what a shame, 11 Nov 2008
I love Wilbur smith's books, but this one fell far short of his previous novels. it was far too magical, and far far too far fetched. his strenghts lie in wonderful descriptions of wildlife, hunting and detailed characters. however this book was honestly a pile of nonesense, and i will now hesitate before i purchase my next Wilbur Smith book...

well it passed the time, 09 Nov 2008
Luckily I had read 'River God' etc so long ago so as not to spoil my memories of them, and luckily I only spent a small amount on this book in a charity shop. I happened to be in Egypt on holiday when I read it, so the setting suited mine, and it passed the time on the sun bed and on the plane going home!

I like fantasy, but this seems to be merely the tacky ramblings of an old man, and has nothing whatsoever to do with genuine ancient Egyptian mythology. If things got slow in the endless journeying he just chucked in another battle with another random tribe and even this got boring after a while.

And as for the ending, well really! 'Indiana Potter and the Stem Cell Researchers of Doom'!
So our hero rides off into the sunset with new bits and a new body, and I have a horrible suspicion it might take another book to go and regenerate his woman too - so be warned!
All in all a sad slump for this author.

Taitas Quest or Wilburs?, 25 Oct 2008
I have read all the Wilbur Smith books and have been an avid fan. This one is such a disappointment. The sexual content I found most uncomfortable as the main character an old eunuch lusts after a young girl and strives to restore his lost manhood so that eventually he is able to enjoy a full relationship with the girl. The addition of magic and fantasy to a series that has always had a strong believable streak made me feel I was reading a triple XXX version of Harry Potter. If you are new to Wilbur Smith dont be put off by this one. The others are great reads.

Dreadful, 20 Oct 2008
Avoid this book. It's the most contrived, self-indulgent rubbish I've ever read, and I say that as an avid Clive Cussler fan (!).

a rotten end to a great series of books, 09 Oct 2008
I've read many of WS's books and usually love them. I was looking forward to this, the 4th Taita book and really enjoyed it up until they journey to "Shangri La" and apes are acting as bouncers in the tunnel. Then as I read that Meren's eye is about to be regrown from stem cells, I got completely fed up with the story. Then Taita's penis is regrown and of course, it's much bigger, heavier and better than his original. His love for Fenn who has not yet had her 1st period is a bit pervy as is his move on her once she has! Oh, and then he gets reborn as a 30 year old man - its just gets sillier and sillier - SHAME ON YOU, W.S. This is a sad and crappy end to the wonderful series

what a shame, 11 Nov 2008
I love Wilbur smith's books, but this one fell far short of his previous novels. it was far too magical, and far far too far fetched. his strenghts lie in wonderful descriptions of wildlife, hunting and detailed characters. however this book was honestly a pile of nonesense, and i will now hesitate before i purchase my next Wilbur Smith book...

well it passed the time, 09 Nov 2008
Luckily I had read 'River God' etc so long ago so as not to spoil my memories of them, and luckily I only spent a small amount on this book in a charity shop. I happened to be in Egypt on holiday when I read it, so the setting suited mine, and it passed the time on the sun bed and on the plane going home!

I like fantasy, but this seems to be merely the tacky ramblings of an old man, and has nothing whatsoever to do with genuine ancient Egyptian mythology. If things got slow in the endless journeying he just chucked in another battle with another random tribe and even this got boring after a while.

And as for the ending, well really! 'Indiana Potter and the Stem Cell Researchers of Doom'!
So our hero rides off into the sunset with new bits and a new body, and I have a horrible suspicion it might take another book to go and regenerate his woman too - so be warned!
All in all a sad slump for this author.

Taitas Quest or Wilburs?, 25 Oct 2008
I have read all the Wilbur Smith books and have been an avid fan. This one is such a disappointment. The sexual content I found most uncomfortable as the main character an old eunuch lusts after a young girl and strives to restore his lost manhood so that eventually he is able to enjoy a full relationship with the girl. The addition of magic and fantasy to a series that has always had a strong believable streak made me feel I was reading a triple XXX version of Harry Potter. If you are new to Wilbur Smith dont be put off by this one. The others are great reads.

Dreadful, 20 Oct 2008
Avoid this book. It's the most contrived, self-indulgent rubbish I've ever read, and I say that as an avid Clive Cussler fan (!).

a rotten end to a great series of books, 09 Oct 2008
I've read many of WS's books and usually love them. I was looking forward to this, the 4th Taita book and really enjoyed it up until they journey to "Shangri La" and apes are acting as bouncers in the tunnel. Then as I read that Meren's eye is about to be regrown from stem cells, I got completely fed up with the story. Then Taita's penis is regrown and of course, it's much bigger, heavier and better than his original. His love for Fenn who has not yet had her 1st period is a bit pervy as is his move on her once she has! Oh, and then he gets reborn as a 30 year old man - its just gets sillier and sillier - SHAME ON YOU, W.S. This is a sad and crappy end to the wonderful series

River god,Brilliant, 10 Oct 2008
Someone lent me this book to read because they liked it,it was the start of a long long reading experience, I just couldn't put it down and I ended up reading the whole series.Anyone who doesn't like it must lack imagination of this epic story.Totally loved it.

One of my favourite books of all time, 28 Aug 2008
A cleverly written book that will make you think you're reading fact not fiction. The real life settings supported by the obvious extensive research that the author has undertaken.

Read this then read "The Seventh Scroll". Truly enchanting and gripping stuff!

Enthralling, 06 Jun 2008
I returned from a Nile Cruise captivated by the history of Egypt and someone leant me a copy of The Quest. On examination I discovered that this was the 4th of a series, so embarked on a journey starting with River God. This is the first Wilbur Smith book I've read and I was impressed. A good story, well written and from what I can make out from my limited knowledge, historically accurate. At 672 pages, a fairly long read, so will probably leave it a couple of books before I resume my journey with The Seventh Scroll. But still looking forward to it.

Best book, EVER., 16 May 2008
I love this book to distraction! This book has taught me so much about life in Ancient Egypt, love, war and people in general.

I cannot emphasise enough how good this book is, this should be a compulsory read for everyone. This book will stay with you long after you have finished it, which sounds a little cliché but has never been truer for any book that I've read.

In a league of its own, 01 Apr 2008
My words here won't do this book justice! The story is told by Egyptian slave, Taita. He tells the turbulent story of his mistress, Lostris, and her lover, Tanus. The attention to detail is incredible and you really get to love and hate the characters accordingly. Wilbur Smith is a master storyteller. The author's note at the back of the book is also very intriguing!

what a shame, 11 Nov 2008
I love Wilbur smith's books, but this one fell far short of his previous novels. it was far too magical, and far far too far fetched. his strenghts lie in wonderful descriptions of wildlife, hunting and detailed characters. however this book was honestly a pile of nonesense, and i will now hesitate before i purchase my next Wilbur Smith book...

well it passed the time, 09 Nov 2008
Luckily I had read 'River God' etc so long ago so as not to spoil my memories of them, and luckily I only spent a small amount on this book in a charity shop. I happened to be in Egypt on holiday when I read it, so the setting suited mine, and it passed the time on the sun bed and on the plane going home!

I like fantasy, but this seems to be merely the tacky ramblings of an old man, and has nothing whatsoever to do with genuine ancient Egyptian mythology. If things got slow in the endless journeying he just chucked in another battle with another random tribe and even this got boring after a while.

And as for the ending, well really! 'Indiana Potter and the Stem Cell Researchers of Doom'!
So our hero rides off into the sunset with new bits and a new body, and I have a horrible suspicion it might take another book to go and regenerate his woman too - so be warned!
All in all a sad slump for this author.

Taitas Quest or Wilburs?, 25 Oct 2008
I have read all the Wilbur Smith books and have been an avid fan. This one is such a disappointment. The sexual content I found most uncomfortable as the main character an old eunuch lusts after a young girl and strives to restore his lost manhood so that eventually he is able to enjoy a full relationship with the girl. The addition of magic and fantasy to a series that has always had a strong believable streak made me feel I was reading a triple XXX version of Harry Potter. If you are new to Wilbur Smith dont be put off by this one. The others are great reads.

Dreadful, 20 Oct 2008
Avoid this book. It's the most contrived, self-indulgent rubbish I've ever read, and I say that as an avid Clive Cussler fan (!).

a rotten end to a great series of books, 09 Oct 2008
I've read many of WS's books and usually love them. I was looking forward to this, the 4th Taita book and really enjoyed it up until they journey to "Shangri La" and apes are acting as bouncers in the tunnel. Then as I read that Meren's eye is about to be regrown from stem cells, I got completely fed up with the story. Then Taita's penis is regrown and of course, it's much bigger, heavier and better than his original. His love for Fenn who has not yet had her 1st period is a bit pervy as is his move on her once she has! Oh, and then he gets reborn as a 30 year old man - its just gets sillier and sillier - SHAME ON YOU, W.S. This is a sad and crappy end to the wonderful series

River god,Brilliant, 10 Oct 2008
Someone lent me this book to read because they liked it,it was the start of a long long reading experience, I just couldn't put it down and I ended up reading the whole series.Anyone who doesn't like it must lack imagination of this epic story.Totally loved it.

