|
Browse categories
|
 |
|
|
|
|
 |
|
|
 Customer Reviews
unbelievable strength, 27 Aug 2008
In a world filled with crime and death, war and poverty, many seek the salvation of religion to overcome.
We hear many stories about cults in America, stories of teenagers leaving then people they love to stay in communes where they are brainwashed, humiliated, abused and used.
This is the true accounts of three sisters who had no choice but to be born into one of these cults, the children of god.
From a very early age these poor children were systematically abused physically and mentally by the adult members of the group.
How these girls triumphed over these sick people astounds me and I congratulate them and hope that their lives are not tainted by these evil people.
This cult is still going and the story of these girls is a warning to us all. This is not easy reading but it is a book one must read.
Disturbing but Courageous, 26 Aug 2008
It is never pleasant to read some disturbing experiences that these young lady's have gone through. I kept questioning myself on why I was reading what I was. My wife, Mother in Law & sister in law all read this book & found it disturbing. The only reason I could find as to why I wanted to read such a book, was in the hope that the 3 lady's were now back together & leading 'normal' lives.
If you are planning to purchase this book, the details, I found, are very explicit. However, the truth has to be known & the truth definitely comes out in this book. Yes I feel extremely sorry for these young lady's knowing that while I was growing up, there were people suffering like they did. These young lady's are very brave. Brave to that fact of making it known the disgusting things these so-called 'adults' put them through & then these 'adults' trying to justify their crimes through the word of the lord.
I can only wish Kristina, Celeste & Juliana well, & congratulate them on their brave fight & wish them well in their continued fight to expose organisations such as the 'Children of God'.
This is a very good, well written, but painful book. The 3 lady's courage can be found to be inspirational & a lesson to us all.
disturbing, 27 Jun 2008
I didn't think I could finish this book. It really effected me that so much evil could still exist in the name of a God that despises child abuse.
The three sisters were very brave to allow this book to go to print and tell the truth. The sad thing is that I believe I met some of the group on a trip to Portugal many years ago, without realising the full extent of the cult's beliefs. I can still see the face of the small little girl who was performing for us...
absolutely fantastic, 27 May 2008
this was the most moving, upsetting, yet amusing at times, book i have read in a very long time. These women are a total inspiration to me and I thank them for sharing thier story with us. I am familiar with the CoG and was interested to read what it was really like from the inside. A gripping and compelling story that was uncomfortable at times but well worth reading.
Truly Wow, 07 May 2008
I chose this book for some reason, from the army of others like these which are on the shelves at them moment. Not knowing anything about the 'CoG' or 'The Family' as I lived in South Africa, and don't think they had much or any contact there. On reading these very well written, and compelling life stories by three amazing woman, I can not help but be thankful for the up bringing I had.
I am truly relieved that they have been able to survive their past, and help others and each other. You girls deserve all the happiness that life can bring.
Thank you for your inspiring lives, and sharing it with us!!!
To those in the Family who reject what these woman say, God will have the final say!
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
Customer Reviews
unbelievable strength, 27 Aug 2008
In a world filled with crime and death, war and poverty, many seek the salvation of religion to overcome.
We hear many stories about cults in America, stories of teenagers leaving then people they love to stay in communes where they are brainwashed, humiliated, abused and used.
This is the true accounts of three sisters who had no choice but to be born into one of these cults, the children of god.
From a very early age these poor children were systematically abused physically and mentally by the adult members of the group.
How these girls triumphed over these sick people astounds me and I congratulate them and hope that their lives are not tainted by these evil people.
This cult is still going and the story of these girls is a warning to us all. This is not easy reading but it is a book one must read.
Disturbing but Courageous, 26 Aug 2008
It is never pleasant to read some disturbing experiences that these young lady's have gone through. I kept questioning myself on why I was reading what I was. My wife, Mother in Law & sister in law all read this book & found it disturbing. The only reason I could find as to why I wanted to read such a book, was in the hope that the 3 lady's were now back together & leading 'normal' lives.
If you are planning to purchase this book, the details, I found, are very explicit. However, the truth has to be known & the truth definitely comes out in this book. Yes I feel extremely sorry for these young lady's knowing that while I was growing up, there were people suffering like they did. These young lady's are very brave. Brave to that fact of making it known the disgusting things these so-called 'adults' put them through & then these 'adults' trying to justify their crimes through the word of the lord.
I can only wish Kristina, Celeste & Juliana well, & congratulate them on their brave fight & wish them well in their continued fight to expose organisations such as the 'Children of God'.
This is a very good, well written, but painful book. The 3 lady's courage can be found to be inspirational & a lesson to us all.
disturbing, 27 Jun 2008
I didn't think I could finish this book. It really effected me that so much evil could still exist in the name of a God that despises child abuse.
The three sisters were very brave to allow this book to go to print and tell the truth. The sad thing is that I believe I met some of the group on a trip to Portugal many years ago, without realising the full extent of the cult's beliefs. I can still see the face of the small little girl who was performing for us...
absolutely fantastic, 27 May 2008
this was the most moving, upsetting, yet amusing at times, book i have read in a very long time. These women are a total inspiration to me and I thank them for sharing thier story with us. I am familiar with the CoG and was interested to read what it was really like from the inside. A gripping and compelling story that was uncomfortable at times but well worth reading.
Truly Wow, 07 May 2008
I chose this book for some reason, from the army of others like these which are on the shelves at them moment. Not knowing anything about the 'CoG' or 'The Family' as I lived in South Africa, and don't think they had much or any contact there. On reading these very well written, and compelling life stories by three amazing woman, I can not help but be thankful for the up bringing I had.
I am truly relieved that they have been able to survive their past, and help others and each other. You girls deserve all the happiness that life can bring.
Thank you for your inspiring lives, and sharing it with us!!!
To those in the Family who reject what these woman say, God will have the final say!
Bravery, 21 Aug 2008
Having read this book from cover to cover I would like to say that Stuart has showed true courage and Bravery throught both his childhood and adulthood. I actually live very near to where this event took place and thank my lucky stars that I had the childhood that I did. I am glad to hear that Stuart is now able to get on with his life with his family (who obviously adore him very much).
Thank you Stuart, for sharing your story with us., 12 Jun 2008
This book is amazing, just like the author. I think its the most horrific story of child abuse I've ever read and I cannot praise Stuart enough for having survived his ordeal and having come out the other side. You're an inspiration to us all and I am so glad you found love with Tracy.
I found the way he was treated while in prison disgusting and I'm glad he spoke up for himself and took those responsible to court! I dont agree with one person's comment that he shouldn't have said to the guards that he'd been abused. He had every right to expect to be treated fairly in prison, ESPECIALLY considering what he'd been through. I hope those prison guards have seen this book and are thoroughly ashamed of themselves.
Read this book. Its important to know and remember always, that abuse happens, it may be happening right now as I type this and we need to keep this message alive so that we can stop it from happening to innocent children.
Thank you once again Stuart, I wish you and your family all the happiness in the world!
A true brave boy.. who turned into a brave man, 06 Apr 2008
Wow.... that sums up this book in one word, i read this book in 1day flat i just couldnt put it down. It was such an gripping story of how a young boy battled his way through everything to become a young man to battle through prison to become a father and part of his own family.. The book was amazing and real heart touching story. Some parts are unbearable to even imagine and i hold the most respect for Stuart Howarth the auther of the book and i loved this book!!
Shocking but gripping read, 23 Mar 2008
If I hadn't read the review on amazon by the author himself and his partner plus the foreword in the book I don't think I could have carried on with reading the book. The story was horrific, more so than any horror story I have read because it actually happened and in my life time too in my area of the world. I didn't have a fab childhood myself and I know how that has affected me so how can Stuart recover? He must be an amazingly strong person and I admire him for that. I couldn't put this book down, I read on and on. I can't wait for the follow on book because I really want to know the rest of the story.
Absolutely unputdownable !, 14 Feb 2008
I didn`t have a great childhood myself and some of the things stuart talks about took me back there - a miserable place that i`m glad to be away from. However, the more i read of stuart`s book, the more i realised that, yes, my own childhood could have been one hell of a lot worse - it could have been as bad as his. I would like to shake this man`s hand and tell him he has much to be proud of-he lost a few battles along the way - but he won the war. Amazing book - amazing man !
|
|
|
 |
|
|
|
Customer Reviews
unbelievable strength, 27 Aug 2008
In a world filled with crime and death, war and poverty, many seek the salvation of religion to overcome.
We hear many stories about cults in America, stories of teenagers leaving then people they love to stay in communes where they are brainwashed, humiliated, abused and used.
This is the true accounts of three sisters who had no choice but to be born into one of these cults, the children of god.
From a very early age these poor children were systematically abused physically and mentally by the adult members of the group.
