A Place Beyond Courage, 16 Oct 2008
This is the third book I have read by Elizabeth Chadwick, the others being 'The Greatest Knight' and 'The Scarlet Lion', and I can say this is the best yet. Chadwick does for English medievel history what Wilbur Smith has done for colonial africa - educate. Highly Recommended.


Another fabulous tale!, 05 May 2008
I know when I pick up a book written by Elizabeth Chadwick I'll be in for a treat and A Place Beyond Courage is no exception.
This story, based on a real figure in history, is full and evolving.
The story sweeps you through one man's life, John FitzGilbert, the Royal Marshal, as he travels the medieval paths of political turmoil, intrigue, love and family, all done with courage and integrity.

This book is a keeper, just as all Elizabeth Chadwick's books are for me.

John FitzGilbert: beyond the `hammers and anvils', 12 Feb 2008
I picked up this novel with some trepidation. How could the father of William Marshal (newly ensconced in my personal gallery of heroes) possibly be as interesting as his son? How could the maker of the infamous `hammers and anvils' speech possibly be a hero? Still, I was confident that if anyone could make this work it would be Elizabeth Chadwick. The painstaking research that made William Marshal come to life for me would surely do the same in respect of his father.

I wasn't disappointed. I didn't expect to like John FitzGilbert as much as I did. But in the process of reading Ms Chadwick's novel I obtained an appreciation, admiration and respect for John that took me by surprise. In this novel, Ms Chadwick managed to make the man himself human without ignoring the apparent cruelty of the `hammers and anvils' speech. I devoured this book in a few short days.

I know the broad history of this period so knew where most of the major turning points were and which directions events would take. But what I did not have, and what Ms Chadwick has so ably infused into the mixture was a sense of the people themselves and the impacts on their lives of the choices they needed to make.

John Marshal doesn't quite displace his son in my gallery of heroes, but he certainly joins him. Thanks, Ms Chadwick, for making another relatively obscure and heroic figure come to life.

Highly recommended to all who love well written medieval fiction.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith


WOW as always!!!!, 01 Feb 2008
I have read almost all of Elizabeth's books and i love each and every one. I feel i'm part of the Marshal family. The women in each book are strong and femine making them a joy to read. This book is lovely and i haven't been able to put it down,to entre the world that Elizabeth creates is always a delight and one of my greatest pleasures.
This book, a cuppa and a bar of choc.....Heaven!!!

A HISTORICAL WINNER, 16 Nov 2007
A PLACE BEYOND COURAGE, continues the remarkable story of the Marshal family. While the superb - The Greatest Knight - gave us the tale of William Marshal, Chadwick, looks back and unearths another defined, singular man; his father John, Marshal to Henry I of England.

John, shrewd (in the best sense of the word), sensible, ambitious, forcible and in no undefined terms both masculine and man of his time, uses his wits and vigor to achieve a successful social rank and respect while laying the groundwork for a dynamic dynasty.

Caught between the enduring battle between Matila and Stephen, John proves adept at meeting both their needs (before handily switching sides) --compromising, only as need be and surely to benefit his own in the end. His marriages play no small part in his life and Chadwick has managed to breathe life into this little known area of the first Marshal's life.

History whisks flawlessly throughout this novel. However,it still has heart without overplaying the romance which the author astutely balances between warrior/diplomat and rough-man-of-his-era-gentleman.

Of a side note: The cover art is stunning. The colors are vibrant and it has a honesty as it conveys the story in a glance. Brilliant!

A Place Beyond Courage, 16 Oct 2008
This is the third book I have read by Elizabeth Chadwick, the others being 'The Greatest Knight' and 'The Scarlet Lion', and I can say this is the best yet. Chadwick does for English medievel history what Wilbur Smith has done for colonial africa - educate. Highly Recommended.


Another fabulous tale!, 05 May 2008
I know when I pick up a book written by Elizabeth Chadwick I'll be in for a treat and A Place Beyond Courage is no exception.
This story, based on a real figure in history, is full and evolving.
The story sweeps you through one man's life, John FitzGilbert, the Royal Marshal, as he travels the medieval paths of political turmoil, intrigue, love and family, all done with courage and integrity.

This book is a keeper, just as all Elizabeth Chadwick's books are for me.

John FitzGilbert: beyond the `hammers and anvils', 12 Feb 2008
I picked up this novel with some trepidation. How could the father of William Marshal (newly ensconced in my personal gallery of heroes) possibly be as interesting as his son? How could the maker of the infamous `hammers and anvils' speech possibly be a hero? Still, I was confident that if anyone could make this work it would be Elizabeth Chadwick. The painstaking research that made William Marshal come to life for me would surely do the same in respect of his father.

I wasn't disappointed. I didn't expect to like John FitzGilbert as much as I did. But in the process of reading Ms Chadwick's novel I obtained an appreciation, admiration and respect for John that took me by surprise. In this novel, Ms Chadwick managed to make the man himself human without ignoring the apparent cruelty of the `hammers and anvils' speech. I devoured this book in a few short days.

I know the broad history of this period so knew where most of the major turning points were and which directions events would take. But what I did not have, and what Ms Chadwick has so ably infused into the mixture was a sense of the people themselves and the impacts on their lives of the choices they needed to make.

John Marshal doesn't quite displace his son in my gallery of heroes, but he certainly joins him. Thanks, Ms Chadwick, for making another relatively obscure and heroic figure come to life.

Highly recommended to all who love well written medieval fiction.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith


WOW as always!!!!, 01 Feb 2008
I have read almost all of Elizabeth's books and i love each and every one. I feel i'm part of the Marshal family. The women in each book are strong and femine making them a joy to read. This book is lovely and i haven't been able to put it down,to entre the world that Elizabeth creates is always a delight and one of my greatest pleasures.
This book, a cuppa and a bar of choc.....Heaven!!!

A HISTORICAL WINNER, 16 Nov 2007
A PLACE BEYOND COURAGE, continues the remarkable story of the Marshal family. While the superb - The Greatest Knight - gave us the tale of William Marshal, Chadwick, looks back and unearths another defined, singular man; his father John, Marshal to Henry I of England.

John, shrewd (in the best sense of the word), sensible, ambitious, forcible and in no undefined terms both masculine and man of his time, uses his wits and vigor to achieve a successful social rank and respect while laying the groundwork for a dynamic dynasty.

Caught between the enduring battle between Matila and Stephen, John proves adept at meeting both their needs (before handily switching sides) --compromising, only as need be and surely to benefit his own in the end. His marriages play no small part in his life and Chadwick has managed to breathe life into this little known area of the first Marshal's life.

History whisks flawlessly throughout this novel. However,it still has heart without overplaying the romance which the author astutely balances between warrior/diplomat and rough-man-of-his-era-gentleman.

Of a side note: The cover art is stunning. The colors are vibrant and it has a honesty as it conveys the story in a glance. Brilliant!

`You are stronger than you think', 11 Oct 2008
Ms Chadwick's latest novel draws additional historical figures from the shadows of the 12th century and imbues them with vibrant life. Roger Bigod, is the disputed heir to the earldom of Norfolk from approximately 1177. This dispute, which involved Roger's stepmother and stepbrothers, commenced during the reign of Henry II and extended for over a decade before being resolved by Richard I. The dispute brings Roger to court, where he meets Ida de Tosney who is Henry II's young mistress and the mother of his son. Eventually, Ida and Roger marry and while the marriage is a consequence of mutual attraction, it has its costs and burdens.

Ms Chadwick's greatest strength is her ability to combine historical accuracy and characters whose actions can be viewed from a contemporary perspective without any loss of authenticity. This accuracy is important to Ms Chadwick, and it is conveyed to the reader in a way which, while it seems effortless, is a tribute to detailed research. We may not know, with great certainty and at this distance, exactly how Roger and Ida interacted with each other on a personal basis but the novel largely accords with the known facts and provides a fascinating insight into a particularly turbulent time in English history. The medieval code of chivalry carried with it both burdens and costs as well as benefits and privileges.

For me, an added attraction is the links between the Bigods and another of my personal heroes: William Marshal. I was aware of Roger Bigod before reading this novel but not especially interested in him. Now I find that Ms Chadwick has - yet again - introduced me to an historical character about whom I need to know more. Fortunately, I am provided with a select bibliography which gives me a great starting point.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith


Another winner from Chadwick!, 04 Oct 2008
The Time of Singing retells the story of Roger Bigod, son of Hugh Bigod Earl of Norfolk, who joined the younger Henry in his revolt against his father Henry II. When the revolt fails Hugh loses the Earldom and lands and when he dies there is a bitter dispute over the right to inherit the Earldom between Roger and his step-mother and her two sons. While Roger serves Henry and bides his time to claim his Earldom young Ida de Tosney arrives in court as the King's ward. Henry is smitten and has other plans for Ida and he makes her his mistress and she eventually bears him a son, William. Unhappy with her position as mistress to the king, Ida casts her hopes on Roger and Henry allows them to marry -- although she must leave her son behind.

Henry still withholds the Earldom, but he does restore some of their lands and Ida and Roger build a life and family together and begin rebuild Framlingham Castle to greater heights than it was before. Once Richard I takes the crown at the death of Henry the Earldom is restored to Roger, and the rest of the book recounts their lives as they struggle to keep everything they hold dear as the battle lines are drawn during Richard's absence on crusade and subsequent kidnapping threatens to bankrupt England.

A very enjoyable surprise for me was the appearance of my personal favorite hero, William Marshal - I did not expect him at all, or to feature so prominently - but it appears Bigod and Marshal were contemporaries and friends. Another big surprise was Ida's son William - who readers of fiction set during the reigns of John and Henry III will recognize as William Longespée, and I have to admit many of my favorite moments in the book were of William and his attempts at a relationship with his mother, Roger and their children.

While I enjoyed this book very much, this is not an action packed, page turning, sit on the edge of your seat type of book, but one to sit back and savor like a fine red wine or a box of chocolates (or both!!). As always with Chadwick's books, the way she brings the medieval period to life in such a graceful and effortless way, be it the sights, sounds, smells, food, clothes and battles is just awesome. As quoted on some of her book jackets, the next best thing to time travel. 4.5/5 stars.