One of my favourite books of all time, 28 Aug 2008
A cleverly written book that will make you think you're reading fact not fiction. The real life settings supported by the obvious extensive research that the author has undertaken.

Read this then read "The Seventh Scroll". Truly enchanting and gripping stuff!

Enthralling, 06 Jun 2008
I returned from a Nile Cruise captivated by the history of Egypt and someone leant me a copy of The Quest. On examination I discovered that this was the 4th of a series, so embarked on a journey starting with River God. This is the first Wilbur Smith book I've read and I was impressed. A good story, well written and from what I can make out from my limited knowledge, historically accurate. At 672 pages, a fairly long read, so will probably leave it a couple of books before I resume my journey with The Seventh Scroll. But still looking forward to it.

Best book, EVER., 16 May 2008
I love this book to distraction! This book has taught me so much about life in Ancient Egypt, love, war and people in general.

I cannot emphasise enough how good this book is, this should be a compulsory read for everyone. This book will stay with you long after you have finished it, which sounds a little cliché but has never been truer for any book that I've read.

In a league of its own, 01 Apr 2008
My words here won't do this book justice! The story is told by Egyptian slave, Taita. He tells the turbulent story of his mistress, Lostris, and her lover, Tanus. The attention to detail is incredible and you really get to love and hate the characters accordingly. Wilbur Smith is a master storyteller. The author's note at the back of the book is also very intriguing!

Seventh Scroll, 06 Jul 2008
Make sure you read River God first then this it is amazing its like an indiana jones film, in fact thay should make a film of it! Its got everything sexy women, hero, bad guys, and a serious adventure, it is a must read and you can read time and time again. brillant!

best ever story teller, 26 Feb 2008
I have read all of Wilbur Smith's books and never fail to enjoy them. I read this when it first came out and was "chuffed" that this carried on the story but in modern times. I have just ordered Quest and look forward to reading this but am reading Warlock again to refresh me. I was inspired by these stories to go to Egypt and while reading Warlock again, I can relate to some of the places. Definitely will be reading these 4 stories again and again, although, knowing Wilbur Smith, he will probably develop this storyline again and again, like his South African books. If you haven't read these, read them as they give great insights into the turbulence of that country. Cannot recommend Wilbur enough for a damn good read!!!

Written for children, 05 Feb 2008
This book reminds me of The Hardy Boys series... Surely no intelligent person over the age of 8 could enjoy the stilted dialogue and pathetically unrealistic actions of the characters??
I think Wilbur Smith has been isolated into a fairy world of chivalry and old fashioned snobbery that leaves me with a sour taste in my mouth. Again Mr. Smith has taken a turn for the worse with this predictable tale.

Very disappointing compared to River God, 06 Dec 2007
After reading the absolutely brilliant River God, I rightfully had huge expectations for The Seventh Scroll.
It is a good book written in classic Wilbur Smith style, but unfortunately it leaves a lot to be desired with its fast paced story, shallow characters and predictable plot.
Smith is definitely a master story teller which can vividly paint the scenes in your mind, but this book seriously lacks the poignancy of his previous work. From this I get the impression that it was mostly written by his editors.

Overall, the book is entertaining and will keep you turning pages, but fails to build on the Egyptian epic started in River God. I seriously hope this book does not mark the series' descent.


Brilliant, 25 Aug 2007
What a great follow up for River God, heroes, heroines, goodies, baddies and all the time dear old Taita is in the background. I could not put this book down, it really is a great read, a breathtaking adventure. Anyone who hasn't read this series, you really need to start with River God before you read this.

Wilbur Smith (a name synonymous with the massive blockbuster thriller) has recaptured the verve and impact of his earlier work in Warlock. This Egyptian epic thriller follows on from the equally accomplished River God and The Seventh Scroll and re-establishes Smith at the top echelons of thriller writing. The customary continent-spanning canvas is here, with a key new element in an adroitly handled supernatural aspect that gives the sequence the feel of fantasy whilst still retaining the plausibility that was always Smith's strongest asset.

The reader is plunged into a vividly realised evocation of life in ancient Egypt but one presented with insights into the various characters that infuse a very contemporary feel. In the secluded deserts of North Africa, Taita has spent the years since the death of his adored Queen Lostris studying to become a Warlock, steeped in the arcane arts of the ancient Gods and a master practitioner of magic. Responding to an occult summons, Taita abandons the desert and returns to civilisation, only to find himself at the centre of a massive conflagration in which dark and sinister forces are undermining the throne of Egypt and attempting to destroy the young prince Nefer. Soon, his hard-won skills are tested to the limit.

As in the previous books in the sequence, Smith knows that a strong and passionate agenda on the part of his protagonists will allow the reader to identify with them, despite the gap of centuries. Here, it is family ties: Taita is defending the young prince who is the grandson of his lost Queen, and we are quickly engaged in a narrative that rarely flags over its considerable length. The action set pieces are as impressive as one would expect:

The instant he was within range the Cobra struck again, but Nefer caught the blow on the thick leather folds of the bag. The beast's fangs snagged in the leather and held fast. As Nefer swung back the snake was dragged with him. It was hauled cleanly out of the nest, a writhing, seething ball of coils and polished scales. It thrashed against Nefer's legs, the heavy tail lashing him, hissing fearsomely, clouds of venom spraying from its gaping jaws and dribbling down the leather bag. So great was its weight that Nefer's whole body was shaken violently.

--Barry Forshaw

what a shame, 11 Nov 2008
I love Wilbur smith's books, but this one fell far short of his previous novels. it was far too magical, and far far too far fetched. his strenghts lie in wonderful descriptions of wildlife, hunting and detailed characters. however this book was honestly a pile of nonesense, and i will now hesitate before i purchase my next Wilbur Smith book...

well it passed the time, 09 Nov 2008
Luckily I had read 'River God' etc so long ago so as not to spoil my memories of them, and luckily I only spent a small amount on this book in a charity shop. I happened to be in Egypt on holiday when I read it, so the setting suited mine, and it passed the time on the sun bed and on the plane going home!

I like fantasy, but this seems to be merely the tacky ramblings of an old man, and has nothing whatsoever to do with genuine ancient Egyptian mythology. If things got slow in the endless journeying he just chucked in another battle with another random tribe and even this got boring after a while.

And as for the ending, well really! 'Indiana Potter and the Stem Cell Researchers of Doom'!
So our hero rides off into the sunset with new bits and a new body, and I have a horrible suspicion it might take another book to go and regenerate his woman too - so be warned!
All in all a sad slump for this author.

Taitas Quest or Wilburs?, 25 Oct 2008
I have read all the Wilbur Smith books and have been an avid fan. This one is such a disappointment. The sexual content I found most uncomfortable as the main character an old eunuch lusts after a young girl and strives to restore his lost manhood so that eventually he is able to enjoy a full relationship with the girl. The addition of magic and fantasy to a series that has always had a strong believable streak made me feel I was reading a triple XXX version of Harry Potter. If you are new to Wilbur Smith dont be put off by this one. The others are great reads.

Dreadful, 20 Oct 2008
Avoid this book. It's the most contrived, self-indulgent rubbish I've ever read, and I say that as an avid Clive Cussler fan (!).

a rotten end to a great series of books, 09 Oct 2008
I've read many of WS's books and usually love them. I was looking forward to this, the 4th Taita book and really enjoyed it up until they journey to "Shangri La" and apes are acting as bouncers in the tunnel. Then as I read that Meren's eye is about to be regrown from stem cells, I got completely fed up with the story. Then Taita's penis is regrown and of course, it's much bigger, heavier and better than his original. His love for Fenn who has not yet had her 1st period is a bit pervy as is his move on her once she has! Oh, and then he gets reborn as a 30 year old man - its just gets sillier and sillier - SHAME ON YOU, W.S. This is a sad and crappy end to the wonderful series

River god,Brilliant, 10 Oct 2008
Someone lent me this book to read because they liked it,it was the start of a long long reading experience, I just couldn't put it down and I ended up reading the whole series.Anyone who doesn't like it must lack imagination of this epic story.Totally loved it.

One of my favourite books of all time, 28 Aug 2008
A cleverly written book that will make you think you're reading fact not fiction. The real life settings supported by the obvious extensive research that the author has undertaken.

Read this then read "The Seventh Scroll". Truly enchanting and gripping stuff!

Enthralling, 06 Jun 2008
I returned from a Nile Cruise captivated by the history of Egypt and someone leant me a copy of The Quest. On examination I discovered that this was the 4th of a series, so embarked on a journey starting with River God. This is the first Wilbur Smith book I've read and I was impressed. A good story, well written and from what I can make out from my limited knowledge, historically accurate. At 672 pages, a fairly long read, so will probably leave it a couple of books before I resume my journey with The Seventh Scroll. But still looking forward to it.

Best book, EVER., 16 May 2008
I love this book to distraction! This book has taught me so much about life in Ancient Egypt, love, war and people in general.

I cannot emphasise enough how good this book is, this should be a compulsory read for everyone. This book will stay with you long after you have finished it, which sounds a little cliché but has never been truer for any book that I've read.

