A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

A new reader from Kingston, 08 Apr 2008
This book was recommended by a friend who knew I have limited time to read. He suggested this Judy Astley book. Another friend who had a copy also felt it was worth passing on to me.
This well written entertaining easy reading book did not disappoint and has encouraged me to read more of this author. Many situations one can easily relate to. Judy, keep at it and Thanks.

Good to cheer you up in mid Feb, 06 Feb 2008
I read this because my grandma recommended it, it's not my normal kind of read. However it was a very nice thing to sit down to on a cold winter's day. Really good. I can't tell you too much of the plot or I'll spoil it, but it's written in a very amusing way with lots of good observations on modern life. The bit about what exactly "sick" means when a teenager says it, is a conversation my friend Janet was having only about a week ago. I also thought it had just enough danger and peril to make me really worried (that gruesome cupboard on the landing, I'll say no more....) and a nicely unexpected ending... I shed a real tear too! My only suggestion: I would have liked more of Mimi the brilliant teenager - bring her back in her own side-project please!

Judy Astley does it again, 04 Feb 2008
Another truly enjoyable read from Judy Astley - read cover to cover on train journey , a book best read in one sitting. A daring subject, often painful, gripping from beginning to end.

Another superb read, 31 Jan 2008
Another brilliant effort from Astley, I am recommending this book to everyone. I really look forward to Astley's novels every year and this years has not disappointed.

Anne-Marie, 29 Jan 2008
Astley has as ever managed another fantastic novel. If you are an Astley fan you'll love it, and for those who are new to this author it's a must! Highly recommended.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

A new reader from Kingston, 08 Apr 2008
This book was recommended by a friend who knew I have limited time to read. He suggested this Judy Astley book. Another friend who had a copy also felt it was worth passing on to me.
This well written entertaining easy reading book did not disappoint and has encouraged me to read more of this author. Many situations one can easily relate to. Judy, keep at it and Thanks.

Good to cheer you up in mid Feb, 06 Feb 2008
I read this because my grandma recommended it, it's not my normal kind of read. However it was a very nice thing to sit down to on a cold winter's day. Really good. I can't tell you too much of the plot or I'll spoil it, but it's written in a very amusing way with lots of good observations on modern life. The bit about what exactly "sick" means when a teenager says it, is a conversation my friend Janet was having only about a week ago. I also thought it had just enough danger and peril to make me really worried (that gruesome cupboard on the landing, I'll say no more....) and a nicely unexpected ending... I shed a real tear too! My only suggestion: I would have liked more of Mimi the brilliant teenager - bring her back in her own side-project please!

Judy Astley does it again, 04 Feb 2008
Another truly enjoyable read from Judy Astley - read cover to cover on train journey , a book best read in one sitting. A daring subject, often painful, gripping from beginning to end.

Another superb read, 31 Jan 2008
Another brilliant effort from Astley, I am recommending this book to everyone. I really look forward to Astley's novels every year and this years has not disappointed.

Anne-Marie, 29 Jan 2008
Astley has as ever managed another fantastic novel. If you are an Astley fan you'll love it, and for those who are new to this author it's a must! Highly recommended.

Very entertaining - wickedly funny!, 14 Jan 2002
I love Judy Astley's novels and I really, really enjoyed this one. It's very funny, but also warm and sensitive. I definitely recommend it!

Genuinely amusing read, 30 Aug 2001
...I have read all of Judy Astley's books and whilst this may not be the best it is certainly entertaining and well written. The characters are recognisable from life and the book is most definitely worth a read.

extremely disappointing read, 31 May 2001
I have never read any Judy Astley books before, nor am I likely to again, on the strength of this one. I found the characters awfully weak, and quite honestly struggled to finish the book. I cannot quite believe that the same readers who enjoy erica james' magnificent storytelling would relish this one. Most authors have a below par book, so perhaps this is judy astleys? One to avoid if you can, or certainly buy it from a charity shop, but don't pay the full price for it.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

A new reader from Kingston, 08 Apr 2008
This book was recommended by a friend who knew I have limited time to read. He suggested this Judy Astley book. Another friend who had a copy also felt it was worth passing on to me.
This well written entertaining easy reading book did not disappoint and has encouraged me to read more of this author. Many situations one can easily relate to. Judy, keep at it and Thanks.

Good to cheer you up in mid Feb, 06 Feb 2008
I read this because my grandma recommended it, it's not my normal kind of read. However it was a very nice thing to sit down to on a cold winter's day. Really good. I can't tell you too much of the plot or I'll spoil it, but it's written in a very amusing way with lots of good observations on modern life. The bit about what exactly "sick" means when a teenager says it, is a conversation my friend Janet was having only about a week ago. I also thought it had just enough danger and peril to make me really worried (that gruesome cupboard on the landing, I'll say no more....) and a nicely unexpected ending... I shed a real tear too! My only suggestion: I would have liked more of Mimi the brilliant teenager - bring her back in her own side-project please!

Judy Astley does it again, 04 Feb 2008
Another truly enjoyable read from Judy Astley - read cover to cover on train journey , a book best read in one sitting. A daring subject, often painful, gripping from beginning to end.

Another superb read, 31 Jan 2008
Another brilliant effort from Astley, I am recommending this book to everyone. I really look forward to Astley's novels every year and this years has not disappointed.

Anne-Marie, 29 Jan 2008
Astley has as ever managed another fantastic novel. If you are an Astley fan you'll love it, and for those who are new to this author it's a must! Highly recommended.

Very entertaining - wickedly funny!, 14 Jan 2002
I love Judy Astley's novels and I really, really enjoyed this one. It's very funny, but also warm and sensitive. I definitely recommend it!

