivers lays on physical attraction is somewhat disturbing (p.187,189). Romantic love appears to play just as much a role as religion in determining the course of events, as evidenced in the fact that one of the religious climaxes of the novel (baptism) is promptly overshadowed by a romantic climax (marriage). The fact that this baptism was rather premature (one of the characters later observes that the baptized person does not even really understand what it means to be a Christian! p.309) appears to confirm this.

The above criticisms may seem harsh but they are honest. At the same time, there are many positive theological insights that Rivers successfully and effectively shares. The fact that the apostle John quotes numerous Scripture passages verbatim is a real strength. The portrayal of spiritual conflict as the gospel is proclaimed in pagan territory is particularly convincing. Rivers' description of demonic powers at work among the pagans under the guise of their gods is powerful and accurate. Thankfully the third volume of the series is not ALL internal conflict like the second volume, and thus overcomes some of its weaknesses. There are also some exciting action scenes reminiscent of the first volume. A reasonable effort, but unfortunately not enough to equal the first gem produced in this series. Like Atretes, Rivers is back, but not with the same glory as we saw at our first meeting.

A wonderful conclusion, 26 Apr 2001
The final part of 'The Mark Of The Lion' trilogy. This book follows the events in the life of Atretes, who was first introduced in 'Voice In The Wind'. The gutsy determination of Rizpah, along with the struggles she faces combine to make this a compelling story. The author takes us on a journey into another culture and it is easy to become completely engrossed in the fascinating historical side to the story. You have to admire this lady for the hours of research she must have had to do to produce such a brilliant novel. A wonderful conclusion to a brilliant series.

Rizpah, 08 Jun 1999
I can identify so much with Rizpah, that I even named my screename for her. I enjoyed this last of the trilogy. My favorite character has to be Theophilis. His quiet and gentle spirit, and his faith and love, comforted me. He seemed like the kind of grandfather I always wished I'd had. I cant wait for the next book to come out so that I can find out what happens to everyone.

No words can express!, 25 Apr 1999
This 3rd and final book of the Mark of the Lion Series was SUCH A BLESSING to me! I am a lot like Rizpah (I tend to be stubborn in situations like hers, and I am sometimes far too outspoken for my own good). This book encouraged me in so many ways... proved how deep God's forgiveness and love reach, and how dramatically they change the lives of those they touch! I was so BLESSED! This book dramatically portrays God's faithfulness, answers to prayer, and real-life examples of where we would all be without God. Even if you haven't read Books 1 and 2, this one stands alone and is a must-read.

Not as good as the first two, 26 Nov 1998
I have read the first two books in this series and I really didn't enjoy this one as much as the others. I was bored with the book almost from the start. I would recomend the first two, A Voice in the Wind and An Echo in the Darkness, but not this one.

From the back cover:, 16 Sep 2008
Token Creek 1884

Jessie Wheeler knows how to take care of herself and her girls. The owner of Token Creek's general store has been doing it for a long time -nearly eight years - since the day her husband walked out on her.

Seth Redding, Jessie's husband, has done a lot of thinking in those years, some of it in a jail cell. Looking back on his marriage, he can't believe he left Jessie and their baby. It was true that Jessie had her own way of doing things and could be hardheaded. But they had shared a special kind of love too, at least early on. If only he'd known then what he knows now ...

Seth is a changed man, but will he ever be able to show Jessie that? Will she even let him try?

Jessie's story, told from the beginning, is a timeless account of the transforming power of God's love and forgiveness.

Electrifying and edifying, 23 Sep 2008
These three books were the best that I have ever read because not only were they a fantastic read, they also challenged me in terms of my christian walk and how I behave in times of stress and trouble. I have now read them over and over again, and my daughter has too. I really love history and Francine took me back in time, I was really there!

Go Francine! And may the Lord bless you and family beyond your wildest dreams!

Three books, one message of God's love, 25 Apr 2003
An excellent trilogy. A set of books that can be read again and again. Each book interacts with the others, therefore I suggest all three should be bought at the same time, since I had to 'beg, borrow and steal' before I was able to have a fulfilling read. The reader is transported back to ancient Rome and is able to identify with the struggles of the inwardly beautiful (as well as outside to me!!) Hadassah and the strong, untameable Artrtes, only to realise we are still living in a world with the same morals and ideas...excellent. I also recommend Redeeming Love (see my review: da_mancoonian, November 2001)

WOW!, 23 Apr 2002
After an intial thought, I'm not going to get into these, I couldn't but them down. The heroine Haddassah is what you dream to be like, her faith and devotion to God is amazing. Francine Rivers has completely woven history, and truth together.

I could not put it down., 08 Jun 1999
I learn so much from this series about the histroy of the Jews and Rome, the love of God to his people, and so much more. I really could not put it down and I told so many people about it. It impressed me so much, I could feel the power of God as I read it. The greatness of God and His goodness. I am not one to get into books or even movies to the point that I show an emotion, but this moved me to cry and laugh, fear and rejoice with the chatacters of the book. It brings you into another world and makes you want to