In a league of its own, 01 Apr 2008
My words here won't do this book justice! The story is told by Egyptian slave, Taita. He tells the turbulent story of his mistress, Lostris, and her lover, Tanus. The attention to detail is incredible and you really get to love and hate the characters accordingly. Wilbur Smith is a master storyteller. The author's note at the back of the book is also very intriguing!

Seventh Scroll, 06 Jul 2008
Make sure you read River God first then this it is amazing its like an indiana jones film, in fact thay should make a film of it! Its got everything sexy women, hero, bad guys, and a serious adventure, it is a must read and you can read time and time again. brillant!

best ever story teller, 26 Feb 2008
I have read all of Wilbur Smith's books and never fail to enjoy them. I read this when it first came out and was "chuffed" that this carried on the story but in modern times. I have just ordered Quest and look forward to reading this but am reading Warlock again to refresh me. I was inspired by these stories to go to Egypt and while reading Warlock again, I can relate to some of the places. Definitely will be reading these 4 stories again and again, although, knowing Wilbur Smith, he will probably develop this storyline again and again, like his South African books. If you haven't read these, read them as they give great insights into the turbulence of that country. Cannot recommend Wilbur enough for a damn good read!!!

Written for children, 05 Feb 2008
This book reminds me of The Hardy Boys series... Surely no intelligent person over the age of 8 could enjoy the stilted dialogue and pathetically unrealistic actions of the characters??
I think Wilbur Smith has been isolated into a fairy world of chivalry and old fashioned snobbery that leaves me with a sour taste in my mouth. Again Mr. Smith has taken a turn for the worse with this predictable tale.

Very disappointing compared to River God, 06 Dec 2007
After reading the absolutely brilliant River God, I rightfully had huge expectations for The Seventh Scroll.
It is a good book written in classic Wilbur Smith style, but unfortunately it leaves a lot to be desired with its fast paced story, shallow characters and predictable plot.
Smith is definitely a master story teller which can vividly paint the scenes in your mind, but this book seriously lacks the poignancy of his previous work. From this I get the impression that it was mostly written by his editors.

Overall, the book is entertaining and will keep you turning pages, but fails to build on the Egyptian epic started in River God. I seriously hope this book does not mark the series' descent.


Brilliant, 25 Aug 2007
What a great follow up for River God, heroes, heroines, goodies, baddies and all the time dear old Taita is in the background. I could not put this book down, it really is a great read, a breathtaking adventure. Anyone who hasn't read this series, you really need to start with River God before you read this.

Brilliant, 14 Jan 2008
After the somewhat disappointing The Seventh Scroll, I feared the series is deteriorating. Fortunately, Warlock is no disappointment. In fact, in some aspects it's even better than River God! I know is hard to believe, but its true.

Wilbur Smith is a master story-teller, and continues a great epic in superb fashion with his exquisite prose, fascinating characters and captivating story. It is masterfully written and the story's unfolding will surprise the most readers with its twists and turns. It will keep you hooked from start to finish.

It will make to laugh, it will make you cry, it will give you goose-bumps, it will leave you gaping with amazement... Read this book!


Disapointing ending!, 13 Sep 2007
98% of the book was set building up towards the final battle, and then, in the closing pages, the battle is done, the victor does their (brief) thing, then BANG. The end.

It was all very much anti-climatic, but still a bloody good read.

Marked down one for the ending that felt rushed.

EXCELLENT, 07 Mar 2007
This was the third novel I read by Wilbur Smith.I basically bought it because I loved Egyptian history.

It was an excellent story and I enjoyed it. Don't want to say anything about the story because I don't want to spoil it for you.

It was an enjoyable read and the story caught you right from the start, it takes you on a great journey.

Looking forward to the fourth in the series.

Compulsive read. :-)

Brilliant book to read after "River God", 01 Aug 2004
I like to call this a 'Sequal' to 'River God'. Of course, you don't HAVE to read the latter before this, but both are incredibly gripping, and page-turning. Make sure you haven't got anything else to do when you start reading this, because you won't want to stop! Again, excallent if you love Ancient Egypt. The story gets going more or less straight away and its action all the way through!

Warlock: The Egyptians Strike Back, 09 Jul 2004
the original in this trio of books, river god, without a doubt makes my favourite read in the history of my favourite reads. Part 2 , the seventh scroll - flashing forward a few millennia also was fantastic (maybe even top 10). Warlock, going back to ancient Egypt, should have followed in the same success... however as strong as it was, it failed to meet the high bar of its predecessors. I would put it down to the formula being changed. Where as it needed a fresh approach & a new concept to make it a novel in its own rights, I am not entirely convinced that this was the recipe for success. the formula in question is the introduction of magic / wizardry / sorcerous powers / the force (?!). The book is set a few decades after the 1st novel (overlook the fact that taita is probably outlived ancient Egyptian life expectancy many times over!). Queen Lostris is dead, her bloodline is in danger of ending, new powers are emerging in the political arena, and Taita, well taita the hero from river god has left the house of lostris and now is a hermit in the wilderness, studying, praying and doing all things mystical to become a warlock. note the similarities with a character from a well loved series of films? cough! old Ben kenobi, star wars cough! further case study comparisons include a not-so-unique escape from an enemy palace within the novel. "these aren't the droids your looking for..."

Despite being the title character, taita surprisingly takes more of a back seat role. for this I was glad - as a favourite character in river god - his warlocky abilities in this book didn't grip me or allow me to 'believe' in the tale as much. I preferred the action to remain on the 'down to earth' characters. saying that, however, it was refreshing to have taita's presence, as with him, you kinda knew things couldn't go too wrong - especially with those powers...

A big change from river god - is the switch from 1st person narrative to 3rd person. I think I prefer the former option - it adds a lot more personality and opportunity for emotive description. with the tale following many different stories & characters it would have been hard to have a single narrator. Again, a change in the formula from original, possibly taking some of the charm away. However the characterisation, storylines and wilbur's trademark 'romance' remain strong and make up for some of the losses as such. to touch upon the romance, some would describe as too in-your-face and over powering. I disagree. I will say that the encounters seemingly come out of nowhere, are very graphic (in quite a tasteful way), and then disappear just as fast. a number of times whilst reading (as a self-confessed skim reader), I would end a page and question 'did I just read that?' and would have to flick back and re-read just to make sure. its good to be shocked now and again. There are some great character cameos from 1st novel - which I loved even if they were brief. I soon forgot their lack of presence outside the first few chapters as the story gripped me again in true wilbur smith style.

I'm glad I read it, I think the Egyptian series has now brought itself to a well deserved end. For those devotee river god fans - I think its unavoidable to get another taste of taita's tales - although beware, it is a completely different concept / formula from that of #1. still a 'gripper' and a 'hard-to-put-downer' but definitely not river god returns. Any one picking this book up afresh, would suggest getting the background flavour and taste for the series by reading river god & seventh scroll first.

what a shame, 11 Nov 2008
I love Wilbur smith's books, but this one fell far short of his previous novels. it was far too magical, and far far too far fetched. his strenghts lie in wonderful descriptions of wildlife, hunting and detailed characters. however this book was honestly a pile of nonesense, and i will now hesitate before i purchase my next Wilbur Smith book...

well it passed the time, 09 Nov 2008
Luckily I had read 'River God' etc so long ago so as not to spoil my memories of them, and luckily I only spent a small amount on this book in a charity shop. I happened to be in Egypt on holiday when I read it, so the setting suited mine, and it passed the time on the sun bed and on the plane going home!

I like fantasy, but this seems to be merely the tacky ramblings of an old man, and has nothing whatsoever to do with genuine ancient Egyptian mythology. If things got slow in the endless journeying he just chucked in another battle with another random tribe and even this got boring after a while.

And as for the ending, well really! 'Indiana Potter and the Stem Cell Researchers of Doom'!
So our hero rides off into the sunset with new bits and a new body, and I have a horrible suspicion it might take another book to go and regenerate his woman too - so be warned!
All in all a sad slump for this author.

Taitas Quest or Wilburs?, 25 Oct 2008
I have read all the Wilbur Smith books and have been an avid fan. This one is such a disappointment. The sexual content I found most uncomfortable as the main character an old eunuch lusts after a young girl and strives to restore his lost manhood so that eventually he is able to enjoy a full relationship with the girl. The addition of magic and fantasy to a series that has always had a strong believable streak made me feel I was reading a triple XXX version of Harry Potter. If you are new to Wilbur Smith dont be put off by this one. The others are great reads.

Dreadful, 20 Oct 2008
Avoid this book. It's the most contrived, self-indulgent rubbish I've ever read, and I say that as an avid Clive Cussler fan (!).

a rotten end to a great series of books, 09 Oct 2008
I've read many of WS's books and usually love them. I was looking forward to this, the 4th Taita book and really enjoyed it up until they journey to "Shangri La" and apes are acting as bouncers in the tunnel. Then as I read that Meren's eye is about to be regrown from stem cells, I got completely fed up with the story. Then Taita's penis is regrown and of course, it's much bigger, heavier and better than his original. His love for Fenn who has not yet had her 1st period is a bit pervy as is his move on her once she has! Oh, and then he gets reborn as a 30 year old man - its just gets sillier and sillier - SHAME ON YOU, W.S. This is a sad and crappy end to the wonderful series

River god,Brilliant, 10 Oct 2008
Someone lent me this book to read because they liked it,it was the start of a long long reading experience, I just couldn't put it down and I ended up reading the whole series.Anyone who doesn't like it must lack imagination of this epic story.Totally loved it.