Genuinely amusing read, 30 Aug 2001
...I have read all of Judy Astley's books and whilst this may not be the best it is certainly entertaining and well written. The characters are recognisable from life and the book is most definitely worth a read.

extremely disappointing read, 31 May 2001
I have never read any Judy Astley books before, nor am I likely to again, on the strength of this one. I found the characters awfully weak, and quite honestly struggled to finish the book. I cannot quite believe that the same readers who enjoy erica james' magnificent storytelling would relish this one. Most authors have a below par book, so perhaps this is judy astleys? One to avoid if you can, or certainly buy it from a charity shop, but don't pay the full price for it.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

A new reader from Kingston, 08 Apr 2008
This book was recommended by a friend who knew I have limited time to read. He suggested this Judy Astley book. Another friend who had a copy also felt it was worth passing on to me.
This well written entertaining easy reading book did not disappoint and has encouraged me to read more of this author. Many situations one can easily relate to. Judy, keep at it and Thanks.

Good to cheer you up in mid Feb, 06 Feb 2008
I read this because my grandma recommended it, it's not my normal kind of read. However it was a very nice thing to sit down to on a cold winter's day. Really good. I can't tell you too much of the plot or I'll spoil it, but it's written in a very amusing way with lots of good observations on modern life. The bit about what exactly "sick" means when a teenager says it, is a conversation my friend Janet was having only about a week ago. I also thought it had just enough danger and peril to make me really worried (that gruesome cupboard on the landing, I'll say no more....) and a nicely unexpected ending... I shed a real tear too! My only suggestion: I would have liked more of Mimi the brilliant teenager - bring her back in her own side-project please!

Judy Astley does it again, 04 Feb 2008
Another truly enjoyable read from Judy Astley - read cover to cover on train journey , a book best read in one sitting. A daring subject, often painful, gripping from beginning to end.

Another superb read, 31 Jan 2008
Another brilliant effort from Astley, I am recommending this book to everyone. I really look forward to Astley's novels every year and this years has not disappointed.

Anne-Marie, 29 Jan 2008
Astley has as ever managed another fantastic novel. If you are an Astley fan you'll love it, and for those who are new to this author it's a must! Highly recommended.

Very entertaining - wickedly funny!, 14 Jan 2002
I love Judy Astley's novels and I really, really enjoyed this one. It's very funny, but also warm and sensitive. I definitely recommend it!

Genuinely amusing read, 30 Aug 2001
...I have read all of Judy Astley's books and whilst this may not be the best it is certainly entertaining and well written. The characters are recognisable from life and the book is most definitely worth a read.

extremely disappointing read, 31 May 2001
I have never read any Judy Astley books before, nor am I likely to again, on the strength of this one. I found the characters awfully weak, and quite honestly struggled to finish the book. I cannot quite believe that the same readers who enjoy erica james' magnificent storytelling would relish this one. Most authors have a below par book, so perhaps this is judy astleys? One to avoid if you can, or certainly buy it from a charity shop, but don't pay the full price for it.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

NEW TO THIS AUTHOR BUT THOUGHT IT WAS A GREAT BOOK, 15 Feb 2005
This was the first book by Judy Astley I have read and I was pleasantly suprised. However the ending seemed unfinished!

I wanted to read on and on which I suppose is the ploy!

I would recommend this book for a flight or a beach, or for single girls everywhere.

Lost Potential, 11 Apr 2004
Judy Astley's books are typical of the type to be found on the beach, at the airport, etc. light, mostly enjoyable reading. With this one, though, I found the characters had only vague lives - it had the potential for an excellent storyline but much was left unfinished and I felt disappointed that her "excitement at being alone and able to do her own thing" was finally ground down as she succumbed in the end. I so wanted her to be the independent woman.
She never really was alone, anyway, her vastly annoying mother, her friends intent on matching her with anything in trousers (in particular an ex-teacher who was slime personified), her sad elderly neighbour, her limp ex-husband, all combined to fill almost every waking moment of her life. We never did find out who the culprits were of the burglary, were they caught? And what was the fate of Mrs Jenkins?
However, one of the few laugh out loud moments - the scorched skirt scene - brought tears to my eyes once I realised she hadn't been hurt. If only there could have been more of these "images in the mind" moments.

average, 22 Apr 2003
on hearing good reports about Judy Astley's novels i was glad to have come upon unchained melanie. however it didn't live up to the hype i found the main charcter melanie a little annoying with little personality. it was comical in places and with a great charcter of mel's next door neighbour. if you have ever had an annoying neighbour you will understand how mel feels about her! it wasn't exceptional but has a few laughs along the way

not quite up to scratch..., 08 May 2002
Normally, on opening a Judy Astley book, I become consumed by the myriad characters, the chaotic family life, the sometimes slightly sordid undertones....but this book was an exception. For a start, the Melanie of the title lives alone, so whilst we are treated to glimpses of her (ex) husband and daughter's lives, we do not get the sense of family life that we do in Astley's previous novels. In its place is much pontificating on the pleasures of being able to live alone, which leads to a somewhat empty feeling- the main character is very solitary and even her misadventures feel very pedestrian. (She rebels by having a garden makeover and betting small amounts on the GGs, which says it all really... )
I also found it very unsympathetic that Melanie was so delighted to see her only child go to university, with no apparent regret or sentimentalism- this just did not ring true!Nevertheless, it's not all bad. Astley's style remains engaging, and she has many positive points to make about women living alone- I just wish she had encapsulated tham in a more riveting and personable story.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

A new reader from Kingston, 08 Apr 2008
This book was recommended by a friend who knew I have limited time to read. He suggested this Judy Astley book. Another friend who had a copy also felt it was worth passing on to me.
This well written entertaining easy reading book did not disappoint and has encouraged me to read more of this author. Many situations one can easily relate to. Judy, keep at it and Thanks.

Good to cheer you up in mid Feb, 06 Feb 2008
I read this because my grandma recommended it, it's not my normal kind of read. However it was a very nice thing to sit down to on a cold winter's day. Really good. I can't tell you too much of the plot or I'll spoil it, but it's written in a very amusing way with lots of good observations on modern life. The bit about what exactly "sick" means when a teenager says it, is a conversation my friend Janet was having only about a week ago. I also thought it had just enough danger and peril to make me really worried (that gruesome cupboard on the landing, I'll say no more....) and a nicely unexpected ending... I shed a real tear too! My only suggestion: I would have liked more of Mimi the brilliant teenager - bring her back in her own side-project please!