How these girls triumphed over these sick people astounds me and I congratulate them and hope that their lives are not tainted by these evil people.
This cult is still going and the story of these girls is a warning to us all. This is not easy reading but it is a book one must read.
Disturbing but Courageous, 26 Aug 2008
It is never pleasant to read some disturbing experiences that these young lady's have gone through. I kept questioning myself on why I was reading what I was. My wife, Mother in Law & sister in law all read this book & found it disturbing. The only reason I could find as to why I wanted to read such a book, was in the hope that the 3 lady's were now back together & leading 'normal' lives.
If you are planning to purchase this book, the details, I found, are very explicit. However, the truth has to be known & the truth definitely comes out in this book. Yes I feel extremely sorry for these young lady's knowing that while I was growing up, there were people suffering like they did. These young lady's are very brave. Brave to that fact of making it known the disgusting things these so-called 'adults' put them through & then these 'adults' trying to justify their crimes through the word of the lord.
I can only wish Kristina, Celeste & Juliana well, & congratulate them on their brave fight & wish them well in their continued fight to expose organisations such as the 'Children of God'.
This is a very good, well written, but painful book. The 3 lady's courage can be found to be inspirational & a lesson to us all.
disturbing, 27 Jun 2008
I didn't think I could finish this book. It really effected me that so much evil could still exist in the name of a God that despises child abuse.
The three sisters were very brave to allow this book to go to print and tell the truth. The sad thing is that I believe I met some of the group on a trip to Portugal many years ago, without realising the full extent of the cult's beliefs. I can still see the face of the small little girl who was performing for us...
absolutely fantastic, 27 May 2008
this was the most moving, upsetting, yet amusing at times, book i have read in a very long time. These women are a total inspiration to me and I thank them for sharing thier story with us. I am familiar with the CoG and was interested to read what it was really like from the inside. A gripping and compelling story that was uncomfortable at times but well worth reading.
Truly Wow, 07 May 2008
I chose this book for some reason, from the army of others like these which are on the shelves at them moment. Not knowing anything about the 'CoG' or 'The Family' as I lived in South Africa, and don't think they had much or any contact there. On reading these very well written, and compelling life stories by three amazing woman, I can not help but be thankful for the up bringing I had.
I am truly relieved that they have been able to survive their past, and help others and each other. You girls deserve all the happiness that life can bring.
Thank you for your inspiring lives, and sharing it with us!!!
To those in the Family who reject what these woman say, God will have the final say!
Bravery, 21 Aug 2008
Having read this book from cover to cover I would like to say that Stuart has showed true courage and Bravery throught both his childhood and adulthood. I actually live very near to where this event took place and thank my lucky stars that I had the childhood that I did. I am glad to hear that Stuart is now able to get on with his life with his family (who obviously adore him very much).
Thank you Stuart, for sharing your story with us., 12 Jun 2008
This book is amazing, just like the author. I think its the most horrific story of child abuse I've ever read and I cannot praise Stuart enough for having survived his ordeal and having come out the other side. You're an inspiration to us all and I am so glad you found love with Tracy.
I found the way he was treated while in prison disgusting and I'm glad he spoke up for himself and took those responsible to court! I dont agree with one person's comment that he shouldn't have said to the guards that he'd been abused. He had every right to expect to be treated fairly in prison, ESPECIALLY considering what he'd been through. I hope those prison guards have seen this book and are thoroughly ashamed of themselves.
Read this book. Its important to know and remember always, that abuse happens, it may be happening right now as I type this and we need to keep this message alive so that we can stop it from happening to innocent children.
Thank you once again Stuart, I wish you and your family all the happiness in the world!
A true brave boy.. who turned into a brave man, 06 Apr 2008
Wow.... that sums up this book in one word, i read this book in 1day flat i just couldnt put it down. It was such an gripping story of how a young boy battled his way through everything to become a young man to battle through prison to become a father and part of his own family.. The book was amazing and real heart touching story. Some parts are unbearable to even imagine and i hold the most respect for Stuart Howarth the auther of the book and i loved this book!!
Shocking but gripping read, 23 Mar 2008
If I hadn't read the review on amazon by the author himself and his partner plus the foreword in the book I don't think I could have carried on with reading the book. The story was horrific, more so than any horror story I have read because it actually happened and in my life time too in my area of the world. I didn't have a fab childhood myself and I know how that has affected me so how can Stuart recover? He must be an amazingly strong person and I admire him for that. I couldn't put this book down, I read on and on. I can't wait for the follow on book because I really want to know the rest of the story.
Absolutely unputdownable !, 14 Feb 2008
I didn`t have a great childhood myself and some of the things stuart talks about took me back there - a miserable place that i`m glad to be away from. However, the more i read of stuart`s book, the more i realised that, yes, my own childhood could have been one hell of a lot worse - it could have been as bad as his. I would like to shake this man`s hand and tell him he has much to be proud of-he lost a few battles along the way - but he won the war. Amazing book - amazing man !
An admirable story of courage, 07 Apr 2008
I have nothing but admiration for Celine's courage, tenacity and integrity. She has had the courage to tell her story and persevere through life-difficulties to which many of us would have succumbed. She suffered horribly at the hands of those who should have protected and loved her, but she never waivered in knowing what was good and right and in creating her own loving family.
I hope this book inspires others to shine the light in those dark corners and to have the courage to create a positive life of own's own.
The first edition of the book (not this edition, but one with a reddish cover) does contain some imperfections, but so what. Blame the editors and not the writer. The editors should have done a better job - editing their writers' work IS their job! But, apparently, this, the second edition of this book, has been better edited.
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Customer Reviews
unbelievable strength, 27 Aug 2008
In a world filled with crime and death, war and poverty, many seek the salvation of religion to overcome.
We hear many stories about cults in America, stories of teenagers leaving then people they love to stay in communes where they are brainwashed, humiliated, abused and used.
This is the true accounts of three sisters who had no choice but to be born into one of these cults, the children of god.
From a very early age these poor children were systematically abused physically and mentally by the adult members of the group.
How these girls triumphed over these sick people astounds me and I congratulate them and hope that their lives are not tainted by these evil people.
This cult is still going and the story of these girls is a warning to us all. This is not easy reading but it is a book one must read. Disturbing but Courageous, 26 Aug 2008
It is never pleasant to read some disturbing experiences that these young lady's have gone through. I kept questioning myself on why I was reading what I was. My wife, Mother in Law & sister in law all read this book & found it disturbing. The only reason I could find as to why I wanted to read such a book, was in the hope that the 3 lady's were now back together & leading 'normal' lives.
If you are planning to purchase this book, the details, I found, are very explicit. However, the truth has to be known & the truth definitely comes out in this book. Yes I feel extremely sorry for these young lady's knowing that while I was growing up, there were people suffering like they did. These young lady's are very brave. Brave to that fact of making it known the disgusting things these so-called 'adults' put them through & then these 'adults' trying to justify their crimes through the word of the lord.
I can only wish Kristina, Celeste & Juliana well, & congratulate them on their brave fight & wish them well in their continued fight to expose organisations such as the 'Children of God'.
This is a very good, well written, but painful book. The 3 lady's courage can be found to be inspirational & a lesson to us all. disturbing, 27 Jun 2008
I didn't think I could finish this book. It really effected me that so much evil could still exist in the name of a God that despises child abuse.
The three sisters were very brave to allow this book to go to print and tell the truth. The sad thing is that I believe I met some of the group on a trip to Portugal many years ago, without realising the full extent of the cult's beliefs. I can still see the face of the small little girl who was performing for us... absolutely fantastic, 27 May 2008
this was the most moving, upsetting, yet amusing at times, book i have read in a very long time. These women are a total inspiration to me and I thank them for sharing thier story with us. I am familiar with the CoG and was interested to read what it was really like from the inside. A gripping and compelling story that was uncomfortable at times but well worth reading. Truly Wow, 07 May 2008
I chose this book for some reason, from the army of others like these which are on the shelves at them moment. Not knowing anything about the 'CoG' or 'The Family' as I lived in South Africa, and don't think they had much or any contact there. On reading these very well written, and compelling life stories by three amazing woman, I can not help but be thankful for the up bringing I had.
I am truly relieved that they have been able to survive their past, and help others and each other. You girls deserve all the happiness that life can bring.
Thank you for your inspiring lives, and sharing it with us!!!
To those in the Family who reject what these woman say, God will have the final say!
Bravery, 21 Aug 2008
Having read this book from cover to cover I would like to say that Stuart has showed true courage and Bravery throught both his childhood and adulthood. I actually live very near to where this event took place and thank my lucky stars that I had the childhood that I did. I am glad to hear that Stuart is now able to get on with his life with his family (who obviously adore him very much).