One of my favourite books of all time, 28 Aug 2008
A cleverly written book that will make you think you're reading fact not fiction. The real life settings supported by the obvious extensive research that the author has undertaken.

Read this then read "The Seventh Scroll". Truly enchanting and gripping stuff!

Enthralling, 06 Jun 2008
I returned from a Nile Cruise captivated by the history of Egypt and someone leant me a copy of The Quest. On examination I discovered that this was the 4th of a series, so embarked on a journey starting with River God. This is the first Wilbur Smith book I've read and I was impressed. A good story, well written and from what I can make out from my limited knowledge, historically accurate. At 672 pages, a fairly long read, so will probably leave it a couple of books before I resume my journey with The Seventh Scroll. But still looking forward to it.

Best book, EVER., 16 May 2008
I love this book to distraction! This book has taught me so much about life in Ancient Egypt, love, war and people in general.

I cannot emphasise enough how good this book is, this should be a compulsory read for everyone. This book will stay with you long after you have finished it, which sounds a little cliché but has never been truer for any book that I've read.

In a league of its own, 01 Apr 2008
My words here won't do this book justice! The story is told by Egyptian slave, Taita. He tells the turbulent story of his mistress, Lostris, and her lover, Tanus. The attention to detail is incredible and you really get to love and hate the characters accordingly. Wilbur Smith is a master storyteller. The author's note at the back of the book is also very intriguing!

Seventh Scroll, 06 Jul 2008
Make sure you read River God first then this it is amazing its like an indiana jones film, in fact thay should make a film of it! Its got everything sexy women, hero, bad guys, and a serious adventure, it is a must read and you can read time and time again. brillant!

best ever story teller, 26 Feb 2008
I have read all of Wilbur Smith's books and never fail to enjoy them. I read this when it first came out and was "chuffed" that this carried on the story but in modern times. I have just ordered Quest and look forward to reading this but am reading Warlock again to refresh me. I was inspired by these stories to go to Egypt and while reading Warlock again, I can relate to some of the places. Definitely will be reading these 4 stories again and again, although, knowing Wilbur Smith, he will probably develop this storyline again and again, like his South African books. If you haven't read these, read them as they give great insights into the turbulence of that country. Cannot recommend Wilbur enough for a damn good read!!!

Written for children, 05 Feb 2008
This book reminds me of The Hardy Boys series... Surely no intelligent person over the age of 8 could enjoy the stilted dialogue and pathetically unrealistic actions of the characters??
I think Wilbur Smith has been isolated into a fairy world of chivalry and old fashioned snobbery that leaves me with a sour taste in my mouth. Again Mr. Smith has taken a turn for the worse with this predictable tale.

Very disappointing compared to River God, 06 Dec 2007
After reading the absolutely brilliant River God, I rightfully had huge expectations for The Seventh Scroll.
It is a good book written in classic Wilbur Smith style, but unfortunately it leaves a lot to be desired with its fast paced story, shallow characters and predictable plot.
Smith is definitely a master story teller which can vividly paint the scenes in your mind, but this book seriously lacks the poignancy of his previous work. From this I get the impression that it was mostly written by his editors.

Overall, the book is entertaining and will keep you turning pages, but fails to build on the Egyptian epic started in River God. I seriously hope this book does not mark the series' descent.


Brilliant, 25 Aug 2007
What a great follow up for River God, heroes, heroines, goodies, baddies and all the time dear old Taita is in the background. I could not put this book down, it really is a great read, a breathtaking adventure. Anyone who hasn't read this series, you really need to start with River God before you read this.

Brilliant, 14 Jan 2008
After the somewhat disappointing The Seventh Scroll, I feared the series is deteriorating. Fortunately, Warlock is no disappointment. In fact, in some aspects it's even better than River God! I know is hard to believe, but its true.

Wilbur Smith is a master story-teller, and continues a great epic in superb fashion with his exquisite prose, fascinating characters and captivating story. It is masterfully written and the story's unfolding will surprise the most readers with its twists and turns. It will keep you hooked from start to finish.

It will make to laugh, it will make you cry, it will give you goose-bumps, it will leave you gaping with amazement... Read this book!


Disapointing ending!, 13 Sep 2007
98% of the book was set building up towards the final battle, and then, in the closing pages, the battle is done, the victor does their (brief) thing, then BANG. The end.

It was all very much anti-climatic, but still a bloody good read.

Marked down one for the ending that felt rushed.

EXCELLENT, 07 Mar 2007
This was the third novel I read by Wilbur Smith.I basically bought it because I loved Egyptian history.

It was an excellent story and I enjoyed it. Don't want to say anything about the story because I don't want to spoil it for you.

It was an enjoyable read and the story caught you right from the start, it takes you on a great journey.

Looking forward to the fourth in the series.

Compulsive read. :-)

Brilliant book to read after "River God", 01 Aug 2004
I like to call this a 'Sequal' to 'River God'. Of course, you don't HAVE to read the latter before this, but both are incredibly gripping, and page-turning. Make sure you haven't got anything else to do when you start reading this, because you won't want to stop! Again, excallent if you love Ancient Egypt. The story gets going more or less straight away and its action all the way through!

Warlock: The Egyptians Strike Back, 09 Jul 2004
the original in this trio of books, river god, without a doubt makes my favourite read in the history of my favourite reads. Part 2 , the seventh scroll - flashing forward a few millennia also was fantastic (maybe even top 10). Warlock, going back to ancient Egypt, should have followed in the same success... however as strong as it was, it failed to meet the high bar of its predecessors. I would put it down to the formula being changed. Where as it needed a fresh approach & a new concept to make it a novel in its own rights, I am not entirely convinced that this was the recipe for success. the formula in question is the introduction of magic / wizardry / sorcerous powers / the force (?!). The book is set a few decades after the 1st novel (overlook the fact that taita is probably outlived ancient Egyptian life expectancy many times over!). Queen Lostris is dead, her bloodline is in danger of ending, new powers are emerging in the political arena, and Taita, well taita the hero from river god has left the house of lostris and now is a hermit in the wilderness, studying, praying and doing all things mystical to become a warlock. note the similarities with a character from a well loved series of films? cough! old Ben kenobi, star wars cough! further case study comparisons include a not-so-unique escape from an enemy palace within the novel. "these aren't the droids your looking for..."

Despite being the title character, taita surprisingly takes more of a back seat role. for this I was glad - as a favourite character in river god - his warlocky abilities in this book didn't grip me or allow me to 'believe' in the tale as much. I preferred the action to remain on the 'down to earth' characters. saying that, however, it was refreshing to have taita's presence, as with him, you kinda knew things couldn't go too wrong - especially with those powers...

A big change from river god - is the switch from 1st person narrative to 3rd person. I think I prefer the former option - it adds a lot more personality and opportunity for emotive description. with the tale following many different stories & characters it would have been hard to have a single narrator. Again, a change in the formula from original, possibly taking some of the charm away. However the characterisation, storylines and wilbur's trademark 'romance' remain strong and make up for some of the losses as such. to touch upon the romance, some would describe as too in-your-face and over powering. I disagree. I will say that the encounters seemingly come out of nowhere, are very graphic (in quite a tasteful way), and then disappear just as fast. a number of times whilst reading (as a self-confessed skim reader), I would end a page and question 'did I just read that?' and would have to flick back and re-read just to make sure. its good to be shocked now and again. There are some great character cameos from 1st novel - which I loved even if they were brief. I soon forgot their lack of presence outside the first few chapters as the story gripped me again in true wilbur smith style.

I'm glad I read it, I think the Egyptian series has now brought itself to a well deserved end. For those devotee river god fans - I think its unavoidable to get another taste of taita's tales - although beware, it is a completely different concept / formula from that of #1. still a 'gripper' and a 'hard-to-put-downer' but definitely not river god returns. Any one picking this book up afresh, would suggest getting the background flavour and taste for the series by reading river god & seventh scroll first.

Awesome, 08 Jun 2008
A stunning sequel picking up where the Lion feeds left off in exploding pace and drama. If you enjoyed The lion feeds and have not read this yet then I ask 'What's wrong with you order a copy now!!'

Compelling and moving., 01 Aug 2005
Still new to Wilber Smith and enjoying his work enormously. If adventure is your thing then look no further than this guy. In his second novel we pick up a few years after where we left of in 'When the lion feeds' following spontaneous adventurer Sean Courtney. War is rife is South Africa and we travel with Sean into the Boer war. But soon we learn that a far more bitter battle lies ahead for our hero. A deep family hatred is there for all too see. The way Smith draws you into the story is something special, and you find it hard to put the book down. When something happens to the characters involved, you find yourself taking the punches as they take them. The way the book describes the African topology and climate will create a desire to explore the country yourself. It is easy to see why Smith is so highly rated. He is quite a brilliant writer. Emotional and heart-warming, a fantastic sequel, not to be ignored!