Judy Astley does it again, 04 Feb 2008
Another truly enjoyable read from Judy Astley - read cover to cover on train journey , a book best read in one sitting. A daring subject, often painful, gripping from beginning to end.

Another superb read, 31 Jan 2008
Another brilliant effort from Astley, I am recommending this book to everyone. I really look forward to Astley's novels every year and this years has not disappointed.

Anne-Marie, 29 Jan 2008
Astley has as ever managed another fantastic novel. If you are an Astley fan you'll love it, and for those who are new to this author it's a must! Highly recommended.

Very entertaining - wickedly funny!, 14 Jan 2002
I love Judy Astley's novels and I really, really enjoyed this one. It's very funny, but also warm and sensitive. I definitely recommend it!

Genuinely amusing read, 30 Aug 2001
...I have read all of Judy Astley's books and whilst this may not be the best it is certainly entertaining and well written. The characters are recognisable from life and the book is most definitely worth a read.

extremely disappointing read, 31 May 2001
I have never read any Judy Astley books before, nor am I likely to again, on the strength of this one. I found the characters awfully weak, and quite honestly struggled to finish the book. I cannot quite believe that the same readers who enjoy erica james' magnificent storytelling would relish this one. Most authors have a below par book, so perhaps this is judy astleys? One to avoid if you can, or certainly buy it from a charity shop, but don't pay the full price for it.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

NEW TO THIS AUTHOR BUT THOUGHT IT WAS A GREAT BOOK, 15 Feb 2005
This was the first book by Judy Astley I have read and I was pleasantly suprised. However the ending seemed unfinished!

I wanted to read on and on which I suppose is the ploy!

I would recommend this book for a flight or a beach, or for single girls everywhere.

Lost Potential, 11 Apr 2004
Judy Astley's books are typical of the type to be found on the beach, at the airport, etc. light, mostly enjoyable reading. With this one, though, I found the characters had only vague lives - it had the potential for an excellent storyline but much was left unfinished and I felt disappointed that her "excitement at being alone and able to do her own thing" was finally ground down as she succumbed in the end. I so wanted her to be the independent woman.
She never really was alone, anyway, her vastly annoying mother, her friends intent on matching her with anything in trousers (in particular an ex-teacher who was slime personified), her sad elderly neighbour, her limp ex-husband, all combined to fill almost every waking moment of her life. We never did find out who the culprits were of the burglary, were they caught? And what was the fate of Mrs Jenkins?
However, one of the few laugh out loud moments - the scorched skirt scene - brought tears to my eyes once I realised she hadn't been hurt. If only there could have been more of these "images in the mind" moments.

average, 22 Apr 2003
on hearing good reports about Judy Astley's novels i was glad to have come upon unchained melanie. however it didn't live up to the hype i found the main charcter melanie a little annoying with little personality. it was comical in places and with a great charcter of mel's next door neighbour. if you have ever had an annoying neighbour you will understand how mel feels about her! it wasn't exceptional but has a few laughs along the way

not quite up to scratch..., 08 May 2002
Normally, on opening a Judy Astley book, I become consumed by the myriad characters, the chaotic family life, the sometimes slightly sordid undertones....but this book was an exception. For a start, the Melanie of the title lives alone, so whilst we are treated to glimpses of her (ex) husband and daughter's lives, we do not get the sense of family life that we do in Astley's previous novels. In its place is much pontificating on the pleasures of being able to live alone, which leads to a somewhat empty feeling- the main character is very solitary and even her misadventures feel very pedestrian. (She rebels by having a garden makeover and betting small amounts on the GGs, which says it all really... )
I also found it very unsympathetic that Melanie was so delighted to see her only child go to university, with no apparent regret or sentimentalism- this just did not ring true!Nevertheless, it's not all bad. Astley's style remains engaging, and she has many positive points to make about women living alone- I just wish she had encapsulated tham in a more riveting and personable story.

Could have been good, but wasnt, 11 Jun 2005
Sadly, Size Matters wasnt anywhere near as good as All Inclusive which was the first book I read from Judy Astley. Hope it was a one-off as I've just started a new one.

Size matters could have really been good, a great subject many of us can identify with, but it didn't really work, too much boring dialogue for my liking. Give it a miss and go onto All Inclusive.

Rubbish, rubbish...rubish!, 19 Jul 2004
I NEVER stop reading a book halfway through, I ALWAYS have to persevere all the way through...except with this one. I kept trying to read it, putting it down and reading another book, going back for another try, but I just can't read any more. This is the first book in my entire late-twenty-something life that I have not completed reading!
The story is boring, I cannot relate to any of the characters, the low-down deprived school kids that arrive at school in 4x4's does not ring true (and as a school-mom from a Midlands council estate, I know this from experience) and it is just more like something I would suggest a much older - 50's plus - kind of age range may find interesting, but I personally don't care much to read about peoples ideas of bad furnature or cushions. I want some action in my novels. Not nonsensical rubbish that does not make me want to continue reading.

Go on, have another slice!, 04 Jul 2004
This book goes to show that you shouldn't judge a book by it's cover. Before I read it, I was slightly worried that the main character (Jay, director of a cleaning company) was going to be constantly moaning about the size of her hips! Thankfully, it didn't turn out that way.
Size matters follows the different diets tried by a mother of three who doesn't want to be ridikuled by her cousin, Delphine. It also follows the lives of her offspring - a new pregnancy, a crush, and a slightly psycopathic best friend.
I liked the way that each of the plots branched out, and how the characters seemed down to earth. The only thing stopping me from giving it 5 stars is the fact that a firmer conclusion could be drawn at the end. I would have loved to have known what the cleaners got up to in the end!