Thank you Stuart, for sharing your story with us., 12 Jun 2008
This book is amazing, just like the author. I think its the most horrific story of child abuse I've ever read and I cannot praise Stuart enough for having survived his ordeal and having come out the other side. You're an inspiration to us all and I am so glad you found love with Tracy.
I found the way he was treated while in prison disgusting and I'm glad he spoke up for himself and took those responsible to court! I dont agree with one person's comment that he shouldn't have said to the guards that he'd been abused. He had every right to expect to be treated fairly in prison, ESPECIALLY considering what he'd been through. I hope those prison guards have seen this book and are thoroughly ashamed of themselves.
Read this book. Its important to know and remember always, that abuse happens, it may be happening right now as I type this and we need to keep this message alive so that we can stop it from happening to innocent children.
Thank you once again Stuart, I wish you and your family all the happiness in the world!
A true brave boy.. who turned into a brave man, 06 Apr 2008
Wow.... that sums up this book in one word, i read this book in 1day flat i just couldnt put it down. It was such an gripping story of how a young boy battled his way through everything to become a young man to battle through prison to become a father and part of his own family.. The book was amazing and real heart touching story. Some parts are unbearable to even imagine and i hold the most respect for Stuart Howarth the auther of the book and i loved this book!! Shocking but gripping read, 23 Mar 2008
If I hadn't read the review on amazon by the author himself and his partner plus the foreword in the book I don't think I could have carried on with reading the book. The story was horrific, more so than any horror story I have read because it actually happened and in my life time too in my area of the world. I didn't have a fab childhood myself and I know how that has affected me so how can Stuart recover? He must be an amazingly strong person and I admire him for that. I couldn't put this book down, I read on and on. I can't wait for the follow on book because I really want to know the rest of the story. Absolutely unputdownable !, 14 Feb 2008
I didn`t have a great childhood myself and some of the things stuart talks about took me back there - a miserable place that i`m glad to be away from. However, the more i read of stuart`s book, the more i realised that, yes, my own childhood could have been one hell of a lot worse - it could have been as bad as his. I would like to shake this man`s hand and tell him he has much to be proud of-he lost a few battles along the way - but he won the war. Amazing book - amazing man ! An admirable story of courage, 07 Apr 2008
I have nothing but admiration for Celine's courage, tenacity and integrity. She has had the courage to tell her story and persevere through life-difficulties to which many of us would have succumbed. She suffered horribly at the hands of those who should have protected and loved her, but she never waivered in knowing what was good and right and in creating her own loving family.
I hope this book inspires others to shine the light in those dark corners and to have the courage to create a positive life of own's own.
The first edition of the book (not this edition, but one with a reddish cover) does contain some imperfections, but so what. Blame the editors and not the writer. The editors should have done a better job - editing their writers' work IS their job! But, apparently, this, the second edition of this book, has been better edited. Informative but lacking, 17 Jan 2008
This is a good read, and disturbingly interesting, but it's also a little out dated and missing vital information, but it is well written and generally objective, neither condemming nor justifying, giving a different view than the one we all imagine on hearing that name 'Mary Bell.' Excellent read for true crime and psychology fans, 08 Nov 2004
I grew up in Newcastle, the city where Mary Bell committed her crimes, in the 1980s and as such was always aware of this case and the "folklore" built up around it in a city that won't forget these awful crimes. As such I was very kean to read "The Case of Mary Bell" to understand more of the truth behind the case and perhaps gain some insight as to how on earth an 11 year old girl comes to murder two innocent little boys. The book has not disappointed me at all. Sereny has produces a fascinating account of the case. She is an excellent writer and as a consequence the book is very readable and her theories clear and easy to follow. Sereny was present throughout Mary's trial and subsequently visited Mary in her detention centre. She has also talked to the the vast majority of the parties involved in the case, from the police to the families of both perpetrator and victims. Her research was clearly very thorough, her presentation of events is clear and it would seem very accurate. Sereny's examination of Mary's character and possible motivations is fascinating and she does not attempt to either condemn her as evil or diminish her responsibility for her crimes. Her opinions on Mary and her co-defendent Norma Bell (no relation to Mary) are interesting, well argued and fair. The examination of the relationship between Mary and Norma was in my opinion particularly interesting as it was key to the case. It was fascinating to read how such a young child could so manipulate an older girl and indeed the adults around her for her own ends. At the time this book was originally written, the 1970s, not much was really known about Mary's background, but Sereny has gathered as much information as she could and produces some good reasoning on what made Mary kill as a result. Her family is looked into in depth, at least as much as the family was willing to reveal at the time. The first hand information they provide is very valuable in understanding the whole case. Interviews with those in the community as a whole also provide a fascinating insight into how these crimes affected a whole community for many years and still affects it, I believe, today. Sereny also discusses the way the justice system treats children who kill and again produces some interesting thoughts on this. While it is clear Sereny has sympathy with Mary and Norma, and does not like the way the system treats such children, her analysis is both fair and constructive. Her examination of the trial process is thorough and I also found it fascinating to see how children are interviewed by the police in such matters. The book, though written some time ago, is still highly relevant today in our increasingly violent and disillusioned society. In this new edition Sereny has added a short but interesting and thought provoking section on the Bulger case from the 1990s which presents some interesting theories and also shows how little has changed in the years between the two cases, both in society as a whole and the attitude towards such children, and also in the justice system. Indeed it seems little has changed even today and another such killer could well be in the making now. Overall this is an excellent and important text in our modern culture and a must for those interested in true crime and psychology.
Eerily compelling and compassionate, 15 Mar 2003
Gitta Sereny's study is split into two halves - a blow-by-blow account of the trial, and an analysis of the familial background and social circumstances of Mary Bell's life as well as her detention after her conviction of manslaughter on two counts, due to diminished responsiblity. Essentially, Mary Bell murdered two small boys at the age of eleven in 1968, and in the second case the boy was evidently throttled, before having the initial "M" carved into his stomach after death with a razor blade, and his face sprinkled with flowers. What is most remarkable and distressing is the extent to which Mary sought attention and boasted of her crimes in notes she and her cohort, Norma Bell (no relation, acquitted of charges of murder and manslaughter), left in a nursery which they broke into, and displayed aberrant and classically psychopathic behaviour after the incident. What is essential is that this case study is approached with an open mind, for it is a liberal social study which lays much of the blame of society for the "cries unheard", the title of the follow-up to this study. It is fair and humane, as well as perceptive and informative. As Sereny herself would say, it is compassionate without being sentimental. An essential read for those troubled or concerned by child psychopaths and the reform of the social security and welfare system in the U.K..
slow paced yet interesting, 06 Dec 2000
this is an informative account of the child murderer Mary Bell. The author investigates the potrayal of the child as evil, the role of her accomplice, and the media attention received. The book gives a general overview of the case and whilst it is interesting it is quite a slow read.
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Customer Reviews
unbelievable strength, 27 Aug 2008
In a world filled with crime and death, war and poverty, many seek the salvation of religion to overcome.
We hear many stories about cults in America, stories of teenagers leaving then people they love to stay in communes where they are brainwashed, humiliated, abused and used.
This is the true accounts of three sisters who had no choice but to be born into one of these cults, the children of god.
From a very early age these poor children were systematically abused physically and mentally by the adult members of the group.
How these girls triumphed over these sick people astounds me and I congratulate them and hope that their lives are not tainted by these evil people.
This cult is still going and the story of these girls is a warning to us all. This is not easy reading but it is a book one must read. Disturbing but Courageous, 26 Aug 2008
It is never pleasant to read some disturbing experiences that these young lady's have gone through. I kept questioning myself on why I was reading what I was. My wife, Mother in Law & sister in law all read this book & found it disturbing. The only reason I could find as to why I wanted to read such a book, was in the hope that the 3 lady's were now back together & leading 'normal' lives.
If you are planning to purchase this book, the details, I found, are very explicit. However, the truth has to be known & the truth definitely comes out in this book. Yes I feel extremely sorry for these young lady's knowing that while I was growing up, there were people suffering like they did. These young lady's are very brave. Brave to that fact of making it known the disgusting things these so-called 'adults' put them through & then these 'adults' trying to justify their crimes through the word of the lord.
I can only wish Kristina, Celeste & Juliana well, & congratulate them on their brave fight & wish them well in their continued fight to expose organisations such as the 'Children of God'.
This is a very good, well written, but painful book. The 3 lady's courage can be found to be inspirational & a lesson to us all. disturbing, 27 Jun 2008
I didn't think I could finish this book. It really effected me that so much evil could still exist in the name of a God that despises child abuse.