History Brought to Life, 04 Oct 2008
Elizabeth Chadwick's superb new novel, The Time of Singing, details the life of Roger Bigod, Earl of Norfolk during the time of Henry II and his sons. Chadwick's ability to bring history to life is never more apparent than it is in this illustrious depiction of the political and human world of medieval England.

Bigod, who was a companion of William Marshal, the subject of two of Chadwick's earlier novels, is first found as a young man who defies his father's rebellion and must come to terms with the type of man he will be. Bigod must constantly walk a narrow path in order to receive what is rightfully his, and the family drama of fighting for the inheritance follows him throughout his life. Interwoven in Roger's story is that of his wife, Ida, who was once the reluctant mistress of Henry II, and whose love and support provide Bigod with the stability he didn't experience early on in life. Chadwick expertly weaves fact into fiction as we see how Roger and Ida overcome the obstacles of the turbulent times in which they lived.

Once again, Elizabeth Chadwick has given us an outstanding glimpse into the lives of actual people who lived so long ago. The writing is engrossing and the plot is well paced. I could easily envision all the characters and events, and as usual, I was sad to let go of my medieval friends when I closed the last page. Storytelling at its finest! Highly, highly recommended.

A Place Beyond Courage, 16 Oct 2008
This is the third book I have read by Elizabeth Chadwick, the others being 'The Greatest Knight' and 'The Scarlet Lion', and I can say this is the best yet. Chadwick does for English medievel history what Wilbur Smith has done for colonial africa - educate. Highly Recommended.


Another fabulous tale!, 05 May 2008
I know when I pick up a book written by Elizabeth Chadwick I'll be in for a treat and A Place Beyond Courage is no exception.
This story, based on a real figure in history, is full and evolving.
The story sweeps you through one man's life, John FitzGilbert, the Royal Marshal, as he travels the medieval paths of political turmoil, intrigue, love and family, all done with courage and integrity.

This book is a keeper, just as all Elizabeth Chadwick's books are for me.

John FitzGilbert: beyond the `hammers and anvils', 12 Feb 2008
I picked up this novel with some trepidation. How could the father of William Marshal (newly ensconced in my personal gallery of heroes) possibly be as interesting as his son? How could the maker of the infamous `hammers and anvils' speech possibly be a hero? Still, I was confident that if anyone could make this work it would be Elizabeth Chadwick. The painstaking research that made William Marshal come to life for me would surely do the same in respect of his father.

I wasn't disappointed. I didn't expect to like John FitzGilbert as much as I did. But in the process of reading Ms Chadwick's novel I obtained an appreciation, admiration and respect for John that took me by surprise. In this novel, Ms Chadwick managed to make the man himself human without ignoring the apparent cruelty of the `hammers and anvils' speech. I devoured this book in a few short days.

I know the broad history of this period so knew where most of the major turning points were and which directions events would take. But what I did not have, and what Ms Chadwick has so ably infused into the mixture was a sense of the people themselves and the impacts on their lives of the choices they needed to make.

John Marshal doesn't quite displace his son in my gallery of heroes, but he certainly joins him. Thanks, Ms Chadwick, for making another relatively obscure and heroic figure come to life.

Highly recommended to all who love well written medieval fiction.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith


WOW as always!!!!, 01 Feb 2008
I have read almost all of Elizabeth's books and i love each and every one. I feel i'm part of the Marshal family. The women in each book are strong and femine making them a joy to read. This book is lovely and i haven't been able to put it down,to entre the world that Elizabeth creates is always a delight and one of my greatest pleasures.
This book, a cuppa and a bar of choc.....Heaven!!!

A HISTORICAL WINNER, 16 Nov 2007
A PLACE BEYOND COURAGE, continues the remarkable story of the Marshal family. While the superb - The Greatest Knight - gave us the tale of William Marshal, Chadwick, looks back and unearths another defined, singular man; his father John, Marshal to Henry I of England.

John, shrewd (in the best sense of the word), sensible, ambitious, forcible and in no undefined terms both masculine and man of his time, uses his wits and vigor to achieve a successful social rank and respect while laying the groundwork for a dynamic dynasty.

Caught between the enduring battle between Matila and Stephen, John proves adept at meeting both their needs (before handily switching sides) --compromising, only as need be and surely to benefit his own in the end. His marriages play no small part in his life and Chadwick has managed to breathe life into this little known area of the first Marshal's life.

History whisks flawlessly throughout this novel. However,it still has heart without overplaying the romance which the author astutely balances between warrior/diplomat and rough-man-of-his-era-gentleman.

Of a side note: The cover art is stunning. The colors are vibrant and it has a honesty as it conveys the story in a glance. Brilliant!

`You are stronger than you think', 11 Oct 2008
Ms Chadwick's latest novel draws additional historical figures from the shadows of the 12th century and imbues them with vibrant life. Roger Bigod, is the disputed heir to the earldom of Norfolk from approximately 1177. This dispute, which involved Roger's stepmother and stepbrothers, commenced during the reign of Henry II and extended for over a decade before being resolved by Richard I. The dispute brings Roger to court, where he meets Ida de Tosney who is Henry II's young mistress and the mother of his son. Eventually, Ida and Roger marry and while the marriage is a consequence of mutual attraction, it has its costs and burdens.

Ms Chadwick's greatest strength is her ability to combine historical accuracy and characters whose actions can be viewed from a contemporary perspective without any loss of authenticity. This accuracy is important to Ms Chadwick, and it is conveyed to the reader in a way which, while it seems effortless, is a tribute to detailed research. We may not know, with great certainty and at this distance, exactly how Roger and Ida interacted with each other on a personal basis but the novel largely accords with the known facts and provides a fascinating insight into a particularly turbulent time in English history. The medieval code of chivalry carried with it both burdens and costs as well as benefits and privileges.

For me, an added attraction is the links between the Bigods and another of my personal heroes: William Marshal. I was aware of Roger Bigod before reading this novel but not especially interested in him. Now I find that Ms Chadwick has - yet again - introduced me to an historical character about whom I need to know more. Fortunately, I am provided with a select bibliography which gives me a great starting point.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith


Another winner from Chadwick!, 04 Oct 2008
The Time of Singing retells the story of Roger Bigod, son of Hugh Bigod Earl of Norfolk, who joined the younger Henry in his revolt against his father Henry II. When the revolt fails Hugh loses the Earldom and lands and when he dies there is a bitter dispute over the right to inherit the Earldom between Roger and his step-mother and her two sons. While Roger serves Henry and bides his time to claim his Earldom young Ida de Tosney arrives in court as the King's ward. Henry is smitten and has other plans for Ida and he makes her his mistress and she eventually bears him a son, William. Unhappy with her position as mistress to the king, Ida casts her hopes on Roger and Henry allows them to marry -- although she must leave her son behind.

Henry still withholds the Earldom, but he does restore some of their lands and Ida and Roger build a life and family together and begin rebuild Framlingham Castle to greater heights than it was before. Once Richard I takes the crown at the death of Henry the Earldom is restored to Roger, and the rest of the book recounts their lives as they struggle to keep everything they hold dear as the battle lines are drawn during Richard's absence on crusade and subsequent kidnapping threatens to bankrupt England.

A very enjoyable surprise for me was the appearance of my personal favorite hero, William Marshal - I did not expect him at all, or to feature so prominently - but it appears Bigod and Marshal were contemporaries and friends. Another big surprise was Ida's son William - who readers of fiction set during the reigns of John and Henry III will recognize as William Longespée, and I have to admit many of my favorite moments in the book were of William and his attempts at a relationship with his mother, Roger and their children.

While I enjoyed this book very much, this is not an action packed, page turning, sit on the edge of your seat type of book, but one to sit back and savor like a fine red wine or a box of chocolates (or both!!). As always with Chadwick's books, the way she brings the medieval period to life in such a graceful and effortless way, be it the sights, sounds, smells, food, clothes and battles is just awesome. As quoted on some of her book jackets, the next best thing to time travel. 4.5/5 stars.

History Brought to Life, 04 Oct 2008
Elizabeth Chadwick's superb new novel, The Time of Singing, details the life of Roger Bigod, Earl of Norfolk during the time of Henry II and his sons. Chadwick's ability to bring history to life is never more apparent than it is in this illustrious depiction of the political and human world of medieval England.

Bigod, who was a companion of William Marshal, the subject of two of Chadwick's earlier novels, is first found as a young man who defies his father's rebellion and must come to terms with the type of man he will be. Bigod must constantly walk a narrow path in order to receive what is rightfully his, and the family drama of fighting for the inheritance follows him throughout his life. Interwoven in Roger's story is that of his wife, Ida, who was once the reluctant mistress of Henry II, and whose love and support provide Bigod with the stability he didn't experience early on in life. Chadwick expertly weaves fact into fiction as we see how Roger and Ida overcome the obstacles of the turbulent times in which they lived.

Once again, Elizabeth Chadwick has given us an outstanding glimpse into the lives of actual people who lived so long ago. The writing is engrossing and the plot is well paced. I could easily envision all the characters and events, and as usual, I was sad to let go of my medieval friends when I closed the last page. Storytelling at its finest! Highly, highly recommended.

Another new favorite, 09 Nov 2008
This wonderful novel covers the life of William Marshal from when he was a newly-minted knight, up until King Richard returns from crusade and capture in 1194. The title of the novel comes from Archbishop of Canterbury Stephen Langton (1150-1228), who described William Marshal as being "the greatest knight that ever lived." Even if you don't believe Langton's statement, Marshal definitely had a reputation for being courtly, acquired while in the service of Eleanor of Aquitaine and her sons, Henry the Younger, Richard, and John. He also acquired a reputation for his political prowess.