A Refreshingly Good Read, 16 May 2004
I loved this book. I read it through from cover to cover in one session and then wanted to read it straight through again. Judy Astley writes about every day life - the ups and downs of her heroine Jay who lives with her architect husband and three children, and together with a friend rus her own cleaning business. Jay has been feeling somewhat middle aged for a while, but the imminent return of her cousin Delphine from Australia (the girl who when they were growing up together had everything, including the enviable figure), makes her determined to do something about it, and she launches herself on a series of diets, with somewhat unexpected consequences.
The characters are believable and well-drawn, but as a fellow cat lover, it was the little feline touches which made it for me. I'm sure many of those people who live with (I hesitate to use the word "own") a cat will be able to relate to the increasingly hilarious entries of Daffodil the Burmese, culminating in her dragging a fully grown rook into the dining room when the extended family are sitting down to a special celebration lunch.
This was the first book by Judy Astley that I read, and it has encouraged me to go out and buy her other books. For a feel-good read that made me laugh out loud, Size Matters comes thoroughly recommended.

Another Winner, 06 May 2004
Judy has pulled it off again! Based as usual on her close observation of life and her way with wit, "Size Matters" is another of those "read at a sitting" delights that you really need for the beach or the gite, (assuming you're not on a diet). It will be another sure winner with the fans Judy has made with her earlier delights like "Just for the Summer" "Excess baggage", and "Seven for a secret". Read it before you need the larege print edition!

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

A new reader from Kingston, 08 Apr 2008
This book was recommended by a friend who knew I have limited time to read. He suggested this Judy Astley book. Another friend who had a copy also felt it was worth passing on to me.
This well written entertaining easy reading book did not disappoint and has encouraged me to read more of this author. Many situations one can easily relate to. Judy, keep at it and Thanks.

Good to cheer you up in mid Feb, 06 Feb 2008
I read this because my grandma recommended it, it's not my normal kind of read. However it was a very nice thing to sit down to on a cold winter's day. Really good. I can't tell you too much of the plot or I'll spoil it, but it's written in a very amusing way with lots of good observations on modern life. The bit about what exactly "sick" means when a teenager says it, is a conversation my friend Janet was having only about a week ago. I also thought it had just enough danger and peril to make me really worried (that gruesome cupboard on the landing, I'll say no more....) and a nicely unexpected ending... I shed a real tear too! My only suggestion: I would have liked more of Mimi the brilliant teenager - bring her back in her own side-project please!

Judy Astley does it again, 04 Feb 2008
Another truly enjoyable read from Judy Astley - read cover to cover on train journey , a book best read in one sitting. A daring subject, often painful, gripping from beginning to end.

Another superb read, 31 Jan 2008
Another brilliant effort from Astley, I am recommending this book to everyone. I really look forward to Astley's novels every year and this years has not disappointed.

Anne-Marie, 29 Jan 2008
Astley has as ever managed another fantastic novel. If you are an Astley fan you'll love it, and for those who are new to this author it's a must! Highly recommended.

Very entertaining - wickedly funny!, 14 Jan 2002
I love Judy Astley's novels and I really, really enjoyed this one. It's very funny, but also warm and sensitive. I definitely recommend it!

Genuinely amusing read, 30 Aug 2001
...I have read all of Judy Astley's books and whilst this may not be the best it is certainly entertaining and well written. The characters are recognisable from life and the book is most definitely worth a read.

extremely disappointing read, 31 May 2001
I have never read any Judy Astley books before, nor am I likely to again, on the strength of this one. I found the characters awfully weak, and quite honestly struggled to finish the book. I cannot quite believe that the same readers who enjoy erica james' magnificent storytelling would relish this one. Most authors have a below par book, so perhaps this is judy astleys? One to avoid if you can, or certainly buy it from a charity shop, but don't pay the full price for it.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

NEW TO THIS AUTHOR BUT THOUGHT IT WAS A GREAT BOOK, 15 Feb 2005
This was the first book by Judy Astley I have read and I was pleasantly suprised. However the ending seemed unfinished!

I wanted to read on and on which I suppose is the ploy!

I would recommend this book for a flight or a beach, or for single girls everywhere.

Lost Potential, 11 Apr 2004
Judy Astley's books are typical of the type to be found on the beach, at the airport, etc. light, mostly enjoyable reading. With this one, though, I found the characters had only vague lives - it had the potential for an excellent storyline but much was left unfinished and I felt disappointed that her "excitement at being alone and able to do her own thing" was finally ground down as she succumbed in the end. I so wanted her to be the independent woman.
She never really was alone, anyway, her vastly annoying mother, her friends intent on matching her with anything in trousers (in particular an ex-teacher who was slime personified), her sad elderly neighbour, her limp ex-husband, all combined to fill almost every waking moment of her life. We never did find out who the culprits were of the burglary, were they caught? And what was the fate of Mrs Jenkins?
However, one of the few laugh out loud moments - the scorched skirt scene - brought tears to my eyes once I realised she hadn't been hurt. If only there could have been more of these "images in the mind" moments.

average, 22 Apr 2003
on hearing good reports about Judy Astley's novels i was glad to have come upon unchained melanie. however it didn't live up to the hype i found the main charcter melanie a little annoying with little personality. it was comical in places and with a great charcter of mel's next door neighbour. if you have ever had an annoying neighbour you will understand how mel feels about her! it wasn't exceptional but has a few laughs along the way

not quite up to scratch..., 08 May 2002
Normally, on opening a Judy Astley book, I become consumed by the myriad characters, the chaotic family life, the sometimes slightly sordid undertones....but this book was an exception. For a start, the Melanie of the title lives alone, so whilst we are treated to glimpses of her (ex) husband and daughter's lives, we do not get the sense of family life that we do in Astley's previous novels. In its place is much pontificating on the pleasures of being able to live alone, which leads to a somewhat empty feeling- the main character is very solitary and even her misadventures feel very pedestrian. (She rebels by having a garden makeover and betting small amounts on the GGs, which says it all really... )
I also found it very unsympathetic that Melanie was so delighted to see her only child go to university, with no apparent regret or sentimentalism- this just did not ring true!Nevertheless, it's not all bad. Astley's style remains engaging, and she has many positive points to make about women living alone- I just wish she had encapsulated tham in a more riveting and personable story.

Could have been good, but wasnt, 11 Jun 2005
Sadly, Size Matters wasnt anywhere near as good as All Inclusive which was the first book I read from Judy Astley. Hope it was a one-off as I've just started a new one.