The three sisters were very brave to allow this book to go to print and tell the truth. The sad thing is that I believe I met some of the group on a trip to Portugal many years ago, without realising the full extent of the cult's beliefs. I can still see the face of the small little girl who was performing for us... absolutely fantastic, 27 May 2008
this was the most moving, upsetting, yet amusing at times, book i have read in a very long time. These women are a total inspiration to me and I thank them for sharing thier story with us. I am familiar with the CoG and was interested to read what it was really like from the inside. A gripping and compelling story that was uncomfortable at times but well worth reading. Truly Wow, 07 May 2008
I chose this book for some reason, from the army of others like these which are on the shelves at them moment. Not knowing anything about the 'CoG' or 'The Family' as I lived in South Africa, and don't think they had much or any contact there. On reading these very well written, and compelling life stories by three amazing woman, I can not help but be thankful for the up bringing I had.
I am truly relieved that they have been able to survive their past, and help others and each other. You girls deserve all the happiness that life can bring.
Thank you for your inspiring lives, and sharing it with us!!!
To those in the Family who reject what these woman say, God will have the final say!
Bravery, 21 Aug 2008
Having read this book from cover to cover I would like to say that Stuart has showed true courage and Bravery throught both his childhood and adulthood. I actually live very near to where this event took place and thank my lucky stars that I had the childhood that I did. I am glad to hear that Stuart is now able to get on with his life with his family (who obviously adore him very much).
Thank you Stuart, for sharing your story with us., 12 Jun 2008
This book is amazing, just like the author. I think its the most horrific story of child abuse I've ever read and I cannot praise Stuart enough for having survived his ordeal and having come out the other side. You're an inspiration to us all and I am so glad you found love with Tracy.
I found the way he was treated while in prison disgusting and I'm glad he spoke up for himself and took those responsible to court! I dont agree with one person's comment that he shouldn't have said to the guards that he'd been abused. He had every right to expect to be treated fairly in prison, ESPECIALLY considering what he'd been through. I hope those prison guards have seen this book and are thoroughly ashamed of themselves.
Read this book. Its important to know and remember always, that abuse happens, it may be happening right now as I type this and we need to keep this message alive so that we can stop it from happening to innocent children.
Thank you once again Stuart, I wish you and your family all the happiness in the world!
A true brave boy.. who turned into a brave man, 06 Apr 2008
Wow.... that sums up this book in one word, i read this book in 1day flat i just couldnt put it down. It was such an gripping story of how a young boy battled his way through everything to become a young man to battle through prison to become a father and part of his own family.. The book was amazing and real heart touching story. Some parts are unbearable to even imagine and i hold the most respect for Stuart Howarth the auther of the book and i loved this book!! Shocking but gripping read, 23 Mar 2008
If I hadn't read the review on amazon by the author himself and his partner plus the foreword in the book I don't think I could have carried on with reading the book. The story was horrific, more so than any horror story I have read because it actually happened and in my life time too in my area of the world. I didn't have a fab childhood myself and I know how that has affected me so how can Stuart recover? He must be an amazingly strong person and I admire him for that. I couldn't put this book down, I read on and on. I can't wait for the follow on book because I really want to know the rest of the story. Absolutely unputdownable !, 14 Feb 2008
I didn`t have a great childhood myself and some of the things stuart talks about took me back there - a miserable place that i`m glad to be away from. However, the more i read of stuart`s book, the more i realised that, yes, my own childhood could have been one hell of a lot worse - it could have been as bad as his. I would like to shake this man`s hand and tell him he has much to be proud of-he lost a few battles along the way - but he won the war. Amazing book - amazing man ! An admirable story of courage, 07 Apr 2008
I have nothing but admiration for Celine's courage, tenacity and integrity. She has had the courage to tell her story and persevere through life-difficulties to which many of us would have succumbed. She suffered horribly at the hands of those who should have protected and loved her, but she never waivered in knowing what was good and right and in creating her own loving family.
I hope this book inspires others to shine the light in those dark corners and to have the courage to create a positive life of own's own.
The first edition of the book (not this edition, but one with a reddish cover) does contain some imperfections, but so what. Blame the editors and not the writer. The editors should have done a better job - editing their writers' work IS their job! But, apparently, this, the second edition of this book, has been better edited. Informative but lacking, 17 Jan 2008
This is a good read, and disturbingly interesting, but it's also a little out dated and missing vital information, but it is well written and generally objective, neither condemming nor justifying, giving a different view than the one we all imagine on hearing that name 'Mary Bell.' Excellent read for true crime and psychology fans, 08 Nov 2004
I grew up in Newcastle, the city where Mary Bell committed her crimes, in the 1980s and as such was always aware of this case and the "folklore" built up around it in a city that won't forget these awful crimes. As such I was very kean to read "The Case of Mary Bell" to understand more of the truth behind the case and perhaps gain some insight as to how on earth an 11 year old girl comes to murder two innocent little boys. The book has not disappointed me at all. Sereny has produces a fascinating account of the case. She is an excellent writer and as a consequence the book is very readable and her theories clear and easy to follow. Sereny was present throughout Mary's trial and subsequently visited Mary in her detention centre. She has also talked to the the vast majority of the parties involved in the case, from the police to the families of both perpetrator and victims. Her research was clearly very thorough, her presentation of events is clear and it would seem very accurate. Sereny's examination of Mary's character and possible motivations is fascinating and she does not attempt to either condemn her as evil or diminish her responsibility for her crimes. Her opinions on Mary and her co-defendent Norma Bell (no relation to Mary) are interesting, well argued and fair. The examination of the relationship between Mary and Norma was in my opinion particularly interesting as it was key to the case. It was fascinating to read how such a young child could so manipulate an older girl and indeed the adults around her for her own ends. At the time this book was originally written, the 1970s, not much was really known about Mary's background, but Sereny has gathered as much information as she could and produces some good reasoning on what made Mary kill as a result. Her family is looked into in depth, at least as much as the family was willing to reveal at the time. The first hand information they provide is very valuable in understanding the whole case. Interviews with those in the community as a whole also provide a fascinating insight into how these crimes affected a whole community for many years and still affects it, I believe, today. Sereny also discusses the way the justice system treats children who kill and again produces some interesting thoughts on this. While it is clear Sereny has sympathy with Mary and Norma, and does not like the way the system treats such children, her analysis is both fair and constructive. Her examination of the trial process is thorough and I also found it fascinating to see how children are interviewed by the police in such matters. The book, though written some time ago, is still highly relevant today in our increasingly violent and disillusioned society. In this new edition Sereny has added a short but interesting and thought provoking section on the Bulger case from the 1990s which presents some interesting theories and also shows how little has changed in the years between the two cases, both in society as a whole and the attitude towards such children, and also in the justice system. Indeed it seems little has changed even today and another such killer could well be in the making now. Overall this is an excellent and important text in our modern culture and a must for those interested in true crime and psychology.
Eerily compelling and compassionate, 15 Mar 2003
Gitta Sereny's study is split into two halves - a blow-by-blow account of the trial, and an analysis of the familial background and social circumstances of Mary Bell's life as well as her detention after her conviction of manslaughter on two counts, due to diminished responsiblity. Essentially, Mary Bell murdered two small boys at the age of eleven in 1968, and in the second case the boy was evidently throttled, before having the initial "M" carved into his stomach after death with a razor blade, and his face sprinkled with flowers. What is most remarkable and distressing is the extent to which Mary sought attention and boasted of her crimes in notes she and her cohort, Norma Bell (no relation, acquitted of charges of murder and manslaughter), left in a nursery which they broke into, and displayed aberrant and classically psychopathic behaviour after the incident. What is essential is that this case study is approached with an open mind, for it is a liberal social study which lays much of the blame of society for the "cries unheard", the title of the follow-up to this study. It is fair and humane, as well as perceptive and informative. As Sereny herself would say, it is compassionate without being sentimental. An essential read for those troubled or concerned by child psychopaths and the reform of the social security and welfare system in the U.K..
slow paced yet interesting, 06 Dec 2000
this is an informative account of the child murderer Mary Bell. The author investigates the potrayal of the child as evil, the role of her accomplice, and the media attention received. The book gives a general overview of the case and whilst it is interesting it is quite a slow read.
A story of true courage, 22 May 2008
Sarah's Story managed to stir so many different emotions in me as the reader. It made me cry with heartfelt sorrow, it made me angry, it shocked and filled me with an overwhelming need for justice for Sarah and all the other abused children who's story we may not read but is just as real as Sarah's. Sarah's Story also managed to fill me with a sense of admiration at the courage shown by a little girl, who, against all odds, managed to find the courage to stop the abuse.
It is a truly inspirational story of how the wrong kind of love can destroy a child's life, and how the right kind of love can be instrumental in that child's recovery and freedom. If ever there was a story to inspire other abused children to have hope and strength, this is it.