What a follow up!, 13 Jul 2000
After coming back from the wilderness, a rich man once again, only to find himself to have all his Ivory & money taken from him by the Boers, he find himself drawn into a war that divids the country. He has to make his mind up as to which side he will fight for ( & I won't tell you, because it will just ruin it! ) To gat there he has to cross through emeny lines, and it is here that he finds the woman of his dreams, but that would be all to simple. Togeather with this and the war its self, Wilbur Smith turns this into a compelling and exiciteing novel

What a way to continue the Courtney family saga!

what a shame, 11 Nov 2008
I love Wilbur smith's books, but this one fell far short of his previous novels. it was far too magical, and far far too far fetched. his strenghts lie in wonderful descriptions of wildlife, hunting and detailed characters. however this book was honestly a pile of nonesense, and i will now hesitate before i purchase my next Wilbur Smith book...

well it passed the time, 09 Nov 2008
Luckily I had read 'River God' etc so long ago so as not to spoil my memories of them, and luckily I only spent a small amount on this book in a charity shop. I happened to be in Egypt on holiday when I read it, so the setting suited mine, and it passed the time on the sun bed and on the plane going home!

I like fantasy, but this seems to be merely the tacky ramblings of an old man, and has nothing whatsoever to do with genuine ancient Egyptian mythology. If things got slow in the endless journeying he just chucked in another battle with another random tribe and even this got boring after a while.

And as for the ending, well really! 'Indiana Potter and the Stem Cell Researchers of Doom'!
So our hero rides off into the sunset with new bits and a new body, and I have a horrible suspicion it might take another book to go and regenerate his woman too - so be warned!
All in all a sad slump for this author.

Taitas Quest or Wilburs?, 25 Oct 2008
I have read all the Wilbur Smith books and have been an avid fan. This one is such a disappointment. The sexual content I found most uncomfortable as the main character an old eunuch lusts after a young girl and strives to restore his lost manhood so that eventually he is able to enjoy a full relationship with the girl. The addition of magic and fantasy to a series that has always had a strong believable streak made me feel I was reading a triple XXX version of Harry Potter. If you are new to Wilbur Smith dont be put off by this one. The others are great reads.

Dreadful, 20 Oct 2008
Avoid this book. It's the most contrived, self-indulgent rubbish I've ever read, and I say that as an avid Clive Cussler fan (!).

a rotten end to a great series of books, 09 Oct 2008
I've read many of WS's books and usually love them. I was looking forward to this, the 4th Taita book and really enjoyed it up until they journey to "Shangri La" and apes are acting as bouncers in the tunnel. Then as I read that Meren's eye is about to be regrown from stem cells, I got completely fed up with the story. Then Taita's penis is regrown and of course, it's much bigger, heavier and better than his original. His love for Fenn who has not yet had her 1st period is a bit pervy as is his move on her once she has! Oh, and then he gets reborn as a 30 year old man - its just gets sillier and sillier - SHAME ON YOU, W.S. This is a sad and crappy end to the wonderful series

River god,Brilliant, 10 Oct 2008
Someone lent me this book to read because they liked it,it was the start of a long long reading experience, I just couldn't put it down and I ended up reading the whole series.Anyone who doesn't like it must lack imagination of this epic story.Totally loved it.

One of my favourite books of all time, 28 Aug 2008
A cleverly written book that will make you think you're reading fact not fiction. The real life settings supported by the obvious extensive research that the author has undertaken.

Read this then read "The Seventh Scroll". Truly enchanting and gripping stuff!

Enthralling, 06 Jun 2008
I returned from a Nile Cruise captivated by the history of Egypt and someone leant me a copy of The Quest. On examination I discovered that this was the 4th of a series, so embarked on a journey starting with River God. This is the first Wilbur Smith book I've read and I was impressed. A good story, well written and from what I can make out from my limited knowledge, historically accurate. At 672 pages, a fairly long read, so will probably leave it a couple of books before I resume my journey with The Seventh Scroll. But still looking forward to it.

Best book, EVER., 16 May 2008
I love this book to distraction! This book has taught me so much about life in Ancient Egypt, love, war and people in general.

I cannot emphasise enough how good this book is, this should be a compulsory read for everyone. This book will stay with you long after you have finished it, which sounds a little cliché but has never been truer for any book that I've read.

In a league of its own, 01 Apr 2008
My words here won't do this book justice! The story is told by Egyptian slave, Taita. He tells the turbulent story of his mistress, Lostris, and her lover, Tanus. The attention to detail is incredible and you really get to love and hate the characters accordingly. Wilbur Smith is a master storyteller. The author's note at the back of the book is also very intriguing!

Seventh Scroll, 06 Jul 2008
Make sure you read River God first then this it is amazing its like an indiana jones film, in fact thay should make a film of it! Its got everything sexy women, hero, bad guys, and a serious adventure, it is a must read and you can read time and time again. brillant!

best ever story teller, 26 Feb 2008
I have read all of Wilbur Smith's books and never fail to enjoy them. I read this when it first came out and was "chuffed" that this carried on the story but in modern times. I have just ordered Quest and look forward to reading this but am reading Warlock again to refresh me. I was inspired by these stories to go to Egypt and while reading Warlock again, I can relate to some of the places. Definitely will be reading these 4 stories again and again, although, knowing Wilbur Smith, he will probably develop this storyline again and again, like his South African books. If you haven't read these, read them as they give great insights into the turbulence of that country. Cannot recommend Wilbur enough for a damn good read!!!

Written for children, 05 Feb 2008
This book reminds me of The Hardy Boys series... Surely no intelligent person over the age of 8 could enjoy the stilted dialogue and pathetically unrealistic actions of the characters??
I think Wilbur Smith has been isolated into a fairy world of chivalry and old fashioned snobbery that leaves me with a sour taste in my mouth. Again Mr. Smith has taken a turn for the worse with this predictable tale.

Very disappointing compared to River God, 06 Dec 2007
After reading the absolutely brilliant River God, I rightfully had huge expectations for The Seventh Scroll.
It is a good book written in classic Wilbur Smith style, but unfortunately it leaves a lot to be desired with its fast paced story, shallow characters and predictable plot.
Smith is definitely a master story teller which can vividly paint the scenes in your mind, but this book seriously lacks the poignancy of his previous work. From this I get the impression that it was mostly written by his editors.

Overall, the book is entertaining and will keep you turning pages, but fails to build on the Egyptian epic started in River God. I seriously hope this book does not mark the series' descent.


Brilliant, 25 Aug 2007
What a great follow up for River God, heroes, heroines, goodies, baddies and all the time dear old Taita is in the background. I could not put this book down, it really is a great read, a breathtaking adventure. Anyone who hasn't read this series, you really need to start with River God before you read this.

Brilliant, 14 Jan 2008
After the somewhat disappointing The Seventh Scroll, I feared the series is deteriorating. Fortunately, Warlock is no disappointment. In fact, in some aspects it's even better than River God! I know is hard to believe, but its true.

Wilbur Smith is a master story-teller, and continues a great epic in superb fashion with his exquisite prose, fascinating characters and captivating story. It is masterfully written and the story's unfolding will surprise the most readers with its twists and turns. It will keep you hooked from start to finish.

It will make to laugh, it will make you cry, it will give you goose-bumps, it will leave you gaping with amazement... Read this book!


Disapointing ending!, 13 Sep 2007
98% of the book was set building up towards the final battle, and then, in the closing pages, the battle is done, the victor does their (brief) thing, then BANG. The end.

It was all very much anti-climatic, but still a bloody good read.

Marked down one for the ending that felt rushed.

EXCELLENT, 07 Mar 2007
This was the third novel I read by Wilbur Smith.I basically bought it because I loved Egyptian history.

It was an excellent story and I enjoyed it. Don't want to say anything about the story because I don't want to spoil it for you.

It was an enjoyable read and the story caught you right from the start, it takes you on a great journey.

Looking forward to the fourth in the series.

Compulsive read. :-)

Brilliant book to read after "River God", 01 Aug 2004
I like to call this a 'Sequal' to 'River God'. Of course, you don't HAVE to read the latter before this, but both are incredibly gripping, and page-turning. Make sure you haven't got anything else to do when you start reading this, because you won't want to stop! Again, excallent if you love Ancient Egypt. The story gets going more or less straight away and its action all the way through!

Warlock: The Egyptians Strike Back, 09 Jul 2004
the original in this trio of books, river god, without a doubt makes my favourite read in the history of my favourite reads. Part 2 , the seventh scroll - flashing forward a few millennia also was fantastic (maybe even top 10). Warlock, going back to ancient Egypt, should have followed in the same success... however as strong as it was, it failed to meet the high bar of its predecessors. I would put it down to the formula being changed. Where as it needed a fresh approach & a new concept to make it a novel in its own rights, I am not entirely convinced that this was the recipe for success. the formula in question is the introduction of magic / wizardry / sorcerous powers / the force (?!). The book is set a few decades after the 1st novel (overlook the fact that taita is probably outlived ancient Egyptian life expectancy many times over!). Queen Lostris is dead, her bloodline is in danger of ending, new powers are emerging in the political arena, and Taita, well taita the hero from river god has left the house of lostris and now is a hermit in the wilderness, studying, praying and doing all things mystical to become a warlock. note the similarities with a character from a well loved series of films? cough! old Ben kenobi, star wars cough! further case study comparisons include a not-so-unique escape from an enemy palace within the novel. "these aren't the droids your looking for..."