What can I say? I loved this book! Elizabeth Chadwick bit off a lot in telling William Marshal's story, because she could have gotten mired in the details of the complicated politics of the period. Instead, she focused on Marshal's story as it related to those events, which I thought was fantastic. Chadwick's research is meticulous, and her eye for small details makes you fell as though you're actually there experiencing things with William. With regards to the man himself, may I just say that I have not just the slightest crush on him? Chadwick portrays him as courteous, loyal, charismatic, and intelligent (hmmm, maybe the author has a bit of a crush on him herself?). I had to force myself to read The Greatest Knight slowly, because I wanted to take it all in one bit at a time. I enjoyed this book so much that I've already ordered and am anticipating reading the sequel, The Scarlet Lion.

A fabulous way to learn about history!, 14 Jul 2008
I had a great History teacher - but, boy do I wish I'd also had Elizabeth Chadwick to read when I was at school! I love History, but I'd never heard much of William Marshall until I read this book! It inspired me to do my own research into this man, and, crickey! What a hero! Why isn't the life of this great Englishman taught at every school? In "The Greatest Knight", those dark ages from the centuries at the turn of the first millenium come alive and they are peopled with characters you can identify with, who live real lives and have everyday worries which, I have to say, make ours today pale into insignificance. I await each new book of Ms Chadwick's with fevered anticipation, and at the end of each, I am sad to say goodbye to characters I come to regard as friends. If you have a 14 or 15 year old son or daughter who is a reluctant student of History, and you are broad minded enough to not mind the occasional saucy bits (Ooh missus! But not too explicit, I don't think) then let them read these and they will be transported in time, and find a new perspective on stale old studies. Fabulous!

The Greatest Read, 21 Apr 2008
Ive not long read both The Greatest Knight and The Scarlett Lion and I have to say I enjoyed both.The first book is more centered on William Marshal and the latter book on his wife Isabelle,Ive never read a book that ive found myself with tears rolling down my cheeks when its come to an end.A MUST READ.

Planta genista , 02 Apr 2008
I began by reading the second in this series of two books, but before I got too engrossed ordered the first one, and am finding it enthrally and engrossing. I have always liked reading about the Plantagenets and William Marshalls life reads better than a film script, why hasn`t anyone filmed it for the screen,or is it just too good. It seems ages since we saw a good historical film such as Becket, the newer crop of Tudor orientated films are becoming too much. First Henry VIII then Elizabeth, and now the Boleyns. I have lived near to the homes William Marshall lived in, and find Miss Chandwicks` flair for description compelling, you can almost see what she is describing. It promises to be a very good book and so does the follow up The Scarlet Lion.

History coming alive, 05 Mar 2008
Elizabeth Chadwick writes the most fantastic books, I have read most if not all of them but William Marshal I have to say is my favourite charcter. I don't want to spoil the books by saying to much about them but they have a good mix of heros, heroines and of course villains. They are full of facts as well as fiction which are combined well to bring the stories alive. I have introduced my mother to Elizabeth Chadwick books and like me she loved them, but my mother in law did not and could not get past the fisrt chapers.

A Place Beyond Courage, 16 Oct 2008
This is the third book I have read by Elizabeth Chadwick, the others being 'The Greatest Knight' and 'The Scarlet Lion', and I can say this is the best yet. Chadwick does for English medievel history what Wilbur Smith has done for colonial africa - educate. Highly Recommended.


Another fabulous tale!, 05 May 2008
I know when I pick up a book written by Elizabeth Chadwick I'll be in for a treat and A Place Beyond Courage is no exception.
This story, based on a real figure in history, is full and evolving.
The story sweeps you through one man's life, John FitzGilbert, the Royal Marshal, as he travels the medieval paths of political turmoil, intrigue, love and family, all done with courage and integrity.

This book is a keeper, just as all Elizabeth Chadwick's books are for me.

John FitzGilbert: beyond the `hammers and anvils', 12 Feb 2008
I picked up this novel with some trepidation. How could the father of William Marshal (newly ensconced in my personal gallery of heroes) possibly be as interesting as his son? How could the maker of the infamous `hammers and anvils' speech possibly be a hero? Still, I was confident that if anyone could make this work it would be Elizabeth Chadwick. The painstaking research that made William Marshal come to life for me would surely do the same in respect of his father.

I wasn't disappointed. I didn't expect to like John FitzGilbert as much as I did. But in the process of reading Ms Chadwick's novel I obtained an appreciation, admiration and respect for John that took me by surprise. In this novel, Ms Chadwick managed to make the man himself human without ignoring the apparent cruelty of the `hammers and anvils' speech. I devoured this book in a few short days.

I know the broad history of this period so knew where most of the major turning points were and which directions events would take. But what I did not have, and what Ms Chadwick has so ably infused into the mixture was a sense of the people themselves and the impacts on their lives of the choices they needed to make.

John Marshal doesn't quite displace his son in my gallery of heroes, but he certainly joins him. Thanks, Ms Chadwick, for making another relatively obscure and heroic figure come to life.

Highly recommended to all who love well written medieval fiction.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith


WOW as always!!!!, 01 Feb 2008
I have read almost all of Elizabeth's books and i love each and every one. I feel i'm part of the Marshal family. The women in each book are strong and femine making them a joy to read. This book is lovely and i haven't been able to put it down,to entre the world that Elizabeth creates is always a delight and one of my greatest pleasures.
This book, a cuppa and a bar of choc.....Heaven!!!

A HISTORICAL WINNER, 16 Nov 2007
A PLACE BEYOND COURAGE, continues the remarkable story of the Marshal family. While the superb - The Greatest Knight - gave us the tale of William Marshal, Chadwick, looks back and unearths another defined, singular man; his father John, Marshal to Henry I of England.

John, shrewd (in the best sense of the word), sensible, ambitious, forcible and in no undefined terms both masculine and man of his time, uses his wits and vigor to achieve a successful social rank and respect while laying the groundwork for a dynamic dynasty.

Caught between the enduring battle between Matila and Stephen, John proves adept at meeting both their needs (before handily switching sides) --compromising, only as need be and surely to benefit his own in the end. His marriages play no small part in his life and Chadwick has managed to breathe life into this little known area of the first Marshal's life.

History whisks flawlessly throughout this novel. However,it still has heart without overplaying the romance which the author astutely balances between warrior/diplomat and rough-man-of-his-era-gentleman.

Of a side note: The cover art is stunning. The colors are vibrant and it has a honesty as it conveys the story in a glance. Brilliant!

`You are stronger than you think', 11 Oct 2008
Ms Chadwick's latest novel draws additional historical figures from the shadows of the 12th century and imbues them with vibrant life. Roger Bigod, is the disputed heir to the earldom of Norfolk from approximately 1177. This dispute, which involved Roger's stepmother and stepbrothers, commenced during the reign of Henry II and extended for over a decade before being resolved by Richard I. The dispute brings Roger to court, where he meets Ida de Tosney who is Henry II's young mistress and the mother of his son. Eventually, Ida and Roger marry and while the marriage is a consequence of mutual attraction, it has its costs and burdens.

Ms Chadwick's greatest strength is her ability to combine historical accuracy and characters whose actions can be viewed from a contemporary perspective without any loss of authenticity. This accuracy is important to Ms Chadwick, and it is conveyed to the reader in a way which, while it seems effortless, is a tribute to detailed research. We may not know, with great certainty and at this distance, exactly how Roger and Ida interacted with each other on a personal basis but the novel largely accords with the known facts and provides a fascinating insight into a particularly turbulent time in English history. The medieval code of chivalry carried with it both burdens and costs as well as benefits and privileges.

For me, an added attraction is the links between the Bigods and another of my personal heroes: William Marshal. I was aware of Roger Bigod before reading this novel but not especially interested in him. Now I find that Ms Chadwick has - yet again - introduced me to an historical character about whom I need to know more. Fortunately, I am provided with a select bibliography which gives me a great starting point.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith


Another winner from Chadwick!, 04 Oct 2008
The Time of Singing retells the story of Roger Bigod, son of Hugh Bigod Earl of Norfolk, who joined the younger Henry in his revolt against his father Henry II. When the revolt fails Hugh loses the Earldom and lands and when he dies there is a bitter dispute over the right to inherit the Earldom between Roger and his step-mother and her two sons. While Roger serves Henry and bides his time to claim his Earldom young Ida de Tosney arrives in court as the King's ward. Henry is smitten and has other plans for Ida and he makes her his mistress and she eventually bears him a son, William. Unhappy with her position as mistress to the king, Ida casts her hopes on Roger and Henry allows them to marry -- although she must leave her son behind.

Henry still withholds the Earldom, but he does restore some of their lands and Ida and Roger build a life and family together and begin rebuild Framlingham Castle to greater heights than it was before. Once Richard I takes the crown at the death of Henry the Earldom is restored to Roger, and the rest of the book recounts their lives as they struggle to keep everything they hold dear as the battle lines are drawn during Richard's absence on crusade and subsequent kidnapping threatens to bankrupt England.

A very enjoyable surprise for me was the appearance of my personal favorite hero, William Marshal - I did not expect him at all, or to feature so prominently - but it appears Bigod and Marshal were contemporaries and friends. Another big surprise was Ida's son William - who readers of fiction set during the reigns of John and Henry III will recognize as William Longespée, and I have to admit many of my favorite moments in the book were of William and his attempts at a relationship with his mother, Roger and their children.

While I enjoyed this book very much, this is not an action packed, page turning, sit on the edge of your seat type of book, but one to sit back and savor like a fine red wine or a box of chocolates (or both!!). As always with Chadwick's books, the way she brings the medieval period to life in such a graceful and effortless way, be it the sights, sounds, smells, food, clothes and battles is just awesome. As quoted on some of her book jackets, the next best thing to time travel. 4.5/5 stars.

History Brought to Life, 04 Oct 2008
Elizabeth Chadwick's superb new novel, The Time of Singing, details the life of Roger Bigod, Earl of Norfolk during the time of Henry II and his sons. Chadwick's ability to bring history to life is never more apparent than it is in this illustrious depiction of the political and human world of medieval England.