Moving and inspirational, 07 Apr 2008
I feel I should review Sarah's book and give her the acknowledgement she deserves as an author. 'Sarah's Story', (Living with the Past), is a harrowing story and although her journey through life was not one of physical abuse, the sexual abuse she, and others like her suffered in their lives, is no less harrowing than Dave Peltzers. How do you measure such acts of betrayal against any child?
Amazon request book reviews, not comments about a book being published under a different title. I am sure that Sarah had no part in her publishers decision to publish her story in paperback using a different title. (I'm sure they aren't the first or last to do this). Stay strong Sarah and be a true survivor. You and all the other writers, who care and relive their horrific memories, in order to tell their stories to the world continue to educate us all on the true scale of the atrocities of sexual abuse against children.
|
|
|
 |
As I Lay Me Down to Sleep
|
Eileen MunroCarol McKay;
;
|
|
Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days
*Best price found from Amazon Marketplace seller
|
*Amazon: £2.30
|
|
Customer Reviews
unbelievable strength, 27 Aug 2008
In a world filled with crime and death, war and poverty, many seek the salvation of religion to overcome.
We hear many stories about cults in America, stories of teenagers leaving then people they love to stay in communes where they are brainwashed, humiliated, abused and used.
This is the true accounts of three sisters who had no choice but to be born into one of these cults, the children of god.
From a very early age these poor children were systematically abused physically and mentally by the adult members of the group.
How these girls triumphed over these sick people astounds me and I congratulate them and hope that their lives are not tainted by these evil people.
This cult is still going and the story of these girls is a warning to us all. This is not easy reading but it is a book one must read. Disturbing but Courageous, 26 Aug 2008
It is never pleasant to read some disturbing experiences that these young lady's have gone through. I kept questioning myself on why I was reading what I was. My wife, Mother in Law & sister in law all read this book & found it disturbing. The only reason I could find as to why I wanted to read such a book, was in the hope that the 3 lady's were now back together & leading 'normal' lives.
If you are planning to purchase this book, the details, I found, are very explicit. However, the truth has to be known & the truth definitely comes out in this book. Yes I feel extremely sorry for these young lady's knowing that while I was growing up, there were people suffering like they did. These young lady's are very brave. Brave to that fact of making it known the disgusting things these so-called 'adults' put them through & then these 'adults' trying to justify their crimes through the word of the lord.
I can only wish Kristina, Celeste & Juliana well, & congratulate them on their brave fight & wish them well in their continued fight to expose organisations such as the 'Children of God'.
This is a very good, well written, but painful book. The 3 lady's courage can be found to be inspirational & a lesson to us all. disturbing, 27 Jun 2008
I didn't think I could finish this book. It really effected me that so much evil could still exist in the name of a God that despises child abuse.
The three sisters were very brave to allow this book to go to print and tell the truth. The sad thing is that I believe I met some of the group on a trip to Portugal many years ago, without realising the full extent of the cult's beliefs. I can still see the face of the small little girl who was performing for us... absolutely fantastic, 27 May 2008
this was the most moving, upsetting, yet amusing at times, book i have read in a very long time. These women are a total inspiration to me and I thank them for sharing thier story with us. I am familiar with the CoG and was interested to read what it was really like from the inside. A gripping and compelling story that was uncomfortable at times but well worth reading. Truly Wow, 07 May 2008
I chose this book for some reason, from the army of others like these which are on the shelves at them moment. Not knowing anything about the 'CoG' or 'The Family' as I lived in South Africa, and don't think they had much or any contact there. On reading these very well written, and compelling life stories by three amazing woman, I can not help but be thankful for the up bringing I had.
I am truly relieved that they have been able to survive their past, and help others and each other. You girls deserve all the happiness that life can bring.
Thank you for your inspiring lives, and sharing it with us!!!
To those in the Family who reject what these woman say, God will have the final say!
Bravery, 21 Aug 2008
Having read this book from cover to cover I would like to say that Stuart has showed true courage and Bravery throught both his childhood and adulthood. I actually live very near to where this event took place and thank my lucky stars that I had the childhood that I did. I am glad to hear that Stuart is now able to get on with his life with his family (who obviously adore him very much).
Thank you Stuart, for sharing your story with us., 12 Jun 2008
This book is amazing, just like the author. I think its the most horrific story of child abuse I've ever read and I cannot praise Stuart enough for having survived his ordeal and having come out the other side. You're an inspiration to us all and I am so glad you found love with Tracy.
I found the way he was treated while in prison disgusting and I'm glad he spoke up for himself and took those responsible to court! I dont agree with one person's comment that he shouldn't have said to the guards that he'd been abused. He had every right to expect to be treated fairly in prison, ESPECIALLY considering what he'd been through. I hope those prison guards have seen this book and are thoroughly ashamed of themselves.
Read this book. Its important to know and remember always, that abuse happens, it may be happening right now as I type this and we need to keep this message alive so that we can stop it from happening to innocent children.
Thank you once again Stuart, I wish you and your family all the happiness in the world!
A true brave boy.. who turned into a brave man, 06 Apr 2008
Wow.... that sums up this book in one word, i read this book in 1day flat i just couldnt put it down. It was such an gripping story of how a young boy battled his way through everything to become a young man to battle through prison to become a father and part of his own family.. The book was amazing and real heart touching story. Some parts are unbearable to even imagine and i hold the most respect for Stuart Howarth the auther of the book and i loved this book!! Shocking but gripping read, 23 Mar 2008
If I hadn't read the review on amazon by the author himself and his partner plus the foreword in the book I don't think I could have carried on with reading the book. The story was horrific, more so than any horror story I have read because it actually happened and in my life time too in my area of the world. I didn't have a fab childhood myself and I know how that has affected me so how can Stuart recover? He must be an amazingly strong person and I admire him for that. I couldn't put this book down, I read on and on. I can't wait for the follow on book because I really want to know the rest of the story. Absolutely unputdownable !, 14 Feb 2008
I didn`t have a great childhood myself and some of the things stuart talks about took me back there - a miserable place that i`m glad to be away from. However, the more i read of stuart`s book, the more i realised that, yes, my own childhood could have been one hell of a lot worse - it could have been as bad as his. I would like to shake this man`s hand and tell him he has much to be proud of-he lost a few battles along the way - but he won the war. Amazing book - amazing man ! An admirable story of courage, 07 Apr 2008
I have nothing but admiration for Celine's courage, tenacity and integrity. She has had the courage to tell her story and persevere through life-difficulties to which many of us would have succumbed. She suffered horribly at the hands of those who should have protected and loved her, but she never waivered in knowing what was good and right and in creating her own loving family.
I hope this book inspires others to shine the light in those dark corners and to have the courage to create a positive life of own's own.
The first edition of the book (not this edition, but one with a reddish cover) does contain some imperfections, but so what. Blame the editors and not the writer. The editors should have done a better job - editing their writers' work IS their job! But, apparently, this, the second edition of this book, has been better edited. Informative but lacking, 17 Jan 2008
This is a good read, and disturbingly interesting, but it's also a little out dated and missing vital information, but it is well written and generally objective, neither condemming nor justifying, giving a different view than the one we all imagine on hearing that name 'Mary Bell.' Excellent read for true crime and psychology fans, 08 Nov 2004
I grew up in Newcastle, the city where Mary Bell committed her crimes, in the 1980s and as such was always aware of this case and the "folklore" built up around it in a city that won't forget these awful crimes. As such I was very kean to read "The Case of Mary Bell" to understand more of the truth behind the case and perhaps gain some insight as to how on earth an 11 year old girl comes to murder two innocent little boys. The book has not disappointed me at all. Sereny has produces a fascinating account of the case. She is an excellent writer and as a consequence the book is very readable and her theories clear and easy to follow. Sereny was present throughout Mary's trial and subsequently visited Mary in her detention centre. She has also talked to the the vast majority of the parties involved in the case, from the police to the families of both perpetrator and victims. Her research was clearly very thorough, her presentation of events is clear and it would seem very accurate. Sereny's examination of Mary's character and possible motivations is fascinating and she does not attempt to either condemn her as evil or diminish her responsibility for her crimes. Her opinions on Mary and her co-defendent Norma Bell (no relation to Mary) are interesting, well argued and fair. The examination of the relationship between Mary and Norma was in my opinion particularly interesting as it was key to the case. It was fascinating to read how such a young child could so manipulate an older girl and indeed the adults around her for her own ends. At the time this book was originally written, the 1970s, not much was really known about Mary's background, but Sereny has gathered as much information as she could and produces some good reasoning on what made Mary kill as a result. Her family is looked into in depth, at least as much as the family was willing to reveal at the time. The first hand information they provide is very valuable in understanding the whole case. Interviews with those in the community as a whole also provide a fascinating insight into how these crimes affected a whole community for many years and still affects it, I believe, today. Sereny also discusses the way the justice system treats children who kill and again produces some interesting thoughts on this. While it is clear Sereny has sympathy with Mary and Norma, and does not like the way the system treats such children, her analysis is both fair and constructive. Her examination of the trial process is thorough and I also found it fascinating to see how children are interviewed by the police in such matters. The book, though written some time ago, is still highly relevant today in our increasingly violent and disillusioned society. In this new edition Sereny has added a short but interesting and thought provoking section on the Bulger case from the 1990s which presents some interesting theories and also shows how little has changed in the years between the two cases, both in society as a whole and the attitude towards such children, and also in the justice system. Indeed it seems little has changed even today and another such killer could well be in the making now. Overall this is an excellent and important text in our modern culture and a must for those interested in true crime and psychology.