Size matters could have really been good, a great subject many of us can identify with, but it didn't really work, too much boring dialogue for my liking. Give it a miss and go onto All Inclusive.

Rubbish, rubbish...rubish!, 19 Jul 2004
I NEVER stop reading a book halfway through, I ALWAYS have to persevere all the way through...except with this one. I kept trying to read it, putting it down and reading another book, going back for another try, but I just can't read any more. This is the first book in my entire late-twenty-something life that I have not completed reading!
The story is boring, I cannot relate to any of the characters, the low-down deprived school kids that arrive at school in 4x4's does not ring true (and as a school-mom from a Midlands council estate, I know this from experience) and it is just more like something I would suggest a much older - 50's plus - kind of age range may find interesting, but I personally don't care much to read about peoples ideas of bad furnature or cushions. I want some action in my novels. Not nonsensical rubbish that does not make me want to continue reading.

Go on, have another slice!, 04 Jul 2004
This book goes to show that you shouldn't judge a book by it's cover. Before I read it, I was slightly worried that the main character (Jay, director of a cleaning company) was going to be constantly moaning about the size of her hips! Thankfully, it didn't turn out that way.
Size matters follows the different diets tried by a mother of three who doesn't want to be ridikuled by her cousin, Delphine. It also follows the lives of her offspring - a new pregnancy, a crush, and a slightly psycopathic best friend.
I liked the way that each of the plots branched out, and how the characters seemed down to earth. The only thing stopping me from giving it 5 stars is the fact that a firmer conclusion could be drawn at the end. I would have loved to have known what the cleaners got up to in the end!

A Refreshingly Good Read, 16 May 2004
I loved this book. I read it through from cover to cover in one session and then wanted to read it straight through again. Judy Astley writes about every day life - the ups and downs of her heroine Jay who lives with her architect husband and three children, and together with a friend rus her own cleaning business. Jay has been feeling somewhat middle aged for a while, but the imminent return of her cousin Delphine from Australia (the girl who when they were growing up together had everything, including the enviable figure), makes her determined to do something about it, and she launches herself on a series of diets, with somewhat unexpected consequences.
The characters are believable and well-drawn, but as a fellow cat lover, it was the little feline touches which made it for me. I'm sure many of those people who live with (I hesitate to use the word "own") a cat will be able to relate to the increasingly hilarious entries of Daffodil the Burmese, culminating in her dragging a fully grown rook into the dining room when the extended family are sitting down to a special celebration lunch.
This was the first book by Judy Astley that I read, and it has encouraged me to go out and buy her other books. For a feel-good read that made me laugh out loud, Size Matters comes thoroughly recommended.

Another Winner, 06 May 2004
Judy has pulled it off again! Based as usual on her close observation of life and her way with wit, "Size Matters" is another of those "read at a sitting" delights that you really need for the beach or the gite, (assuming you're not on a diet). It will be another sure winner with the fans Judy has made with her earlier delights like "Just for the Summer" "Excess baggage", and "Seven for a secret". Read it before you need the larege print edition!

Amusing!, 19 Oct 2007
An amusing read and much better than the last one I read by this author, All Inclusive. However from the cover picture I did actually think the story was going to include some travelling, but it was all about the build up!! Some of the comments reminded me of our own situation, when as 'empty nesters' we decided to sell the family home and come and live abroad.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

A new reader from Kingston, 08 Apr 2008
This book was recommended by a friend who knew I have limited time to read. He suggested this Judy Astley book. Another friend who had a copy also felt it was worth passing on to me.
This well written entertaining easy reading book did not disappoint and has encouraged me to read more of this author. Many situations one can easily relate to. Judy, keep at it and Thanks.

Good to cheer you up in mid Feb, 06 Feb 2008
I read this because my grandma recommended it, it's not my normal kind of read. However it was a very nice thing to sit down to on a cold winter's day. Really good. I can't tell you too much of the plot or I'll spoil it, but it's written in a very amusing way with lots of good observations on modern life. The bit about what exactly "sick" means when a teenager says it, is a conversation my friend Janet was having only about a week ago. I also thought it had just enough danger and peril to make me really worried (that gruesome cupboard on the landing, I'll say no more....) and a nicely unexpected ending... I shed a real tear too! My only suggestion: I would have liked more of Mimi the brilliant teenager - bring her back in her own side-project please!

Judy Astley does it again, 04 Feb 2008
Another truly enjoyable read from Judy Astley - read cover to cover on train journey , a book best read in one sitting. A daring subject, often painful, gripping from beginning to end.

Another superb read, 31 Jan 2008
Another brilliant effort from Astley, I am recommending this book to everyone. I really look forward to Astley's novels every year and this years has not disappointed.

Anne-Marie, 29 Jan 2008
Astley has as ever managed another fantastic novel. If you are an Astley fan you'll love it, and for those who are new to this author it's a must! Highly recommended.

Very entertaining - wickedly funny!, 14 Jan 2002
I love Judy Astley's novels and I really, really enjoyed this one. It's very funny, but also warm and sensitive. I definitely recommend it!

Genuinely amusing read, 30 Aug 2001
...I have read all of Judy Astley's books and whilst this may not be the best it is certainly entertaining and well written. The characters are recognisable from life and the book is most definitely worth a read.

extremely disappointing read, 31 May 2001
I have never read any Judy Astley books before, nor am I likely to again, on the strength of this one. I found the characters awfully weak, and quite honestly struggled to finish the book. I cannot quite believe that the same readers who enjoy erica james' magnificent storytelling would relish this one. Most authors have a below par book, so perhaps this is judy astleys? One to avoid if you can, or certainly buy it from a charity shop, but don't pay the full price for it.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

NEW TO THIS AUTHOR BUT THOUGHT IT WAS A GREAT BOOK, 15 Feb 2005
This was the first book by Judy Astley I have read and I was pleasantly suprised. However the ending seemed unfinished!

I wanted to read on and on which I suppose is the ploy!

I would recommend this book for a flight or a beach, or for single girls everywhere.