Despite being the title character, taita surprisingly takes more of a back seat role. for this I was glad - as a favourite character in river god - his warlocky abilities in this book didn't grip me or allow me to 'believe' in the tale as much. I preferred the action to remain on the 'down to earth' characters. saying that, however, it was refreshing to have taita's presence, as with him, you kinda knew things couldn't go too wrong - especially with those powers...

A big change from river god - is the switch from 1st person narrative to 3rd person. I think I prefer the former option - it adds a lot more personality and opportunity for emotive description. with the tale following many different stories & characters it would have been hard to have a single narrator. Again, a change in the formula from original, possibly taking some of the charm away. However the characterisation, storylines and wilbur's trademark 'romance' remain strong and make up for some of the losses as such. to touch upon the romance, some would describe as too in-your-face and over powering. I disagree. I will say that the encounters seemingly come out of nowhere, are very graphic (in quite a tasteful way), and then disappear just as fast. a number of times whilst reading (as a self-confessed skim reader), I would end a page and question 'did I just read that?' and would have to flick back and re-read just to make sure. its good to be shocked now and again. There are some great character cameos from 1st novel - which I loved even if they were brief. I soon forgot their lack of presence outside the first few chapters as the story gripped me again in true wilbur smith style.

I'm glad I read it, I think the Egyptian series has now brought itself to a well deserved end. For those devotee river god fans - I think its unavoidable to get another taste of taita's tales - although beware, it is a completely different concept / formula from that of #1. still a 'gripper' and a 'hard-to-put-downer' but definitely not river god returns. Any one picking this book up afresh, would suggest getting the background flavour and taste for the series by reading river god & seventh scroll first.

Awesome, 08 Jun 2008
A stunning sequel picking up where the Lion feeds left off in exploding pace and drama. If you enjoyed The lion feeds and have not read this yet then I ask 'What's wrong with you order a copy now!!'

Compelling and moving., 01 Aug 2005
Still new to Wilber Smith and enjoying his work enormously. If adventure is your thing then look no further than this guy. In his second novel we pick up a few years after where we left of in 'When the lion feeds' following spontaneous adventurer Sean Courtney. War is rife is South Africa and we travel with Sean into the Boer war. But soon we learn that a far more bitter battle lies ahead for our hero. A deep family hatred is there for all too see. The way Smith draws you into the story is something special, and you find it hard to put the book down. When something happens to the characters involved, you find yourself taking the punches as they take them. The way the book describes the African topology and climate will create a desire to explore the country yourself. It is easy to see why Smith is so highly rated. He is quite a brilliant writer. Emotional and heart-warming, a fantastic sequel, not to be ignored!

What a follow up!, 13 Jul 2000
After coming back from the wilderness, a rich man once again, only to find himself to have all his Ivory & money taken from him by the Boers, he find himself drawn into a war that divids the country. He has to make his mind up as to which side he will fight for ( & I won't tell you, because it will just ruin it! ) To gat there he has to cross through emeny lines, and it is here that he finds the woman of his dreams, but that would be all to simple. Togeather with this and the war its self, Wilbur Smith turns this into a compelling and exiciteing novel

What a way to continue the Courtney family saga!

When the lion reads, 08 Jun 2008
This story is definatly not what I was expecting, but I THOROUGHLY enjoyed this engrossing read, the main character, Sean, is a real man's man, an excellent creation. Few writers can genuinly shock me but Mr Smith certainly can and does, if you haven't read this yet then do so asap.

The first and best Smith by a mile., 28 Nov 2007
Ah, these were the days - when Wilbur Smith wrote great stuff. Now he writes just average stuff, but in my opinion, When The Lion Feeds will be regarded as one of the best adventures of the genre ever.

Set during the Zulu wars and the subsequent diamond rush, Smith set out as he meant to go on with the outstanding Sean Courtney. A hugely strong man who rampages his way through life, a drinker of strong whisky, a seducer of women and fast with his fists, Smith revolves a whirlwind adventure around him from the killing fields of the veldt, the whorehouses of Natal and the mines of Kimberly.

It's not high-brow literature; it's just a magnificent, blood and greed-soaked romp through Southern Africa circa late 19th Century. The plot steamrollers along and breakneck pace, and even the lulls in the action are loaded with meaning and suspense. But let's not over-analyze it - it is what it is. If you like a great, well-rounded historic adventure with exotic locations, women, drinking, fighting and hunting, it doesn't get any better than this. If Hemingway turned the same plots into art forms, Smith just batters you with relentless adventure. If you're new to Wilbur Smith, start at the beginning with the Courtney series or the Ballantyne series. Smith is a shoe-in for the top of the bestseller lists these days, but his foundation was built on these earlier works that are far far better than the very average stuff he's turning out now.





Compelling, 01 Nov 2007
`When the Lion Feeds' is one of those rare books that I was simply unable to put down. It has the right mix of African imagery, historical reference and compelling story line.

If you liked this, you need to check out `Cry of the Justice Bird' by Jon Haylett. You won't be disappointed.

Certainly one of the best novels written., 15 Jul 2007
I've just finished this book for probbaly the fifth or sixth time, i forget which, and it is still as good as the first time i read it about six years ago.

I've since read every one of Wilbur's offerings, so how funny that his first published book should be arguably his best.

Put simply, it's just a great, great story. It has it all. War, Violence, love and tragedy. It paints a beautifull and realistic picture of late 1800s South Africa.

That's all that needs to be said really, just read it for yourself, you won't be dissapointed.

Quite simply, a must read, 16 May 2007
How happy I am that one cold, wet and windy day sitting bored out of my mind, round my grandparents house aged 17 that my grandad gave me his copy of this book. Untill this moment in time the only ones I had ever read were the ones I had to for school!
As soon as I had finished the first page I was hooked, the only time that day the book got put down was to eat dinner & that was under protest!

Smith's fantastic writing style and his descripitive powers are amazing, he brings every page in the book to life and you really do feel that you are living the story with him.

It may now be ten years since I first read this book but that hasn't stoped me re-reading it many times and each time it has been the same compelling read that it was the first time! I have since gone on to read all his works, but for me this still stands out as the best, surley this should go down as one of the great classics of all time.

what a shame, 11 Nov 2008
I love Wilbur smith's books, but this one fell far short of his previous novels. it was far too magical, and far far too far fetched. his strenghts lie in wonderful descriptions of wildlife, hunting and detailed characters. however this book was honestly a pile of nonesense, and i will now hesitate before i purchase my next Wilbur Smith book...

well it passed the time, 09 Nov 2008
Luckily I had read 'River God' etc so long ago so as not to spoil my memories of them, and luckily I only spent a small amount on this book in a charity shop. I happened to be in Egypt on holiday when I read it, so the setting suited mine, and it passed the time on the sun bed and on the plane going home!

I like fantasy, but this seems to be merely the tacky ramblings of an old man, and has nothing whatsoever to do with genuine ancient Egyptian mythology. If things got slow in the endless journeying he just chucked in another battle with another random tribe and even this got boring after a while.

And as for the ending, well really! 'Indiana Potter and the Stem Cell Researchers of Doom'!
So our hero rides off into the sunset with new bits and a new body, and I have a horrible suspicion it might take another book to go and regenerate his woman too - so be warned!
All in all a sad slump for this author.

Taitas Quest or Wilburs?, 25 Oct 2008
I have read all the Wilbur Smith books and have been an avid fan. This one is such a disappointment. The sexual content I found most uncomfortable as the main character an old eunuch lusts after a young girl and strives to restore his lost manhood so that eventually he is able to enjoy a full relationship with the girl. The addition of magic and fantasy to a series that has always had a strong believable streak made me feel I was reading a triple XXX version of Harry Potter. If you are new to Wilbur Smith dont be put off by this one. The others are great reads.

Dreadful, 20 Oct 2008
Avoid this book. It's the most contrived, self-indulgent rubbish I've ever read, and I say that as an avid Clive Cussler fan (!).

a rotten end to a great series of books, 09 Oct 2008
I've read many of WS's books and usually love them. I was looking forward to this, the 4th Taita book and really enjoyed it up until they journey to "Shangri La" and apes are acting as bouncers in the tunnel. Then as I read that Meren's eye is about to be regrown from stem cells, I got completely fed up with the story. Then Taita's penis is regrown and of course, it's much bigger, heavier and better than his original. His love for Fenn who has not yet had her 1st period is a bit pervy as is his move on her once she has! Oh, and then he gets reborn as a 30 year old man - its just gets sillier and sillier - SHAME ON YOU, W.S. This is a sad and crappy end to the wonderful series

River god,Brilliant, 10 Oct 2008
Someone lent me this book to read because they liked it,it was the start of a long long reading experience, I just couldn't put it down and I ended up reading the whole series.Anyone who doesn't like it must lack imagination of this epic story.Totally loved it.