Bigod, who was a companion of William Marshal, the subject of two of Chadwick's earlier novels, is first found as a young man who defies his father's rebellion and must come to terms with the type of man he will be. Bigod must constantly walk a narrow path in order to receive what is rightfully his, and the family drama of fighting for the inheritance follows him throughout his life. Interwoven in Roger's story is that of his wife, Ida, who was once the reluctant mistress of Henry II, and whose love and support provide Bigod with the stability he didn't experience early on in life. Chadwick expertly weaves fact into fiction as we see how Roger and Ida overcome the obstacles of the turbulent times in which they lived.

Once again, Elizabeth Chadwick has given us an outstanding glimpse into the lives of actual people who lived so long ago. The writing is engrossing and the plot is well paced. I could easily envision all the characters and events, and as usual, I was sad to let go of my medieval friends when I closed the last page. Storytelling at its finest! Highly, highly recommended.

Another new favorite, 09 Nov 2008
This wonderful novel covers the life of William Marshal from when he was a newly-minted knight, up until King Richard returns from crusade and capture in 1194. The title of the novel comes from Archbishop of Canterbury Stephen Langton (1150-1228), who described William Marshal as being "the greatest knight that ever lived." Even if you don't believe Langton's statement, Marshal definitely had a reputation for being courtly, acquired while in the service of Eleanor of Aquitaine and her sons, Henry the Younger, Richard, and John. He also acquired a reputation for his political prowess.

What can I say? I loved this book! Elizabeth Chadwick bit off a lot in telling William Marshal's story, because she could have gotten mired in the details of the complicated politics of the period. Instead, she focused on Marshal's story as it related to those events, which I thought was fantastic. Chadwick's research is meticulous, and her eye for small details makes you fell as though you're actually there experiencing things with William. With regards to the man himself, may I just say that I have not just the slightest crush on him? Chadwick portrays him as courteous, loyal, charismatic, and intelligent (hmmm, maybe the author has a bit of a crush on him herself?). I had to force myself to read The Greatest Knight slowly, because I wanted to take it all in one bit at a time. I enjoyed this book so much that I've already ordered and am anticipating reading the sequel, The Scarlet Lion.

A fabulous way to learn about history!, 14 Jul 2008
I had a great History teacher - but, boy do I wish I'd also had Elizabeth Chadwick to read when I was at school! I love History, but I'd never heard much of William Marshall until I read this book! It inspired me to do my own research into this man, and, crickey! What a hero! Why isn't the life of this great Englishman taught at every school? In "The Greatest Knight", those dark ages from the centuries at the turn of the first millenium come alive and they are peopled with characters you can identify with, who live real lives and have everyday worries which, I have to say, make ours today pale into insignificance. I await each new book of Ms Chadwick's with fevered anticipation, and at the end of each, I am sad to say goodbye to characters I come to regard as friends. If you have a 14 or 15 year old son or daughter who is a reluctant student of History, and you are broad minded enough to not mind the occasional saucy bits (Ooh missus! But not too explicit, I don't think) then let them read these and they will be transported in time, and find a new perspective on stale old studies. Fabulous!

The Greatest Read, 21 Apr 2008
Ive not long read both The Greatest Knight and The Scarlett Lion and I have to say I enjoyed both.The first book is more centered on William Marshal and the latter book on his wife Isabelle,Ive never read a book that ive found myself with tears rolling down my cheeks when its come to an end.A MUST READ.

Planta genista , 02 Apr 2008
I began by reading the second in this series of two books, but before I got too engrossed ordered the first one, and am finding it enthrally and engrossing. I have always liked reading about the Plantagenets and William Marshalls life reads better than a film script, why hasn`t anyone filmed it for the screen,or is it just too good. It seems ages since we saw a good historical film such as Becket, the newer crop of Tudor orientated films are becoming too much. First Henry VIII then Elizabeth, and now the Boleyns. I have lived near to the homes William Marshall lived in, and find Miss Chandwicks` flair for description compelling, you can almost see what she is describing. It promises to be a very good book and so does the follow up The Scarlet Lion.

History coming alive, 05 Mar 2008
Elizabeth Chadwick writes the most fantastic books, I have read most if not all of them but William Marshal I have to say is my favourite charcter. I don't want to spoil the books by saying to much about them but they have a good mix of heros, heroines and of course villains. They are full of facts as well as fiction which are combined well to bring the stories alive. I have introduced my mother to Elizabeth Chadwick books and like me she loved them, but my mother in law did not and could not get past the fisrt chapers.

From household knight to Regent of England, 06 Nov 2008
English history is my personal esoteric interest, especially the period of the first Plantagenet monarchs: Henry II, Richard I (the Lionheart), John, and Henry III. Orbiting each of the four at one time or another was England's incomparable, albeit unsung, representative of feudal loyalty, William Marshal, who became 1st Earl of Pembroke. In addition to serving the monarchs mentioned, Marshal also pledged vassalage to Henry II's queen, Eleanor of Aquitaine, and the Young King Henry, the eldest son of Henry II and Eleanor acknowledged and crowned as the heir and future king while his father was still in his prime and ruling. Of course, William pledged his loyal service to only one at a time as honorable circumstance or invitation called upon him to do so, and that occasionally made it a dodgy walk along the precipice considering the notable dysfunctionality of Henry II's family.

The SCARLET LION is Elizabeth Chadwick's sequel to The Greatest Knight: The Story of William Marshal. The book pair is a supremely engaging work of historical fiction about medieval England for any casual or serious student of the time and the 1st Earl of Pembroke.

William was born in 1146 and died at age 73. The forty-three chapters plus Epilogue of THE GREATEST KNIGHT span the period from the summer of 1167, when Marshal was a newly minted young knight in the household of Sir Guillaume de Tancarville, Chamberlain of Normandy and a distant kinsman, to May 1194, when William, accompanied by his heiress wife, Isabelle de Clare, and their two sons and daughter, embark by ship for Normandy with Marshal's lord at the time, King Richard.

The forty-six chapters plus Epilogue of THE SCARLET LION span the period from the summer of 1197, near the end of the Lionheart's reign, to Marshal's death in the spring of 1219.

Each chapter advances the two-volume plot by several months to three years depending on the events of importance in William's life. THE GREATEST KNIGHT comprises his time in Queen Eleanor's retinue, his years in the Young King's household, his touneying days, the Young King's revolt against his father, the Young King's death, his time in Henry II's retinue, Henry's death during the revolt by Richard and John, his marriage to Isabelle, his appointment as a Royal Justiciar by King Richard, John's revolt against Richard during the latter's German imprisonment, Richard's ransom, and Richard's return to England. THE SCARLET LION encompasses the birth of the rest of Marshal's ten children, the death's of Richard and Queen Mother Eleanor, the time William and Isabelle spent in Ireland administering the latter's inherited lands, Marshal's uneasy relationship with King John, Magna Carta and the Baron's Revolt, John's death, William's role as Regent for the boy-king Henry III, and the invasion of England by, and the English defeat of, the French Crown Prince Louis.

The only (minor) criticism I can level is that nothing is written about the terms of the Magna Carta, a traditional and venerable pillar to Anglo-American democracy; an educational opportunity was thus lost.

THE GREATEST KNIGHT and THE SCARLET LION are based on the biography of Marshal's life, the HISTOIRE DE GUILLAUME LE MARECHAL, commissioned by his family soon after his death. Elizabeth Chadwick embellishes those parts of William's life not covered by the HISTOIRE, but in a manner she trusts is consistent with the man's personality and achievements. The two books should perhaps be read as companion pieces to a fine non-fiction narrative, William Marshal: The Flower of Chivalry by Georges Duby, also based on the HISTOIRE.

Chadwick's Marshal duo not only serves as a thoroughly engaging vehicle of reading entertainment, but also as a lesson in the disadvantages of governance by feudalism, which was first and foremost a vertical network of social, military, and legal obligations between members of the nobility on several levels, from lowest knight to King, sometimes even crossing national boundaries. This often resulted in a perilous situation that called for careful stepping. As the reader will see, Marshal managed to survive in the lions' den, and indeed prospered, with his honor intact to become England's preeminent example of integrity and chivalry.

Marshal is buried in London's Temple Church. I regret that I never knew enough to pay my respects at his tomb on any of my many visits to the city. In our age of blemished or non-existent heroes, honor is due.


Wonderful sequel to Greatest Knight, 21 Feb 2008
A fine, action-packed and colourful continuation of the story of William the Marshal. The characters all seem convincingly portrayed and not mere historical ciphers. The ending will have you in tears.

Outstanding Sequel to a Brilliant Novel!, 14 Feb 2008
Unable to wait for the American release, I had to pick up Elizabeth Chadwick's newest novel, The Scarlet Lion, from Amazon.uk as soon as it was available. And I am so glad I did! This is one author who continues to give us quality historical fiction that will leave you breathless and eagerly awaiting her next venture.

Elizabeth Chadwick has given us a gift---the sequel to her outstanding novel, The Greatest Knight. The Scarlet Lion picks up the life of William Marshal, Earl of Pembroke and eventual Regent of England in the early 1200s. To say that this man was more than a mere knight would be an understatement of the first order, and would be a disservice to the writing skills Ms. Chadwick displays so well.

Where should I begin in describing this magnificent novel? Maybe I will start with William's accomplishments, all of which were almost unheard of for someone who had to make his own way in life. Or perhaps I should begin with the cast of characters who populate this tale, among them Richard the Lion Heart, King John of Magna Carta fame, and the young Henry III who was placed in the care of Marshal upon the death of his father. But starting with those would take away the heart of the novel: the uncommon relationship between William and his wife, Isabelle. William, in a time when women were basically chattel, cherished his wife and listened to her counsel. Ms. Chadwick has taken all of these historical facts and woven them into one grand tapestry that brings Marshal to life and inserts him into your heart, mind, and soul. Her research is impeccable, and her gift of phrase will make you want to slow down while reading so as to savor every word.