Lost Potential, 11 Apr 2004
Judy Astley's books are typical of the type to be found on the beach, at the airport, etc. light, mostly enjoyable reading. With this one, though, I found the characters had only vague lives - it had the potential for an excellent storyline but much was left unfinished and I felt disappointed that her "excitement at being alone and able to do her own thing" was finally ground down as she succumbed in the end. I so wanted her to be the independent woman.
She never really was alone, anyway, her vastly annoying mother, her friends intent on matching her with anything in trousers (in particular an ex-teacher who was slime personified), her sad elderly neighbour, her limp ex-husband, all combined to fill almost every waking moment of her life. We never did find out who the culprits were of the burglary, were they caught? And what was the fate of Mrs Jenkins?
However, one of the few laugh out loud moments - the scorched skirt scene - brought tears to my eyes once I realised she hadn't been hurt. If only there could have been more of these "images in the mind" moments.

average, 22 Apr 2003
on hearing good reports about Judy Astley's novels i was glad to have come upon unchained melanie. however it didn't live up to the hype i found the main charcter melanie a little annoying with little personality. it was comical in places and with a great charcter of mel's next door neighbour. if you have ever had an annoying neighbour you will understand how mel feels about her! it wasn't exceptional but has a few laughs along the way

not quite up to scratch..., 08 May 2002
Normally, on opening a Judy Astley book, I become consumed by the myriad characters, the chaotic family life, the sometimes slightly sordid undertones....but this book was an exception. For a start, the Melanie of the title lives alone, so whilst we are treated to glimpses of her (ex) husband and daughter's lives, we do not get the sense of family life that we do in Astley's previous novels. In its place is much pontificating on the pleasures of being able to live alone, which leads to a somewhat empty feeling- the main character is very solitary and even her misadventures feel very pedestrian. (She rebels by having a garden makeover and betting small amounts on the GGs, which says it all really... )
I also found it very unsympathetic that Melanie was so delighted to see her only child go to university, with no apparent regret or sentimentalism- this just did not ring true!Nevertheless, it's not all bad. Astley's style remains engaging, and she has many positive points to make about women living alone- I just wish she had encapsulated tham in a more riveting and personable story.

Could have been good, but wasnt, 11 Jun 2005
Sadly, Size Matters wasnt anywhere near as good as All Inclusive which was the first book I read from Judy Astley. Hope it was a one-off as I've just started a new one.

Size matters could have really been good, a great subject many of us can identify with, but it didn't really work, too much boring dialogue for my liking. Give it a miss and go onto All Inclusive.

Rubbish, rubbish...rubish!, 19 Jul 2004
I NEVER stop reading a book halfway through, I ALWAYS have to persevere all the way through...except with this one. I kept trying to read it, putting it down and reading another book, going back for another try, but I just can't read any more. This is the first book in my entire late-twenty-something life that I have not completed reading!
The story is boring, I cannot relate to any of the characters, the low-down deprived school kids that arrive at school in 4x4's does not ring true (and as a school-mom from a Midlands council estate, I know this from experience) and it is just more like something I would suggest a much older - 50's plus - kind of age range may find interesting, but I personally don't care much to read about peoples ideas of bad furnature or cushions. I want some action in my novels. Not nonsensical rubbish that does not make me want to continue reading.

Go on, have another slice!, 04 Jul 2004
This book goes to show that you shouldn't judge a book by it's cover. Before I read it, I was slightly worried that the main character (Jay, director of a cleaning company) was going to be constantly moaning about the size of her hips! Thankfully, it didn't turn out that way.
Size matters follows the different diets tried by a mother of three who doesn't want to be ridikuled by her cousin, Delphine. It also follows the lives of her offspring - a new pregnancy, a crush, and a slightly psycopathic best friend.
I liked the way that each of the plots branched out, and how the characters seemed down to earth. The only thing stopping me from giving it 5 stars is the fact that a firmer conclusion could be drawn at the end. I would have loved to have known what the cleaners got up to in the end!

A Refreshingly Good Read, 16 May 2004
I loved this book. I read it through from cover to cover in one session and then wanted to read it straight through again. Judy Astley writes about every day life - the ups and downs of her heroine Jay who lives with her architect husband and three children, and together with a friend rus her own cleaning business. Jay has been feeling somewhat middle aged for a while, but the imminent return of her cousin Delphine from Australia (the girl who when they were growing up together had everything, including the enviable figure), makes her determined to do something about it, and she launches herself on a series of diets, with somewhat unexpected consequences.
The characters are believable and well-drawn, but as a fellow cat lover, it was the little feline touches which made it for me. I'm sure many of those people who live with (I hesitate to use the word "own") a cat will be able to relate to the increasingly hilarious entries of Daffodil the Burmese, culminating in her dragging a fully grown rook into the dining room when the extended family are sitting down to a special celebration lunch.
This was the first book by Judy Astley that I read, and it has encouraged me to go out and buy her other books. For a feel-good read that made me laugh out loud, Size Matters comes thoroughly recommended.

Another Winner, 06 May 2004
Judy has pulled it off again! Based as usual on her close observation of life and her way with wit, "Size Matters" is another of those "read at a sitting" delights that you really need for the beach or the gite, (assuming you're not on a diet). It will be another sure winner with the fans Judy has made with her earlier delights like "Just for the Summer" "Excess baggage", and "Seven for a secret". Read it before you need the larege print edition!

Amusing!, 19 Oct 2007
An amusing read and much better than the last one I read by this author, All Inclusive. However from the cover picture I did actually think the story was going to include some travelling, but it was all about the build up!! Some of the comments reminded me of our own situation, when as 'empty nesters' we decided to sell the family home and come and live abroad.

Bit boring, 25 Sep 2008
i reached chapter 10 on this book but gave up last night it just kept going on to me so i've started a new book

Funny and pleasant , 24 Jul 2007
This book was enjoyable. It was a bit short but it was an all round pleasant book. There was some chuckling on my part but I felt on the whole I wasn't entirely gripped by the story. It didnt take long to read though and I would recomend as something light hearted to read.