One of my favourite books of all time, 28 Aug 2008
A cleverly written book that will make you think you're reading fact not fiction. The real life settings supported by the obvious extensive research that the author has undertaken.

Read this then read "The Seventh Scroll". Truly enchanting and gripping stuff!

Enthralling, 06 Jun 2008
I returned from a Nile Cruise captivated by the history of Egypt and someone leant me a copy of The Quest. On examination I discovered that this was the 4th of a series, so embarked on a journey starting with River God. This is the first Wilbur Smith book I've read and I was impressed. A good story, well written and from what I can make out from my limited knowledge, historically accurate. At 672 pages, a fairly long read, so will probably leave it a couple of books before I resume my journey with The Seventh Scroll. But still looking forward to it.

Best book, EVER., 16 May 2008
I love this book to distraction! This book has taught me so much about life in Ancient Egypt, love, war and people in general.

I cannot emphasise enough how good this book is, this should be a compulsory read for everyone. This book will stay with you long after you have finished it, which sounds a little cliché but has never been truer for any book that I've read.

In a league of its own, 01 Apr 2008
My words here won't do this book justice! The story is told by Egyptian slave, Taita. He tells the turbulent story of his mistress, Lostris, and her lover, Tanus. The attention to detail is incredible and you really get to love and hate the characters accordingly. Wilbur Smith is a master storyteller. The author's note at the back of the book is also very intriguing!

Seventh Scroll, 06 Jul 2008
Make sure you read River God first then this it is amazing its like an indiana jones film, in fact thay should make a film of it! Its got everything sexy women, hero, bad guys, and a serious adventure, it is a must read and you can read time and time again. brillant!

best ever story teller, 26 Feb 2008
I have read all of Wilbur Smith's books and never fail to enjoy them. I read this when it first came out and was "chuffed" that this carried on the story but in modern times. I have just ordered Quest and look forward to reading this but am reading Warlock again to refresh me. I was inspired by these stories to go to Egypt and while reading Warlock again, I can relate to some of the places. Definitely will be reading these 4 stories again and again, although, knowing Wilbur Smith, he will probably develop this storyline again and again, like his South African books. If you haven't read these, read them as they give great insights into the turbulence of that country. Cannot recommend Wilbur enough for a damn good read!!!

Written for children, 05 Feb 2008
This book reminds me of The Hardy Boys series... Surely no intelligent person over the age of 8 could enjoy the stilted dialogue and pathetically unrealistic actions of the characters??
I think Wilbur Smith has been isolated into a fairy world of chivalry and old fashioned snobbery that leaves me with a sour taste in my mouth. Again Mr. Smith has taken a turn for the worse with this predictable tale.

Very disappointing compared to River God, 06 Dec 2007
After reading the absolutely brilliant River God, I rightfully had huge expectations for The Seventh Scroll.
It is a good book written in classic Wilbur Smith style, but unfortunately it leaves a lot to be desired with its fast paced story, shallow characters and predictable plot.
Smith is definitely a master story teller which can vividly paint the scenes in your mind, but this book seriously lacks the poignancy of his previous work. From this I get the impression that it was mostly written by his editors.

Overall, the book is entertaining and will keep you turning pages, but fails to build on the Egyptian epic started in River God. I seriously hope this book does not mark the series' descent.


Brilliant, 25 Aug 2007
What a great follow up for River God, heroes, heroines, goodies, baddies and all the time dear old Taita is in the background. I could not put this book down, it really is a great read, a breathtaking adventure. Anyone who hasn't read this series, you really need to start with River God before you read this.

Brilliant, 14 Jan 2008
After the somewhat disappointing The Seventh Scroll, I feared the series is deteriorating. Fortunately, Warlock is no disappointment. In fact, in some aspects it's even better than River God! I know is hard to believe, but its true.

Wilbur Smith is a master story-teller, and continues a great epic in superb fashion with his exquisite prose, fascinating characters and captivating story. It is masterfully written and the story's unfolding will surprise the most readers with its twists and turns. It will keep you hooked from start to finish.

It will make to laugh, it will make you cry, it will give you goose-bumps, it will leave you gaping with amazement... Read this book!


Disapointing ending!, 13 Sep 2007
98% of the book was set building up towards the final battle, and then, in the closing pages, the battle is done, the victor does their (brief) thing, then BANG. The end.

It was all very much anti-climatic, but still a bloody good read.

Marked down one for the ending that felt rushed.

EXCELLENT, 07 Mar 2007
This was the third novel I read by Wilbur Smith.I basically bought it because I loved Egyptian history.

It was an excellent story and I enjoyed it. Don't want to say anything about the story because I don't want to spoil it for you.

It was an enjoyable read and the story caught you right from the start, it takes you on a great journey.

Looking forward to the fourth in the series.

Compulsive read. :-)

Brilliant book to read after "River God", 01 Aug 2004
I like to call this a 'Sequal' to 'River God'. Of course, you don't HAVE to read the latter before this, but both are incredibly gripping, and page-turning. Make sure you haven't got anything else to do when you start reading this, because you won't want to stop! Again, excallent if you love Ancient Egypt. The story gets going more or less straight away and its action all the way through!

Warlock: The Egyptians Strike Back, 09 Jul 2004
the original in this trio of books, river god, without a doubt makes my favourite read in the history of my favourite reads. Part 2 , the seventh scroll - flashing forward a few millennia also was fantastic (maybe even top 10). Warlock, going back to ancient Egypt, should have followed in the same success... however as strong as it was, it failed to meet the high bar of its predecessors. I would put it down to the formula being changed. Where as it needed a fresh approach & a new concept to make it a novel in its own rights, I am not entirely convinced that this was the recipe for success. the formula in question is the introduction of magic / wizardry / sorcerous powers / the force (?!). The book is set a few decades after the 1st novel (overlook the fact that taita is probably outlived ancient Egyptian life expectancy many times over!). Queen Lostris is dead, her bloodline is in danger of ending, new powers are emerging in the political arena, and Taita, well taita the hero from river god has left the house of lostris and now is a hermit in the wilderness, studying, praying and doing all things mystical to become a warlock. note the similarities with a character from a well loved series of films? cough! old Ben kenobi, star wars cough! further case study comparisons include a not-so-unique escape from an enemy palace within the novel. "these aren't the droids your looking for..."

Despite being the title character, taita surprisingly takes more of a back seat role. for this I was glad - as a favourite character in river god - his warlocky abilities in this book didn't grip me or allow me to 'believe' in the tale as much. I preferred the action to remain on the 'down to earth' characters. saying that, however, it was refreshing to have taita's presence, as with him, you kinda knew things couldn't go too wrong - especially with those powers...

A big change from river god - is the switch from 1st person narrative to 3rd person. I think I prefer the former option - it adds a lot more personality and opportunity for emotive description. with the tale following many different stories & characters it would have been hard to have a single narrator. Again, a change in the formula from original, possibly taking some of the charm away. However the characterisation, storylines and wilbur's trademark 'romance' remain strong and make up for some of the losses as such. to touch upon the romance, some would describe as too in-your-face and over powering. I disagree. I will say that the encounters seemingly come out of nowhere, are very graphic (in quite a tasteful way), and then disappear just as fast. a number of times whilst reading (as a self-confessed skim reader), I would end a page and question 'did I just read that?' and would have to flick back and re-read just to make sure. its good to be shocked now and again. There are some great character cameos from 1st novel - which I loved even if they were brief. I soon forgot their lack of presence outside the first few chapters as the story gripped me again in true wilbur smith style.

I'm glad I read it, I think the Egyptian series has now brought itself to a well deserved end. For those devotee river god fans - I think its unavoidable to get another taste of taita's tales - although beware, it is a completely different concept / formula from that of #1. still a 'gripper' and a 'hard-to-put-downer' but definitely not river god returns. Any one picking this book up afresh, would suggest getting the background flavour and taste for the series by reading river god & seventh scroll first.

Awesome, 08 Jun 2008
A stunning sequel picking up where the Lion feeds left off in exploding pace and drama. If you enjoyed The lion feeds and have not read this yet then I ask 'What's wrong with you order a copy now!!'

Compelling and moving., 01 Aug 2005
Still new to Wilber Smith and enjoying his work enormously. If adventure is your thing then look no further than this guy. In his second novel we pick up a few years after where we left of in 'When the lion feeds' following spontaneous adventurer Sean Courtney. War is rife is South Africa and we travel with Sean into the Boer war. But soon we learn that a far more bitter battle lies ahead for our hero. A deep family hatred is there for all too see. The way Smith draws you into the story is something special, and you find it hard to put the book down. When something happens to the characters involved, you find yourself taking the punches as they take them. The way the book describes the African topology and climate will create a desire to explore the country yourself. It is easy to see why Smith is so highly rated. He is quite a brilliant writer. Emotional and heart-warming, a fantastic sequel, not to be ignored!