To those who are lovers of good fiction, this is one of the best and truly deserving of a widespread audience. To those who are lovers of historical fiction, I can say with complete assurance that this will be a book you will treasure forever. Ms. Chadwick's skill in recreating the past pulls you into the story immediately, and won't let you go once you close the book. Highly, highly recommended.


What a fantastic story, 05 Oct 2007
This is the second Elizabeth Chadwick book I have read. Daughters of the Grail was my first and I loved that too. She really is a great writer of a period of history I am not really very conversant with. I do love history but tend to go for the Tudor period onwards as a rule, but am becoming quite hooked on the medieval era thanks to Ms Chadwick. The story of William and Isabelle is great on its own, but it is good to have the information we all know about Kings Richard and John 'padded out' in such an interesting way. Even the day to day lives of these people come alive. I was particularly interested as I live in Gloucester and was fascinated by the bits of the story that took place there and around Tintern Abbey.

Excellent follow-up, 16 Sep 2007
The Greatest Knight is a wonderful book, and this follow-up is equally excellent. My job involves research on old historical texts so I enjoy most those books which bring real events and people alive. Elizabeth Chadwick does this so well, even the detail of daily life rings true. This a great story about abuse of political power. After King John succeeds Richard, he makes life increasingly difficult for William and Isabelle. They try to avoid him by moving to their Irish estate but John holds their sons hostage. Isabelle is an amazing character, and William is easily her match. Chadwick gives them believable life in an excellent story of intrigue and suspense. I loved it.

A Place Beyond Courage, 16 Oct 2008
This is the third book I have read by Elizabeth Chadwick, the others being 'The Greatest Knight' and 'The Scarlet Lion', and I can say this is the best yet. Chadwick does for English medievel history what Wilbur Smith has done for colonial africa - educate. Highly Recommended.


Another fabulous tale!, 05 May 2008
I know when I pick up a book written by Elizabeth Chadwick I'll be in for a treat and A Place Beyond Courage is no exception.
This story, based on a real figure in history, is full and evolving.
The story sweeps you through one man's life, John FitzGilbert, the Royal Marshal, as he travels the medieval paths of political turmoil, intrigue, love and family, all done with courage and integrity.

This book is a keeper, just as all Elizabeth Chadwick's books are for me.

John FitzGilbert: beyond the `hammers and anvils', 12 Feb 2008
I picked up this novel with some trepidation. How could the father of William Marshal (newly ensconced in my personal gallery of heroes) possibly be as interesting as his son? How could the maker of the infamous `hammers and anvils' speech possibly be a hero? Still, I was confident that if anyone could make this work it would be Elizabeth Chadwick. The painstaking research that made William Marshal come to life for me would surely do the same in respect of his father.

I wasn't disappointed. I didn't expect to like John FitzGilbert as much as I did. But in the process of reading Ms Chadwick's novel I obtained an appreciation, admiration and respect for John that took me by surprise. In this novel, Ms Chadwick managed to make the man himself human without ignoring the apparent cruelty of the `hammers and anvils' speech. I devoured this book in a few short days.

I know the broad history of this period so knew where most of the major turning points were and which directions events would take. But what I did not have, and what Ms Chadwick has so ably infused into the mixture was a sense of the people themselves and the impacts on their lives of the choices they needed to make.

John Marshal doesn't quite displace his son in my gallery of heroes, but he certainly joins him. Thanks, Ms Chadwick, for making another relatively obscure and heroic figure come to life.

Highly recommended to all who love well written medieval fiction.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith


WOW as always!!!!, 01 Feb 2008
I have read almost all of Elizabeth's books and i love each and every one. I feel i'm part of the Marshal family. The women in each book are strong and femine making them a joy to read. This book is lovely and i haven't been able to put it down,to entre the world that Elizabeth creates is always a delight and one of my greatest pleasures.
This book, a cuppa and a bar of choc.....Heaven!!!

A HISTORICAL WINNER, 16 Nov 2007
A PLACE BEYOND COURAGE, continues the remarkable story of the Marshal family. While the superb - The Greatest Knight - gave us the tale of William Marshal, Chadwick, looks back and unearths another defined, singular man; his father John, Marshal to Henry I of England.

John, shrewd (in the best sense of the word), sensible, ambitious, forcible and in no undefined terms both masculine and man of his time, uses his wits and vigor to achieve a successful social rank and respect while laying the groundwork for a dynamic dynasty.

Caught between the enduring battle between Matila and Stephen, John proves adept at meeting both their needs (before handily switching sides) --compromising, only as need be and surely to benefit his own in the end. His marriages play no small part in his life and Chadwick has managed to breathe life into this little known area of the first Marshal's life.

History whisks flawlessly throughout this novel. However,it still has heart without overplaying the romance which the author astutely balances between warrior/diplomat and rough-man-of-his-era-gentleman.

Of a side note: The cover art is stunning. The colors are vibrant and it has a honesty as it conveys the story in a glance. Brilliant!

`You are stronger than you think', 11 Oct 2008
Ms Chadwick's latest novel draws additional historical figures from the shadows of the 12th century and imbues them with vibrant life. Roger Bigod, is the disputed heir to the earldom of Norfolk from approximately 1177. This dispute, which involved Roger's stepmother and stepbrothers, commenced during the reign of Henry II and extended for over a decade before being resolved by Richard I. The dispute brings Roger to court, where he meets Ida de Tosney who is Henry II's young mistress and the mother of his son. Eventually, Ida and Roger marry and while the marriage is a consequence of mutual attraction, it has its costs and burdens.

Ms Chadwick's greatest strength is her ability to combine historical accuracy and characters whose actions can be viewed from a contemporary perspective without any loss of authenticity. This accuracy is important to Ms Chadwick, and it is conveyed to the reader in a way which, while it seems effortless, is a tribute to detailed research. We may not know, with great certainty and at this distance, exactly how Roger and Ida interacted with each other on a personal basis but the novel largely accords with the known facts and provides a fascinating insight into a particularly turbulent time in English history. The medieval code of chivalry carried with it both burdens and costs as well as benefits and privileges.

For me, an added attraction is the links between the Bigods and another of my personal heroes: William Marshal. I was aware of Roger Bigod before reading this novel but not especially interested in him. Now I find that Ms Chadwick has - yet again - introduced me to an historical character about whom I need to know more. Fortunately, I am provided with a select bibliography which gives me a great starting point.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith


Another winner from Chadwick!, 04 Oct 2008
The Time of Singing retells the story of Roger Bigod, son of Hugh Bigod Earl of Norfolk, who joined the younger Henry in his revolt against his father Henry II. When the revolt fails Hugh loses the Earldom and lands and when he dies there is a bitter dispute over the right to inherit the Earldom between Roger and his step-mother and her two sons. While Roger serves Henry and bides his time to claim his Earldom young Ida de Tosney arrives in court as the King's ward. Henry is smitten and has other plans for Ida and he makes her his mistress and she eventually bears him a son, William. Unhappy with her position as mistress to the king, Ida casts her hopes on Roger and Henry allows them to marry -- although she must leave her son behind.

Henry still withholds the Earldom, but he does restore some of their lands and Ida and Roger build a life and family together and begin rebuild Framlingham Castle to greater heights than it was before. Once Richard I takes the crown at the death of Henry the Earldom is restored to Roger, and the rest of the book recounts their lives as they struggle to keep everything they hold dear as the battle lines are drawn during Richard's absence on crusade and subsequent kidnapping threatens to bankrupt England.

A very enjoyable surprise for me was the appearance of my personal favorite hero, William Marshal - I did not expect him at all, or to feature so prominently - but it appears Bigod and Marshal were contemporaries and friends. Another big surprise was Ida's son William - who readers of fiction set during the reigns of John and Henry III will recognize as William Longespée, and I have to admit many of my favorite moments in the book were of William and his attempts at a relationship with his mother, Roger and their children.

While I enjoyed this book very much, this is not an action packed, page turning, sit on the edge of your seat type of book, but one to sit back and savor like a fine red wine or a box of chocolates (or both!!). As always with Chadwick's books, the way she brings the medieval period to life in such a graceful and effortless way, be it the sights, sounds, smells, food, clothes and battles is just awesome. As quoted on some of her book jackets, the next best thing to time travel. 4.5/5 stars.

History Brought to Life, 04 Oct 2008
Elizabeth Chadwick's superb new novel, The Time of Singing, details the life of Roger Bigod, Earl of Norfolk during the time of Henry II and his sons. Chadwick's ability to bring history to life is never more apparent than it is in this illustrious depiction of the political and human world of medieval England.

Bigod, who was a companion of William Marshal, the subject of two of Chadwick's earlier novels, is first found as a young man who defies his father's rebellion and must come to terms with the type of man he will be. Bigod must constantly walk a narrow path in order to receive what is rightfully his, and the family drama of fighting for the inheritance follows him throughout his life. Interwoven in Roger's story is that of his wife, Ida, who was once the reluctant mistress of Henry II, and whose love and support provide Bigod with the stability he didn't experience early on in life. Chadwick expertly weaves fact into fiction as we see how Roger and Ida overcome the obstacles of the turbulent times in which they lived.

Once again, Elizabeth Chadwick has given us an outstanding glimpse into the lives of actual people who lived so long ago. The writing is engrossing and the plot is well paced. I could easily envision all the characters and events, and as usual, I was sad to let go of my medieval friends when I closed the last page. Storytelling at its finest! Highly, highly recommended.

Another new favorite, 09 Nov 2008
This wonderful novel covers the life of William Marshal from when he was a newly-minted knight, up until King Richard returns from crusade and capture in 1194. The title of the novel comes from Archbishop of Canterbury Stephen Langton (1150-1228), who described William Marshal as being "the greatest knight that ever lived." Even if you don't believe Langton's statement, Marshal definitely had a reputation for being courtly, acquired while in the service of Eleanor of Aquitaine and her sons, Henry the Younger, Richard, and John. He also acquired a reputation for his political prowess.