Eerily compelling and compassionate, 15 Mar 2003
Gitta Sereny's study is split into two halves - a blow-by-blow account of the trial, and an analysis of the familial background and social circumstances of Mary Bell's life as well as her detention after her conviction of manslaughter on two counts, due to diminished responsiblity. Essentially, Mary Bell murdered two small boys at the age of eleven in 1968, and in the second case the boy was evidently throttled, before having the initial "M" carved into his stomach after death with a razor blade, and his face sprinkled with flowers. What is most remarkable and distressing is the extent to which Mary sought attention and boasted of her crimes in notes she and her cohort, Norma Bell (no relation, acquitted of charges of murder and manslaughter), left in a nursery which they broke into, and displayed aberrant and classically psychopathic behaviour after the incident. What is essential is that this case study is approached with an open mind, for it is a liberal social study which lays much of the blame of society for the "cries unheard", the title of the follow-up to this study. It is fair and humane, as well as perceptive and informative. As Sereny herself would say, it is compassionate without being sentimental. An essential read for those troubled or concerned by child psychopaths and the reform of the social security and welfare system in the U.K..
slow paced yet interesting, 06 Dec 2000
this is an informative account of the child murderer Mary Bell. The author investigates the potrayal of the child as evil, the role of her accomplice, and the media attention received. The book gives a general overview of the case and whilst it is interesting it is quite a slow read.
A story of true courage, 22 May 2008
Sarah's Story managed to stir so many different emotions in me as the reader. It made me cry with heartfelt sorrow, it made me angry, it shocked and filled me with an overwhelming need for justice for Sarah and all the other abused children who's story we may not read but is just as real as Sarah's. Sarah's Story also managed to fill me with a sense of admiration at the courage shown by a little girl, who, against all odds, managed to find the courage to stop the abuse.
It is a truly inspirational story of how the wrong kind of love can destroy a child's life, and how the right kind of love can be instrumental in that child's recovery and freedom. If ever there was a story to inspire other abused children to have hope and strength, this is it.
Moving and inspirational, 07 Apr 2008
I feel I should review Sarah's book and give her the acknowledgement she deserves as an author. 'Sarah's Story', (Living with the Past), is a harrowing story and although her journey through life was not one of physical abuse, the sexual abuse she, and others like her suffered in their lives, is no less harrowing than Dave Peltzers. How do you measure such acts of betrayal against any child?
Amazon request book reviews, not comments about a book being published under a different title. I am sure that Sarah had no part in her publishers decision to publish her story in paperback using a different title. (I'm sure they aren't the first or last to do this). Stay strong Sarah and be a true survivor. You and all the other writers, who care and relive their horrific memories, in order to tell their stories to the world continue to educate us all on the true scale of the atrocities of sexual abuse against children.
A movie adaptation must follow, 07 Nov 2008
Forget the raft of misery lit clogging up the bookshops. Yes, this is the story of a young girl from birth to sixteen. She was adopted,abused, neglected by individuals and institutions. But this book for all the familiar subject matter is written in such an honest, straight-forward, unembellished way as to set it apart from the rest.
It is a rollercoaster ride of a read, in which a girl, adrift in a society which constantly overlooks her needs and potential, tries to cope.She copes, mainly using her mantra of "Nothing in, nothing out."
So powerful was this book that I read it in one sitting and I would highly recommend it. It's not misery lit but it is a powerfully moving read.
|
|
|
 |
|
Broken
Usually dispatched within 1-2 business days
*Best price found from Amazon Marketplace seller
|
*Amazon: £0.81
|
|
Customer Reviews
unbelievable strength, 27 Aug 2008
In a world filled with crime and death, war and poverty, many seek the salvation of religion to overcome.
We hear many stories about cults in America, stories of teenagers leaving then people they love to stay in communes where they are brainwashed, humiliated, abused and used.
This is the true accounts of three sisters who had no choice but to be born into one of these cults, the children of god.
From a very early age these poor children were systematically abused physically and mentally by the adult members of the group.
How these girls triumphed over these sick people astounds me and I congratulate them and hope that their lives are not tainted by these evil people.
This cult is still going and the story of these girls is a warning to us all. This is not easy reading but it is a book one must read. Disturbing but Courageous, 26 Aug 2008
It is never pleasant to read some disturbing experiences that these young lady's have gone through. I kept questioning myself on why I was reading what I was. My wife, Mother in Law & sister in law all read this book & found it disturbing. The only reason I could find as to why I wanted to read such a book, was in the hope that the 3 lady's were now back together & leading 'normal' lives.
If you are planning to purchase this book, the details, I found, are very explicit. However, the truth has to be known & the truth definitely comes out in this book. Yes I feel extremely sorry for these young lady's knowing that while I was growing up, there were people suffering like they did. These young lady's are very brave. Brave to that fact of making it known the disgusting things these so-called 'adults' put them through & then these 'adults' trying to justify their crimes through the word of the lord.
I can only wish Kristina, Celeste & Juliana well, & congratulate them on their brave fight & wish them well in their continued fight to expose organisations such as the 'Children of God'.
This is a very good, well written, but painful book. The 3 lady's courage can be found to be inspirational & a lesson to us all. disturbing, 27 Jun 2008
I didn't think I could finish this book. It really effected me that so much evil could still exist in the name of a God that despises child abuse.
The three sisters were very brave to allow this book to go to print and tell the truth. The sad thing is that I believe I met some of the group on a trip to Portugal many years ago, without realising the full extent of the cult's beliefs. I can still see the face of the small little girl who was performing for us... absolutely fantastic, 27 May 2008
this was the most moving, upsetting, yet amusing at times, book i have read in a very long time. These women are a total inspiration to me and I thank them for sharing thier story with us. I am familiar with the CoG and was interested to read what it was really like from the inside. A gripping and compelling story that was uncomfortable at times but well worth reading. Truly Wow, 07 May 2008
I chose this book for some reason, from the army of others like these which are on the shelves at them moment. Not knowing anything about the 'CoG' or 'The Family' as I lived in South Africa, and don't think they had much or any contact there. On reading these very well written, and compelling life stories by three amazing woman, I can not help but be thankful for the up bringing I had.
I am truly relieved that they have been able to survive their past, and help others and each other. You girls deserve all the happiness that life can bring.
Thank you for your inspiring lives, and sharing it with us!!!
To those in the Family who reject what these woman say, God will have the final say!
Bravery, 21 Aug 2008
Having read this book from cover to cover I would like to say that Stuart has showed true courage and Bravery throught both his childhood and adulthood. I actually live very near to where this event took place and thank my lucky stars that I had the childhood that I did. I am glad to hear that Stuart is now able to get on with his life with his family (who obviously adore him very much).
Thank you Stuart, for sharing your story with us., 12 Jun 2008
This book is amazing, just like the author. I think its the most horrific story of child abuse I've ever read and I cannot praise Stuart enough for having survived his ordeal and having come out the other side. You're an inspiration to us all and I am so glad you found love with Tracy.
I found the way he was treated while in prison disgusting and I'm glad he spoke up for himself and took those responsible to court! I dont agree with one person's comment that he shouldn't have said to the guards that he'd been abused. He had every right to expect to be treated fairly in prison, ESPECIALLY considering what he'd been through. I hope those prison guards have seen this book and are thoroughly ashamed of themselves.
Read this book. Its important to know and remember always, that abuse happens, it may be happening right now as I type this and we need to keep this message alive so that we can stop it from happening to innocent children.
Thank you once again Stuart, I wish you and your family all the happiness in the world!