Pleasant Surprise, 15 Aug 2001
Judy Astley's tale of the goings on in a well to do suburban cul-de-sac was easily the funniest book I read on holiday this summer. The characters and the situations that they get into are keenly observed, (you might recognise your friends here) and some of them uncomfortably familiar (your friends might recognise you!). Before reading Pleasant Vices, only Tom Sharpe's books had made me laugh out loud - they both share an hilarious turn of phrase. There is a sense of Sharpe's wicked observation of human character and foibles in Astley's book and even if her characters are not so bizarre as his, they are all the more believable for that. This is the first Judy Astley book that I have read but it certainly won't be the last.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

A new reader from Kingston, 08 Apr 2008
This book was recommended by a friend who knew I have limited time to read. He suggested this Judy Astley book. Another friend who had a copy also felt it was worth passing on to me.
This well written entertaining easy reading book did not disappoint and has encouraged me to read more of this author. Many situations one can easily relate to. Judy, keep at it and Thanks.

Good to cheer you up in mid Feb, 06 Feb 2008
I read this because my grandma recommended it, it's not my normal kind of read. However it was a very nice thing to sit down to on a cold winter's day. Really good. I can't tell you too much of the plot or I'll spoil it, but it's written in a very amusing way with lots of good observations on modern life. The bit about what exactly "sick" means when a teenager says it, is a conversation my friend Janet was having only about a week ago. I also thought it had just enough danger and peril to make me really worried (that gruesome cupboard on the landing, I'll say no more....) and a nicely unexpected ending... I shed a real tear too! My only suggestion: I would have liked more of Mimi the brilliant teenager - bring her back in her own side-project please!

Judy Astley does it again, 04 Feb 2008
Another truly enjoyable read from Judy Astley - read cover to cover on train journey , a book best read in one sitting. A daring subject, often painful, gripping from beginning to end.

Another superb read, 31 Jan 2008
Another brilliant effort from Astley, I am recommending this book to everyone. I really look forward to Astley's novels every year and this years has not disappointed.

Anne-Marie, 29 Jan 2008
Astley has as ever managed another fantastic novel. If you are an Astley fan you'll love it, and for those who are new to this author it's a must! Highly recommended.

Very entertaining - wickedly funny!, 14 Jan 2002
I love Judy Astley's novels and I really, really enjoyed this one. It's very funny, but also warm and sensitive. I definitely recommend it!

Genuinely amusing read, 30 Aug 2001
...I have read all of Judy Astley's books and whilst this may not be the best it is certainly entertaining and well written. The characters are recognisable from life and the book is most definitely worth a read.

extremely disappointing read, 31 May 2001
I have never read any Judy Astley books before, nor am I likely to again, on the strength of this one. I found the characters awfully weak, and quite honestly struggled to finish the book. I cannot quite believe that the same readers who enjoy erica james' magnificent storytelling would relish this one. Most authors have a below par book, so perhaps this is judy astleys? One to avoid if you can, or certainly buy it from a charity shop, but don't pay the full price for it.

A satisfying read, 16 Aug 2008
Judy Astley writes about issues we can all relate to, and her latest book, 'Other People's Husbands', is no exception. This book is a light, enjoyable read. We meet Sara and Conrad who are both at crisis point, and who have to deal with their issues separately. We also meet their two daughters, Cass and Panda, along with some other family and friends. All the characters are likeable, and Sara is someone to whom you can really warm to, as well as relate to. Conrad is very humourous. Themes such as love, growing old, extra-marital affairs, being a parent/grandparent are all covered. Art also features, which adds an interesting dimension. There is a lot of insightful description. The ending leaves you feeling satisfied.

Interesting characters, 28 Jul 2008
Sara wonders whether she is suffering from a mid life crisis whereas her husband- Conrad - is determined not to grow any older as his 70th birthday approaches. The story follows Sara and Conrad and their two daughters, Cassandra and Pandora as they battle with life and its problems. Judy Astley creates interesting characters with issues all her readers will be able to relate to. Is Conrad really thinking seriously about ending it all? Will Sara step off the straight and narrow with the fanciable Ben? Can Cassandra and Paul get back together? What about Pandora? Then there's Sara's sister Lizzie who comes to stay. There's always something happening to keep you interested. I loved the ending - which wraps up the whole thing in a very satisfying manner. I enjoyed it and would recommend it as a good holiday read.

Funny, truthful, and just a little bit sad, 22 Jul 2008
Judy Astley's Other People's Husbands goes where other books fear to. She writes about life as it is, but with an insight most of us living life usually miss. This book is funny, full of scary insight and makes you cry, just a bit. Perfect.

NEW TO THIS AUTHOR BUT THOUGHT IT WAS A GREAT BOOK, 15 Feb 2005
This was the first book by Judy Astley I have read and I was pleasantly suprised. However the ending seemed unfinished!

I wanted to read on and on which I suppose is the ploy!

I would recommend this book for a flight or a beach, or for single girls everywhere.

Lost Potential, 11 Apr 2004
Judy Astley's books are typical of the type to be found on the beach, at the airport, etc. light, mostly enjoyable reading. With this one, though, I found the characters had only vague lives - it had the potential for an excellent storyline but much was left unfinished and I felt disappointed that her "excitement at being alone and able to do her own thing" was finally ground down as she succumbed in the end. I so wanted her to be the independent woman.
She never really was alone, anyway, her vastly annoying mother, her friends intent on matching her with anything in trousers (in particular an ex-teacher who was slime personified), her sad elderly neighbour, her limp ex-husband, all combined to fill almost every waking moment of her life. We never did find out who the culprits were of the burglary, were they caught? And what was the fate of Mrs Jenkins?
However, one of the few laugh out loud moments - the scorched skirt scene - brought tears to my eyes once I realised she hadn't been hurt. If only there could have been more of these "images in the mind" moments.

average, 22 Apr 2003
on hearing good reports about Judy Astley's novels i was glad to have come upon unchained melanie. however it didn't live up to the hype i found the main charcter melanie a little annoying with little personality. it was comical in places and with a great charcter of mel's next door neighbour. if you have ever had an annoying neighbour you will understand how mel feels about her! it wasn't exceptional but has a few laughs along the way

not quite up to scratch..., 08 May 2002
Normally, on opening a Judy Astley book, I become consumed by the myriad characters, the chaotic family life, the sometimes slightly sordid undertones....but this book was an exception. For a start, the Melanie of the title lives alone, so whilst we are treated to glimpses of her (ex) husband and daughter's lives, we do not get the sense of family life that we do in Astley's previous novels. In its place is much pontificating on the pleasures of being able to live alone, which leads to a somewhat empty feeling- the main character is very solitary and even her misadventures feel very pedestrian. (She rebels by having a garden makeover and betting small amounts on the GGs, which says it all really... )
I also found it very unsympathetic that Melanie was so delighted to see her only child go to university, with no apparent regret or sentimentalism- this just did not ring true!Nevertheless, it's not all bad. Astley's style remains engaging, and she has many positive points to make about women living alone- I just wish she had encapsulated tham in a more riveting and personable story.