What can I say? I loved this book! Elizabeth Chadwick bit off a lot in telling William Marshal's story, because she could have gotten mired in the details of the complicated politics of the period. Instead, she focused on Marshal's story as it related to those events, which I thought was fantastic. Chadwick's research is meticulous, and her eye for small details makes you fell as though you're actually there experiencing things with William. With regards to the man himself, may I just say that I have not just the slightest crush on him? Chadwick portrays him as courteous, loyal, charismatic, and intelligent (hmmm, maybe the author has a bit of a crush on him herself?). I had to force myself to read The Greatest Knight slowly, because I wanted to take it all in one bit at a time. I enjoyed this book so much that I've already ordered and am anticipating reading the sequel, The Scarlet Lion.

A fabulous way to learn about history!, 14 Jul 2008
I had a great History teacher - but, boy do I wish I'd also had Elizabeth Chadwick to read when I was at school! I love History, but I'd never heard much of William Marshall until I read this book! It inspired me to do my own research into this man, and, crickey! What a hero! Why isn't the life of this great Englishman taught at every school? In "The Greatest Knight", those dark ages from the centuries at the turn of the first millenium come alive and they are peopled with characters you can identify with, who live real lives and have everyday worries which, I have to say, make ours today pale into insignificance. I await each new book of Ms Chadwick's with fevered anticipation, and at the end of each, I am sad to say goodbye to characters I come to regard as friends. If you have a 14 or 15 year old son or daughter who is a reluctant student of History, and you are broad minded enough to not mind the occasional saucy bits (Ooh missus! But not too explicit, I don't think) then let them read these and they will be transported in time, and find a new perspective on stale old studies. Fabulous!

The Greatest Read, 21 Apr 2008
Ive not long read both The Greatest Knight and The Scarlett Lion and I have to say I enjoyed both.The first book is more centered on William Marshal and the latter book on his wife Isabelle,Ive never read a book that ive found myself with tears rolling down my cheeks when its come to an end.A MUST READ.

Planta genista , 02 Apr 2008
I began by reading the second in this series of two books, but before I got too engrossed ordered the first one, and am finding it enthrally and engrossing. I have always liked reading about the Plantagenets and William Marshalls life reads better than a film script, why hasn`t anyone filmed it for the screen,or is it just too good. It seems ages since we saw a good historical film such as Becket, the newer crop of Tudor orientated films are becoming too much. First Henry VIII then Elizabeth, and now the Boleyns. I have lived near to the homes William Marshall lived in, and find Miss Chandwicks` flair for description compelling, you can almost see what she is describing. It promises to be a very good book and so does the follow up The Scarlet Lion.

History coming alive, 05 Mar 2008
Elizabeth Chadwick writes the most fantastic books, I have read most if not all of them but William Marshal I have to say is my favourite charcter. I don't want to spoil the books by saying to much about them but they have a good mix of heros, heroines and of course villains. They are full of facts as well as fiction which are combined well to bring the stories alive. I have introduced my mother to Elizabeth Chadwick books and like me she loved them, but my mother in law did not and could not get past the fisrt chapers.

From household knight to Regent of England, 06 Nov 2008
English history is my personal esoteric interest, especially the period of the first Plantagenet monarchs: Henry II, Richard I (the Lionheart), John, and Henry III. Orbiting each of the four at one time or another was England's incomparable, albeit unsung, representative of feudal loyalty, William Marshal, who became 1st Earl of Pembroke. In addition to serving the monarchs mentioned, Marshal also pledged vassalage to Henry II's queen, Eleanor of Aquitaine, and the Young King Henry, the eldest son of Henry II and Eleanor acknowledged and crowned as the heir and future king while his father was still in his prime and ruling. Of course, William pledged his loyal service to only one at a time as honorable circumstance or invitation called upon him to do so, and that occasionally made it a dodgy walk along the precipice considering the notable dysfunctionality of Henry II's family.

The SCARLET LION is Elizabeth Chadwick's sequel to The Greatest Knight: The Story of William Marshal. The book pair is a supremely engaging work of historical fiction about medieval England for any casual or serious student of the time and the 1st Earl of Pembroke.

William was born in 1146 and died at age 73. The forty-three chapters plus Epilogue of THE GREATEST KNIGHT span the period from the summer of 1167, when Marshal was a newly minted young knight in the household of Sir Guillaume de Tancarville, Chamberlain of Normandy and a distant kinsman, to May 1194, when William, accompanied by his heiress wife, Isabelle de Clare, and their two sons and daughter, embark by ship for Normandy with Marshal's lord at the time, King Richard.

The forty-six chapters plus Epilogue of THE SCARLET LION span the period from the summer of 1197, near the end of the Lionheart's reign, to Marshal's death in the spring of 1219.

Each chapter advances the two-volume plot by several months to three years depending on the events of importance in William's life. THE GREATEST KNIGHT comprises his time in Queen Eleanor's retinue, his years in the Young King's household, his touneying days, the Young King's revolt against his father, the Young King's death, his time in Henry II's retinue, Henry's death during the revolt by Richard and John, his marriage to Isabelle, his appointment as a Royal Justiciar by King Richard, John's revolt against Richard during the latter's German imprisonment, Richard's ransom, and Richard's return to England. THE SCARLET LION encompasses the birth of the rest of Marshal's ten children, the death's of Richard and Queen Mother Eleanor, the time William and Isabelle spent in Ireland administering the latter's inherited lands, Marshal's uneasy relationship with King John, Magna Carta and the Baron's Revolt, John's death, William's role as Regent for the boy-king Henry III, and the invasion of England by, and the English defeat of, the French Crown Prince Louis.

The only (minor) criticism I can level is that nothing is written about the terms of the Magna Carta, a traditional and venerable pillar to Anglo-American democracy; an educational opportunity was thus lost.

THE GREATEST KNIGHT and THE SCARLET LION are based on the biography of Marshal's life, the HISTOIRE DE GUILLAUME LE MARECHAL, commissioned by his family soon after his death. Elizabeth Chadwick embellishes those parts of William's life not covered by the HISTOIRE, but in a manner she trusts is consistent with the man's personality and achievements. The two books should perhaps be read as companion pieces to a fine non-fiction narrative, William Marshal: The Flower of Chivalry by Georges Duby, also based on the HISTOIRE.

Chadwick's Marshal duo not only serves as a thoroughly engaging vehicle of reading entertainment, but also as a lesson in the disadvantages of governance by feudalism, which was first and foremost a vertical network of social, military, and legal obligations between members of the nobility on several levels, from lowest knight to King, sometimes even crossing national boundaries. This often resulted in a perilous situation that called for careful stepping. As the reader will see, Marshal managed to survive in the lions' den, and indeed prospered, with his honor intact to become England's preeminent example of integrity and chivalry.

Marshal is buried in London's Temple Church. I regret that I never knew enough to pay my respects at his tomb on any of my many visits to the city. In our age of blemished or non-existent heroes, honor is due.


Wonderful sequel to Greatest Knight, 21 Feb 2008
A fine, action-packed and colourful continuation of the story of William the Marshal. The characters all seem convincingly portrayed and not mere historical ciphers. The ending will have you in tears.

Outstanding Sequel to a Brilliant Novel!, 14 Feb 2008
Unable to wait for the American release, I had to pick up Elizabeth Chadwick's newest novel, The Scarlet Lion, from Amazon.uk as soon as it was available. And I am so glad I did! This is one author who continues to give us quality historical fiction that will leave you breathless and eagerly awaiting her next venture.

Elizabeth Chadwick has given us a gift---the sequel to her outstanding novel, The Greatest Knight. The Scarlet Lion picks up the life of William Marshal, Earl of Pembroke and eventual Regent of England in the early 1200s. To say that this man was more than a mere knight would be an understatement of the first order, and would be a disservice to the writing skills Ms. Chadwick displays so well.

Where should I begin in describing this magnificent novel? Maybe I will start with William's accomplishments, all of which were almost unheard of for someone who had to make his own way in life. Or perhaps I should begin with the cast of characters who populate this tale, among them Richard the Lion Heart, King John of Magna Carta fame, and the young Henry III who was placed in the care of Marshal upon the death of his father. But starting with those would take away the heart of the novel: the uncommon relationship between William and his wife, Isabelle. William, in a time when women were basically chattel, cherished his wife and listened to her counsel. Ms. Chadwick has taken all of these historical facts and woven them into one grand tapestry that brings Marshal to life and inserts him into your heart, mind, and soul. Her research is impeccable, and her gift of phrase will make you want to slow down while reading so as to savor every word.

To those who are lovers of good fiction, this is one of the best and truly deserving of a widespread audience. To those who are lovers of historical fiction, I can say with complete assurance that this will be a book you will treasure forever. Ms. Chadwick's skill in recreating the past pulls you into the story immediately, and won't let you go once you close the book. Highly, highly recommended.


What a fantastic story, 05 Oct 2007
This is the second Elizabeth Chadwick book I have read. Daughters of the Grail was my first and I loved that too. She really is a great writer of a period of history I am not really very conversant with. I do love history but tend to go for the Tudor period onwards as a rule, but am becoming quite hooked on the medieval era thanks to Ms Chadwick. The story of William and Isabelle is great on its own, but it is good to have the information we all know about Kings Richard and John 'padded out' in such an interesting way. Even the day to day lives of these people come alive. I was particularly interested as I live in Gloucester and was fascinated by the bits of the story that took place there and around Tintern Abbey.

Excellent follow-up, 16 Sep 2007
The Greatest Knight is a wonderful book, and this follow-up is equally excellent. My job involves research on old historical texts so I enjoy most those books which bring real events and people alive. Elizabeth Chadwick does this so well, even the detail of daily life rings true. This a great story about abuse of political power. After King John succeeds Richard, he makes life increasingly difficult for William and Isabelle. They try to avoid him by moving to their Irish estate but John holds their sons hostage. Isabelle is an amazing character, and William is easily her match. Chadwick gives them believable life in an excellent story of intrigue and suspense. I loved it.