A true brave boy.. who turned into a brave man, 06 Apr 2008
Wow.... that sums up this book in one word, i read this book in 1day flat i just couldnt put it down. It was such an gripping story of how a young boy battled his way through everything to become a young man to battle through prison to become a father and part of his own family.. The book was amazing and real heart touching story. Some parts are unbearable to even imagine and i hold the most respect for Stuart Howarth the auther of the book and i loved this book!! Shocking but gripping read, 23 Mar 2008
If I hadn't read the review on amazon by the author himself and his partner plus the foreword in the book I don't think I could have carried on with reading the book. The story was horrific, more so than any horror story I have read because it actually happened and in my life time too in my area of the world. I didn't have a fab childhood myself and I know how that has affected me so how can Stuart recover? He must be an amazingly strong person and I admire him for that. I couldn't put this book down, I read on and on. I can't wait for the follow on book because I really want to know the rest of the story. Absolutely unputdownable !, 14 Feb 2008
I didn`t have a great childhood myself and some of the things stuart talks about took me back there - a miserable place that i`m glad to be away from. However, the more i read of stuart`s book, the more i realised that, yes, my own childhood could have been one hell of a lot worse - it could have been as bad as his. I would like to shake this man`s hand and tell him he has much to be proud of-he lost a few battles along the way - but he won the war. Amazing book - amazing man ! An admirable story of courage, 07 Apr 2008
I have nothing but admiration for Celine's courage, tenacity and integrity. She has had the courage to tell her story and persevere through life-difficulties to which many of us would have succumbed. She suffered horribly at the hands of those who should have protected and loved her, but she never waivered in knowing what was good and right and in creating her own loving family.
I hope this book inspires others to shine the light in those dark corners and to have the courage to create a positive life of own's own.
The first edition of the book (not this edition, but one with a reddish cover) does contain some imperfections, but so what. Blame the editors and not the writer. The editors should have done a better job - editing their writers' work IS their job! But, apparently, this, the second edition of this book, has been better edited. Informative but lacking, 17 Jan 2008
This is a good read, and disturbingly interesting, but it's also a little out dated and missing vital information, but it is well written and generally objective, neither condemming nor justifying, giving a different view than the one we all imagine on hearing that name 'Mary Bell.' Excellent read for true crime and psychology fans, 08 Nov 2004
I grew up in Newcastle, the city where Mary Bell committed her crimes, in the 1980s and as such was always aware of this case and the "folklore" built up around it in a city that won't forget these awful crimes. As such I was very kean to read "The Case of Mary Bell" to understand more of the truth behind the case and perhaps gain some insight as to how on earth an 11 year old girl comes to murder two innocent little boys. The book has not disappointed me at all. Sereny has produces a fascinating account of the case. She is an excellent writer and as a consequence the book is very readable and her theories clear and easy to follow. Sereny was present throughout Mary's trial and subsequently visited Mary in her detention centre. She has also talked to the the vast majority of the parties involved in the case, from the police to the families of both perpetrator and victims. Her research was clearly very thorough, her presentation of events is clear and it would seem very accurate. Sereny's examination of Mary's character and possible motivations is fascinating and she does not attempt to either condemn her as evil or diminish her responsibility for her crimes. Her opinions on Mary and her co-defendent Norma Bell (no relation to Mary) are interesting, well argued and fair. The examination of the relationship between Mary and Norma was in my opinion particularly interesting as it was key to the case. It was fascinating to read how such a young child could so manipulate an older girl and indeed the adults around her for her own ends. At the time this book was originally written, the 1970s, not much was really known about Mary's background, but Sereny has gathered as much information as she could and produces some good reasoning on what made Mary kill as a result. Her family is looked into in depth, at least as much as the family was willing to reveal at the time. The first hand information they provide is very valuable in understanding the whole case. Interviews with those in the community as a whole also provide a fascinating insight into how these crimes affected a whole community for many years and still affects it, I believe, today. Sereny also discusses the way the justice system treats children who kill and again produces some interesting thoughts on this. While it is clear Sereny has sympathy with Mary and Norma, and does not like the way the system treats such children, her analysis is both fair and constructive. Her examination of the trial process is thorough and I also found it fascinating to see how children are interviewed by the police in such matters. The book, though written some time ago, is still highly relevant today in our increasingly violent and disillusioned society. In this new edition Sereny has added a short but interesting and thought provoking section on the Bulger case from the 1990s which presents some interesting theories and also shows how little has changed in the years between the two cases, both in society as a whole and the attitude towards such children, and also in the justice system. Indeed it seems little has changed even today and another such killer could well be in the making now. Overall this is an excellent and important text in our modern culture and a must for those interested in true crime and psychology.
Eerily compelling and compassionate, 15 Mar 2003
Gitta Sereny's study is split into two halves - a blow-by-blow account of the trial, and an analysis of the familial background and social circumstances of Mary Bell's life as well as her detention after her conviction of manslaughter on two counts, due to diminished responsiblity. Essentially, Mary Bell murdered two small boys at the age of eleven in 1968, and in the second case the boy was evidently throttled, before having the initial "M" carved into his stomach after death with a razor blade, and his face sprinkled with flowers. What is most remarkable and distressing is the extent to which Mary sought attention and boasted of her crimes in notes she and her cohort, Norma Bell (no relation, acquitted of charges of murder and manslaughter), left in a nursery which they broke into, and displayed aberrant and classically psychopathic behaviour after the incident. What is essential is that this case study is approached with an open mind, for it is a liberal social study which lays much of the blame of society for the "cries unheard", the title of the follow-up to this study. It is fair and humane, as well as perceptive and informative. As Sereny herself would say, it is compassionate without being sentimental. An essential read for those troubled or concerned by child psychopaths and the reform of the social security and welfare system in the U.K..
slow paced yet interesting, 06 Dec 2000
this is an informative account of the child murderer Mary Bell. The author investigates the potrayal of the child as evil, the role of her accomplice, and the media attention received. The book gives a general overview of the case and whilst it is interesting it is quite a slow read.
A story of true courage, 22 May 2008
Sarah's Story managed to stir so many different emotions in me as the reader. It made me cry with heartfelt sorrow, it made me angry, it shocked and filled me with an overwhelming need for justice for Sarah and all the other abused children who's story we may not read but is just as real as Sarah's. Sarah's Story also managed to fill me with a sense of admiration at the courage shown by a little girl, who, against all odds, managed to find the courage to stop the abuse.
It is a truly inspirational story of how the wrong kind of love can destroy a child's life, and how the right kind of love can be instrumental in that child's recovery and freedom. If ever there was a story to inspire other abused children to have hope and strength, this is it.
Moving and inspirational, 07 Apr 2008
I feel I should review Sarah's book and give her the acknowledgement she deserves as an author. 'Sarah's Story', (Living with the Past), is a harrowing story and although her journey through life was not one of physical abuse, the sexual abuse she, and others like her suffered in their lives, is no less harrowing than Dave Peltzers. How do you measure such acts of betrayal against any child?
Amazon request book reviews, not comments about a book being published under a different title. I am sure that Sarah had no part in her publishers decision to publish her story in paperback using a different title. (I'm sure they aren't the first or last to do this). Stay strong Sarah and be a true survivor. You and all the other writers, who care and relive their horrific memories, in order to tell their stories to the world continue to educate us all on the true scale of the atrocities of sexual abuse against children.
A movie adaptation must follow, 07 Nov 2008
Forget the raft of misery lit clogging up the bookshops. Yes, this is the story of a young girl from birth to sixteen. She was adopted,abused, neglected by individuals and institutions. But this book for all the familiar subject matter is written in such an honest, straight-forward, unembellished way as to set it apart from the rest.
It is a rollercoaster ride of a read, in which a girl, adrift in a society which constantly overlooks her needs and potential, tries to cope.She copes, mainly using her mantra of "Nothing in, nothing out."
So powerful was this book that I read it in one sitting and I would highly recommend it. It's not misery lit but it is a powerfully moving read.
Broken, 28 Oct 2008
Just heartbreaking. And no, not an easy read. I wanted to go back in time and rip the heads off her parents and everyone who didn't believe her, and just snatch her and take her away from the situation. Not only did Shy live through all that but she is a brilliant writer as well. How many other children are going through what she went through right now??
IF ONLY SOMEONE HAD LISTENED, 21 Oct 2008
This is a true account of what can only be described as a harrowing and unjust life Shy Keenan had to endure.She is now a avid supporter for all children who have and still are living through this horror..I cried when reading this book as I couldnt believe that this could of gone un-noticed by so many services, this was pure ignorance on their part, I just hope that they have learned from this brave woman's experience's and there is support and immediate help to all the children who are still going through this nightmare..Keep going Shy if you can save or help just 1 child from such a life of cruelty it would of been all worth it...
Most Shocking Story, 19 Oct 2008
From the first page you are gripped in a world of shocking abuse. Many times i cried, many times i laughed. The sheer disgust of the abuse keeps you reading, searching for hope in the pages. And when it gets happier you want to cry again. You feel so sorry for Shy and her sister throughout the book. And by the end you are desperate for the abusers to pay for their crimes. A night-in-with-some-chocolate-kinda-book. Tissues needed when reading.