Could have been good, but wasnt, 11 Jun 2005
Sadly, Size Matters wasnt anywhere near as good as All Inclusive which was the first book I read from Judy Astley. Hope it was a one-off as I've just started a new one.

Size matters could have really been good, a great subject many of us can identify with, but it didn't really work, too much boring dialogue for my liking. Give it a miss and go onto All Inclusive.

Rubbish, rubbish...rubish!, 19 Jul 2004
I NEVER stop reading a book halfway through, I ALWAYS have to persevere all the way through...except with this one. I kept trying to read it, putting it down and reading another book, going back for another try, but I just can't read any more. This is the first book in my entire late-twenty-something life that I have not completed reading!
The story is boring, I cannot relate to any of the characters, the low-down deprived school kids that arrive at school in 4x4's does not ring true (and as a school-mom from a Midlands council estate, I know this from experience) and it is just more like something I would suggest a much older - 50's plus - kind of age range may find interesting, but I personally don't care much to read about peoples ideas of bad furnature or cushions. I want some action in my novels. Not nonsensical rubbish that does not make me want to continue reading.

Go on, have another slice!, 04 Jul 2004
This book goes to show that you shouldn't judge a book by it's cover. Before I read it, I was slightly worried that the main character (Jay, director of a cleaning company) was going to be constantly moaning about the size of her hips! Thankfully, it didn't turn out that way.
Size matters follows the different diets tried by a mother of three who doesn't want to be ridikuled by her cousin, Delphine. It also follows the lives of her offspring - a new pregnancy, a crush, and a slightly psycopathic best friend.
I liked the way that each of the plots branched out, and how the characters seemed down to earth. The only thing stopping me from giving it 5 stars is the fact that a firmer conclusion could be drawn at the end. I would have loved to have known what the cleaners got up to in the end!

A Refreshingly Good Read, 16 May 2004
I loved this book. I read it through from cover to cover in one session and then wanted to read it straight through again. Judy Astley writes about every day life - the ups and downs of her heroine Jay who lives with her architect husband and three children, and together with a friend rus her own cleaning business. Jay has been feeling somewhat middle aged for a while, but the imminent return of her cousin Delphine from Australia (the girl who when they were growing up together had everything, including the enviable figure), makes her determined to do something about it, and she launches herself on a series of diets, with somewhat unexpected consequences.
The characters are believable and well-drawn, but as a fellow cat lover, it was the little feline touches which made it for me. I'm sure many of those people who live with (I hesitate to use the word "own") a cat will be able to relate to the increasingly hilarious entries of Daffodil the Burmese, culminating in her dragging a fully grown rook into the dining room when the extended family are sitting down to a special celebration lunch.
This was the first book by Judy Astley that I read, and it has encouraged me to go out and buy her other books. For a feel-good read that made me laugh out loud, Size Matters comes thoroughly recommended.

Another Winner, 06 May 2004
Judy has pulled it off again! Based as usual on her close observation of life and her way with wit, "Size Matters" is another of those "read at a sitting" delights that you really need for the beach or the gite, (assuming you're not on a diet). It will be another sure winner with the fans Judy has made with her earlier delights like "Just for the Summer" "Excess baggage", and "Seven for a secret". Read it before you need the larege print edition!

Amusing!, 19 Oct 2007
An amusing read and much better than the last one I read by this author, All Inclusive. However from the cover picture I did actually think the story was going to include some travelling, but it was all about the build up!! Some of the comments reminded me of our own situation, when as 'empty nesters' we decided to sell the family home and come and live abroad.

Bit boring, 25 Sep 2008
i reached chapter 10 on this book but gave up last night it just kept going on to me so i've started a new book

Funny and pleasant , 24 Jul 2007
This book was enjoyable. It was a bit short but it was an all round pleasant book. There was some chuckling on my part but I felt on the whole I wasn't entirely gripped by the story. It didnt take long to read though and I would recomend as something light hearted to read.

Pleasant Surprise, 15 Aug 2001
Judy Astley's tale of the goings on in a well to do suburban cul-de-sac was easily the funniest book I read on holiday this summer. The characters and the situations that they get into are keenly observed, (you might recognise your friends here) and some of them uncomfortably familiar (your friends might recognise you!). Before reading Pleasant Vices, only Tom Sharpe's books had made me laugh out loud - they both share an hilarious turn of phrase. There is a sense of Sharpe's wicked observation of human character and foibles in Astley's book and even if her characters are not so bizarre as his, they are all the more believable for that. This is the first Judy Astley book that I have read but it certainly won't be the last.

Astley at her best!, 16 Mar 2003
This is my joint favourite Astley novel, along with the fantastic Muddy Waters. The characters and motivations in this book run deeper than in some of her other novels, and the story is particularly intriguing- and heart-rending. It's about a family whose world is turned upside down with the arrival of a young woman who turns out to be the mother's long-forgotten natural daughter, who was adopted as a baby. Her stay in the family home is the catalyst for a dissection of the morals of keeping secrets, and the dangers of unearthing them- as well as for an in-depth portrait of an 'average' family who are not so average after all. This is the kind of emotional upheaval Astley excels at portraying, and here she does it beautifully.
What's more, although the ending hints at resolution, not everything ends up all 'neat and tidy'- just like life itself. A great read!