Great Read, 08 Jul 2008
Since I read this book, I have often thought of Whittington as I know the area quite well - the ruins of the castle are still there and that's what makes this a great book - that it is based on a true story.
It's well written and transports you to the time and place in a wonderful way. The characters are believable and the historical research for them must have been considerable.
It is the first of Chadwick's book I have read and I shall certainly read her others.

Making the legends of Robin Hood look dull!!, 30 Mar 2008
Im a great reader of Elizabeth Chadwick and enjoy the escapism and feel for period each one gives. I would say that Lords of the White Castle is her finest work to date. Fulke Fitz Warin is a real historical character who truly deserves his fascinating story to be told. This true story of an outlaw during King Johns reign will really appeal to those who enjoy the Robin Hood legends as it captures the very essence minus cheese. Its romantic, exciting, accurate and un put downable, and as an added bonus it features "The greatest Knight" William Marshal having both Historical heros in one book makes it perfect.

OUTSTANDING!, 06 Jul 2007
Once again, this author has swept me away for a weekend in another time. It's just like being there -- plus a history lesson too. I have to wonder if these real life characters were the basis of the Robin Hood legends. We'll never know.

It was especially fun to read a bit about Llewyllen (sp??) the great, as I had just finished Sharon Kay Penman's Welsh trilogy.

If you enjoy historical fiction, then you cannot go wrong with Elizabeth Chadwick.

Good read, a little too long., 03 Oct 2006
After having read "Shadows and Strongholds" and thoroughly enjoyed it, I had high expectations from its sequel (which was actually written before S&S). It certainly is another great story, although Chadwick is at times not as captivating as usual. I feel that perhaps the book would have benefited from cutting out about a hundred pages after ...

(!!! BEGINNING OF SPOILER !!!) ... the king finally awards them Whittington. (!!! END OF SPOILER !!!)

The book is certainly chunky enough, so cutting out 100 pages should still leave a fairly sizable book. Even so, it was an enjoyable read, although I would recommend "Shadows and Strongholds" to first-time Chadwick readers.

A Place Beyond Courage, 16 Oct 2008
This is the third book I have read by Elizabeth Chadwick, the others being 'The Greatest Knight' and 'The Scarlet Lion', and I can say this is the best yet. Chadwick does for English medievel history what Wilbur Smith has done for colonial africa - educate. Highly Recommended.


Another fabulous tale!, 05 May 2008
I know when I pick up a book written by Elizabeth Chadwick I'll be in for a treat and A Place Beyond Courage is no exception.
This story, based on a real figure in history, is full and evolving.
The story sweeps you through one man's life, John FitzGilbert, the Royal Marshal, as he travels the medieval paths of political turmoil, intrigue, love and family, all done with courage and integrity.

This book is a keeper, just as all Elizabeth Chadwick's books are for me.

John FitzGilbert: beyond the `hammers and anvils', 12 Feb 2008
I picked up this novel with some trepidation. How could the father of William Marshal (newly ensconced in my personal gallery of heroes) possibly be as interesting as his son? How could the maker of the infamous `hammers and anvils' speech possibly be a hero? Still, I was confident that if anyone could make this work it would be Elizabeth Chadwick. The painstaking research that made William Marshal come to life for me would surely do the same in respect of his father.

I wasn't disappointed. I didn't expect to like John FitzGilbert as much as I did. But in the process of reading Ms Chadwick's novel I obtained an appreciation, admiration and respect for John that took me by surprise. In this novel, Ms Chadwick managed to make the man himself human without ignoring the apparent cruelty of the `hammers and anvils' speech. I devoured this book in a few short days.

I know the broad history of this period so knew where most of the major turning points were and which directions events would take. But what I did not have, and what Ms Chadwick has so ably infused into the mixture was a sense of the people themselves and the impacts on their lives of the choices they needed to make.

John Marshal doesn't quite displace his son in my gallery of heroes, but he certainly joins him. Thanks, Ms Chadwick, for making another relatively obscure and heroic figure come to life.

Highly recommended to all who love well written medieval fiction.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith


WOW as always!!!!, 01 Feb 2008
I have read almost all of Elizabeth's books and i love each and every one. I feel i'm part of the Marshal family. The women in each book are strong and femine making them a joy to read. This book is lovely and i haven't been able to put it down,to entre the world that Elizabeth creates is always a delight and one of my greatest pleasures.
This book, a cuppa and a bar of choc.....Heaven!!!

A HISTORICAL WINNER, 16 Nov 2007
A PLACE BEYOND COURAGE, continues the remarkable story of the Marshal family. While the superb - The Greatest Knight - gave us the tale of William Marshal, Chadwick, looks back and unearths another defined, singular man; his father John, Marshal to Henry I of England.

John, shrewd (in the best sense of the word), sensible, ambitious, forcible and in no undefined terms both masculine and man of his time, uses his wits and vigor to achieve a successful social rank and respect while laying the groundwork for a dynamic dynasty.

Caught between the enduring battle between Matila and Stephen, John proves adept at meeting both their needs (before handily switching sides) --compromising, only as need be and surely to benefit his own in the end. His marriages play no small part in his life and Chadwick has managed to breathe life into this little known area of the first Marshal's life.

History whisks flawlessly throughout this novel. However,it still has heart without overplaying the romance which the author astutely balances between warrior/diplomat and rough-man-of-his-era-gentleman.

Of a side note: The cover art is stunning. The colors are vibrant and it has a honesty as it conveys the story in a glance. Brilliant!

`You are stronger than you think', 11 Oct 2008
Ms Chadwick's latest novel draws additional historical figures from the shadows of the 12th century and imbues them with vibrant life. Roger Bigod, is the disputed heir to the earldom of Norfolk from approximately 1177. This dispute, which involved Roger's stepmother and stepbrothers, commenced during the reign of Henry II and extended for over a decade before being resolved by Richard I. The dispute brings Roger to court, where he meets Ida de Tosney who is Henry II's young mistress and the mother of his son. Eventually, Ida and Roger marry and while the marriage is a consequence of mutual attraction, it has its costs and burdens.

Ms Chadwick's greatest strength is her ability to combine historical accuracy and characters whose actions can be viewed from a contemporary perspective without any loss of authenticity. This accuracy is important to Ms Chadwick, and it is conveyed to the reader in a way which, while it seems effortless, is a tribute to detailed research. We may not know, with great certainty and at this distance, exactly how Roger and Ida interacted with each other on a personal basis but the novel largely accords with the known facts and provides a fascinating insight into a particularly turbulent time in English history. The medieval code of chivalry carried with it both burdens and costs as well as benefits and privileges.

For me, an added attraction is the links between the Bigods and another of my personal heroes: William Marshal. I was aware of Roger Bigod before reading this novel but not especially interested in him. Now I find that Ms Chadwick has - yet again - introduced me to an historical character about whom I need to know more. Fortunately, I am provided with a select bibliography which gives me a great starting point.

Jennifer Cameron-Smith


Another winner from Chadwick!, 04 Oct 2008
The Time of Singing retells the story of Roger Bigod, son of Hugh Bigod Earl of Norfolk, who joined the younger Henry in his revolt against his father Henry II. When the revolt fails Hugh loses the Earldom and lands and when he dies there is a bitter dispute over the right to inherit the Earldom between Roger and his step-mother and her two sons. While Roger serves Henry and bides his time to claim his Earldom young Ida de Tosney arrives in court as the King's ward. Henry is smitten and has other plans for Ida and he makes her his mistress and she eventually bears him a son, William. Unhappy with her position as mistress to the king, Ida casts her hopes on Roger and Henry allows them to marry -- although she must leave her son behind.

Henry still withholds the Earldom, but he does restore some of their lands and Ida and Roger build a life and family together and begin rebuild Framlingham Castle to greater heights than it was before. Once Richard I takes the crown at the death of Henry the Earldom is restored to Roger, and the rest of the book recounts their lives as they struggle to keep everything they hold dear as the battle lines are drawn during Richard's absence on crusade and subsequent kidnapping threatens to bankrupt England.

A very enjoyable surprise for me was the appearance of my personal favorite hero, William Marshal - I did not expect him at all, or to feature so prominently - but it appears Bigod and Marshal were contemporaries and friends. Another big surprise was Ida's son William - who readers of fiction set during the reigns of John and Henry III will recognize as William Longespée, and I have to admit many of my favorite moments in the book were of William and his attempts at a relationship with his mother, Roger and their children.

While I enjoyed this book very much, this is not an action packed, page turning, sit on the edge of your seat type of book, but one to sit back and savor like a fine red wine or a box of chocolates (or both!!). As always with Chadwick's books, the way she brings the medieval period to life in such a graceful and effortless way, be it the sights, sounds, smells, food, clothes and battles is just awesome. As quoted on some of her book jackets, the next best thing to time travel. 4.5/5 stars.

History Brought to Life, 04 Oct 2008
Elizabeth Chadwick's superb new novel, The Time of Singing, details the life of Roger Bigod, Earl of Norfolk during the time of Henry II and his sons. Chadwick's ability to bring history to life is never more apparent than it is in this illustrious depiction of the political and human world of medieval England.

Bigod, who was a companion of William Marshal, the subject of two of Chadwick's earlier novels, is first found as a young man who defies his father's rebellion and must come to terms with the type of man he will be. Bigod must constantly walk a narrow path in order to receive what is rightfully his, and the family drama of fighting for the inheritance follows him throughout his life. Interwoven in Roger's story is that of his wife, Ida, who was once the reluctant mistress of Henry II, and whose love and support provide Bigod with the stability he didn't experience early on in life. Chadwick expertly weaves fact into fiction as we see how Roger and Ida overcome the obstacles of the turbulent times in which they lived.

Once again, Elizabeth Chadwick has given us an outstanding glimpse into the lives of actual people who lived so long ago. The writing is engrossing and the plot is well paced. I could easily envision all the characters and events, and as usual, I was sad to let go of my medieval friends when I closed the last page. Storytelling at its finest! Highly, highly recommended.