Shy Keenan is inspirational., 14 Oct 2008
I wasn't sure at first if I would be able to read this book, but after putting it all into perspective (I could chose to put the book down but Shy Keenan had to live this life), I bit the bullet and was totally hooked from the first chapter. The majority of the time this book is extremely upsetting but my goodness what an inspiration this women is. Broken has enabled me to gain a better understanding of my own child's thoughts and emotions and because of Shy Keenan's brilliant writing, I feel as if I have become a better Mother. Upon finishing Broken I could not stop myself from absolutely sobbing, partly because of what a horrendous life Shy was forced to lead, but mainly because of the disgusting failings of the authorities that were suppose to be in place to help her. I had to keep reminding myself that this all happened in the last 44 years and not in the 1940/50's.
I have now passed this book to a friend, who has already been asked from a friend of hers if she can borrow it after. Shy Keenan is a trully remarkable and brave woman and from this, we can only all learn.
disturbing, 25 Sep 2008
This book made me swear out loud lots of times, it made me cry out loud lots of times and it warmed my heart lots of times. A must read.
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Customer Reviews
unbelievable strength, 27 Aug 2008
In a world filled with crime and death, war and poverty, many seek the salvation of religion to overcome.
We hear many stories about cults in America, stories of teenagers leaving then people they love to stay in communes where they are brainwashed, humiliated, abused and used.
This is the true accounts of three sisters who had no choice but to be born into one of these cults, the children of god.
From a very early age these poor children were systematically abused physically and mentally by the adult members of the group.
How these girls triumphed over these sick people astounds me and I congratulate them and hope that their lives are not tainted by these evil people.
This cult is still going and the story of these girls is a warning to us all. This is not easy reading but it is a book one must read. Disturbing but Courageous, 26 Aug 2008
It is never pleasant to read some disturbing experiences that these young lady's have gone through. I kept questioning myself on why I was reading what I was. My wife, Mother in Law & sister in law all read this book & found it disturbing. The only reason I could find as to why I wanted to read such a book, was in the hope that the 3 lady's were now back together & leading 'normal' lives.
If you are planning to purchase this book, the details, I found, are very explicit. However, the truth has to be known & the truth definitely comes out in this book. Yes I feel extremely sorry for these young lady's knowing that while I was growing up, there were people suffering like they did. These young lady's are very brave. Brave to that fact of making it known the disgusting things these so-called 'adults' put them through & then these 'adults' trying to justify their crimes through the word of the lord.
I can only wish Kristina, Celeste & Juliana well, & congratulate them on their brave fight & wish them well in their continued fight to expose organisations such as the 'Children of God'.
This is a very good, well written, but painful book. The 3 lady's courage can be found to be inspirational & a lesson to us all. disturbing, 27 Jun 2008
I didn't think I could finish this book. It really effected me that so much evil could still exist in the name of a God that despises child abuse.
The three sisters were very brave to allow this book to go to print and tell the truth. The sad thing is that I believe I met some of the group on a trip to Portugal many years ago, without realising the full extent of the cult's beliefs. I can still see the face of the small little girl who was performing for us... absolutely fantastic, 27 May 2008
this was the most moving, upsetting, yet amusing at times, book i have read in a very long time. These women are a total inspiration to me and I thank them for sharing thier story with us. I am familiar with the CoG and was interested to read what it was really like from the inside. A gripping and compelling story that was uncomfortable at times but well worth reading. Truly Wow, 07 May 2008
I chose this book for some reason, from the army of others like these which are on the shelves at them moment. Not knowing anything about the 'CoG' or 'The Family' as I lived in South Africa, and don't think they had much or any contact there. On reading these very well written, and compelling life stories by three amazing woman, I can not help but be thankful for the up bringing I had.
I am truly relieved that they have been able to survive their past, and help others and each other. You girls deserve all the happiness that life can bring.
Thank you for your inspiring lives, and sharing it with us!!!
To those in the Family who reject what these woman say, God will have the final say!
Bravery, 21 Aug 2008
Having read this book from cover to cover I would like to say that Stuart has showed true courage and Bravery throught both his childhood and adulthood. I actually live very near to where this event took place and thank my lucky stars that I had the childhood that I did. I am glad to hear that Stuart is now able to get on with his life with his family (who obviously adore him very much).
Thank you Stuart, for sharing your story with us., 12 Jun 2008
This book is amazing, just like the author. I think its the most horrific story of child abuse I've ever read and I cannot praise Stuart enough for having survived his ordeal and having come out the other side. You're an inspiration to us all and I am so glad you found love with Tracy.
I found the way he was treated while in prison disgusting and I'm glad he spoke up for himself and took those responsible to court! I dont agree with one person's comment that he shouldn't have said to the guards that he'd been abused. He had every right to expect to be treated fairly in prison, ESPECIALLY considering what he'd been through. I hope those prison guards have seen this book and are thoroughly ashamed of themselves.
Read this book. Its important to know and remember always, that abuse happens, it may be happening right now as I type this and we need to keep this message alive so that we can stop it from happening to innocent children.
Thank you once again Stuart, I wish you and your family all the happiness in the world!
A true brave boy.. who turned into a brave man, 06 Apr 2008
Wow.... that sums up this book in one word, i read this book in 1day flat i just couldnt put it down. It was such an gripping story of how a young boy battled his way through everything to become a young man to battle through prison to become a father and part of his own family.. The book was amazing and real heart touching story. Some parts are unbearable to even imagine and i hold the most respect for Stuart Howarth the auther of the book and i loved this book!! Shocking but gripping read, 23 Mar 2008
If I hadn't read the review on amazon by the author himself and his partner plus the foreword in the book I don't think I could have carried on with reading the book. The story was horrific, more so than any horror story I have read because it actually happened and in my life time too in my area of the world. I didn't have a fab childhood myself and I know how that has affected me so how can Stuart recover? He must be an amazingly strong person and I admire him for that. I couldn't put this book down, I read on and on. I can't wait for the follow on book because I really want to know the rest of the story. Absolutely unputdownable !, 14 Feb 2008
I didn`t have a great childhood myself and some of the things stuart talks about took me back there - a miserable place that i`m glad to be away from. However, the more i read of stuart`s book, the more i realised that, yes, my own childhood could have been one hell of a lot worse - it could have been as bad as his. I would like to shake this man`s hand and tell him he has much to be proud of-he lost a few battles along the way - but he won the war. Amazing book - amazing man ! An admirable story of courage, 07 Apr 2008
I have nothing but admiration for Celine's courage, tenacity and integrity. She has had the courage to tell her story and persevere through life-difficulties to which many of us would have succumbed. She suffered horribly at the hands of those who should have protected and loved her, but she never waivered in knowing what was good and right and in creating her own loving family.
I hope this book inspires others to shine the light in those dark corners and to have the courage to create a positive life of own's own.
The first edition of the book (not this edition, but one with a reddish cover) does contain some imperfections, but so what. Blame the editors and not the writer. The editors should have done a better job - editing their writers' work IS their job! But, apparently, this, the second edition of this book, has been better edited. Informative but lacking, 17 Jan 2008
This is a good read, and disturbingly interesting, but it's also a little out dated and missing vital information, but it is well written and generally objective, neither condemming nor justifying, giving a different view than the one we all imagine on hearing that name 'Mary Bell.' Excellent read for true crime and psychology fans, 08 Nov 2004
I grew up in Newcastle, the city where Mary Bell committed her crimes, in the 1980s and as such was always aware of this case and the "folklore" built up around it in a city that won't forget these awful crimes. As such I was very kean to read "The Case of Mary Bell" to understand more of the truth behind the case and perhaps gain some insight as to how on earth an 11 year old girl comes to murder two innocent little boys. The book has not disappointed me at all. Sereny has produces a fascinating account of the case. She is an excellent writer and as a consequence the book is very readable and her theories clear and easy to follow. Sereny was present throughout Mary's trial and subsequently visited Mary in her detention centre. She has also talked to the the vast majority of the parties involved in the case, from the police to the families of both perpetrator and victims. Her research was clearly very thorough, her presentation of events is clear and it would seem very accurate. Sereny's examination of Mary's character and possible motivations is fascinating and she does not attempt to either condemn her as evil or diminish her responsibility for her crimes. Her opinions on Mary and her co-defendent Norma Bell (no relation to Mary) are interesting, well argued and fair. The examination of the relationship between Mary and Norma was in my opinion particularly interesting as it was key to the case. It was fascinating to read how such a young child could so manipulate an older girl and indeed the adults around her for her own ends. At the time this book was originally written, the 1970s, not much was really known about Mary's background, but Sereny has gathered as much information as she could and produces some good reasoning on what made Mary kill as a result. Her family is looked into in depth, at least as much as the family was willing to reveal at the time. The first hand information they provide is very valuable in understanding the whole case. Interviews with those in the | | |