What a follow up!, 13 Jul 2000
After coming back from the wilderness, a rich man once again, only to find himself to have all his Ivory & money taken from him by the Boers, he find himself drawn into a war that divids the country. He has to make his mind up as to which side he will fight for ( & I won't tell you, because it will just ruin it! ) To gat there he has to cross through emeny lines, and it is here that he finds the woman of his dreams, but that would be all to simple. Togeather with this and the war its self, Wilbur Smith turns this into a compelling and exiciteing novel

What a way to continue the Courtney family saga!

When the lion reads, 08 Jun 2008
This story is definatly not what I was expecting, but I THOROUGHLY enjoyed this engrossing read, the main character, Sean, is a real man's man, an excellent creation. Few writers can genuinly shock me but Mr Smith certainly can and does, if you haven't read this yet then do so asap.

The first and best Smith by a mile., 28 Nov 2007
Ah, these were the days - when Wilbur Smith wrote great stuff. Now he writes just average stuff, but in my opinion, When The Lion Feeds will be regarded as one of the best adventures of the genre ever.

Set during the Zulu wars and the subsequent diamond rush, Smith set out as he meant to go on with the outstanding Sean Courtney. A hugely strong man who rampages his way through life, a drinker of strong whisky, a seducer of women and fast with his fists, Smith revolves a whirlwind adventure around him from the killing fields of the veldt, the whorehouses of Natal and the mines of Kimberly.

It's not high-brow literature; it's just a magnificent, blood and greed-soaked romp through Southern Africa circa late 19th Century. The plot steamrollers along and breakneck pace, and even the lulls in the action are loaded with meaning and suspense. But let's not over-analyze it - it is what it is. If you like a great, well-rounded historic adventure with exotic locations, women, drinking, fighting and hunting, it doesn't get any better than this. If Hemingway turned the same plots into art forms, Smith just batters you with relentless adventure. If you're new to Wilbur Smith, start at the beginning with the Courtney series or the Ballantyne series. Smith is a shoe-in for the top of the bestseller lists these days, but his foundation was built on these earlier works that are far far better than the very average stuff he's turning out now.





Compelling, 01 Nov 2007
`When the Lion Feeds' is one of those rare books that I was simply unable to put down. It has the right mix of African imagery, historical reference and compelling story line.

If you liked this, you need to check out `Cry of the Justice Bird' by Jon Haylett. You won't be disappointed.

Certainly one of the best novels written., 15 Jul 2007
I've just finished this book for probbaly the fifth or sixth time, i forget which, and it is still as good as the first time i read it about six years ago.

I've since read every one of Wilbur's offerings, so how funny that his first published book should be arguably his best.

Put simply, it's just a great, great story. It has it all. War, Violence, love and tragedy. It paints a beautifull and realistic picture of late 1800s South Africa.

That's all that needs to be said really, just read it for yourself, you won't be dissapointed.

Quite simply, a must read, 16 May 2007
How happy I am that one cold, wet and windy day sitting bored out of my mind, round my grandparents house aged 17 that my grandad gave me his copy of this book. Untill this moment in time the only ones I had ever read were the ones I had to for school!
As soon as I had finished the first page I was hooked, the only time that day the book got put down was to eat dinner & that was under protest!

Smith's fantastic writing style and his descripitive powers are amazing, he brings every page in the book to life and you really do feel that you are living the story with him.

It may now be ten years since I first read this book but that hasn't stoped me re-reading it many times and each time it has been the same compelling read that it was the first time! I have since gone on to read all his works, but for me this still stands out as the best, surley this should go down as one of the great classics of all time.

Thumpingly good, 02 Jul 2008
This is the 4th Courtney novel, and we learn of how Michael passed (nearly made blub!!) and the amazing series of events that was to follow. What surprised me most is how different this book was to the previous Courtney books and somehow it seems to be all the better for it.

Best of his earlier works, 18 Nov 2005
I was first attracted to Smith not as a writer of novels about Africa, but by his novel 'Birds of Prey' which is a historical sea adventure. I enjoyed that book so bought his two novels set in Ancient Eygpt (River God & Warlock), which were also great. I then bought a couple of books from his two established series, ie Courtney (When the Lion feeds) and Ballantyne (A Falcon Flies). I found these to be rather boring and hard going compared with those I have previously mentioned. This lead me to move on to other authors. However I recently bought 'A Sparrow Falls' and 'The Burning Shore'. These two novels are set at the same time, starting in France in WW1 and ending in post war southern Africa and the main characters from each play small roles in the other. However that is were the similarity ends. 'A Sparrow Falls' is dull and centred on petty rivalry etc which you can see in every day life, while 'The Burning Shore' has all the characteristics that made me love the first few Smith novels I had read. That is adventure along with beautiful description of the exotic world that the novel is set in. The difference in quality of these two novels makes it hard to believe that they are written by the same author. All I can add is buy this book, you will not regret it. I am now going to buy the sequel to this book, and I hope that it will be in the style of this book rather than the two other Courtney novels I have read (Lion and Sparrow).

Couldn't put it down!, 04 Dec 2003
This is a fantastic book. The first book i have read by Wibur Smith. Its full of adventure, twists and turns, not in the least bit predictable. The detail Smith goes into is so well described that you feel that you are actually there or that you lived what the characters are going through. Don't usually cry when i read books, but a certain part of the story brought me to tears. I shall definatley read Smith again. Go read this book and enjoy it just as much as i did!

Wilbur Smith has done it again!, 25 Oct 2000
This is another work of art by Smith. It's a historical adventure like his other novels I have read, with the usual coloring of romance. This novel is however a little different from Smith's others, in that far from the usual plot of people going on missions to discover African treasures, this novel is about a woman who has had, and lost. She had wealth and a good family, and lost it all. She knew love, and lost that too. In the face of all this and as if this is not enough, she suddenly finds herself in a strange land and amongst strange people. Simply existing in this new land is a struggle. As we go through this ordeal with Centaine de Thiry, we find ourselves more riveted as the chapters go by, and we find ourselves learning more about this "dark" continent called Africa. Smith's novels do more than entertain, they educate, and this is what makes them literary genius. This one is no exception.

a rip roaring read, 13 May 2000
What a book, the great author has surpassed himself this time, the delicious imagery and heartfelt emotion will blow your socks off.

what a shame, 11 Nov 2008
I love Wilbur smith's books, but this one fell far short of his previous novels. it was far too magical, and far far too far fetched. his strenghts lie in wonderful descriptions of wildlife, hunting and detailed characters. however this book was honestly a pile of nonesense, and i will now hesitate before i purchase my next Wilbur Smith book...

well it passed the time, 09 Nov 2008
Luckily I had read 'River God' etc so long ago so as not to spoil my memories of them, and luckily I only spent a small amount on this book in a charity shop. I happened to be in Egypt on holiday when I read it, so the setting suited mine, and it passed the time on the sun bed and on the plane going home!

I like fantasy, but this seems to be merely the tacky ramblings of an old man, and has nothing whatsoever to do with genuine ancient Egyptian mythology. If things got slow in the endless journeying he just chucked in another battle with another random tribe and even this got boring after a while.

And as for the ending, well really! 'Indiana Potter and the Stem Cell Researchers of Doom'!
So our hero rides off into the sunset with new bits and a new body, and I have a horrible suspicion it might take another book to go and regenerate his woman too - so be warned!
All in all a sad slump for this author.

Taitas Quest or Wilburs?, 25 Oct 2008
I have read all the Wilbur Smith books and have been an avid fan. This one is such a disappointment. The sexual content I found most uncomfortable as the main character an old eunuch lusts after a young girl and strives to restore his lost manhood so that eventually he is able to enjoy a full relationship with the girl. The addition of magic and fantasy to a series that has always had a strong believable streak made me feel I was reading a triple XXX version of Harry Potter. If you are new to Wilbur Smith dont be put off by this one. The others are great reads.

Dreadful, 20 Oct 2008
Avoid this book. It's the most contrived, self-indulgent rubbish I've ever read, and I say that as an avid Clive Cussler fan (!).

a rotten end to a great series of books, 09 Oct 2008
I've read many of WS's books and usually love them. I was looking forward to this, the 4th Taita book and really enjoyed it up until they journey to "Shangri La" and apes are acting as bouncers in the tunnel. Then as I read that Meren's eye is about to be regrown from stem cells, I got completely fed up with the story. Then Taita's penis is regrown and of course, it's much bigger, heavier and better than his original. His love for Fenn who has not yet had her 1st period is a bit pervy as is his move on her once she has! Oh, and then he gets reborn as a 30 year old man - its just gets sillier and sillier - SHAME ON YOU, W.S. This is a sad and crappy end to the wonderful series

River god,Brilliant, 10 Oct 2008
Someone lent me this book to read because they liked it,it was the start of a long long reading experience, I just couldn't put it down and I ended up reading the whole series.Anyone who doesn't like it must lack imagination of this epic story.Totally loved it.

One of my favourite books of all time, 28 Aug 2008
A cleverly written book that will make you think you're reading fact not fiction. The real life settings supported by the obvious extensive research that the author has undertaken.

Read this