Another new favorite, 09 Nov 2008
This wonderful novel covers the life of William Marshal from when he was a newly-minted knight, up until King Richard returns from crusade and capture in 1194. The title of the novel comes from Archbishop of Canterbury Stephen Langton (1150-1228), who described William Marshal as being "the greatest knight that ever lived." Even if you don't believe Langton's statement, Marshal definitely had a reputation for being courtly, acquired while in the service of Eleanor of Aquitaine and her sons, Henry the Younger, Richard, and John. He also acquired a reputation for his political prowess.

What can I say? I loved this book! Elizabeth Chadwick bit off a lot in telling William Marshal's story, because she could have gotten mired in the details of the complicated politics of the period. Instead, she focused on Marshal's story as it related to those events, which I thought was fantastic. Chadwick's research is meticulous, and her eye for small details makes you fell as though you're actually there experiencing things with William. With regards to the man himself, may I just say that I have not just the slightest crush on him? Chadwick portrays him as courteous, loyal, charismatic, and intelligent (hmmm, maybe the author has a bit of a crush on him herself?). I had to force myself to read The Greatest Knight slowly, because I wanted to take it all in one bit at a time. I enjoyed this book so much that I've already ordered and am anticipating reading the sequel, The Scarlet Lion.

A fabulous way to learn about history!, 14 Jul 2008
I had a great History teacher - but, boy do I wish I'd also had Elizabeth Chadwick to read when I was at school! I love History, but I'd never heard much of William Marshall until I read this book! It inspired me to do my own research into this man, and, crickey! What a hero! Why isn't the life of this great Englishman taught at every school? In "The Greatest Knight", those dark ages from the centuries at the turn of the first millenium come alive and they are peopled with characters you can identify with, who live real lives and have everyday worries which, I have to say, make ours today pale into insignificance. I await each new book of Ms Chadwick's with fevered anticipation, and at the end of each, I am sad to say goodbye to characters I come to regard as friends. If you have a 14 or 15 year old son or daughter who is a reluctant student of History, and you are broad minded enough to not mind the occasional saucy bits (Ooh missus! But not too explicit, I don't think) then let them read these and they will be transported in time, and find a new perspective on stale old studies. Fabulous!

The Greatest Read, 21 Apr 2008
Ive not long read both The Greatest Knight and The Scarlett Lion and I have to say I enjoyed both.The first book is more centered on William Marshal and the latter book on his wife Isabelle,Ive never read a book that ive found myself with tears rolling down my cheeks when its come to an end.A MUST READ.

Planta genista , 02 Apr 2008
I began by reading the second in this series of two books, but before I got too engrossed ordered the first one, and am finding it enthrally and engrossing. I have always liked reading about the Plantagenets and William Marshalls life reads better than a film script, why hasn`t anyone filmed it for the screen,or is it just too good. It seems ages since we saw a good historical film such as Becket, the newer crop of Tudor orientated films are becoming too much. First Henry VIII then Elizabeth, and now the Boleyns. I have lived near to the homes William Marshall lived in, and find Miss Chandwicks` flair for description compelling, you can almost see what she is describing. It promises to be a very good book and so does the follow up The Scarlet Lion.

History coming alive, 05 Mar 2008
Elizabeth Chadwick writes the most fantastic books, I have read most if not all of them but William Marshal I have to say is my favourite charcter. I don't want to spoil the books by saying to much about them but they have a good mix of heros, heroines and of course villains. They are full of facts as well as fiction which are combined well to bring the stories alive. I have introduced my mother to Elizabeth Chadwick books and like me she loved them, but my mother in law did not and could not get past the fisrt chapers.

From household knight to Regent of England, 06 Nov 2008
English history is my personal esoteric interest, especially the period of the first Plantagenet monarchs: Henry II, Richard I (the Lionheart), John, and Henry III. Orbiting each of the four at one time or another was England's incomparable, albeit unsung, representative of feudal loyalty, William Marshal, who became 1st Earl of Pembroke. In addition to serving the monarchs mentioned, Marshal also pledged vassalage to Henry II's queen, Eleanor of Aquitaine, and the Young King Henry, the eldest son of Henry II and Eleanor acknowledged and crowned as the heir and future king while his father was still in his prime and ruling. Of course, William pledged his loyal service to only one at a time as honorable circumstance or invitation called upon him to do so, and that occasionally made it a dodgy walk along the precipice considering the notable dysfunctionality of Henry II's family.

The SCARLET LION is Elizabeth Chadwick's sequel to The Greatest Knight: The Story of William Marshal. The book pair is a supremely engaging work of historical fiction about medieval England for any casual or serious student of the time and the 1st Earl of Pembroke.

William was born in 1146 and died at age 73. The forty-three chapters plus Epilogue of THE GREATEST KNIGHT span the period from the summer of 1167, when Marshal was a newly minted young knight in the household of Sir Guillaume de Tancarville, Chamberlain of Normandy and a distant kinsman, to May 1194, when William, accompanied by his heiress wife, Isabelle de Clare, and their two sons and daughter, embark by ship for Normandy with Marshal's lord at the time, King Richard.

The forty-six chapters plus Epilogue of THE SCARLET LION span the period from the summer of 1197, near the end of the Lionheart's reign, to Marshal's death in the spring of 1219.

Each chapter advances the two-volume plot by several months to three years depending on the events of importance in William's life. THE GREATEST KNIGHT comprises his time in Queen Eleanor's retinue, his years in the Young King's household, his touneying days, the Young King's revolt against his father, the Young King's death, his time in Henry II's retinue, Henry's death during the revolt by Richard and John, his marriage to Isabelle, his appointment as a Royal Justiciar by King Richard, John's revolt against Richard during the latter's German imprisonment, Richard's ransom, and Richard's return to England. THE SCARLET LION encompasses the birth of the rest of Marshal's ten children, the death's of Richard and Queen Mother Eleanor, the time William and Isabelle spent in Ireland administering the latter's inherited lands, Marshal's uneasy relationship with King John, Magna Carta and the Baron's Revolt, John's death, William's role as Regent for the boy-king Henry III, and the invasion of England by, and the English defeat of, the French Crown Prince Louis.

The only (minor) criticism I can level is that nothing is written about the terms of the Magna Carta, a traditional and venerable pillar to Anglo-American democracy; an educational opportunity was thus lost.

THE GREATEST KNIGHT and THE SCARLET LION are based on the biography of Marshal's life, the HISTOIRE DE GUILLAUME LE MARECHAL, commissioned by his family soon after his death. Elizabeth Chadwick embellishes those parts of William's life not covered by the HISTOIRE, but in a manner she trusts is consistent with the man's personality and achievements. The two books should perhaps be read as companion pieces to a fine non-fiction narrative, William Marshal: The Flower of Chivalry by Georges Duby, also based on the HISTOIRE.

Chadwick's Marshal duo not only serves as a thoroughly engaging vehicle of reading entertainment, but also as a lesson in the disadvantages of governance by feudalism, which was first and foremost a vertical network of social, military, and legal obligations between members of the nobility on several levels, from lowest knight to King, sometimes even crossing national boundaries. This often resulted in a perilous situation that called for careful stepping. As the reader will see, Marshal managed to survive in the lions' den, and indeed prospered, with his honor intact to become England's preeminent example of integrity and chivalry.

Marshal is buried in London's Temple Church. I regret that I never knew enough to pay my respects at his tomb on any of my many visits to the city. In our age of blemished or non-existent heroes, honor is due.


Wonderful sequel to Greatest Knight, 21 Feb 2008
A fine, action-packed and colourful continuation of the story of William the Marshal. The characters all seem convincingly portrayed and not mere historical ciphers. The ending will have you in tears.

Outstanding Sequel to a Brilliant Novel!, 14 Feb 2008
Unable to wait for the American release, I had to pick up Elizabeth Chadwick's newest novel, The Scarlet Lion, from Amazon.uk as soon as it was available. And I am so glad I did! This is one author who continues to give us quality historical fiction that will leave you breathless and eagerly awaiting her next venture.

Elizabeth Chadwick has given us a gift---the sequel to her outstanding novel, The Greatest Knight. The Scarlet Lion picks up the life of William Marshal, Earl of Pembroke and eventual Regent of England in the early 1200s. To say that this man was more than a mere knight would be an understatement of the first order, and would be a disservice to the writing skills Ms. Chadwick displays so well.

Where should I begin in describing this magnificent novel? Maybe I will start with William's accomplishments, all of which were almost unheard of for someone who had to make his own way in life. Or perhaps I should begin with the cast of characters who populate this tale, among them Richard the Lion Heart, King John of Magna Carta fame, and the young Henry III who was placed in the care of Marshal upon the death of his father. But starting with those would take away the heart of the novel: the uncommon relationship between William and his wife, Isabelle. William, in a time when women were basically chattel, cherished his wife and listened to her counsel. Ms. Chadwick has taken all of these historical facts and woven them into one grand tapestry that brings Marshal to life and inserts him into your heart, mind, and soul. Her research is impeccable, and her gift of phrase will make you want to slow down while reading so as to savor every word.

To those who are lovers of good fiction, this is one of the best and truly deserving of a widespread audience. To those who are lovers of historical fiction, I can say with complete assurance that this will be a book you will treasure forever. Ms. Chadwick's skill in recreating the past pulls you into the story immediately, and won't let you go once you close the book. Highly, highly recommended.


What a fantastic story, 05 Oct 2007
This is the second Elizabeth Chadwick book I have read. Daughters of the Grail was my first and I loved that too. She really is a great writer of a period of history I am not really very conversant with. I do love history but tend to go for the Tudor period onwards as a rule, but am becoming quite hooked on the medieval era thanks to Ms Chadwick. The story of William and Isabelle is great on its own, but it is good to have the information we all know about Kings Richard and John 'padded out' in such an interesting way. Even the day to day lives of these people come alive. I was particularly interested as I live in Gloucester and was fascinated by the bits of the story that took place there and around Tintern Abbey.

Excellent follow-up, 16 Sep 2007
The Greatest Knight is a wonderf